Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"Those who slander SANTS will be...."

"Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Whose a True Sant?? · 03 Jan 2006

Sant Kee Ninda Nanaka… Sunday 1st January, 2006 Panthic Weekly Staff Columnist [i]Sant Kee Ninda Nanaka…[/i] [gurbani]ਸੰਤ ਕੀ ਨਿੰਦਾ ਨਾਨਕਾ ਬਹੁਰਿ ਬਹੁਰਿ ਅਵਤਾਰ ॥੧॥[/gurbani] [i]sant kee nindaa naankaa, bahur bahur avtar. ||1||[/i] “One who slanders the Saints, O Nanak, shall be reincarnated over and over again. ||1||” (GauRee, Ang 279, SGGS) Today, as we look around us, we see as many Sadhs and Sants as there are car models. Everywhere you look there is [i]“Sant Baba…. 108,” “Mahapursh Brahmgyani….,” “Karneewalé Baba Ji…”[/i] May God help us all! When a Pakhandi (fake) Sadh, Sant or Baba is exposed for his crimes of rape, abuse, theft, drug-trafficking, distorting Gurbani or misleading thousands of ignorant and vulnerable men and women to stray away from the Guru Granth & Guru Panth, these "Saadhs" and "Sants" accuse those who discover their nefarious deeds of “slandering the Saints.” Off their tongues roll the Gurbani lines of: [gurbani]ਸੰਤ ਕੀ ਨਿੰਦਾ ਨਾਨਕਾ ਬਹੁਰਿ ਬਹੁਰਿ ਅਵਤਾਰ ॥੧॥[/gurbani] “One who slanders the Saints, O Nanak, shall be reincarnated over and over again. ||1||” (GauRee, Ang 279, SGGS) But who made these people “Sants”? Who is to say that they are Saints? Immediately, upon being found out by the sangat of degrading conduct, these so-called "sants" spout this Gurbani line on cue to give them cover from people witnessing the truth of their misdeeds. Due to our own ignorance of the true meaning of Gurbani, we are not able to distinguish who is a true “Sant” and a true “Maha-purakh” (True or Great Being). As a result of our self-inflicted ignorance and lack of connection with the True Guru, we take every man dressed in a white chola (dress) and white dastar (turban) on face value and accept him as a “Sant” without ever trying to find out if he is worthy of the label. May God help us all! If we read Gurbani, He speaks to us directly and the Guru says: [gurbani]ਹਰਿ ਕਾ ਸੰਤੁ ਸਤਗੁਰੁ ਸਤ ਪੁਰਖਾ, ਜੋ ਬੋਲੈ ਹਰਿ ਹਰਿ ਬਾਨੀ ॥ ਜੋ ਜੋ ਕਹੈ ਸੁਣੈ ਸੋ ਮੁਕਤਾ, ਹਮ ਤਿਸ ਕੈ ਸਦ ਕੁਰਬਾਨੀ ॥੧॥ [/gurbani] “The True Guru is the Lord's “Sant” (Saint), the Guru is the Mahapurakh (True Being), who speaks the Bani (Divine Word) of the Lord, Har, Har. Whoever reads this Bani, and listens to it, is liberated from sin. I am forever a sacrifice to that Guru. ||1||” (Dhanaasree, Ang 667, SGGS) Whenever a “Baba” or “Sant” is caught in a sticky situation, he will typically choose to remain quiet and have his followers make press statements representing the Baba by saying [i]“Our Baba is not like that… anyone who slanders him will go to hell… Baba Ji is innocent.”[/i] If the Pakhandi “Baba” or “Sant” is so truly innocent or at least repentent, then why is it that every time someone witnesses with their eyes the truth about the crimes and misdeeds he has committed, he remains quiet and has his followers defend him rather then coming clean. If Tony Blair goes to war against Iraq or does something which the public find objectionable, then Mr. Blair goes in front of the public to honestly clarify his position. Tony Blair or any leader in any democratic state is accountable to the public. They have to justify their position and apologise to the public. However, it seems the so-called “Saadhs,” “Sants,” and “Babé”, postitioning themselves as repositors of Gurmat and supposed stalwarts of moral authority, are not accountable to anyone, whether it be to individuals of the Sadh Sangat or to the body corporate, Guru Khalsa Panth. May God help us all! When a "Baba" is accused of committing sexual misconduct with a woman from his Dera (camp/dwelling), and instead of him truthfully clarifying to the sangat whether the statement is true or false, instead of him defending himself or on moral grounds apologising, instead of holding himself accountable to the Sadh Sangat, the following familliar scenario again takes place; Baba keeps quiet and his followers bark at those who say that “Baba” should be arrested and tried in court. Why are these Pakhandi Babé or Sants very rarely arrested in India? Is it perhaps because the police, government officials, and politicians are their followers, support them in some way, or that they get their helping of blessings from the “Baba.” Their enablers hand them what is comparable to a “get out of jail free” card one gets in the game of Monopoly. May God help us all! What does Guru Ji tell us? [gurbani]ਛੋਡਿ ਛੋਡਿ ਰੇ ਪਾਖੰਡੀ ਮਨ ਕਪਟੁ ਨ ਕੀਜੈ ॥ ਹਰਿ ਕਾ ਨਾਮੁ ਨਿਤ ਨਿਤਹਿ ਲੀਜੈ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ [/gurbani] “O pakhandi (hypocrite), renounce and abandon your hypocrisy; do not practice deception. Constantly, continually, chant the Name of Waheguru. ||1||Pause||” (Raamkali, Ang 973, SGGS) How many “Sants” supported the Dharam Yudh Morcha? How many “Sants” helped to defend the Panth from attacks from the government supported cults and Deras like Nirankaris etc.? How many “Sants” exemplified the Saint-Soldier character of the Khalsa and fought for justice, fear putting themselves on the line or at times being arrested and being martyred upholding their principles and defending the innocent and downtrodden? There are only a handful of these great people who are not saints by the mere clothes they wear, but by their actions. I remember listening to Katha (discourse) delivered by a great Gursikh of the name Giani Baba Kartar Singh Ji from Jatha Bhindra(n). Baba Ji recognised that when Bhai Makhan Shah Ji went to discover where the True Guru (i.e. Guru Tegh Bahadar Ji) resided in the village of Bakala, 22 people claimed to be the Guru. Nowadays there are not 22 people claiming to be “Sants” and self-proclaimed Satgurus, but instead they are in the thousands. Giani Baba Kartar Singh Ji Bhindranwale said that the litmus test to identify a true Sant (saint) is that he or she will never call themselves a “Sant” and will always remain in humility. Furthermore, he said the litmus test of Gurmat is Gurbani. If someone joins people to himself and not to the Guru and Naam, then he is a fake. It is no surprise that during the Dharam Yudh Morcha initiated by Giani Baba Kartar Singh Ji Bhindranwale and led by Shaheed Giani Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale, all the fake Sants and Babé climbed back into their holes and kept a low a profile. Since the mid 1990s, the pakhandi Sant trade flourished to such an extent that they even made a trade union called “Sant Samaj”. Not only do rikshaw drivers and train-workers have a trade-union, but nowadays our white-clothed friends who are driven by Maya and power, have a trade-union which rushes to support them in case, for example, someone rightly accuses one of their members of rape, abuse, sexual misconduct, theft or drug-smuggling. May God help us all! Once Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji was out in the fields with his Sikhs. One Sikh noticed a huge snake coming Guru Sahib’s way. He moved to kill him but Guru Sahib stopped him from doing so. When the snake came near Guru Sahib, Guru Sahib touched the snake with his lotus foot. With the divine and sacred touch of Guru Sahib’s lotus foot, the snake instantly died and his skin opened up. The Sangat was surprised to see that the snake had a lot of worms around and inside of it. The Sikhs asked Guru Sahib what this was all about. Guru Sahib told the Sangat that the snake was a pakhandi (fake) Guru in his previous life. He had a large following and had promised salvation to all of them. Since he was a fake and profited from vulnerable people’s money and offerings, he got the life of a snake in the next life, and all his followers became the insects that were eating up the snake. Guru Sahib said the soul of the fake Guru regretted his past life and thanked Guru Sahib for freeing him from this terrible hell. [gurbani]ਨਾਰਾਇਨ ਨਰਪਤਿ ਨਮਸਕਾਰੈ ॥ ਐਸੇ ਗੁਰ ਕਉ ਬਲਿ ਬਲਿ ਜਾਈਐ ਆਪਿ ਮੁਕਤੁ ਮੋਹਿ ਤਾਰੈ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥[/gurbani] “The one who bows in humble reverence to the Primal Lord, the Lord of all beings – I am a sacrifice, a sacrifice to such a Guru. He Himself is liberated, and He carries me across as well. ||1||Pause||” (KanRa, Ang 1301, SGGS) The True Guru practically demonstrated to the Sikhs that the ones who follows these so called “Sants”, “Babé” and self-proclaimed “Satgurus” will become the insects who will feed off their so called Sants. Gurbani says: [gurbani]ਗੁਰੂ ਜਿਨਾ ਕਾ ਅੰਧੁਲਾ ਚੇਲੇ ਨਾਹੀ ਠਾਉ ॥ ਬਿਨੁ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਨਾਉ ਨ ਪਾਈਐ ਬਿਨੁ ਨਾਵੈ ਕਿਆ ਸੁਆਉ ॥ ਆਇ ਗਇਆ ਪਛੁਤਾਵਣਾ ਜਿਉ ਸੁੰਞੈ ਘਰਿ ਕਾਉ ॥੩॥ [/gurbani] “Those chelé, those devotees, whose spiritual teacher is blind, shall not find their place of rest. Without the True Guru, the Name is not obtained. Without Naam, the Name, what is the use of it all? People come and go, regretting and repenting, like crows in a deserted house. ||3||” (Siri Raag, Ang 57, SGGS) Let us all make a resolution that we will never consider anyone other than Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji to be our savior. We should give utmost respect to the Gursikhs of true conduct and listen to their consul, but we should have expectations of salvation only from Guru Sahib. A true Gursikh will never pose as a “Maha-purakh”, “Sant” or “Brahmgyani”. The Editors can be reached [address removed]

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Prabhjoyt singh · 03 Jan 2006

Pleases can you refer to true sants, such as Sant Jarnail Singh ji khalsa Bhindrawale, Sant Gurbachan Singh ji khalsa Bhindrawale and Sant Kartar Singh ji khalsa Bhindrawale with the Sant title efore their names. PS: who is the first guy and fifth guy in that picture?

