Re: sakhis/stories
Gurpreet Sumra · 05 Jan 2006
gurfateh veer ji,
I dont understand the meaning "at least_____must be in guru granth sahib ji"
now about Bale wale janam sakhi says that
GURU ANGAD DEV JI HAS LEPROSY(KOD) and after this it goes to say a lot of thing.
are you being a sikh ready to admit these stories.
and as per many gurbilas one gurbilas 6win was edited by JATHEDAR VEDANTI AND AS IT WAS AGAINST GURMAT ITS PUBLICATION HAS BEEN STOPPED BY SGPC.
GURFATEH
Re: sakhis/stories
confused ... desi · 07 Jan 2006
bhai bala ji's sakhi .. he wrote sakhis of how many gurus .. i thought he was just with guru nanak devi ji ..
Re: sakhis/stories
Gurpreet Sumra · 07 Jan 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,
thats a problem , veerji, who told you this?
Dont you smell something fishy?????
Gurfateh
Re: sakhis/stories
confused ... desi · 07 Jan 2006
well .. i have come to know .. about bala sandhu .. that .. sakhis about guru angad dev ji .. that in janam sakhi bhai bala .. there is one sakhi .. in which guru angad dev ji .. got kod ..a disease ..
Re: sakhis/stories
confused ... desi · 07 Jan 2006
veerji you tell me taht sakhis from ..
bhai bala
suraj prakash granth
panth prakash granth
when i do search on them .. i get nothing .. but this taht all these three granths has myth stories but not true ..
Re: sakhis/stories
confused ... desi · 08 Jan 2006
huh?? you mean to say ... that bad things are said by vedanti ???
Re: sakhis/stories
Gurpreet Sumra · 08 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh,
Do you think bale wali janamsakhi is on www(world wide web).I dont think so.Bale wali janamsakhi goes like this:
After Guru Nanak Sahib jyoti jyot sama gaye, Bhai(?) bala came and told about Guru Nanak Sahib to Guru Angad Sahib.
My question here is
How many years bhai lehna(I have nothing to do with his life befor he became Guru) lived with Guru Nanak Dev ji?
and still he(bhai lehna who is second nanak guru angad dev ji) needs bala to tell about Guru nanak patshah!!!!!!!!
There is bani of mardana in guru granth sahib ji.where is bala???????
Now if you read properly bale wali janamsakhi it is making fun of bhai mardana ji whereever it get a chance..
Now about Jathedar Vedanti, His gurbilas patshain 6win(edited by him and Dr. Amarjit Singh) whose writer is unknown was banned by SGPC after some Sikh scholars raised questions about it being anti gurmat.
If anyone wants I can translate Vedanti's work.
Gurfateh