Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

108 mala

108 mala

Satbachan Singh · 11 Jan 2006

Please can someone enlighten me as to why a mala has 108 beads. I have asked my local Giani's and all give different answers. Can someone please enlighten me. Gur Fateh [%sig%]

Re: 108 mala

Gurpreet Singh · 11 Jan 2006

Its all Hinduism...atleast thats what I get from reading the significance. http://www.rudraksha-ratna.com/articledt.php?art_id=107 I mean Guru sahib tells us to jaap naam all the time..these guys say 108 times makes it complete...and most of the other things i won't even comment on..lol

Re: 108 mala

Sikhi is Pure · 12 Jan 2006

that same article is being sent around messageboards by Neo (aka Namstang ) pretending to be written by a UK nang. It just goes to show all of these guys are just taking things from hindu sites, and pretending it is sikhism.

Re: 108 mala

hmmmmm · 12 Jan 2006

he is still trying to justify his 108 thing on sikhsangat. he will never learn. funny how he always slags of akj/tapoban. AKJ must be the only ones putting him straight.

Re: 108 mala

Gurpreet Singh · 12 Jan 2006

yeah i noticed the same thing on all the sites referring to this 108 greatness. i WISH THEY would keep the brahmanvaadi out of Sikhi

Re: 108 mala

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 12 Jan 2006

Sikhi is beyond numbers game "Gentee Mentee". It is sad to see that Brahmanvaad influenced people have even made pictures and paintings of Guru Sahib with a mala in his hand and a Mala on His Dastaar. Yet, Gurbani clearly says: [gurbani]mwQy iqlku hiQ mwlw bwnW ] logn rwmu iKlaunw jwnW ]1][/gurbani] Translation:- "People apply "tilaks" (ceremonial marks to their foreheads), in their hands they hold "malas" (prayer beads), and they present themselves in a religious appearance (thinking that they have become Waheguru's Bhagats). People have understood Waheguru to be a play-thing (meaning, an innocent child who can be fooled by these superficial things). ||1|| Its even more saddening that pictures which MISREPRESENT the Guru Sahibs are being sold at Gurdwaras and brought by SIKHS. May Waheguru bless us all with wisdom. Daas, Manvir Singh Khalsa

Re: 108 mala

Gsingh · 12 Jan 2006

in many photos of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji that I have seen... they appear to have a mala.. so whats that about???

Re: 108 mala

Sikh Enkilaab(Sikh Revolution) · 12 Jan 2006

My fellow Singhs', ask realistic and sensible questions. Using a mala, or not does not make any difference. Just because it has in some pictures, that is not artists point of view. Sikhi is simple, there is no need to make difficult or confusing. Use common sense. That's what Baba Nanak did, and he tried to put us onthe path

Re: 108 mala

Confused Khalsa · 12 Jan 2006

i was thinking about this earlier, the whole numbers thing. if you dont do any paath/bani - i believe the best way to start is to actually set a number and do that amount everyday. let's say 3 japji's sahibs - bare minimum. then slowly work your way upto your nitnem banis, and any additional banis. The point of this isnt to signify a certain number being better than another, it is merely making sure you do a certain amount everyday - a minimum. the more you do, the better. 24/7 is the best, and a good way to work your way upto that is to count. Theres no harm in counting unless its some superstitious thing like 108 is better than 109.. vaheguru!

Re: 108 mala

Harmanjit singh · 12 Jan 2006

IT relates with the total breaths taken in 24 Hours and by dwiding it by something it comes 108. Actuly it is to tame your tung to recite gurmanter as I see if I have mala in my hand then it automaticaly starts rather then when I don't have. Secondly very respecable family of gurskihs in Punjab had SWORD OF TENTH GURUJI AND IT HAVE 108 MARKS ON ITS HANDLE (kINGRES) MAY BE TO BE USED IN THE BATTLE FIELD WHEN WE DON'T HAVE MALA IN HAND. Try simran both ways with mala and without mala and find out which is best for yourself don't go for discussions. harmanjit singh

Re: 108 mala

agyani · 13 Jan 2006

guru hargobind has a simrana (28 beads) theres a picture of it...its not all hinduism as u claim

Re: 108 mala

Jj · 13 Jan 2006

i belive the reason a mala is made is to help you jaap naam not to be counted lol but the reason there are 108 is so you can do it more i dont no just my own theory i could be wrong Bhul chuk maaf!!