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

indy · 03 Jan 2006

singhji that post was kinda long

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

singh · 03 Jan 2006

a very well written article. straight to the point.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Singh · 03 Jan 2006

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA. Is that Groovy Harneck in the picture?

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

singh · 03 Jan 2006

wjkk wjkf they are very rare to find sants, they come to earth 4 a purpose send by god. to do parchar, and re light that sikh spirit which the sikhs loose, through various reasons. one perfect exmple of a brahmgyani was sant baba thakur singh ji.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jan 2006

well written and to the point. Congrats to the Pan thic weekly Staff...at last we have a good panthic publication that is not afraid to tell the TRUTH...the Whole Truth and nothing but the Brutal Truth. The "First" THUGGH in the picture is the Burunddee Wallah Amroo nanaksaria..the 13th NANAK..according to his NARKEE CHELAS who wrote the famous.."Mere laal ji letters to a lover in Toronto and the publication of which led to his banning from Malaysia/Singapore...... third one is manna pehova who has been disowned by the Rarra Sahib dera ...the fifth one i also dont know but he looks like virsa of gobind sadan....and the last one is of course narinder Narkee of Toronto ( now in UK under Gurmukhs@yahoo)..and fourth...there is chicago wallah narkee baba just recently exposed having extramarital fun in a motel.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

S Singh · 04 Jan 2006

Number two looks like Hardev Su head of the naraqtharis.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

khalistani · 05 Jan 2006

before u say which of these "sants" fought in 84, it was a sant tha led the fight sant jarnail singh je andf now some people are gonna tell me sant je didnt belive in other sbeing called sant no sant je himself called sant baba gurbachan singh je 108 brahm giani sant gurbachan singh je sant je only said not to call me a sant, call me a DOG our of nimratha they having said this instead of looking at pakhandees y dont u look at the tru jems y not make a post on sant nand singh je, sant ishar singh rara sahib, sant ishar singh je nanaksar, sant attar singh je mustuana wale, sant baba thakur singh je, sant jarnail singh je, this line gos on forever of great gurmukhs and if u gopnna say sant je is only guru je, this is a lie, guru je called bhagath namdev je a sant, showing tha a sant is not guur je a brahm giani is also not guur je, as shown in sukhmanee sahib where it says GOD CREATES brahm gianis godcreates them, he is not one he is supreme, beyond everything its through VAHEGUURS kirpa one can reach these avasthas like gurmukhs such as sant jarnail singh, baba nand singh je, baba ishar singh je, bhai randheer singh je, sant atthar singh je have all attained i think the post is to expose the FAKE sants AND THUGS out there like how bhagath kabir je descirbes beneares ke thugs, fake sants on the outside, with darkness on the inside like cranes, pretending to do bhagthee, but inside have completly different thoughts, not on akaal a post like tha is a greeat post for today its a problem, we think ANYONES sant as long as they got the look but at the same time, when exposing fakes, never forget tha theres alwyas the real deal out there who come to save this world, as sent by guru je whoo come to inspire us to jaap naam, and who help us to better ourselves on our sikhi path but i thinkt he post was a really good post, it made no nindya of real sants, jus exposed the fake ones im not sayin anything agasint this post jus in case people start sayin o well see guru je is the only sant, dont cause its jus untrue but this post is right we shud b careful of these fake saviours guru granth sahib je is the supreme guru, beyond all everything they are the ones who GIVE naam to sants, and they r the controllers and creators of everything and again i say tha i dunt see any sant nindya in this article, or nindya of gurmukhs, and i think it was well written im jus sayin dontpost other posts sayin well there u have it, all sant hasve been exposed, etc. as the uusual thing for these kinds of threads bhula chuka maf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 06 Jan 2006

