Kuddos to SukhpreetSingh for great stand/sacrifice to win Kirpan Right for Sikhs
Breaking News · 16 Jan 2006
WSU changes rule on religious knives
University will comply with ruling and won't arrest Sikh students who carry 10-inch kirpan.
Marisa Schultz / The Detroit News
http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060110/METRO01/601100336/1026/SCHOOLS
DETROIT --Wayne State University is reviewing its public safety policies after a Detroit judge ruled a Sikh student shouldn't have been arrested on campus for carrying a 10-inch knife, known as a kirpan.
Sukhpreet Singh Garcha, a 23-year-old senior and a baptized Sikh, was arrested in August by campus police for carrying the knife on his hip and another 5-inch knife concealed in his waistband. Garcha was charged with violating the city's knife ordinance, which prohibits carrying knives with blades longer than 3 inches.
Garcha said carrying the knife was necessary under Sikhism, a monotheistic religion founded in India. The smaller knife was worn in case the other had to be removed.
The American Civil Liberties Union and the religious group United Sikhs protested Garcha's arrest, saying the kirpan isn't a weapon, but rather an ornamental article of faith that baptized Sikhs must wear at all times.
Judge Rudy Serra of the 36th District Court agreed, saying the city's knife ordinance was intended to apply to people carrying "a knife as a weapon or for some unlawful purpose."
Since Garcha was carrying the kirpan for religious reasons, the ordinance doesn't apply to him.
"There is no question that forbidding him from wearing the kirpan imposes a burden," Serra wrote. "It would be similar to an ordinance that made it illegal to wear a cross or a Star of David."
WSU Public Safety Director Anthony Holt said his officers will comply with the ruling and won't arrest Garcha or other Sikh students who carry the implement.
However, the university still prohibits firearms, explosives, and knives with a blade longer than 3 inches on campus.
The university's attorneys are reviewing possible changes to campus weapons policies to "ensure that everyone can practice religion freely and feel safe on campus," said Alexandra Matish, assistant general counsel for the college.
Serra's opinion upholds the "right of people in Michigan to practice their religion without fear of being thrown in jail," said Michael Steinberg, legal director for the ACLU. "We hope the opinion will provide guidance to the Detroit and Wayne State community about their constitutional duty to refrain from prosecuting Sikhs who wear kirpans as articles of faith."
You can reach Marisa Schultz at (313) 222-2310 or [address removed].
-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-
U.S. judge says police wrong to arrest Sikh student for carrying knives
http://news.findlaw.com/ap/o/51/01-10-2006/86da0008869c4f2b.html
(AP) - DETROIT-Police at Wayne State University should not have arrested a student for carrying knives that were part of his Sikh religious beliefs, a judge said.
Sukhpreet Singh Garcha, 23, was arrested Aug. 14 for carrying a 10-inch (25.4-centimeter) knife on his hip and a 5-inch (12.7-centimeter) knife concealed in his waistband. He was charged with violating Detroit's knife ordinance, which prohibits carrying knives with blades longer than 3 inches (7.62 centimeters).
Carrying a ritual knife known as a kirpan at all times is a basic tenet of Sikhism, an Indian-based faith with an estimated 25 million followers worldwide.
The American Civil Liberties Union and United Sikhs protested the arrest.
Detroit 36th District Court Judge Rudy Serra ruled last month that the knife ordinance was intended to apply to people carrying "a knife as a weapon or for some unlawful purpose."
Since Garcha was carrying the kirpan for religious reasons, the ordinance did not apply, the judge said.
"There is no question that forbidding him from wearing the kirpan imposes a burden," the judge said. "It would be similar to an ordinance that made it illegal to wear a cross or a Star of David."
Wayne State Public Safety Director Anthony Holt said campus officers will not arrest Garcha or other Sikh students who carry a kirpan, The Detroit News reported Tuesday.
---
On the Net:
United Sikhs: http://www.unitedsikhs.org
Web site about the kirpan: http://www.sikhs.ca/kirpan
-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-
Other related news
http://www.indiadaily.com/breaking_news/55738.asp
http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060110/METRO01/601100336/1026/SCHOOLS
http://www.freep.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060113/NEWS07/601130360/1009
http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20051213/METRO/512130338/1003
http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20051212/METRO/512120336/1003
http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/2165/2006-01-15.html
http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/2088/2005-12-18.html
http://sify.com/news/fullstory.php?id=14118231
[%sig%]
Re: Kuddos to SukhpreetSingh for great stand/sacrifice to win Kirpan Right for Sikhs
Bhopinder Singh · 16 Jan 2006
If you have courage to sustain what you belief ,things happen.One should also remmember singhs who helped a fellow sikh theirby helping themselves.Specially those that encouraged singh to stand and face the thing and even went to court with him
One should also remmember those who advised singh to wear small kirpan and that to underneath and avoid any trouble,also the singh should come forward and write about them so that the real singhs be known to the Panth and the fakes be exposed.It will help many singhs facing such situations as a inspiration from a brother singh.The real test of sikhi are such situations and I know Sukhpreet singh has found the truth of fake and real
Re: Kuddos to SukhpreetSingh for great stand/sacrifice to win Kirpan Right for S
Breaking News · 16 Jan 2006
India Daily
US varsity to allow kirpans on campus
Jan. 13, 2006
http://www.indiadaily.com/breaking_news/55738.asp
Going by American psyche, kirpans are essentially knives that can kill. So if guns are not allowed in school or university campuses then neither should knives. But that rule is about to change in one American university. Wayne State University is reviewing its public safety policy after a Detroit judge ruled that a Sikh student should not have been arrested on campus for carrying a kirpan. Sukhpreet Singh Garcha, a 23-year-old senior, was arrested by campus security police in August for sporting a 10-inch knife at his hip and another 5-inch knife in his waistband. The city's knife ordinance prohibits carrying knives with blades longer than 3 inches. The American Civil Liberties Union and the religious group United Sikhs protested Garcha's arrest, saying the kirpan is not a weapon, but an ornamental article of faith that baptised Sikhs must wear at all times. Judge Rudy Serra of the 36th District Court agreed. In her decision she wrote that the city's knife ordinance was intended to apply to people carrying "a knife as a weapon or for some unlawful purpose." Since Garcha was carrying the kirpan for religious reasons, the ordinance does not apply to him. "It would be similar to an ordinance that made it illegal to wear a cross or a Star of David," Serra wrote. WSU Public Safety Director Anthony Holt said his officers would comply with the ruling and would not arrest Garcha or other Sikh students who carry the implement. For all the rest, however, the university still prohibits knives with a blade longer than three inches on campus.
