Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

singh · 16 Jan 2006

how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray? im speaking of when they obviously treat and speak to you differntly in professional settings...? how do you deal with you not being served as a citizen who was born in this country, and in turned humiliated, and where you know you cant do anything about it? i was at an emergency room at hospital in a gora part of town where i was served last, waited 4 hours, treated very rudely by reception a though i was a theif, and had the doctor literally laugh at me and tell me that the problem i was suffering frmo wasnt an 'emergency'. it was odd becasue noone in the emergency room was 'near death' like the way she defined 'emergency'. the problem was enough for me to miss work and not be able to drive, i wanted to make sure it wasnt serious. the doctor told me that i should go to a family doctor and that if i wanted to be checked, she could check me, but she would have to go to the other side of the hall to get her light, as though i was burderning her. i then said no its ok, because she already let me know there wasnt really any point. she then said shes going to have to write that 'patient refused treatment' on her report. i then told her that i didnt wait 4 hours to refuse treatment, and that she was the one who said that there was no point checking me. Its odd because usually a doctor would check you out first ie check atleast eyes ears and do a heart beat check of all things...and only then tell you to see a family doctor. overall it was a waste of time, and humiliating, and nothing i can do about it. what should i do..its kind of irking me. write a letter? will it do anything?

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

sevadar · 16 Jan 2006

write a letter to the hospital compliants department/officer. you will usually find it on their website. Write it with sehaj, and explain clearly why you were unhappy.

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

bgt · 16 Jan 2006

i think you have a point to complain with. but to call it indirect racism MAY be conclusion jumping. MAY be. Apologies if i'm wrong as such situations are not nice. Nevertheless, its very easy yo be on the receiving end of something and misconstruing to mean something else. WaheGuru

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

Write a letter · 16 Jan 2006

Make a complaint, emai them or phone there number, man these people think they have a right to do these things cus they in charge, you complain, at least there stats will show it, if nothing else !!

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

someone · 16 Jan 2006

write letters to hospital authorities...if nothing comes out of that then u should send details to ur local newspaper telling of the issue...also Contact Panthic weekly with full details... [address removed]

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

here's a thought · 16 Jan 2006

Dear Singh, For the past few months I have been working in ER settings in different cities in Canada, and although I am not a nurse or doctor, as part of my research on health, I have been exposed to those different environments. I must say, that I was very disappointed to see the way that patients were treated in general. And those areas that I worked in were almost 95% goray, and the white patients were also treated with much less respect and dignity as we would typically expect. I'm not discounting the fact that the nurses and doctor were perhaps racist, although the nature of those fast paced and often stressful environments typically leads to behaviour, which appears quite "densensitized" to us. Realistically, doctors working in the ER see patients with life threatening injuries, so that while a problem may in fact be very distressing, painful and burdensome for us, RELATIVELY to those other cases, to the doctor the problem may appear quite trivial. Again, I am not intending to undermine the significance of your problem. Many of the nurses through my observations appeared very burned out, and disatisfied, perhaps due to the stressful hours, and demanding patients. My main point being is that, I found over the months, that patients typically were quite disatisfied with the long hours, and many people aren't properly informed that patients are seen on priority based on the nature of the problem, not by time of arrival. Again, while this may have been a racist incident, I want to assure you that through my own experiences, your experience may be more common than you think. Peace [%sig%]

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

singh · 16 Jan 2006

" here's a thought", i totally understand what youre talking about, and took that into account. but its hard not to notice the smiles goray get when the receptionist was talking to them, and the treatment I, a singh with a white distar and dhari got. by the time i left, the entire waiting room was empty, everyone else had got their turn before even me though i was there ahead of most of them. according to them i had no emergency, but why did everyone else get seen before me? its hard not to notice these things. im not one to jump to conclusions, but there might be more singhs or singhnis who get treated this way.

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

MOW! · 16 Jan 2006

i dont think you can jump to the conclusion its racism, if you speak to the patients in hospitals the vast majority will complain about the interaction they have with staff, especially doctors.

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

ks · 17 Jan 2006

with the number of sikh doctors, it's odd that you'd get such treatment. Seriously, what's the point of every bintushintu becoming a doctor if our own are getting the shaft by the medical world? also, er patients are not seen in the order they came in---they are treated according to severity. Maybe you didn't say you had severe enough pain (no use being stoic when you go to the er)?

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

simple singhani · 17 Jan 2006

But if he felt it was racist towards him.. then maybe it was. we dont know.. because we didn't see the look on her face or the way she spoke. I know what you mean singh. People are indirectly racist and usually its not you jumping to conclusions especially if your one that doesn't go looking for trouble.

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

singh · 17 Jan 2006

guys, i was born and raised in canada, and ive come to know how people are when they are either or nice or rude.... i wont say it was racism, but its definitely odd. the patients go in order to a room, and i went in when the waiting room was full. when i levae there is not a single person around in the waiting room OR the patient rooms... the last thing i do is jump to conclusions, but the doctor laughed at me...which is odd...plus she came in WITHOUT my file and without any tools. (i understand you guys are trying to play devils advocate guys, but come on...a little support here. im begining to think that IM the wrong one here for going to a hospital to be TREATED regardless of the severity. I felt it COULD have become more serious, justbecause it had increased day by day. I pay taxes for these doctors to help me, and if they do not have enough sense to check me FIRST then let me know that i should see a family doctor, then thats acceptable. but to come in with NOTHING in hand is odd. you guys sure know how to make me regret posting this...)

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

here's a thought · 17 Jan 2006

Singh, I am sorry if I in any way undermined your experience, and again, I didn't hope to discount your account. There may in fact have been racist attitudes by the department, and that is terribly unfortunate. It doesn't hurt to contact the complaints department, or whatever means you are directed to in order to express your real concerns. My only intention was to alert to you some similiar events that I witnessed, and perhaps allay some of your worries. But, again, I was not there. I myself have felt DIRECT racism and know the destructive effects. So again, that situtation at best is odd, and at worst, you were the victim of prejudicial doctors and nurses which is very unfortunate, but sadly a reality. And I do support your account, and am glad you shared your views with the sangat. I hope we can always support eachother! [%sig%]

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

singh · 18 Jan 2006

as guru nanak dev ji did in his travels, when greedy pandits turned him away from their villages, he just turned to the other direction.... gurbani also says do not argue with a fool, so just be on your way i guess....

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

g singh · 18 Jan 2006

"singh" you didnt get seen most likely because they give order in ER based on who is in the worst condition, not who came in first. If you came in with a potentially broken arm and needed an X-Ray, and than someone came in behind you with a 104 fever, most likely they would get seen first.

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

singh · 18 Jan 2006

yeah, just an update, i had been having pain my lower abomen so i went to the doctor yesterday and what do you know.......he sent me straight to the emergency room......go figure. this situation is very annoying.

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

Chardi kala · 19 Jan 2006

you have my sympathies singh, its amazing how the medical world has changed, there is no more caring for patients, the governments have helped turn them in robots by not giving them the help they require, in the uK the NHS is a joke and your right if you are indian and go to hosipital with broken english you better have a translator or you could end up being ignored for your whole stay, it's a shame that hospitals are becoming places where no one wants to go but unless something is done, we'll probably end up being looked after by robots in the future (not too much difference to now then :( )

Re: how do you deal with 'indirect' racism from goray

uk singh · 19 Jan 2006

singh - I think you should try another hospital. hopefully they will be more welcoming.