vjkk, vjkf pleassssssseeeeeeeeeee.........pleeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaasssssseeeeeeee STOP CALLING ANYONE SANTTTTTTTT......I DON'T CARE WHO IT IS....DOES MATTER BECAUSE....in Gurbani, the word Sant in singular form is refered to GURU JEE, and in plural form is refered to SADH SANGAT (SANGAT)......ok so please i don't care who your talking about, there is only 1 and only 1 sant living today and that is Sree Guru Granth Sahib Jee..... You can call someone, Bhai, Bibi, Bhai Sahib, Baba, and even Gyani, but never Sant cause only 1 sant is living today and that is Sree Guru Granth Sahib Jee but don't get me wrong..i'm not saying i don't respect Baba Jarnail Singh Jee, etc.... I'm saying is you can call him baba (in the olden days baba was a respectable word and still is)... if Baba Deep Singh Jee, the 4 Sahibzaday, etc couldn't be called Sant,, then how can any of these people. If someone with even a blood relation to Guru Jee couldn't be called Sant than how can someone not even a relative or anything close be called Sant. If someone who's contributed to the creation of Sree Guru Grath Sahib Jee (the bhagat's/etc)...can't be called Sants then how could anyone else. So pleaseee.... no one is a Sant. IN HISTORY THERE WERE 11 SANTS, AND ONLY THE 11th ONE IS LIVING AND THERE WILL BE ONLY 11 SANTS NOT EVEN A DECIMAL NUMBER MOREEE. you get the point... so i hope to see on thisss entire forummm (the new everyday messages) that no one puts Sant before any ones names. admin jeo, please if possible take out the word sant infront of names in any newer messages. and please lets not get into this Sant issue because EVERYONE out there that read this post knows the truth and you CANNOT DENIE IT! Bhul Chukh Maph Karnee Jee vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Gurpreet Sumra · 06 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh, veer harmeet singh ji, may waheguru shower all his blessings on you and your family. You have said what Gurbani says. Let us go back to the period prior 1947, there was no sant, 1)baba deep singh(is he less then sant -------buhat sare wale) 2)bhai mani singh(is he less then kar sewa wale babe) Now I want to say about now a days Bhai satwant Singh ji who gave punishment to indira aunty was only 19 years old at that time and we are not even willing to call him bhai,why dont we celebrate their shaheedi diwas(WE DONT EVEN CELEBRATE BABA BANDA SINGH'S MARTYRDOM DAY) SHAME ON US. Now you want to call those ppl as sants who has corrupted Guru Sahib's teachings. Again I am an admirer of Baba Jarnail singh bhindrawale, but if at all you listened him he himself says"kuch log kehnde ne santaan nu eh gal kehni achhi nahi lagdi,main kis nu keha haa main sant haan" Gurfateh

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Jan 2006

110% behind Harmeet Singh Ji. DHAN DHAN DHAN DHAN GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB MAHARAJ JI.....

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Kookar Tere Darbaar · 07 Jan 2006

Agree with Harmeet Singh. Why is no-one satisfied with Great Gursikhs being revered and honoured as "Bhai Sahib", "Bhai", or "Baba." So its okay that we use "Bhai", or "Baba" for: -- Bhai Mati Daas jee -- Bhai Sati Daas jee -- Bhai Dyala jee - Bhai Gurdaas jee -- Bhai Nand Lal jee -- Baba Deep Singh jee - Bhai Mani Singh jee - Baba Budha jee the list goes on but in the 21st century we have "MODERNIZED" and don't want "OUT-DATED LABELS" to address Great Gursikhs.... instead we nelly willy use "Sant" and "Brahm-gyani." 1/ The Word loses significane and value when it is used to describe anyone wearing a white dress and turban who calls himself a Sant or whose followers call them a Sant 2/ I am sure a True Gursikh would happy being called anything - thats the least of his worries! in one word its crazy!!! God forbid that in another 50 years time being a "SANT" will be a recognised OCCUPATION in India and you can apply to be a "SANT" with an application form or something.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

M S Nijjar · 07 Jan 2006

A SANT will be a SANT!!! NEVER question the fact of Sant Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale being a Sant or not Jihna Suthee Quam Jugaee!!! THAN THAN 108 BRAHMGIANI SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE MAHAPURSH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Singh Panth da · 07 Jan 2006

M S Nijjar Jeeo, We will happily call Baba Jarnail Singh Ji "Sant" or "BrahmGyanee" Jarnail Singh Ji, when everyone starts to referring to all of our Gurus, Panj Paiyaray, Chaar-Sahib Zaday, 40 muktay, and all of the Shaheeds of the past and present with the same titles. The truth is you would not, you are are stuck in a mode where you use that title for those that suit you. Most of you will call Guru Nanak Dev Ji as "Baba Nanak" or Baba Deep Singh period, but will not hesitate to have 2 million sant, brahmgyanee, 108 prefixes, and post fixes to the particular person you idolize. Either referr to ALL Gursikhs that way or leave those titles for GURU JI only! DHAN DHAN SAT-PURAKH SANT PURAKH POORAN-BRAHGYAANEE SATGURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE MAHARAAAJ : The INFINITE (that's right not just 8, 108, 110, or 1008, or 10008 but INFINITE, Puran Sarbat Kalaa-Samrath) [gurbani]Bwgu hoAw guir sMqu imlwieAw ][/gurbani] By good fortune, I have met the Saint-Guru. [gurbani]pRBu AibnwsI Gr mih pwieAw ][/gurbani] I have found the Immortal Lord within the home of my own self. [%sig%]

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

ok · 07 Jan 2006

FANTASTIC POST @ top, and i totally agree, harmeet singh MS nijjar, go back up and TRY to read and UNDERSTAND with an OPEN MIND what ppl have been trying to get across. Dont go around tellin others who is a sant and who is not. Sure, Baba Jarnail Singh Jee was a true gem, and what he did most sikhs today (inc. me) couldn't emulate. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> THAN THAN 108 BRAHMGIANI SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE MAHAPURSH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fine, if you want to praise Baba Jarnail Singh Jee in this way, go ahead. there's only ONE person in my heart that I will forever praise... Vaheguru jee Ka Khalsaa, Vaheguru jee kee fateh!!!

