Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

suicide wrong or right?

suicide wrong or right?

?? · 04 Jan 2006

is suicde wrong or right?? just a random question ?? suicide due to depresson or heard life i agree is wrong but what about people like dilavir singh he blew himself up 2 get rid off chief minsiter beanteh???

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Chi Chi · 04 Jan 2006

u joker!!! what Bhai Dilavar Singh jee wasnt suicide it was shaheedi!!! clear difference!! but suicide is rong!!

Re: suicide wrong or right?

? · 04 Jan 2006

suicide is never right, blowing youreself up is suicide suicide is mahapaap, ppl who blew themselves up are not shaheed.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2006

suicide is a massive sin. those who commit suicide will certainly not be liberated.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

uksingh · 05 Jan 2006

How about all the Sikhs that ingested cyanide to prevent being captured by GOI in the 90's? Was this suicide acceptable?

Re: suicide wrong or right?

to ? · 05 Jan 2006

so dalavar singh jee wasnt shaheed??

Re: suicide wrong or right?

. · 05 Jan 2006

suicide is paap, its against gods will to take youre own life, suicide cant be called shaheed

Re: suicide wrong or right?

? · 05 Jan 2006

just as those who cut their hair to carry out missions cannot be called shaheed, you cannot call those who blew themselves up to complete a mission or prevent torure shaheed.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Aman UK · 05 Jan 2006

nothing wrong with wanting to die... kabeer muhi maranae kaa chaao hai maro th har kai dhuaar || - Kabeer, I am anxious to die; let me die at the Lord's Door. math har pooshhai koun hai paraa hamaarai baar ||61|| - I hope that the Lord does not ask, ""Who is this, lying at my door?""||61|| kabeer marathaa marathaa jag muaa mar bh n jaanai koe || - Kabeer, the world is dying - dying to death, but no one knows how to truly die. aisee maranee jo marai bahur n maranaa hoe ||1|| - Whoever dies, let him die such a death, that he does not have to die again. ||1|| [%sig%]

Re: suicide wrong or right?

000 · 05 Jan 2006

bhai dalivir singh was a suicide bomber he blew himself up to kill a pappi he may hve cut his beard and stuff but he wasnt a sikh cuz of dat maybe u cud call him a sedghdhari? sometimes in order to do good u need 2 do bad he may not have got into sachkhand but he did sacrfice himself against the injustice of the india goverment

Re: suicide wrong or right?

akjukute · 06 Jan 2006

aman uk, the shabad you have quoted you have not understood, and as a result have misinterpreted it. the shabad is referring to being dead while still alive- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- aasaa bheethar rehai niraasaa tho naanak eaek milai ||4|| In the midst of hope, remain untouched by hope; then, O Nanak, you shall meet the One Lord. ||4|| ein bidhh saagar thareeai || In this way, you shall cross over the world-ocean. jeevathiaa eio mareeai ||1|| rehaao dhoojaa ||3|| THIS IS THE WAY TO REMAIN DEAD WHILE YET ALIVE. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- the door is the door to sachkand, where ones soul reunites with god -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- jith dhar vasehi kavan dhar keheeai dharaa bheethar dhar kavan lehai || Where is that door, where You live, O Lord? What is that door called? Among all doors, who can find that door? jis dhar kaaran firaa oudhaasee so dhar koee aae kehai ||1|| For the sake of that door, I wander around sadly, detached from the world; if only someone would come and tell me about that door. ||1|| kin bidhh saagar thareeai || How can I cross over the world-ocean? jeevathiaa neh mareeai ||1|| rehaao || While I am living, I cannot be dead. ||1||Pause|| dhukh dharavaajaa rohu rakhavaalaa aasaa a(n)dhaesaa dhue patt jarrae || Pain is the door, and anger is the guard; hope and anxiety are the two shutters. maaeiaa jal khaaee paanee ghar baadhhiaa sath kai aasan purakh rehai ||2|| Maya is the water in the moat; in the middle of this moat, he has built his home. The Primal Lord sits in the Seat of Truth. ||2|| ki(n)thae naamaa a(n)th n jaaniaa thum sar naahee avar harae || You have so many Names, Lord, I do not know their limit. There is no other equal to You. oochaa nehee kehanaa man mehi rehanaa aapae jaanai aap karae ||3|| Do not speak out loud - remain in your mind. The Lord Himself knows, and He Himself acts. ||3|| jab aasaa a(n)dhaesaa thab hee kio kar eaek kehai || As long as there is hope, there is anxiety; so how can anyone speak of the One Lord? aasaa bheethar rehai niraasaa tho naanak eaek milai ||4|| In the midst of hope, remain untouched by hope; then, O Nanak, you shall meet the One Lord. ||4|| ein bidhh saagar thareeai || In this way, you shall cross over the world-ocean. jeevathiaa eio mareeai ||1|| rehaao dhoojaa ||3|| This is the way to remain dead while yet alive.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Prabhjoyt singh · 06 Jan 2006

