Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

raagis taking money

raagis taking money

paapi · 07 Jan 2006

dearest gurmuksh, firstly and foremost, i am the biggest paapi of all and hope to cause to offence to any one. i am the least of all to judge. however, there is a question which i need answering with the help of a few gurmuks. i would like ot ask why raagis take money for reciting keertan. i know the most obvious answer would be simply 'a job'. but why is this so 'obvious'?. why has this become second nature in this day and age. i believe that reciting gurbani is in front of a sangat, indeed a seva which should be done selflessly, a serving the sangat, with no ulterior motives and nothing in return. however, it has shocked me to find that so many people find it acceptable that raagis take money, not only do they charge, but they are putting price tags on taking hukamnama and performing asa di vaar as well as the money people put at the vaja. this has become so normal in society today that a lo t of the people i have spoken to have become brainwashed into thinking that as more raagis do this........the more normal this practice hs become plz gurmukhs, respond sensibly and think abut it bul chuk maafi

Re: raagis taking money

khalistani · 08 Jan 2006

out of pyaar we give it these ragis travel all arounbd the world, where u think tickets come from? how u think there families live they got kidds we give it our of our own pyaar for our brothers and sisters bhula hcuka maf

Re: raagis taking money

Singh · 08 Jan 2006

if you claim it is acceptable for people to be paid to do keertan seva (pay people because they have nicer voices than "regular" people) then going by this logic is it acceptable to pay people to do langar seva (if they can cook better than "regular" people")? what is the difference

Re: raagis taking money

gurpreet singh · 08 Jan 2006

raagis live a grisht jeevan. THEY NEED MONEY. they have kids that need to be fed. Look at all the gurdwaras around the world that have keertan going on 24/7, if u didnt pay the raagis who would be doing keertan between the normal working hours 9-5? Even guru sahibs darbaar used to have paid raagis. Guru Sahibs fauj was also paid. If you wanna do nishkaam keertan seva,,,,good for you...........but gurdwarey require paid raagis as well, unless you only want to have keertan going on a couple days a week or a couple hours a day.

Re: raagis taking money

Truth · 08 Jan 2006

cause they got mouths to feed...if rehansabhayees were happening everyday....then even Jatha Singhs would require kirtan bheta to feed their families.

Re: raagis taking money

s i n g h · 08 Jan 2006

There is nothing wrong with raagis getting paid for doing keertan on stage. It falls under 'kirth kamayee' on their part, and could be seen as a portion of 'daswandh' on ours. What raagis do is an honest, truthful work, with truthful intentions... There is no deception or mischief involved... unless they are doing parchaar against gurmat and gurbani. If sangath wants to support their efforts to continue to do this seva, I don't understand why any objections should be raised... Now, I can understand that some raagis can become laalachi and perhaps try to take advantage of this... but is this not a personal issue that even you and I have to deal with in our personal lives? We all have to deal with our greed.. raagis can be affected by greed too... doesn't neccessarily give us the right to condemn them on it. Nishkaam keertan seva is great... no doubt about it. In fact, on occasion, I have seen raagis direct their maya to the gurdwara sahib's golak as appreciation for letting them do that seva.... but think of it this way, raagi jathay make a living off an activity which brings only GOOD to others, while there are people who make a living off activities which may involve things like cheating or lieing... which one seems more justified? which one would you rather do? I wish my company would pay me to do a sikhi-related job all day long... I'd take that job in a second... Wouldn't you? bhul chuk maafi

Re: raagis taking money

Gurpreet Sumra · 08 Jan 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, well said gurpreet singh ji. Now for those who raised this question why don't u become raagi????? stop thinking about sachkhand,or khand below sachkhand do some kirtan in sadh sangat.do some katha if you have guts to do so. Katha should be as per Gurmat(shri guru granth sahib ji). Gurfateh

Re: raagis taking money

Dhanwant · 09 Jan 2006

by givin money u show appreciation to the ragi.whoeva appreciates the 'kala' the talent the 'gun' shown by the ragi will praise him somehow .most ppl do it wid money.its like wen ur grandma gives u money...we neva refuse it because it makes u feel gud ,,,same wid raagis...they feel gud.dis tradition is oncoming since 5th Guru Sri Guru Arjun Dev Ji who also used to praise raagis wid silver or gold coins.if Guruji himself did this then i dont understand why we r questioning.R u jealous that some r makin more money than u??hahaha!!If ppl giv money let them its ther wish n if raagis accept the money becus not all do,then let them.if u dont want to judge then dont be forced to judge hunah??U say u dont like to judge..im surprised u asked such a question.

Re: raagis taking money

Harcharan Singh · 09 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khasla Waheguru ji ki Fateh, As far as I know Guru Nanak Nishkam Sevak Jathaa does not pay anyone (please correct me if wrong). All seva including Kirtan/Kathaa/Building work etc is done by Nishkam sevadaars (who all hold full time jobs) or guests on a rotational system. I find this to be very inspiring as I have come accross many Kirtan singers (I only use the word Raagi/Kirtani for people who perform Guru Ji's kirtan to Guru Ji's Hukmi Raag - as the name would suggest), who I would not call "genuine". Many of these guys are not bad, but there sole reason for being a Granthi/Kirtan Singer etc is to make money (which everyone needs to do). I personally think the no 1 criteria is to want to be one with Waheguru, and trust him, he will provide (via the sangats pyaar). Sat Sri Akaal

Re: raagis taking money

. · 09 Jan 2006

doing kirtan is not a job, those who do kirtan for money will never get ras from kirtan, they have but money on the mind. they should get a proper job, then do kirtan out of prem for guruji.

Re: raagis taking money

?????????????? · 09 Jan 2006

can i just say tht its reasonable enough that raagis need to make a living in life so why cant they get a job and do keertan as a seva? im not on a mission to give them ll a bad name but aint it right that seva is a selfless service......with nothing wanted in return? if money is given as appreciation for the raagi who thereby more and more thinks of how to improve his performance.......then doensnt that make keertan a job? i disagree with most of these posts and agree with the origonal post, however a good point made is that they do ned ot make a livin. i dont object to ppl giving money.........jus to the raagis takin it. [%sig%]