Re: 108 mala

use a calculator · 13 Jan 2006

i am not against malas. i find them helpful. but this is 108 stuff is hindu mat. so from 28 we get to 108. But no one can explain why 108? why not 109, 110? the only link to 108 is the hindu course for brahmins. It is what brahmins award to each other. Some sant thought he would be clever and call himself it. Then the fashion has continued. As far as breaths. There are 60 secs x 60 mins x 24 hours = 86400 secs in a days. If divided by 108 equal one breath every 800 secs = one breath every 13 minutes. So live in the real world and stopping believing everything a Toronto nang tells you on his dodgy messageboard.

Re: 108 mala

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. I have not found a Single Panktee from Gurbani..URGING me to use a Mala..BUT there are SEVERAL that CONDEMN using a mala as PAKHAND... Here goes.. [gurbani]gauVI mhlw 1 ] coAw cMdnu AMik cVwvau ] pwt ptMbr pihir hFwvau ] ibnu hir nwm khw suKu pwvau ]1] ikAw pihrau ikAw EiF idKwvau ] ibnu jgdIs khw suKu pwvau ]1] rhwau ] kwnI kuMfl gil moqIAn kI mwlw ] lwl inhwlI PUl gulwlw ] ibnu jgdIs khw suKu Bwlw ]2] nYn slonI suMdr nwrI ] KoV sIgwr krY Aiq ipAwrI ] ibnu jgdIs Bjy inq KuAwrI ]3] dr Gr mhlw syj suKwlI ] Aihinis PUl ibCwvY mwlI ] ibnu hir nwm su dyh duKwlI ]4] hYvr gYvr nyjy vwjy ] lskr nyb KvwsI pwjy ] ibnu jgdIs JUTy idvwjy ]5] isDu khwvau iriD isiD bulwvau ] qwj kulh isir CqRü bnwvau ] ibnu jgdIs khw scu pwvau ]6] Kwnu mlUku khwvau rwjw ] Aby qby kUVy hY pwjw ] ibnu gur sbd n svris kwjw ]7] haumY mmqw gur sbid ivswrI ] gurmiq jwinAw irdY murwrI ] pRxviq nwnku srix qumwrI ]8]10] {pMnw 225} Awsw mhlw 5 ] hir hir AKr duie ieh mwlw ] jpq jpq Bey dIn dieAwlw ]1] krau bynqI siqgur ApunI ] kir ikrpw rwKhu srxweI mo kau dyhu hry hir jpnI ]1] rhwau ] hir mwlw aur AMqir DwrY ] jnm mrx kw dUKu invwrY ]2] ihrdY sm@wlY muiK hir hir bolY ] so jnu ieq auq kqih n folY ]3] khu nwnk jo rwcY nwie ] hir mwlw qw kY sMig jwie ]4]19]70] {pMnw 388}mÚ 1 ] piV pusqk sMiDAw bwdM ] isl pUjis bgul smwDM ] muiK JUT ibBUKx swrM ] qRYpwl iqhwl ibcwrM ] gil mwlw iqlku illwtM ] duie DoqI bsqR kpwtM ] jy jwxis bRhmM krmM ] siB Pokt inscau krmM ] khu nwnk inhcau iDAwvY ] ivxu siqgur vwt n pwvY ]2] {pMnw 470} mwQy iqlku, hiQ mwlw bwnW ] logn, rwmu iKlaunw jwnW ]1] jau hau baurw, qau rwm qorw ] logu, mrmu kh jwnY morw ]1] rhwau ] qorau n pwqI, pUjau n dyvw ] rwm Bgiq ibnu, inhPl syvw ]2] siqguru pUjau, sdw sdw mnwvau ] AYsI syv drgh suKu pwvau ]3] logu khY, kbIru baurwnw ] kbIr kw mrmu rwm pihcwnW ]4]6] {pMnw 1158} [/gurbani] ONLY the FAKE artist impression pictures of our GURUS....especially of Guru nanak ji show Him wearing a Mala etc.... and of course the SANTS and BABAS of DERAS also propogate this..... The Akal Takhat, the SGPC..the authentic Texts have got nothign to say.... So it is up to you..whetehr GURBANI is true or these fake pictures and sants.. For me...its GURBANI every time and for ever.. Jarnail singh

