Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

panthic weekly -some concerns

panthic weekly -some concerns

panthic · 14 Jan 2006

panthic weekly is now basically our panthic newspaper. it represents us. there isn't a paper or a news service like it on the internet. at least for the sikhs who use the internet, it is our news. but what about its credibility? is it most credible? i have received e-mails on news groups that it is run under false names. as the editors and staff do not disclose their real name. also there were some unsubstantiated attacks on panthic weekly, but some of the allegations caused me to think if it is having too much power like CNN? to influence peoples mind and sometimes they try to do "shock reporting" ? how much have they substantiated and backed up all of their stories?

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Jan 2006

This is what happens in the Sikh Panth, We are quick to have doubts about panthic groups. I don't blame your concerns though because everyday we get a shock. Sometimes its someone who we look upto and we see the anti panthic stuff they do. We find it hard to trust anyone. I see most of Panthic weekly stories having back ups. Take for instance the Rulda Article. There's audios that prove that the articles are genuine. The Baba Daljeet story.....when Panthic weekly said it some people claimed that they didn't have proof and it was all made up..later it was proven that he was indeed there with some bibi....now these same people are running articles on their website about it..

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Jan 2006

gurpreet singh :S, although i agree that panthic weekly is doing a pretty good job, if u dont see the bias in their work, i think u need to read a little bit more clearly. If someone would hand one of their articles into a university class they would surely fail because of the huge bias they have. I understand gursikhs run the panthic weekly and they are very passionate towards informing sangat, but, if anyone other than a sikh ever read the paper they would think of it nothing more than a tabloid because of the huge bias it portrays.

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Jan 2006

Gurbani says...AAklee SAHIB Saveah....a SIKH is always to use his God given Akal..Talent..Budhee..brains..intellect..to judge - evaluate- arrive at calculated opinions.... NO SIKH is a BLIND FOLLOWER..... If he is..then he is NOT a SIKH...one Cannot be both "blind" and "Sikh" at the same time. The trouble now a days is that too many just close their eyes and follow the leader....most of the time it is a illeterate sant baba ji....and whatever the sant baba ji says is TRUTH...even when it is absolutley proven Not.

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

panthic · 14 Jan 2006

so bh. jarnail singh ji are you saying that in this case, panthic weekly, is the nakli sant baba, and we are all in following their articles for our enlightenment?

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

Sher Khalsa · 14 Jan 2006

didnt bhai joga singh blindly follow. and if u ask me he was a great sikh

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Jan 2006

he followed a guru................akaal purkh dey sargun saroop.......not just anyone

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

singh · 14 Jan 2006

Gurpreet Singh, could you give us some examples of major newspapers that don't have biases?

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Jan 2006

First of all its a Sikh News Paper and what they do is expose so 'called' sikhs and sant babas who have loads of wellwishers...how do u want them to do that?...life isn't all flowery like we want it to be...panthic weekly is straight up ...if u look at that as being bias then fine u made up ur mind...but i pray for the chardikalaaa of the panth and i pray that panthic weekly continue to give the panth the truth...as it has been doing...we all have mistakes...but give people a chance...u guys expect everything perfect but that won't happen...its kalyug!!

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Jan 2006

Author: panthic Date: 01-14-06 17:26 so bh. jarnail singh ji are you saying that in this case, panthic weekly, is the nakli sant baba, and we are all in following their articles for our enlightenment? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>. Veer...please read my mail once more....aaklee sahib saveahehn..... Jarnail singh

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

singh · 17 Jan 2006

if you have so many complaints about panthic weekly journalism, send them and email and offer to write a few columns or news articles yourselves, smarty pantses!

Re: panthic weekly -some concerns

PW ROCKS · 18 Jan 2006

Panthic Weekly is straight up homie. No nonsense on dat site. Much love 2 da PW singhz keep up dat seva!!!!!!!