"just as those who cut their hair to carry out missions cannot be called shaheed, you cannot call those who blew themselves up to complete a mission or prevent torure shaheed." I would like to see you hack the torture and then maybe your comments could be justified otherwise dont write such crap like this.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

H · 07 Jan 2006

im not sure. see these people who cut their hair and give up their dharam for their own aim, i find wrong. what is wrong with going out as they are and then being shaheed. and if giving up their dharam should be the extreme that they need to go, shouldn't they think twice before committing to their mission? i jus find it against the whole point of the rela shaheeds such as bhai taru ji, bhai mati das, bhai sati das, all the singhnian at mian mir's jail, and our beloved guru's, Guru Arjan Dev Ji and Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji. i've never heard of any of these sikhs ever giving up their dharam to hide from their enemy and strike them from the back. these are souls i regard as shaheeds, true shaheeds! bhul chuk maaf

Re: suicide wrong or right?

? · 07 Jan 2006

prabhjoyt singh-I would like to see you hack the torture and then maybe your comments could be justified otherwise dont write such crap like this. ....................................................................................................................... if im not prepared to accept gods will, even if it means torture i will not get involved in such activities. if you know you cant hack torture, stay at home. suicide is mahapaap, and by commiting it you will be taking steps back, away from god, therefore away from goal of life, therefore against gurmat.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

akjukute · 07 Jan 2006

jaa ko har ra(n)g laago eis jug mehi so keheeath hai sooraa || He alone is called a warrior, who is attached to the Lord's Love in this age. ----------------------- those who attached to nam, have no fear, and suffer no pain (eg) - Bhai Anokh Singh Babbar, who assasinated gobind ram. gobind ram tortured and killed many singhs/singhnees, he urinated in bowls and said drink amrit of gobind ram. on the 20th of august 1987 bhai sahib was arrested and taken into custody, his legs were torn apart, pins were hammered into his heels up through his legs, and also through his chest. his abdomen was ripped open and pins placed through his groin area, through which electric shocks were given. Both his eyeballs were gouged out. Throughout these immense tortures bhai sahib uttered not a single sound of pain, he remained absorbed in nam, and repeated continuously waheguru, waheguru. after an one evening of torture bhai sahib did rehras, and then the following ardas "akal prakh sucha patshah guru nanak dev gareeb nivaaj satguru, the day has which rose in your bhaanaa has passed in happiness, meditating on your name. Suchay patshah night has arrived may it too pass while remembering your name, and in your bhaanaa satguru, may i be shaheed...sucha patshah, save me from becoming a traitor.........satguru, may the sikhi and kesh you have given me last with me till my final breaths..sucha patshah have mercy on all..bolaay so nihaal sat sri akaal!!" after hearing this the sentry on guard became disturbed and handed in his resignation immediatly. his tortures continued, bhai sahib did not once stop repeating naam, and continually thanked waheguru, in acceptance of bhaanaa.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

raj_karega_khalsa · 07 Jan 2006

Bhaee Sahib, what you are saying is that EVERY SINGLE Shaheed who ever gave their lives for Sikhee did paap, went against gods will and rnt rilly Shaheeds.... Every Shaheed had a CHOICE. Die or defend justice, protect dharam. THey accepted death, they died, they chose their death, when they could have survived, so what they did was suicide :S Shaheedee is a CHOICE. Suicide is a CHOICE. i dunno, maybe i just completely confused you and didnt make sense at all...but wut im tryna say is that, Shaheedee is like suicide... but its a suicide defending justice you kno wut im sayin? Bhull Chuk maph

