Re: Was there a TENT, or no?
Kookar TERE Darbaar · 20 Jan 2006
According to the SGPC and the "official" version of the story as printed in books by the Dharam Parchaar Committee (Amritsar) Guru Sahib took each of the Panj into a tent and then presented them to the Sangat on the stage.
End of day - God knows! No point losing sleep over it. End of day whether it was publically done or in a tent, makes little difference to me... my Guru is still great! Great are His Sikhs who are willing to give their head to Guru Sahib in order for the love of His Feet.
Re: Was there a TENT, or no?
Novtej Singh · 20 Jan 2006
Spot on 'opener'. For all you know, it could be a chinese whisper from the Gurus times of whether it happened in fron tof everyone, or whether or not Guru sahib medically attached the heads to different bodies. What did happen is the Khalsa was born.. and today it is still there. Dont worry about finding evidence for miracles..etc there should be some element of belief in the Guru :)
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Was there a TENT, or no?
LionKing (LK) · 21 Jan 2006
Who was this letter written by.?
What proof is there of the authentification?
What is it called in Gurmukhi?
Was it written in persian, and if so were can the original be found?
Excellent post by Kokkar tere Darbar. Whether he used a tent or not - doesn't matter. He created Khalsa, that's it
Re: Was there a TENT, or no?
jugroop singh · 22 Jan 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Dear Veer 'Singh' Ji,
i would write enough to provide a decent context by which the reader could also understand the gravity and genius behind Siree Dasmesh Pita Ji's blessed actions...perhaps along the lines of the following:
"Although there are several differing historical accounts and consequent interpretations regarding the events that took place upon that dramatic day in 1699, the majority of Sikhs are of the firm conviction that the heads of these Five Beloved Disciples were actually severed from their bodies and then later re-attached through The Guru's miraculous powers. As far as His Sikhs are concerned, The Guru requested five heads and that was what He took in order to test the Khalsa's willingness to sacrifice all for their Guru.
It can be argued that without the actual act of decapitation, it would have been an incomplete test and perhaps even a dishonest request upon the part of The Guru; perhaps it is for this reason that Sikhs have such faith that The Guru did as the The Guru said He would.
It also follows therefore that without being 'killed', these Five Beloved Disciples would not have had the opportunity to be 'reborn' as The Khalsa of The Guru which is clearly the very concept that The Guru intended to put across to His Sikhs. However, why did The Guru go through all this trouble to make a seemingly simple point?
To this day, the Amrit Sanchaar (Sikh initiation ceremony) is viewed as a 'life-giving' opportunity where the aspiring Sikh is blessed and literally infused with the immortal nectarian Word which represents God's self-generated Name; this is VahiGuru which translates as 'wondrous enlightener'. They are instructed that when The Name is meditated upon, in tandem with a strictly disciplined Sikh lifestyle, the gateway to inner divine illumination and Oneness with The One will be revealed. They receive The Name and the code of discipline from Five Initiated and fully-practising Sikhs - this is no small coincidence. By showing their willingness to sacrifice their very head for their Guru, The Five have in turn been invested with His authority - in fact, their very presence He has said reepresents His physical manifestation.
It is with this legacy in mind that Sikhs are obliged to take part in that ceremony which was inaugurated during the fertile Spring of 1699 - when five Sikhs were killed and then miraculously revived into the life-giving fraternity of The Khalsa, reborn into The House of The Guru."
the reason why i think u need to explain the above is because without defining what Siree Guru Sahib Ji was actually aiming to do, the reader will be unable to rationalise exactly why there was the need for 'five people to have their heads chooped-off'.
also, before writing this, it would be worthwhile to briefly mention the differing accounts i.e. as above, five goats, tent / no tent etc.
i would then personally end the article by putting forward what i thought actually happened.
hope this helps Veer Ji.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Was there a TENT, or no?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Jan 2006
Veer Ji wrote:
It can be argued that without the actual act of decapitation, it would have been an incomplete test and perhaps even a dishonest request upon the part of The Guru; perhaps it is for this reason that Sikhs have such faith that The Guru did as the The Guru said He would. >>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Remember when Guru Ji "TESTED" a rifle at Dalla's Place in Damdam Sahib ?
Guru Ji declared ..I want to TEST this rifle...and Father and Son came forward and stood before Guru ji ??
Was that an "idle" request...an attempt to "just ask for the fun of it ?" an "incomplete" test...or "dishonest request" ??
And then DID Guru Ji actually SHOOT the father and son..NO they didnt. Guru ji Shot OVER their heads....
I put it that it is FUTILE for us to question Guru Ji...on everything. Whatever He did is RIGHT.
The KHALSA that GURU JI CREATED....gave their HEADS..in FULL VIEW of the entire WORLD....again and again..and again.... in the Walls of SIRHIND...on the Fields of Chamkaur...on the Deserts of North Africa....all the time...as late as 1984.....2006...and will continue to do so..whenever needed to. There is no mystery..no need for Tents and hidden mysteries..
Sadly..now a days some so called "khalsa" do "buisness" and Treachery...hidden inside TENTS..and behind walls...and are then "secretly recorded" by others of the same kind. Real Khalsa Ji are forever in Full View.