Re: 108 mala

avidya · 16 Jan 2006

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh I truly can't believe this discussion! I have seen the malas of Guru Nanak Dev ji Maharaj and Guru Hargobind ji! Gyani ji, yes Gurbani is forever truthful. But what happens when one who is ignorant misunderstands the meaning and is convinced that this distorted meaning is the 'truth' for ever? Along these lines your interpretation of the above verses is in the first case simply inaccurate and distorted! In the first shabad it isn't even referring to a mala as such but a jeweled necklace 'mothian ki mala'! If you HONESTLY believe the second shabad you have quoted is rejecting malas you MUST THEREFORE by proxy use it to support rejecting wearing a turban as it states in the same context in the next line!! Honestly gyani ji this is some very questionnable interpretation. CLEARLY this shabad is referring to hypocracy of taking on the roop of holiness but not actually upholding it on the inside. And the final shabad is Kabir again dismissing the outer orthodoxy in favour of the society of saints. Gurbani is truth - however clearly some fail to recognise that very truth, its message, its intention by purposefully or unknowingly denigrating it by projecting onto meaning which are not intended. Please gyani ji, I ask you in all humbleness, please act like a real gyani and refrain from distorting the meaning of shabds for the sake of your attempts at rejecting tradition.

Re: 108 mala

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

my dearest avidya jio, That is a matter of interpretion...OK I accept....you are entitled to your own distorted views as well.... BUT you didnt [ DID NOT ] offer any single panktee or shahbd which ENCOURAGES/ADVOCATES/Makes it necessary..etc to Have a MALA !!! Are there any ?? I eagerly await your answer... IF a MALA was THAT important surely Gurbani would advocate one..in at least One shabad or Panktee ??? Love Jarnail Singh.

Re: 108 mala

avidya · 16 Jan 2006

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh I personlly would argue that there is different interpretations of certain ideas and concepts, and then there is seriously inaccurate interpretation of Gurbani. As for malas, this isn't a matter of 'where does it say we should'. If we took that approach to practice a lot would go! Correct me if I'm wrong, but there is no direct stipulation in Gurbani for a number of things in the aspects of maryada that we share. In these cases we look to the rehitnamas. Since you do not apply the same approach to rehit, how can you be so sure to claim that malas are 'fake' based on the fact that it doesn't appear in Gurbani? On the issue of the use of a mala, there is likewise nothing in Gurbani directly but there is the evidence of the Guru's relics and history to show that they used them. The fact that two malas exist (if not more) is enough for me, and beautifully bejewelled they are too!

Re: 108 mala

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

avidya ji writes... On the issue of the use of a mala, there is likewise nothing in Gurbani directly but there is the evidence of the Guru's relics and history to show that they used them. The fact that two malas exist (if not more) is enough for me, and beautifully bejewelled they are too! <

Re: 108 mala

agyani · 17 Jan 2006

Of one thing i am sure..GURU JI would NOT "need" a Mala to do SIMRAN..just like a "ocean" wouldnt "need" a "ship" to chart its bed..GURU JI and SIMRAN...and "need" for such a childish thing like a mala to count "jaaps"..simply too much for me. Sorry. Please give me a Direct Ref from Gurbani if you have any. If not it is OK as I am not going for "mala-ogy" any way. ____________________________________________________________ Plz remember our gurus were here to teach us...i mean what need was there for them to do everythin they did TO TEACH US...there is nothing wrong with using a mala, it doesnt make you any less or more of a sikh. Why not just get on with it?

Re: 108 mala

Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 17 Jan 2006

Dear Veer Jeo/Princess wearing of woollen suits, wearing of neck ties, use of fixer for beared, eating of langar on tables and chairs, and eating of meat is not mentioned anywhere in Guru Granth Sahib but Mala was used as a mark of memory because mind were not sharp enough to keep in mind a little to recite Waheguru,and there were no much watches or time pieces to find out the time spent for prayers. Because the spread of Japuji Sahib/Sukhmani Sahib and Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji had to be done, because Gutkas were not available due to printing press and Mughals being anti to sikh guru sahiban, to read besides spread of Punjabi language was also yet to reach various parts of Punjab and elsewhere. Hence Mala helped to recite Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Wahe Jeo. or speak out orally. Still more reasons are there, if there are no arguments for the sake of arguments in my book under publicaion. Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]

Re: 108 mala

avidya · 18 Jan 2006

Gurfateh ha ha, your correct Jarnail Singh ji. I didn't realise! However, the 'simrani' of Guru Hargobind ji is not mothian but of jade I think - bejewelled in that sense, rather than a necklace of mothian. Hope that clears it up.