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 07 Jan 2006

Bete, that dying, which Kabeer Ji has referred and compiled by Guru Arjun Dev Ji, in Guru Granth Sahib ji, has no relevance with Suicide. Kabeer Ji, is talking about the killing of your ego and surrendering before Almighty. Please make clear, for details, contact: Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 07 Jan 2006

If you commit suicide, you have to remain in the cosmos till you complete the total time, alloted for your body by the Ultimate, because you go against His act. After commiting suicide you (means your soul) want to remain in the cosmos, or better, to recite Gurbani and GURMUKH JANAM SAWAR DARGEIH CHALIAA you want to reach unto his Darbar? it is upto you. details? contact: Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]

Re: suicide wrong or right?

? · 09 Jan 2006

shaheed is not choice, you become shaheed when god wills it, you may not fall on the battlefield. you dont decide to become a shaheed, you become shaheed if god wills so, like with bhai anokh singh ji above, he did not commit suicide, his intientions were to destroy evil, do justice, uproot tyranny, and in fighting for such things he became shaheed, this is gods will what wouldnt be according to gods will is deciding for your self when you die, so if bhai sahib ran into the police station and blew himself up, that is suicide. when a warrior goes out to battle, he has victory, and pleasing guru on his mind, a warriors aim is to uproot tyranny, his aim is not to kill himself. if he dies in battle according to gods sweet will, so be it, he will be shaheed, this isnt suicide because he wasnt plannig to kill himself, he was planning to kill the enemy, but died in the process.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Bhopinder Singh · 09 Jan 2006

Bhai Dilavar Singh is shaheed . So are countless others who died for Sikh freedom ,had we as society given them proper sikhi understanding they would have done all that ,they did what they could under the given circumstances .Let us leave it up to Guru sahib as whether he accepts them or not ,worry about yourself and do naam jap.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Bhopinder Singh · 09 Jan 2006

Shaheed is derived from the word shahdat which means witness theirfore shaheeds are witness to tyranny and there deaths become shahadat As for Bhai Dilawar singh ji his turning point was EQUATING BEANT SINGH WITH GURU NANAK AND GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ina a open pandal gathering by one of the touts andwhichBeant Singh never refuted, then he compared him to Gurus for ending freedom struggle of sikhs .Bhai sahib was very upset about it as much as he knew about sikhi he was sure nobody can be equated to guru sahib and that is also hukam of guru sahib. Those lines prompted him todo what he did ,it is well known and even written by him.How could he be equall to guru he said never and never .He made him pay for that comarison and set precedent for future sikhs and there enemies .He embodied the sikh defiance to even die but never except such degradation of there gurus.It makes us sikhs proud and our enemies fearfull for they may fight us in battles and anybody could win or loose but such cowardice will never go unpunished and he stands witness to that.There were many sikhs in that function of Beant and yes Bhai Dilawar singh stood out in the crowd and is indeed Shaheed.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Prabhjoyt singh · 10 Jan 2006

"Bhai Anokh Singh Babbar, who assasinated gobind ram. gobind ram tortured and killed many singhs/singhnees, he urinated in bowls and said drink amrit of gobind ram." Acctualy Bhai Anokh singh didnt kill gobind ram it was Bhai Jugraj singh toofaan

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Jasmin · 10 Jan 2006

If you kill yourself deliberately, thats suicide. If you die in battle, or someone tortures you to death you are a Shaheed. Totally different.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

some geeza · 11 Jan 2006

so u wudnt call dalavar singh babbar shaheed then??? parnam shaheda nu!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Re: suicide wrong or right?

