Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

is it right talking to bibian on msn

is it right talking to bibian on msn

singh1 · 04 Jan 2006

wjkk wjkf i wanted to know is it right talking to bibian on msn, as long it don't mean being lustful in anyway and just havin a general chat

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

sikhspirit · 04 Jan 2006

vjkkvjkf i think its ok, but wot u gonna talk about? If its sum1 you know like cousins, or sum1 from university, or even sum1 from gurdwara then am sure u can have a general chat since you can talk abt things that happened or how u are coping wiv exam stress, giving tips. Besides that i recon its gonna be all lust chattin. peace vjkkvjkf

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

Jsingh · 04 Jan 2006

It is wrong! SPend time instead doing paath and naam japna if you want to have a genral chat with someone. GurooFateh!!!!!!!

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

Gerk · 05 Jan 2006

How many times does this topic come up every month? Of course it is okay. Stop asking this question people, it's common sense.

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

hk · 05 Jan 2006

what about emailing bibiyaan?

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

singh · 05 Jan 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, from a person who never uses MSn. I never understand if people want to speak, why not just use a phone. It is much less time consuming. As far as speaking to bibian. You must recognise what is flirting and what is not? Any type of flirting behaviour is wrong for a Gursikh. Speaking to bibian is part of life, but only as sisters and brothers. Most Gursikhs minimise this contact, as per common sense. It is not just bibian, but most abyassee Gursikhs realise any idle talk to anyone is usually unhelpful. A Gursikh is beautiful, who only speaks of Naam. When we talk, talk about Naaam, Bhagti, seva and inspiration. Alot of people mention about talking to bibian, but I would say far more dangerous, is Gursikhs who eyes wander. Whether at the Gurdwara, or walking down the high street. Any Gursikh (male or female) who eyes wander continously to those of the other gender. That person will never gain contentment, and at some point in there Jeevan will fall. To think of a kurehit is just as bad as doing it. Guru Tegh Bhahdhur ji is very clear about this in his bani. Anyone whos minds wanders on to the bed of the wife of another will always fall. Rather than be regimental to stop kaam, be sincere your approach to look at minising all the things that make to fall to the vikaars. Recognise all the pitfalls, and build a strong jeevan. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

.................. · 05 Jan 2006

is it okay if guys talk to your sister freely? if you say yes, then you are really without shame and self respect.

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

... · 05 Jan 2006

let's be realistic. A lot of young Sikhs have gotten in big trouble through MSN chats. Almost all the bf/gf relationships I know of have started online. If there is something specific you want to discuss or need to ask, then of course it should be fine. If however you want to talk to the other gender for general chit-chat, most likely feelings will develop, you will get more emotionally involved and mistakes will happen. Otherwise do what you want, but if you value your spiritual jeevan, I'd say avoid chatting to the other sex.

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

Solid Singhani · 05 Jan 2006

I think this is a issue which many young boys think is a problem. Firstly it is all in your mind: if you are talking to a girl as a sister or a friend then there is no fault or problem. However if you chatting away, and u know that you are developing 'feelings'/ attachment to this person, only then does it become wrong. Because i have been in the situation where male friends of mine have decided to stop talking to all females - i think this is resonably immature-and half of the worlds population is female, u should try and control youself not run away from the problem. I also think that msn to an extent is just a dating service, where not much Sikhi is discussed.

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

Singh · 05 Jan 2006

This isn't a "small" problem. The most common serious breaches of Rehat that Amritdharis commit are nearly always Kaam related. People can't wonder why modern Sikhs have no Jeevan, when they are chit-chatting to the opposite sex, which would have been heavily frowned upon only a few decades ago in Panjab. It sounds harsh but if you can't even give up mindless chit-chat with the opposite sex or banter on internet chat for your Guru, ask yourself if you have really given your head to your Guru. Either way this type of boy-girl chit-chatting is noticed and even if the people involved don't notice it, their reputation disappears in two minutes flat. They might not even know it but they have no respect or Izzat left within the Gursikh community.

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

ks · 06 Jan 2006

why is man-woman talking/chatting looked down upon? The Gurus stressed grist jeevan, so one must find a spouse. It can be said electronic communication reduces the importance of physicality, it is all words and thus mindset and values which are displayed prominently. if instant message/email lead you to find your spouse, and nothing more comes of it before you are married, what is the big deal? It would seem, again, that this is an issue that reflects more on the user than the technology. I'm sure gursikhs said the same about phones thirty years ago.

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

Reality Check · 06 Jan 2006

This is silly, I personally dont see anything wrong with it! I know some individuals who use this program to talk about issues relating to sikhi real-time. Although I have no time for this kind of stuff since I have responsibilities and commitments, I dont see any harm in the younger generation keeping in touch with each other. I have lost contact with many friends that I would love to chat with. Had there been an oppurtunity in my day I would have taken it! Yes I do agree that things like these can also lead on to anti gurmat activites such as dating. Vijaydeep Singh had a valid point that we must fight our thoughts and run away from them by covering them with a "veil system" etc. Let's not debate about this issue since it is not very 'Tapoban' standard.

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

Reality Check · 06 Jan 2006

Sorry I meant to say we must fight our thoughts and NOT run away from them by covering them with a "veil system" etc

Re: is it right talking to bibian on msn

unreal · 06 Jan 2006

Don't talk to the opposite sex? hmmm. I wonder how much of this is cultural and how much is religious. From a guy's perspective: Can talking to girls lead to kaam? Yes, the possibility is there. Does this mean that those who don't speak to girls have no kaam? Highly unlikely - the same potential exists there as well. For example, consider Middle Eastern culture which, in many cases, forbids interaction between men and women - are the men in these cultures devoid of kaam? Is kaam less for them because they avoid talking with women? I don't think so. Closer to Punjab, consider Afghanistani/Pathani culture which strongly frowns upon/forbids male and female interaction. Logically, Pathani men should have less kaam, potential for kaam then men elsewhere. Does this mean Pathans have less kaam or potential for kaam than men in N. America? I don't think so. An argument could be made that those who avoid all contact with the opposite gender are the ones who obsess about the opposite gender the most. note: I'm not supporting this argument but it can be made. I just do not see how kaam can be eliminated or even reduced by not talking to women when the presence of women is everywhere and our minds acknowledge that presence (unless one is blind and deaf). So what is the answer? Men know that women exist - not talking to them does not wipe them clean from memory. This is an internal battle one fights whether one talks to women or not. As such, this battle requires a Sikh to remain on guard and aware of whether his thoughts are in line with Sikhi or not. Always remaining aware of this battle and the vows we take when receiving amrit is the key to winning the battle, in my opinion. That said, Sikhs should have some guidelines for themselves. There is no point in writing out a concrete "Yes and No" list of what is allowed/disallowed - suffice it to say, you are a son of Guru Gobind Singh ji and your interaction with anyone, including women should reflect that. Anything you would be embarrassed of saying in front of your Guru, you probably shouldn't be saying to anyone else either. my two cents, unreal