Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

A question about Nirmalas

A question about Nirmalas

Kulbir Singh · 12 Jan 2006

A question has been lingering in my mind for a long time. I have heard a story that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj sent some Singhs to Kanshi or Mathura or some other holy city of Hindus to learn Sanskrit and to get well-versed in Vedas, Upanashids etc. The Singhs had to remove their dastars and throw their hair behind to learn Vedas and Sanskrit language. The question I have is what was the need for Siri Guru jee to send Singhs to Kanshi Mathura or Hardwar to learn Sanskrit when greatest scholars and experts were at Satguru jee’s disposal right in Anandpur Sahib and at Paonta Sahib? Guru Sahib was a known patron of scholars and poets at that time and poets and scholars from all over India had flocked to Siri Anandpur Sahib and Paonta Sahib to be with Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib himself was expert in Sanskrit and Brajj. Why did he had to send Singhs elsewhere to learn? I would appreciate if someone could shed light on this. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: A question about Nirmalas

Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 13 Jan 2006

SATGUR KI BATEIN SATGUR HEE JAANEI. Who we are to comment on His action. But we presume that Guru Sahib had seen the future course of action of these people, which may prove treacherous. so they were made to go once for all, because you have not mentioned that they had reached back after learning. (Malesh Khalsa). So long their good deed were (Pun), they remained with Guru Sahib. Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]

Re: A question about Nirmalas

avidya · 13 Jan 2006

Gurfateh Yes, when Pandit Ragunath refused to pass on the knowledge in Guru ji's darbar it was on the grounds that tradition holds that non-Brahmins cannot study the texts, commentaries and traditions. Hence to send non-Brahmins to the very seat, the very heart of Bramnincal learning and tradition, to then learn all that was available, to master it and then translate it into braj bhasha, was to directly undermine this tradition. Likewise, like other traditional tiraths the Nirmalas existed at these places for the purposes of prachaar. To this day, Nirmalas (who have remained as a non-brahminical source of traditional learning) teach anyone including many brahmins themselves a complete sanskrit course taking in all associated literature...thus manifesting Guru ji's desire. Likewise in Kashi itself to this day, those original places exist still functioning as sanskrit vidyalas.

Re: A question about Nirmalas

try to use my brain. · 13 Jan 2006

I was just thinking Guru ji knew everything. Everything in this world and many others. He says in our nitnem that he has seen everything, and this is the only way. Then why did he not have this knowledge of the pundits? Guru ji knew more than them. It still does not make sense.

Re: A question about Nirmalas

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Jan 2006

GUru Sahib doesnt need to make sense...............its guru sahib, why should we ever question what they did guru sahib also more about anything than anyone else, yet they still sent other sikhs to propagate the message of bani

Re: A question about Nirmalas

Harcharan Singh · 15 Jan 2006

Could it be the Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj along with our other Guru Ji's lead their life in a way to show us how to live our life? Could it be that sending the Singhs to learn about other faiths, languages etc was a the setting of a precedent? Could it be that Guru Ji was trying to tell us to always remain knowledgable, because in the struggles of life, knowledge/gian with Guru's kirpa is our biggest asset? Could it be to ensure that Guru Ji's children, his Khalsa, his Sikhs would never discriminate, disrespect, slander or think themselves better than anyone? If looked at this way, what is the problem. Guru Ji has ordered us to learn about other faiths, as the only true way to ensure we will not think ourselves better and treat others with equally. This is why our Guru's learned about all important aspects of life in their time - Religions, War, Music, Politics.... It was obviously forsight on their part, to prepare the Sardaars, leaders of tomorrow to live in a diverse and complicated world. Without the need to say all this is secondary to Shabad, but can mastered in the best with Gur-dhiaan. Our Guru's decisted from performing miracles in order to be role models to us, there is no big mystery. In addition they did not need to work in supernatural ways, they were already at one with Waheguru, they were in complete acceptance of his hukum. Lastly, with no offence at all intended, Vijaydeep Singh has said: Guru ji did had power to show miracle but did not show and did the works of world as in worldyl manner. Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh Ji had power to tople the world yet he remained in jail why? I find this offensive, Bhai Randhir Singh was an exemplary Gursikh, but the above sentance seems to be putting Bhai sahib on par With Guru ji, this is wrong. I am sure other people will interpret this differently, but there is nothing to substantiate Bhai Sahib could topple the world. Only Akaal Purkh has power, comment like the above are irresponsible, and could give people the wrong impression about Bhai Sahib. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: A question about Nirmalas

LionKing (LK) · 15 Jan 2006

Author: Gurpreet Singh Date: 01-14-06 09:07 GUru Sahib doesnt need to make sense...............its guru sahib, why should we ever question what they did **************** Because Guru Ji didn't want us to get into blind faith. Hence why he tested his Khalsa when lowering his teer at a samad of a peer. Khalsa was to question Guru Ji - that was what he wanted - he didn't want Khals to stay in the dark and blindly follow. He gave us logical, Ukal, Budhi, Samaj. Nice post as usual Harcharan Singh ji =)

Re: A question about Nirmalas

Gurpreet Singh · 15 Jan 2006

blinf faith to guru sahib is essential in sikhi, if guru sahib says jump off a bridge, u as a sikh should do it using your panj pyarey example, guru sahib said he needs a head. Bhai Daya Singh go up without asking why, he said my guru sahib asked for something, i shall do what i can do accomadate my guru. I dont think he said "But why do u need a head?"

Re: A question about Nirmalas

Bhopinder Singh · 15 Jan 2006

I think guru sahib wanted sikhs to give knowledge to brahmins as they were languishing in darkness of karamkand. I wonder why guru sahib wrote Jab eh gai birpan ke reet mai na karo inke parteet.