Are we the Modern Khalsas?
Are we the Modern Khalsas? · 18 Nov 2003
Are we the Modern Khalsas?
For many weeks now, I have been at an angry place when I think about the Sikhs of today. Some have shared that anger, while others have chosen to ignore it and the reason behind it, which ironically makes one even feel more desperate of the reality around us—when we (by we I mean the Western Sikh Youth of today—those who have made a proactive decision of calling themselves Sikhs) are not even willing to acknowledge an epidemic, let alone starting to find solutions. But today I really do wish to come from a place of humble imploring- there is just nothing else left. When there is no anger left we fall to our knees.
I was at a Community Restorative Justice Launch today (restorative justice meaning an approach at healing the community, victim, and offender, where the offender takes responsibility—similar to the Sikh tradition of “Panchayat” and “tankaah”). A Christian man, who I had met once before, and after that meeting he learned that he was diagnosed with a fatal illness having only a few months to live. I met him for the first time after learning about his illness again today. The first time we had met, we had started off at the wrong footing. We were in the planning committee of this local event, and I felt it was important to have more multi-religious representation for the event, whereas he felt it would take away by having more than two speakers (Christian and Aboriginal viewpoints).
Well before I met him again today, I had heard about his faith, and his “chardi kala” in accepting his fate. When I met him this morning, I was really happy to have met him in spite of our last conversation. He looked great. Not great physically, but in his spirit. Before going on to the next part of the story, to explain to you how I felt, as a backgrounder let me explain to you my appearance. I am a Sikh woman who wears a dastaar. I don’t feel I live up to the image and responsibility, but hope I will begin to continuously strive towards that goal. I saw Michael and expressed how great it was to see him at the event and how well he looked. And surprisingly he said to me that he was so very happy to see me. He said I looked like an angel and that the peace he had in his faith being the same peace he saw in me. Surprisingly he acknowledged our last meeting where we hadn’t hit a good start and said how happy he was to see me again, and wish he had known me for years and years. Now let me tell you something, I know everything he saw in me, was not what I am (because Waheguru knows) but what he saw was Sikhi, the dastaar, he saw what the dastaar represents. It requires us to be better, it demands it of us.
So today I am imploring all with folded hands, let us demand of ourselves to be better, let us demand it of our brothers and sisters. What I am about to raise cannot be raised through any other forum. It cannot be dealt with from the outside, we have to deal with it within our own Khalsa community. Let us make our brothers take responsibility, let us make our sisters be strong, let us make our community be the leaders.
My father told me when he was young, that if the “pind” learnt of any “sister” that was being abused by her husband, the whole pind would go to that village bring her back and take proactive steps in making the husband and family take responsibility and change.
Today, half a century later, in the “new world” I was at a retreat where one night in the girls cabin, it came out that 5 out of the 8 “Sikh” girls just randomly in that cabin had been sexually abused (by “uncles”, “gianis”, “leaders”).
Today, half a century later, in the “new world” some Khalsa sisters are being beaten up by their “Khalsa” (amritdhari) husbands.
Today, half a century later, in the “new world” some Khalsa sisters are being walked out on by their “Khalsa” (amritdhari) husbands.
Today, half a century later, in the “new world” the Khalsa community is keeping these incidents hush, not wanting it to get out, and yet not doing anything about it.
Today, half a century later, in the “new world” other Khalsa brothers and sisters are embracing these “Khalsa” “husbands” and “uncles” like they have done nothing wrong.
Is this the Khalsa and Sikhism that we want to teach others and our children? Keep quiet? Give them time? Don’t go talking about this or emailing this around?
PLEASE stand behind our Gurus’ Sikhi, don’t make these women ever question why they married a “Khalsa”.
Note: I am well aware these problems are at an epidemic high within our “Punjabi culture”, but let not that be the scapegoat, because it is prevalent within the “Khalsa culture” in the West, within the new generation of Khalsas!
Does it pain you to have me call these people Khalsa—that is the point- it pains me too!
[%sig%]
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
Kulbir Singh · 18 Nov 2003
What bhain jee has written is so true. Our values are changing very fast with time. We are the worshippers of Akaal i.e. timeless one, on whom there is no affect of time. If time has not affect on Vaheguru, then why should it have on Khalsa? The thing is that we are fast losing our basic values, as Bibi jee put it in the above posting.