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

agyani · 07 Jan 2006

one thing strikes me...if its bhai mani singh or bhai gurdas...then why do the akj use titles? or others (not targetting just saying as an example) ..has the title bhai dont been taken down as well as any tom dick or harry singh uses it?

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 07 Jan 2006

vjkk, vjkf agyani jee, if your question is why can anyone use the title of Bhai/Bibi etc when Bhai Mani Singh Jee or Bhai Gurdas Jee who were so great had it then the answer is simple: it's to show respect. When putting up keertan recordings or putting up someones name on a poster or something for an event and Bhai or Bibi is there, it is for respect. Like if you went to that Kirtanee or someone and talked to them, you wouldn't be like vjkk, vjkf BHAI SINGH JEE....you would simply be like vjkk, vjkf and maybe touch their knees to show respect (and lets not get into this touching someone's knees issue because some people won't let you touch their knees and it's not your fault) . It's all about respect... like if your "harry singh" has his hair cut and keeps that title, I don't think anyone else would call him by that title but they wouldn't slander him either or anything like that. And secondly...if you're talking about someone, and you say oh Bhai Singh Jee did beautiful keertan today or something like that, that is also for respect. You wouldn't be like (this is an example) Harjinder Singh did nice keertan today...see by taking out the Bhai and the Jee, the respect seems to be gone doesn't it.... so agyani jee it's all to show respect. I know that Bhai Mani Singh Jee and Bhai Gurdas Jee etc, were great people obviously but Bhai is there again to show respect. So it's not like you would put Bhai only on people who are, lets say more spiritual than others... we can't do that because we respect everyone equally. Respecting is a different issue than aknowledging one's commitments to the Panth and spiritual status, etc. I hope you understand agynai Jee vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

singh · 07 Jan 2006

Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji ki Fateh Thank you harmeet singh ji... brilliant post, completely in line with Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. I hope no one here takes this as slander to all of the great pooran gursikhs mentioned above.. I think we all agree that they are some of the greats sikhs and role models for our panth. What harmeet singh has outlined above, and what other people have followed up with is exactly the open-mindedness that needs to RETURN to the sikh kaum...

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

someone · 08 Jan 2006

I AGREE WITH M S NIJJAR DHAN DHAN SANT BAB JARNAIL SINGH JI KHALSA BHINDRAWALE AND ALL THE OTHER TRUE SANTS THERE HAVE BEEN santa ko mat koi nindo sant raam hae eko

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

khalistani · 08 Jan 2006

veer jes i already said that in gurbanee sant is not used only to refer to guru je in tha thuk, it says GUR sant GURR guru je but there are many shabads tha tell u saints like bhagath namdev je were SANTS gurbanee calls them sants to say gurbanee only uses sant to refer to guru je is jus looking at some gurbanee, mis translation, and then ignoring other gurbanee a sant is osmeone who inspires us to jaap naam, guru je is the giver of it gurbani is clear about this i dunt kno y we got same argument goin around and around when its been proven tha sant ha sbeen refered to in gurbanee to people other than guru je bhula chuka maf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 08 Jan 2006