. · 12 Jan 2006

no some geeza i wouldnt.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

stranger · 12 Jan 2006

so Great Shaheeds like Udham Singh are not Sikhs cos they cut their hair. You who say they are not sikhs and not shaheeds are a bunch of jokers. These great people paid the ultimate price - gave up their lives for the greater cause. How many of you are willing to do that? It is easy to sit in your comfortable chairs and write these long posts trying to be judges of those of gave their lives up for you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Disgusting and disgraceful attitude

Re: suicide wrong or right?

jugroop singh · 12 Jan 2006

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, maybe we're simplifying things a bit too much... taking your own life because you feel crap, have lots of problems or 'hate God' is one thing - that's a cop-out; it's suicide plain and simple. this we are all agreed is against GurMat. however, the disagreement lies over whether or not 'knowingly' carrying out acts which will lead to your death whilst pursuing a panthic cause is suicide or not. one example is detonating a bomb in order to kill a dusht, knowing you will also die as a result of the explosion. the GurSikh does this because s/he feels there is no other strategy which will enable them to eliminate a particular dusht...so it is a last resort. some will class this as the same type of suicide i defined earlier whilst others will see it as something different...they will see it as Kurbani - sacrificing one's own life 'knowingly', as a last resort, for a greater good. to my understanding, this is certainly nothing like a cop-out suicide...i think it's a form of Shaheedi and my heart tells me that SatGuru Ji must have immense love for those GurSikhs who are willing to make such a sacrifice. it is a complex issue though - maybe i am wrong. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Bhopinder Singh · 12 Jan 2006

Bhai Dilavar singh used the ultimate weapon in mordern conventional warfare ,sharpened by the likes of Jagtar singh Hawara the perfect combination of Babbars from top to bottom,really worth the effort . He fought for indeendent Sikh homeland ,directly affecting us sikhs. Although many claimed the action to be theirs but, Paramjit singh Panjwar was the first to say its Babbars and later the truth was known to the whole world. Similarly the action of Gobind ram was done by Babbars .Never had it anything to do with Bhai Toofan singh shaheed although not Bhai Anokh SINGH Shaeed but,had the direct invovment of the high command of Babbars was discolosed by the DGP of Punjab police two days after the action.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Prabhjoyt Singh · 12 Jan 2006

Bhai Jugraj Singh Toofaan actualy caried out the attack you can read it for yourself its on this site.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

kirsty · 13 Jan 2006

suicide is wrong why take your live when ther is so much to accomplish only god can take your live as he is your creator!!!

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Ravinder Singh · 13 Jan 2006

Palestinian militants and other Muslim extremists commit suicide because they blow up innocent people (on a bus, in a nightclub or wherever it is easy to carry out mass murder). Gursikhs like shaheed Bhai Dilaver Singh Babbar are the true shaheeds of this world hand picked by Guru Sahib himself because they blow up mass murderers like Beanta, not innocent people.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

jugroop singh · 14 Jan 2006

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, the point raised by Veer Ravinder Singh Ji is important. whereas many Muslims may believe that collateral damage e.g. the death of innocent bystanders is acceptable because a 'greater good' is being pursued, GurSikh Jujharoos have consistently shown that their ideals were much higher. for instance, i don't imagine that the GurSikhs who did the Seva of eliminating gobind ram took any pleasure from the fact that his young son was also killed during the operation...in fact i imagine they had merciful thoughts after realising what had happened...but such is Bhana... if a Singh were to carry-out a so-called 'suicide bombing', i imagine that they would do their utmost at the planning-stage to ensure that innocent bystanders were not harmed. this is in contrast to Muslim suicide-bombers whose aim it is to kill as many innocent bystanders as possible to make their point. so there are MAJOR DIFFERENCES between the principles that inform GurSikhs when they are doing this particular form of Seva when compared to a run-of-the mill MunMukh terrorist. perhaps certain Sakhis can shed more light upon what is considered suicide and what is not as far as GurMat is concerned... for instance, when the original Mahaan Panj Piyaarae offered their heads knowing they would get them chooped-off, was that not virtual suicide? when the Singhs flocked towards Siree Guru Sahib Ji's gun to allow Him the chance to test it, was that not virtual suicide? when the Singhs and Singhnian lied down on the railway tracks around one-hundred years ago, knowing they would be crushed to death by the oncoming train, was that not virtual suicide? let's also consider hunger strikes - for instance, what if Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh's demands in prison hadn't been met and he had to remain for more than 40 days without food - let's say he left his mortal body on the 60th day in VahiGuru's Bhana...would that have been 'suicide'? my point is that to knowingly allow your death to take place as a last resort, in pursuit of GurMat-inspired justice and ideals, does not seem the same to me as suicide..the former shows courage, fortitude, determination, a sense of pure sacrifice etc. whilst the latter is about giving-up, blaming circumstances, not accepting the nature of Dhukh and Sukh etc. i also think that despite how much we may be inspired by the likes of Udham Singh, the fact remains that Siree Guru Sahib Ji cannot be entirely pleased with such sacrifices because we know He loves Rehit more than individuals. some may find this hard to accept but it is the plain truth - Siree Guru Sahib Ji wants us to remain always as Khalsa no matter what kind of difficulties may be encountered whilst carrying out Seva. this is perhaps why BKI were blessed with the Seva of taking-out so many dushts - their entrance requirements included a strict empasis upon Khalsa Rehit...because this allows Seva to become truly Parvaan. it would be good if the learned GurSikh Veers who regularly post on this forum join the thread and share their GurMat-inspired veechar. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: suicide wrong or right?