We need to come back to the basics and rejuvenate our faith. Let us keep rehit and do amritvela. That is the only way we can bring our old values back.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
my thoughts... · 18 Nov 2003
I totally agree with what bhain ji has written. We have gotten ourselves caught in the web of maya. We need to wake up and go back to the basics as Bhai Kulbir Singh said. We need to keep rehit, and do abhiyaas of naam and bani. It is so easy to forget the purpose of this life, and I think we have done that, we need to go back to the fundamentals of Sikhi. Sikhi cannot be modernized because it is modern and very practical. If we live in the hukam of vaaheguru then these problems will go away.
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
everpresent devils · 19 Nov 2003
old Hispanic saying....."it takes two to do the tango"...........
......don't blame the men for all the women's heartaches
......don't blame the women for all the men's attitudes
"...it takes two to do the tango"
vjkk vjkf from the everpresent devils
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
Singh ready to stand · 19 Nov 2003
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh
kaur & . bring up good points. We, as the children of Guru Gobind Singh Jee, need to take a stand.
Standing back and allowing this to happend, is just as bad as commiting such acts yourself. After all...
> Is this the Khalsa and Sikhism that we want
> to teach others and our children? Keep quiet?
> Give them time? Don’t go talking about this or
> emailing this around?
> PLEASE stand behind our Gurus’ Sikhi, don’t
> make these women ever question why they
> married a “Khalsa”.
Are we the modern Khalsa
another quote directly related
"The hottest places in hell are reserved for those who, in time of great
moral crisis, maintain their neutrality" - Dante Alighieri
Suprisingly enough, the second quote came from a white man. We seem to beleive that we as Sikhs are an elite group of extraordinary people,which may be true but just remember that we're only as extraordinary as our actions... not our intentions
"The road to hell is paved with good intentions" - smart man or women
For those that still don't understand where I am trying to go with this: talking takes us only so far but uniting and taking a stand together as Guru Jee's children,would truely be something amazing. Something that gives us the right to hold our head high and boost about our forfathers (shaheed Singhs that fought for righousness), and to boost about our Guru's kurbania... and not have the other people say to us, "SO THATS WHAT THEY DID, WHAT ARE YOU WORTH?" If we unite today and fix situations like these in our comunity as a comunity, then by all means, we have earned the right to answer "I AM THE FLOWER THAT SPRUNG FROM THEIR SEED..."
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
............. · 20 Nov 2003
I would like to clear up some myths regarding spousal abuse. The following myths and facts I have cut and pasted directly from the Ontario government website. It seems very ironic that every single time the issue of wife abuse is brought up, someone immediately has to bring up that some husbands are abused too- as to take away from the reality, and dilute it by saying it happens both ways equally and seeking to end the discussion (In comparison it is like saying during the June 84 Harminder Sahib attack, hindus were killed by the Government also-- Yes there probably is an extremely small minority in both cases, but how would we feel if this was brought up every single time we spoke about the Harminder Sahib attack-- as if to take away from the reality of the majority of Sikhs being tortured and killed, and somehow saying its equal). This is not an issue of gender wars, but an issue of reality, please be sensitive and reactive to this reality (and lets start looking at solutions and support):
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Myth: Men are abused by their partners as often as women are.
Fact: More than 92% of charges related to spousal assault in Ontario are laid against men. Most charges laid against women are counter-charges laid by assaultive partners or stem from acts of self-defence.
-------------------------
Myth: Men who assault their partners are mentally ill.
Fact: Wife assault is too widespread to be caused by mental illness. Most men who assault their partners are not violent outside the home. They don’t hit their bosses or colleagues. When abusive men hit their partners, they often aim the blows at parts of the body where bruises don’t show. If abusive men were truly mentally ill, they could not limit their violence in this way.
-------------------------------
Myth: Alcohol causes men to abuse their partners.
Fact: Alcohol can make it easier for men to be violent. But the real cause of wife assault is the batterer’s desire for power and control over his partner. Batterers often use alcohol as an excuse to avoid taking responsibility for violent behaviour.
----------------------------------
Myth: Abusers are violent in all their relationships.
Fact: Abusive men are not necessarily violent towards others which makes it hard for others to believe the reality of the situation.
Myth: Wife assault is not a widespread problem.
Fact: In a recent study, one in five Canadian men living with a women admitted to using violence against her.
----------------------------
Myth: Abuse is a private matter.
Fact: physical violence is assault and assault is a crime whether it occurs within or outside a home.
----------------------------
Myth: Wife assault occurs more often among certain groups of people.
Fact: Wife assault occurs in all ethnic, racial, economic, social and age groups. However, violence in more affluent groups is often hidden because these women use shelters, legal clinics and other social services less often.
---------------------------
Myth: Assaulted women could leave their abusive partners if they wanted to.