vjkk, vjkf someone jee, you posted that Shabad in your post but aren't looking at the true meaning of the Shabad. sMqw kau miq koeI inMdhu sMq rwmu hY eykuo ] sa(n)thaa ko math koee ni(n)dhahu sa(n)th raam hai eaekuo || Let no one slander the Saints, because the Saints and the Lord are as one. but see someone jee, this shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Jee, not by the Guru's ... so when Bhagat Kabeer Jee is saying this shabad.. he is referring to the Guru's as the Saints, not some other people. And this is correct because he says the Saints and the Lord are as one and so in other words, the Guru's and the Lord are as one. someone jee, nice try on trying to put oil on the fire.... but ahahaha....you are mistaken.....ahahah...there is no fire to begin with....there is no anger or discrimination or anything like that to begin with... what I have posted above and all my other posts in this thread... I am saying with complete faith in Guru Jee and completeeeeeee humility and pyar. There was no fire to begin with... ahahahhaa....someone jee... what does oil do if it is just spilled on nothing... nothing happends right.... so the same way your post did not effect hopefully anyone... because there was no fire to begin :)...... everything i've and hopefully that everyone else said was with compleettteee pyarr and humility. ok i'm going to solve this Sant issue once and for all. sorry if I make it long , hopefully not too long. ok first read this Shabad... I was just looking around for Gurbani's answers and found it. This answer was found in Gurbani.. Gurbani has all the answers... thank Waheguru that it has been revealed. sMq sBw guru pweIAY mukiq pdwrQu Dyxu ]1] rhwau ] sa(n)th sabhaa gur paaeeai mukath padhaarathh dhhaen ||1|| rehaao || In the Society of the Saints, the Guru is found. He is the Treasure of Liberation, the Source of all good fortune. ||1||Pause|| The society of the Saints is made up of the Guru's, who can be a Saint but not Guru and be as high in order/ spiritual/powerful/blessful as the Guru to be in the society of the Saints? No one right. The Saints are the Guru's... The Gurus are the Saints. Now for those who just can't seem to accept this... here is a question from me to you... why can't you accept that Guru Jee is higher than any of HIS FOLLOWERS? Do they lose their significance if you admit it. Do they lose their pride? Do they lose their popularity? Do they lose their honor? See when you're not accepting that Guru Jee is higher then they lose their honor. They lived a life showing pure humility to Guru and showing everyone that they are Guru's DasnDas. By not accepting that Guru Jee is only Sant and they are not ..you are saying that they are equal to Guru Jee... and this is not the Truth... the people you have mentioned above (the true hero's not talking about the fake ones) wouldn't ever think of themselves as great or as powerful as the Guru's. Compared to Guru Jee they are small, and we are even smaller. They were never proud of what they did or celebrated it or took pride in anything other than Sikhi because Guru Jee said not to be proud of anything. mnu qnu qyrw qU DxI grbu invwir smyau ]3] man than thaeraa thoo dhhanee garab nivaar samaeo ||3|| Mind and body are Yours; You are my Master. Please rid me of my pride, and let me merge with You. ||3|| next example haumY mmqw mohxI sB muTI AhMkwir ]1] rhwau ] houmai mamathaa mohanee sabh mut(h)ee aha(n)kaar ||1|| rehaao || Egotism and possessiveness are very enticing; egotistical pride has plundered everyone. ||1||Pause|| next example isrIrwgu mhlw 1 Gru 4 ] sireeraag mehalaa 1 ghar 4 || Siree Raag, First Mehl, Fourth House: kIqw khw kry min mwnu ] keethaa kehaa karae man maan || Why should the created beings feel pride in their minds? dyvxhwry kY hiQ dwnu ] dhaevanehaarae kai hathh dhaan || The Gift is in the Hands of the Great Giver. BwvY dyie n dyeI soie ] bhaavai dhaee n dhaeee soe || As it pleases Him, He may give, or not give. kIqy kY kihAY ikAw hoie ]1] keethae kai kehiai kiaa hoe ||1|| What can be done by the order of the created beings? ||1|| Awpy scu BwvY iqsu scu ] aapae sach bhaavai this sach || He Himself is True; Truth is pleasing to His Will. AMDw kcw kcu inkcu ]1] rhwau ] a(n)dhhaa kachaa kach nikach ||1|| rehaao || The spiritually blind are unripe and imperfect, inferior and worthless. ||1||Pause|| jw ky ruK ibrK Awrwau ] jaa kae rukh birakh aaraao || The One who owns the trees of the forest and the plants of the garden jyhI Dwqu qyhw iqn nwau ] jaehee dhhaath thaehaa thin naao || according to their nature, He gives them all their names. Pulu Bwau Plu iliKAw pwie ] ful bhaao fal likhiaa paae || The Flower and the Fruit of the Lord's Love are obtained by pre-ordained destiny. Awip bIij Awpy hI Kwie ]2] aap beej aapae hee khaae ||2|| As we plant, so we harvest and eat. ||2|| kcI kMD kcw ivic rwju ] kachee ka(n)dhh kachaa vich raaj || The wall of the body is temporary, as is the soul-mason within it. miq AlUxI iPkw swdu ] math aloonee fikaa saadh || The flavor of the intellect is bland and insipid without the Salt. nwnk Awxy AwvY rwis ] naanak aanae aavai raas || O Nanak, as He wills, He makes things right. ivxu nwvY nwhI swbwis ]3]32] vin naavai naahee saabaas ||3||32|| Without the Name, no one is approved. ||3||32|| And yet everyone is so proud in them and praises them. They never praised themselves. ij ibnu siqgur syvy Awpu gxwiedy iqn AMdir kUVu iPtu iPtu muh iPky ] j bin sathigur saevae aap ganaaeidhae thin a(n)dhar koorr fitt fitt muh fikae || One who does not serve the True Guru, and who praises himself, is filled with falsehood within. Cursed, cursed is his ugly face. next example Dnu DMnu gurU nwnku smdrsI ijin inMdw ausqiq qrI qrWiq ]4]5] dhhan dhha(n)n guroo naanak samadharasee jin ni(n)dhaa ousathath tharee tharaa(n)th ||4||5|| Blessed, blessed, is Guru Nanak, who looks impartially on all; He crosses over and transcends both slander and praise. ||4||5|| their honor stays when they are aknowledged as lower than Guru Jee. But their honor is taken away when they are seen as great as Guru Jee. Being the Slave of the Slave is a greater job the just being the Slave. The more you take your status away from Guru Jee's status... the more you are showing Guru Jee that how loyal you are, example, I will not take this title unless you give it to me and I know that you will only give it to me after I have earned it... so please let me do my duty first and serve you. (refering to Guru/God giving the title) You have to be reasonable... can any of these people have a bolder thrown over their heads off a cliff and stop it with one hand and have the hand print embedded into the bolder? Can any of these people hit their sword on the ground with such force that water come sparkling out like a beutiful water display in the dryest and hottest of weathers? When you admit that they are lower than Guru Jee it makes them happy and Guru Jee happy too. Their efforts are still aknowledged and everything. It's just that the Truth is released. So I hope all of you out there know the Truth now that only Guru Jee is Sant for sure. I respect Guru Jee and all those great hero's immensely but everyone knows the Truth. They are small compared to Guru Jee, but we are even smaller. This Sant issue is over...finally we have LET the light of Waheguru shine on us and show us the answers of Truth through Gurbani. Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU WAHEGURU ( I typed all the Simran with hand... no copy or paste,, promise to Guru Jee.. no lying..... that's for giving me forgiveness if I said anything wrong... Bhul Chukh Maph Karnee Jee vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 08 Jan 2006