[%sig%]
Re: Kuddos to SukhpreetSingh for great stand/sacrifice to win Kirpan Right for Sikhs
Harjinder Singh · 17 Jan 2006
Sukhpreet Singh really deserves kudos for this achievement. I would like to write few words about this great Gursikh.
I have found this young Gursikh having a tremendous pyaar and commitment for the Sikhi. He has been moving super fast to achieve the happiness of Guru Sahib since he came in to Sikhi.
As per my knowledge, Sukhpreet is born and raised in a non-gursikh family. His father is clean shave and Sukhpreet was also clean shave until beginning of 2005. All of sudden he got pyaar for the Sikhi through Internet and started his journey to become a true Sikh of Guru Sahib. He started reading about Sikhism. He would go to the Gurdwara and do tremendous seva with lots of pyaar. In the mid of 2005, He joined the Army of Guru Sahib and became a bebeiki Singh from the day one. I have known him for about a year and have been enjoying his sangat for more than last six months. I have found in him great potential about the future hope of Sikhi.
I am really pound of how Sukhpreet showed his commitment for the Sikhi in this Kirpan battle. Sukhpreet Singh was stopped for openly wearing foot long Kirpan by the Wayne State police on August 16, 2005. Sukhpreet was given two choices. One, He take off the Kirpan and hand it to the Wayne State University Police, where it might be given back after investigation. Two, they will take off his Kirpan and he would be arrested and sent to Detroit police holding and also charged with carrying a weapon. In order to fight this battle Sukhpreet Singh chose the latter option. When he was transferred from Wayne State University Police holding cell to the Detroit Police holding cell, He had denied taking any pictures or being finger printed. Since He denied being finger printed they told him that he could not be released, and that he would be put in jail. At this point, the Detroit Police officer informed him that they would need to take off his remaining Kakars, however, Sukhpreet Singh denied. Sukhpreet Singh told that that it he felt extremely guilty for giving up his Kirpan without a fight, and he will not make that same mistake for the rest of his Kakars. The officer understood that there would have to be a physical confrontation. Finally Sukhpreet Singh was released on bail with the warning that he would not able to wear a Kirpan that is longer than 3 inches in length and if he would be with wearing a Kirpan longer than 3 inches he would be arrested and send to county jail without bail.
Sukhpreet Singh met me soon after he came back from Detroit on that day and discussed all what happened. Although he was very much upset for loosing his Sri Sahib but he was not afraid at all and was very much determined to do what ever it takes to fight for it. He was actually upset and feeling guilty that he did not die for keeping his Kirpan and was prepared to never give up his Sri Sahib again. After that, I think everyone has already read briefly in news what he did to win the case in the court.
Sukhpreet Singh was stopped second time on December 6, 2005 for wearing the foot long Kirpan by the Wayne State police and was given the same two choices again. Sukhpreet Singh bluntly refused to give up his Kirpan under any circumstances. When officer failed to take off the Sri Sahib of this Singh after physically confronting with him he called another cop. When even two cops failed, they called for more police. Finally to take Sri Sahib out of the Miaan (Sheath), four cops were involved physically scuffling with Sukhpreet Singh. Even then, they still could not remove the miaan from the hands of this Singh in front of large crowd of students and teachers gathered over there by that time. Sukhpreet Singh won the heart of all those who saw his commitment to keep his faith. His fellows and his teachers stood behind him and finally Criminal charges were not pressed, and Sukhpreet Singh was released.
Now even after winning the case and personal assurance of police and Wayne State University authorities that he will never be stopped for wearing his foot long Kirpan, Sukhpreet Singh is not sitting back and still fighting hard to get the policy revised in written regarding the Kirpan to ensure that this never get repeated with any other Sikh in Future.
I will request Sukhpreet Singh to write how he got into Sikhi, his experiences in this journey and his own views & message to his fellow Sikhs.
[%sig%]
Re: Kuddos to SukhpreetSingh for great stand/sacrifice to win Kirpan Right for Sikhs
Harcharan Singh · 17 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khasla Waheguru ji ki Fateh
Totally inspiring to see a true Khalsa Veer not compromising our Fathers hukum.
Jo Bole Soh Nihaal - Sat Sri Akaal
Harcharan Singh
Re: Kuddos to SukhpreetSingh for great stand/sacrifice to win Kirpan Right for Sikhs
Wannabe Singh · 18 Jan 2006
wow Bhai Sukhpreet Singh Jee. Keep up the good work!!! May Vaheguru bless you.