Vinegar!!
Information · 08 Jan 2006
Is all Vinegar OK to use in food?
Some Vinegar suggests that it has alcohol in it, i.e. white wine vinegar, cider vinegar. I heard all vinegar has a miniscule amount of alcohol init anyway. Obviously before anyone jumps on the bandwagon that you shouldn't use vinegar because it might have alcohol in it, I don't think you can get drunk on it, I think it might be same as some medicines.
Please can some Gursikhs from a chemistry background give a answer PLEASE!!!
Also lets stick to the topic please as most posts seem to go off subject within the first few posts.
Fateh!!
[%sig%]
Re: Vinegar!!
simple singhani · 08 Jan 2006
how about ketchup? im told the heinz one is pure..
Re: Vinegar!!
Guru kian Beant Faujan · 08 Jan 2006
As I understand the process of distilling vinegar is similar to whisky and rum. The Sarblohi Singhs in India do not use it as it is not bibek. However the Tapoban Singhs do consume it in the process of making paneer. There are other alternatives that should be used, such as lemon juice.
As for ketchup - that is not bibek unless you make it yourself.
Re: Vinegar!!
Balpreet Singh · 08 Jan 2006
Guru Kian Beant Faujan,
Vinegar is not used as a rule to make paneer by the "tapoban singhs". I can't speak for all the sangat that attends the Gurdwara Sahib but most do know that vinegar should not be used. If someone does use it, it is out of ignorance and not the rule.
Re: Vinegar!!
cyber singh · 08 Jan 2006
....theres a difference between chemical 'alcohol' and alcohol that makes you drunk. alcohol is something that has an Oxygen and hydrogen group. your own body makes alcohol in many reactions that are essential to the body. so the question is , does vinegar contain chemicals with OH groups or does it contain drinking alcohol.
alcohol that is for intoxication is fermented using yeast i believe. i doubt vinegar contains this kind of alcohol..
the blanket term 'alcohol' is ignorant
Re: Vinegar!!
Information · 16 Jan 2006
Thank you Sangat Jee for all your responses.
I have spoken to several Sikhs who are from a scientific background and they also say the alcohol used in Vinegar is different to that normally drunk by people.
However is it OK to use Cider Vinegar and white wine vinegar? the only reason I have asked this as I came across these words and wanted to know if they contain alcohol or is vinegar made from apples and grapes.
Re: Vinegar!!
professor MOW! · 16 Jan 2006
the vinegar only has no alcohol if you boil it for a period of time first
but for bibekis such as O i dont think its counts as bibek
Re: Vinegar!!
amarjeet singh · 30 Jan 2006
oh so khalistani if u dont get drunk by it, its alrite.
so i off pop down the pub tonite and ask the bar tender jus to giv me some beer but not enuff 2 make me drunk, is this graet?