vjkk, vjkf my first , second and third posts show the 100% Truth Combined. (just to notice). vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 08 Jan 2006

vjkk, vjkf bhul chukh maph karnee Jee, Satgur/Guru Jee is always 100% True , nothing else. for this.. maybe 99.9..ahhah...i can't choose ..it wouldn't be right. vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

singh · 09 Jan 2006

i wish taksalis would stop being so stupid. Do you honestly think sant jarnial singh would use 108 and mahapursh before his name? He even did not want people to call him a sant. By putting 108 before his name you are making him into a Pundit! 108 has nothing to do with sikhi. It is course which pundits have to pass.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

S Singh · 09 Jan 2006

Khalistani Guru Ji themselves have therefore certified who Sant are. Do you think us mere mortals are capable of certifying who Sant are ? Remember the Bhagats you name have their Bani in our Guru Ji. Only elevated human souls whos bani is included in Guru Ji are referred to as Sant. Considering our Guru Ji were referred to as Gur Sant do you think it is ok to use the same title for anyone ? If this practice is not stopped then in a few years we will have people calling these so called baba Guru Ji as the Namdharis etc already do. It is time to stop missusing these titles. >>veer jes i already said that in gurbanee sant is not used only to refer to guru je in tha thuk, it says GUR sant GURR guru je but there are many shabads tha tell u saints like bhagath namdev je were SANTS gurbanee calls them sants to say gurbanee only uses sant to refer to guru je is jus looking at some gurbanee, mis translation, and then ignoring other gurbanee a sant is osmeone who inspires us to jaap naam, guru je is the giver of it gurbani is clear about this i dunt kno y we got same argument goin around and around when its been proven tha sant ha sbeen refered to in gurbanee to people other than guru je bhula chuka maf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

a kaka · 09 Jan 2006

goes to show how people (cannot) think these days...

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Kharnail Singh Barchha · 09 Jan 2006

i think maybe the confusion arises becasue we attach significance to the word "GURUJI" as referring only to guru nanak ji, guru angad ji and so on....and therefore we have khalsitani saying..there namdev is also called SANT and so i am correct that a person besides guru ji can be sant.. veer khalsitani jio, the nmadev you refer to is right there beside GURU JI in the Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj jio...there is no difference between guru arjun ji and namdev ji....both are in GURU GRANTH JI and both are GURU. Get it Khalsitani veer jio....FIND me a SANT OUTSIDE GURBANI....Dont touch those that are already INSIDE guru granth ji sahib jee maharaj ji....we bow to all of them..as GURU..and they are GURU....whether it is ravidass ji or kabir ji or sadhna ji or namdev ji or guru nanak ji. Find me a "sant" who lived during Guru Ji's time...and who GURU JI calls a "SANT JI"....and refers to him as SANT JI in GURBANI by NAME. ( and whose bani is not included in Guru granth Ji sahib jee. i look forward to your answer jio. PS. please dont make "fun" of my name as one sant balbir did in his post. he is obviously angry at me. this name happens to be wrongly spelt in my birth record due to clerical mistake my got is garcha. bhul chuk maaf karnee jio.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 09 Jan 2006

vjkk, vjkf ok lets stop talking about this Sant issue and foucus on the main point of this thread, talk about those fake anti-Gurmat people/Baba Jee's (i'm using baba ji's because we still have to respect them and look into the good in them not the bad). as for the Sant issue...I'm going to devote my life read books and gurbani to finally see who is a Sant and who isn't (along side all my other commitments like doing keertan etc). And my goal is before I pass away.. I will get my research report to the SGPC and then I will sort all of this out...If someone gets to do it before me lol...it's all in Guru's Kirpa. lol :) Bhul Chuk Maph Karnee vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Bazzer · 10 Jan 2006

