Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

curious · 03 Jan 2006

wjkk wjkf i was just wondering if it is ok for a non-amritdhari to read guru granth sahib ji. and if it is wrong then what is the difference in a non-amritdhari reading paath from a gutka rather than guru sahib? bhul chuk maaf

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

d · 03 Jan 2006

OMG.THIS IS MADNESS.yes of course non-amritdharis can read gurugranthsahib ji..

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

NimaaNa Daas · 03 Jan 2006

OMG! Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee = JAGAT GUROO (Guru of the WORLD!!!!)

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

... · 04 Jan 2006

A non-amritdhari cannot sit in taabiya/hazoori of Guru Sahib. He is free to read from a gutka however if proper respect is given. Only tyar-bar-tyar Khalsa can sit in taabiya/hazoori of Guru Sahib. This is a special position. Only a Khalsa can be the attendant of Guru Sahib.

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Jan 2006

There are two aspects to "reading"....one is for PRIVATE..and one is for PUBLIC. In PUBLIC..Diwan samagam etc ONLY an AMRITDHAREE Tyar bar tyaar Khalsa can READ Guru Garanth ji...take Hukm, vaak, etc. That is Akal Takhat maryada. IN PRIVATE..anyone can read....he/she can be Muslim/christian/chinese...

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

Balpreet Singh · 04 Jan 2006

Gyani jee, I'm afraid I have to disagree with you on this one. I don't think that a non-amritdhari can sit in attendance of Guru Sahib. Before, sitting in attendance was a very big deal. You are probably aware of the ceremony of "charni lagana" which has disappeared now, where a young Sikh was very formally allowed for the first time to read from Guru Sahib in taabiyia. A non-amritdhari is probably not aware of the proper maryada to sit in taabiya (maryada of clean clothes, total ishnaan, etc.). It is not according to proper respect to allow a smoker or drinker to sit in taabiya either in private or public. Non-Sikhs can certainly read from pothis and listen to divaans, but the level of respect accorded to Guru Granth Sahib jee must be a level higher than this.

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

bgt · 09 Jan 2006

daas has received pahul dee daat. but would still feel uncomfortable reading from Maharaj in sangat or even at home as I feel I haven't been taught how to respect Guru Sahib to the fullest. i know i would try to give the most maximum amount of respect and cleaniliness according to my 'own matt' but I would not want to risk it as my matt would definately not be up to standard of tyar-bar-tyar Khalsa who woudl have learnt how to accord the maximum amount of respect. so for a non-Khalsa to deliver baani from Guru Sahib to sangat would definately seem inappropriate. a non-Khalsa doing so at home should also recognise that he may not be according Guru Sahib the amount of respect Akaal Purkh's form would deserve. it should be noted, though, that the current Akal Takhat maryada accepts non-Khalsa reading from Guru Sahib for themselves but not in sangat.

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 09 Jan 2006

Chinese, Muslims and Hindus, they are already reading, whereas, Sikhs are RECITING Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Reciting for us HELPS US to be more attached to SGGS Ji and seek His blessings. Time is changing, let the message of Guru Sahiban reach to all communities and countries, for the sake of generation to come. Please be broad minded and agree to recite SGGS ji, to those Sikhs, who are coming on the track. Please. They will learn full respect in the short span. Otherwise, they may run away from Sikhism!!! for details contact: Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

a kaka · 09 Jan 2006

i agree balpreeet singh jee.

Re: non-amritdharis reading guru granth sahib

stranger · 10 Jan 2006

So if only Amritdhari - Singhs are allowed to read from the SGGG Ji then where do translations stand?????