Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

sikh guru's eating meat?

sikh guru's eating meat?

????????? · 14 Jan 2006

i am currently reading "the sikh religion" by max arthur macauliffe and in this book it states that some Guru's ate meat. were the Guru's ever meat eaters and when did the sikh religion become vegetarian was it at Guru Nanak Dev Ji's time or later because the above book suggests that they used to eat meat.

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

Jasmin · 14 Jan 2006

It seems that Guru Har Rai ( 1630- 1661) was the most sensitive, and the most oppossed to meat.

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

... · 14 Jan 2006

Because a historian says something, doesn't by default make it true. We all know that Guru Hargobind Sahib issued hukumnamas against eating meat.

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

singh · 14 Jan 2006

"..." lets not be so quick to discount what a historian says...it is based on more than just what he "thinks" as for the hukhamname...they are also a source of history. my point...b/c a historian says it is so, is a lot stronger than someone like myself who has no training or education background in history asserting something

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

ekta · 15 Jan 2006

guru ji = akaal purkh, waheguroooo.... KARTA PURKH creator of all...if they can create they can take.

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

Harmanjit singh · 15 Jan 2006

Read shri GURU GRANTH SAHIBJI AND YOU WILL FIND THE ANSWER, The teaching of all the gurus are the same of as of GURU GRANTH SAHIBJI. Harmanjit singh [%sig%]

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

Panthic · 15 Jan 2006

how do you know the historian did reserach, he could have just wrote it on hearsay. If you interview some wierdo like Niddar today, in 200 years time, is what he says equal to what he gurus did? Guramt - the idealogy of the Gurus is clear when it comes to meat. No meat allowed.

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

Guptic · 15 Jan 2006

I think we should Use Gurbani to answer certain questions...Our gurus who told us to jaap naam, immerse ourself in the love of wahegurooo...Would they tell us to take lives of their creatures for our taste buds?

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

LionKing (LK) · 15 Jan 2006

Panthic - who hold Niddar in high esteem. There are several acknowledge scholars/historians who claim that they ate meat (whether I agree or disagree is a completly different issue)

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

ekta · 15 Jan 2006

I highly doubt that Macauliff wuas wrong?

Re: sikh guru's eating meat?

... · 15 Jan 2006

Mcauliffe got his information from "gyanis" and other people he considered scholars. He has been wrong in other things and he is wrong about this as well. His work is still great but there are errors. I mean, if Guru Hargobind Sahib's hukumnama clearly says not to eat meat, I think it's pretty hard to believe he himself did.