LionKing (LK) · 14 Jan 2006

Everyones goign around screaming Suicide in mahapap and so on. If it is a Mahapap why doesn't Guru Ji mention it? As we know suicide is more prevalent now than before - was Guru Ji stupid? Did he not know that suicide would ecome more prevalent? I feel, that he did, but allowed it to stay a gray area. He did nto make it black and whitelike islam and Christianity. Guru Ji knew everything - so why didn't he make it black and white - perhaps it was his hukam to allow it to remain a gray area? Just spectating.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

akjukute · 14 Jan 2006

deciding when your life ends is playing god, that is why it is paap no matter what the circumstances. ppl who commit suicide will only have to be reborn, for going directly against gods will. we fight tyranny in name of faith, to have the right to practice our religion/ principles going against faith/ principle in order to kill the enemy defies the whole point of shaheed. you yourself have commited an act which you are supposed to be fighting to prevent.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Harjas Kaur · 14 Jan 2006

A soldier is willing to die in combat. He gives up his selfishness to do this. He can act for evil or good, depending on which forces he obeys. If he is following Guruji's hukum, and defending the oppressed against injustice, he is acting in a selfless way as a force for good. If he is shaheed, he burns away karam by completely selfless act. If someone is oppressed by evil thoughts, like depression. He is suffering karam, and perhaps even under influence of bad entities. Often drugs or alcohol or evil people are involved. If evil spirits influence him to harm himself, he is under their influence. They are evil, so is his thinking. Where do you think he will go when he dies? If someone suffered terribly, and has great sorrow and pain and is depressed from these sufferings and chooses not to live, he has to answer to Guruji for pain he causes those who love him. His act is selfish. It is wrong, but not necessarily under evil influence. Everything has many variables. Only Guruji is the judge. It could be someone who suffered and kills himself can receive great mercy. It can be someone who was a shaheed actually did evil things like injustice and may be dealt with harshly. All the factors, circumstance and motivation determine rightness and wrongness. Basically if you act out of selfishness and turn away from your family and Guruji's hukum, you are doing wrong. You can get lost or be under evil influence. If you are acting out of selfless motives, even offering up your own life as a sacrifice to save others from evil, and this is Guruji's hukum for Khalsa, then your soul is blessed, your family is blessed, your community is blessed. One act brings suffering, another rejoicing. [%sig%]

Re: suicide wrong or right?

Ranvir · 14 Jan 2006

What about Udham and Bhagat Singh? Were they Shaheed? They cut their hair so that they could infiltrate the British and kill their leaders.

Re: suicide wrong or right?

... · 14 Jan 2006

There is a Shahid according to the Sikh definition and then there are Shahids in general who die for a cause. I don't find Udham Singh or Bhagat Singh to be Shahids in the Sikh definition. They gave a massive sacrifice but a Sikh Shahid is one who does not compromise Sikhi. Suicide is defintely not acceptable in Sikhi. The line most commonly used is [gurbani] Awqm GwqI hY jgq ksweI ][/gurbani]