<<<< as for the Sant issue...I'm going to devote my life read books and gurbani to finally see who is a Sant and who isn't >>>>> You can spend a lifetime reading books and get nowhere. <<< And my goal is before I pass away.. I will get my research report to the SGPC and then I will sort all of this out >>> YOU WILL SORT OUT ? Good nimarta there mate

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

S Singh · 10 Jan 2006

>>ok lets stop talking about this Sant issue and foucus on the main point of this thread, talk about those fake anti-Gurmat people/Baba Jee's (i'm using baba ji's because we still have to respect them and look into the good in them not the bad). Most of those fake Sant in the pictures are in the Sant Samaj. Is a Sant can recognise a Sant then how come the "real" Sant let these fake Sant join their union ? Is it because none of them are really Sant like our Guru Ji and Bhagats were.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

The Observer · 10 Jan 2006

one popular indian channel on sky, I will not mention the name so that it does not promote it. They are giving prime time to videos on darshan das.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 10 Jan 2006

vjkk, vjkf Bazzer Jee...you're right...only Guru Jee knows the answer... what's nimarta?? vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 09 Apr 2006

vjkk, vjkf sorry everyone for me writing me second last post..i don't know what i was writing..please forgive me bhul chuk maph karnee jee :D....VAHEUGURU!!! :D vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

my opinion · 09 Apr 2006

Baba Harnam Singh was sant, Sant Harnam Singh is also fine when referring to him. If you say he was not a sant, somethin wrong with you. Guru sahib says to call him a dog, does not mean we actually do it. So, to those who say this sant and that sant said dont even call me sant, well obviously cuz no real sant goes around saying im a sant u better call me sant. Bhai Randhir Singh was also likely a sant. I have read some of his books and that is the conclusion i came too. If not a Sant than what else can explain his life stories..ohh he was a high avastha gursikh? no this does not sound right, he was sant but did not want to be referred to as sant

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

Harmeet Singh · 09 Apr 2006

vjkk, vjkf it looks like this topic has started again..please during discussion don't slander..don't spread hate...don't fill yourself with ego...just spread love...speak humbly and don't send any personal attacks either... keep all the bad stuff to MINIMAL status. :D VAHEGURU :D vjkk, vjkf

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

.... · 09 Apr 2006

Guru Nanak fed saints and said that is Sacha Sauda. slandering is going against the teachings of first guru.

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

MANKIND · 10 Apr 2006

Author: .... Date: 04-09-06 22:34 Guru Nanak fed saints and said that is Sacha Sauda. slandering is going against the teachings of first guru. <<<<<<<<<<<<<< ALL "SANTS" are more than welcome to come eat in Guru nanak Ji's Guru Ka Langgar....its still SACHA SAUDA.... But todays SANTS..call themselves "DERA SACHA SAUDA"..and ENTICE the innocent Sikhs of the same GURU NANAK....into a web of evil. They are NO "sacha sauda"..not dhanwanta, not manna su, not daljeeta su...the SIMPLE Daal Roti of Guru nanak ji's Sacha Sauda is a no no to them..they want and demand 36 parkaar they Bhojans....and serving girls of 36 nationalities...

Re: "Those who slander SANTS will be...."

LK · 10 Apr 2006

-------------------- It is no surprise that during the Dharam Yudh Morcha initiated by Giani Baba Kartar Singh Ji Bhindranwale and led by Shaheed Giani Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale, all the fake Sants and Babé climbed back into their holes and kept a low a profile. Since the mid 1990s, the pakhandi Sant trade flourished to such an extent that they even made a trade union called “Sant Samaj”. Not only do rikshaw drivers and train-workers have a trade-union, but nowadays our white-clothed friends who are driven by Maya and power, have a trade-union which rushes to support them in case, for example, someone rightly accuses one of their members of rape, abuse, sexual misconduct, theft or drug-smuggling. May God help us all! ------------------------ Actually I was listening to a tape of Prof Darshan Singh Ji this morning. He was talkign about how during the movement, they sent letters to deras, saints, baba jis to join the morcha, since they did not only want political leaders to demand the rights. They wanted religious people involved too (not that they weren't already, but they were classified as 'political leaders'. They arrange a meeting and hold a gather (at Fatehgarh Sahib I believe) inviting the press and everything. No one turns up. Not one single one. ZERO. He quotes Bhai Gurdas Ji - It is important to note that the word used here is 'saadh', not 'sant'. [gurbani]QMmy koie n swD ibn swD n id`sY jg ivc koAw] Drm DOl pukwrY qly KVoAw ]òò][/gurbani] thha(n)mae koe n saadhh bin saadhh n dhsiai jag vich koaa|| dhharam dhhaal pukaarai thalae kharroaa ||aa|| Now this earth cannot be upheld without the saints and no saint is available in the world. Religion in the form of ox is crying beneath. But today we got sants everywhere. In every pind. Every Sher, every corner of Punjab is filled with sants.