Fact: A women may stay in an abusive relationship for many reasons. For example:
She hopes the relationship will get better
She does’t want to break up the family
Her partner’s abuse isolates her from friends and family
She fears for her own and her children’s safety
She depends on her partner’s income
She has lost self-esteem because of her partner’s abuse
She has nowhere else to go
Her partner has threatened to harm her if she leaves
She is worried about her or her partner’s immigration status.
-------------------------------
Myth: Women often provoke assaults and deserve what they get.
Fact: No women ever deserves to be beaten. Assaulted women report a wide range of incidents that trigger violence. For example: "I fried his eggs the wrong way." "I didn’t turn down the radio enough," or I went out with friends without asking his permission." Abusive men often claim their partner provoked an assault to avoid responsibility for their own behaviour. In fact, the true source of violence is the batterer’s desire for power and control over his partner.
------------------------------------
Myth: An abusive man is not a loving partner.
Fact: Often, women stay on in abusive relationships because the abuse may be intermittent and her partner may be quite loving to her during the interim periods.
-------------------------------
Myth: Nobody can help people in a violent relationship.
Fact: People have broken the cycle of violence in their lives. Most had help from others. It is not easy but, it is possible.
----------------------------
Domestic Violence is a form of power and control, and oppression.
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
I Ain't got a clue · 20 Nov 2003
I agree with your post. However I must enforce that the unfortunate issues you have highlighted are isolated incidents within the religion.
I agree we must stand for justice & truth and we must not let evil people hide behind the face of a GurSikh.
The culture is still male dominated and status dominated. The majority don't favour the sevadar who does 'mun di seva', they would rather favour the sevadar who does 'dhan di seva'. It's not the Sikh who does his/her 'matha takhe' with a few pennies, but the Sikh who donates £101 and gets a mention in the Ardas who people look up to. People want the 'meat eating, alcohol drinking' male Doctor to run for pardhan of the Gurdwara, not the GurSikh Janitor. This is the unfortunate cultural attitude which appears to dominate the mainstream Sikhs' way of thinking.
Just my humble 2 cents worth. Apologies for offending anyone.
Degh Tegh Fateh
Panth Ki Jeet
Raj Karega Khalsa
Bholay Shonay Hal, Sat Sri Akal
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
jagjit singh · 20 Nov 2003
waheguru ji kek halsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, there seems to be alot of complaining, but the reality is that no-one comes in front of the Punj pyares with these cases. Unless people speak out, how can people help. Quiet words here and there, are no good, Singhs will not help, unless the victims ask for help, otherwise people just say Singhs are interfering.
I have rarely heard these cases in the jatha, they seem to be common in nanaksar. But I have seen the North, the Singhs get involved in a case of a non-amritdahri bibi, a young girl from Punjab, who was married into a family here. The husband used to beat her, and kicked her out. Being from punjab, with no family here, she was left on the streets. The Singhs took her in and got involved. It tooks months of messing about, and the case is on going. I know of another case, where a young lad was inspired by sikhi, then his parents who are die hard athiests, forced him to leave it. They used to force him to drink. In the end he left home, and went to the streets. The singhs helped him, brought him a house, got him married to a singhni, and now he is happily settled.
The reality is Singhs do help, but people have to ask for it, and tell the truth. I was involved in a case of punjabi girl, with some SP boys. She was going out with a muslim, and when she stopped, the muslim started blackmailing her. Eventually the Singhs sorted that out. But when it came to doing the girls resta, the girl family blamed the SP boys who saved her for corrupting her. This is why people do not always help. Because sometimes, people twist things, and spread lies afterwards. That mona SP boy never helped any girl again.
This is why it is important the victims come forward and speak the truth. Sometimes, the Singhs should not get involved, and the police should. If these bibis are true Singhnias then they should have the courage to speak the truth, they should not need any singhs to help them.
Although easier said than done, the reality is the world is not a nice place, and you have to be tough. People are always going to talk, but as long you are true to yourself and your Guru, you should never be afraid, or feel ashamed.
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru jikefateh
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
I Ain't got a clue · 21 Nov 2003
A few people have quoted that these kind of incidents are common in Nanaksar Jatha. Please tell me what's going on? Has the Nanaksar movement gone haywire?
Re: Are we the Modern Khalsas?
unknown singhni · 24 Nov 2003
thats unfair to ask that " so true". women children are hardly going to relive the experiences all over again, as well as get their names tarnished in the community , we live in this conservative punjabi society where "izzat" is prized that affects peoples lives directly on whom it happens. women are treated second rate as it is.