Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Kulbir Singh · 13 Nov 2003

As written by Bhai Nandlal jee, the majnoo of Vaheguru does not fall for a worldly beauty like Laila: MAJNOON-E-TAU KAI AASHIQ-E-LAILA BAASHAD || Our Guru Sahibaan expects his Sikh to be an Aashiq (premi, lover) not of a worldly beauty but of Vaheguru. In Siri Aasa kee Vaar, Siri Guru jee states: IH, KINEYI AASHIQEE, JE DOOJAI LAGAI JAAYE|| (What kind aashiqee i.e. love is this, that permits to love someone else, other than your beloved Vaheguru?) NANAK, AASHIQ KAANDHIYE, SADD HEE RAHAI SAMAAYE|| (Guru Angad Sahib writes that the true aashiq is so who stays forever merged in Vaheguru) Look how high the ideal of love in Sikhi is and how lowly the worldly (ishq-e-mazaajee) love is. Gurmat preaches that we should be such lovers of Vaheguru that we should stay forever in his yaad (sweet rememberence). Is there anything that the lovers of Vaheguru have not done for their love? The true aashiqs of Vaheguru have sat on red hot pans and had hot sand pour over them. They had their head severed in love for their beloved. They let the aggressors burn them alive in cotton but they did not even once let their love for their beloved one go down. They were cut in half. They were boiled alive. They were made to roll over the killer wheels. The aashiqs of Vaheguru gave their lives at one signal from their beloved Guru. They had their skulls removed for their beloved. They had their children cut into pieces for their beloved one. The aashiqs of Vaheguru spent their youths in jails but did not let their love go down. They kept their rehit intact and against all odds obeyed the hukam of their beloved. This is what aashiqs of Vaheguru did. What did Vaheguru do in return? Vaheguru in return gave them immense bliss of Naam Rass and gave them everlasting spot in Sach Khand. Now let us look at the lives of worldly aashiqs. They too sacrificed a lot. Kaiz who is popularly known as Majnoo gave up his royal status for Laila, his beloved. He went city to city for her and in the end perished in the deserts of Arabia. What did he get in return from Laila? Nothing substantial. Ranjha, gave up Takhat Hazaara and for a dozen years worked as a servant for Choochak (father of Heer). He became a diwaana of Heer but what did Heer do in the end? She married someone else and left for her in-laws at Rangpur KheRa. Poor Dheedo (Raanjha) become a jogi. Sassee perished in the desert for Punoo and Sohni pershised in river chanaa for Mahivaal. What did they get in return? This way we can give several examples of failure of ishq-e-mizaajee. In the case of Laila Majnoo, what could have been the possible peak of this love? At the most Majnoo would have married Laila. So is this an everlasting relationship? Not according to baani. On the other hand, Bhai Taaroo Singh jee had his skull removed by the Muslims, out of love for Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee. What did Bhai Taaroo Singh jee get in return? He already had Naam Rass and now he became one with Vaheguru and is now in Sach Khand with Vaheguru. I don't have any doubts over the intentions of Raanjha and Majnoo. Even Bhai Gurdas jee has praised their spirit and hard work but the reality is that the end result of this love is not that great. Reading baani we learn that the true aashiqs i.e. the Gursikhs of Guru Nanak Dev jee, succeed in getting good results out of their hard work. The worldly aashiqs too are of two categories - ones who are inspired by kaam (99%) and the ones inspired by love for soul e.g. Ranjha, Majnoo etc. The ones inspired by Kaam surely go to hell and the ones like Ranjha and Majnoo too cannot achieve anything high according to baani, because baani preaches that one gets what one aims for and if these guys Ranjha and Majnoo were to get their love, what would they really gain from that? At the most they may marry their love in the next life and then have children from them. Would it result in everlasting rest? No! It will surely put them back in chauraasee (8.4 million life forms). There will be no way out. According to baani, only those ones, who become aashiqs of Vaheguru, get any real results for their hard work. Rest waste their time. In the light of all this, is it not our duty to deliver ourselves by dying on the Amrit Naam of Satguru? Is it not our duty to never miss amritvela and during amritvela japp naam with full concentration? May Guru Sahib make us his real aashiqs. Gurbani is calling out to us, to take precaution during our youth. During the youth time, there is high probability of making a mistake that can leave a scar on the life of Gursikh for rest of his life. It is not worth it. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Gupt Singh · 14 Nov 2003

Beautiful post! It truly is utterly sad when people keep following after the "false love" after being told the truth about the whole matter. So many Jatha and non-jatha youth would be so much more chardi kala if they didn't go after these false concepts. Thank you for your beautiful post Kulbir Singh.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

SINGH · 15 Nov 2003

kulbir singh thanks for putting that up. i also heard theres a puratan sakhi on a beautiful pathan or afghan woman trying to lure bhai hari singh nalua to her charms and it failed after she tried everything, do you have that by any chance? i cant find it anywhere on the net.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Sehajvir Singh · 15 Nov 2003

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. Well done Kulbir Singh. Well DONE!!! I would like to just say that this post is truly wonderful as i hav felt like this for a while about laila magnoo and what not, but didn't know how to express my feelings into words. You have done so briliantly and I applaude you for it. This will be a good refrence when i am trying to explain the pit falls of falling in love with the opposite sex. It was beautiful your words, thank you once again.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Singh · 07 Feb 2005

waheguroo

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

. · 07 Feb 2005

Kulbir Singh wrote: IH, KINEYI AASHIQEE, JE DOOJAI LAGAI JAAYE|| There is no "JE", its only IH, KINEYI AASHIQEE, DOOJAI LAGAI JAAYE|| in Aasaa kee Vaar. [%sig%]

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

silly man · 07 Feb 2005

vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!! there was once a time when i thought that i had "fallen in love" with somebody. i was in an anti-gurmat relationship with a non-gursikh and in the rush of emotions i always thought that this was some type of love. in my heart i knew this persons priorities do not match with gursikhi so they are not even a gurmat match, let alone "love." but in confusion and nervousness, i sat with this person and two very respected elders and told them this is somebody i love and wish to spend my life with. as i was speaking this i could feel a knot in my stomach. now, after breaking the false relationship and seeking forgiveness from the punj pyare, after many months of adjusting my sikhi and trying to become a gursikh again, i have come to a realization. i know who i wish to spend my life with: Guru Jee. vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

daaas · 07 Feb 2005

If there are two gursikhs...... who have been going out for a while ... not too long but long enough to have strong feelings for each other and now they are unseperable....... ...... parents dont agree (well the girls).... both are amritdharis ..... what should they do ??? .... should the girl accept her parents wish of not marrying the guy (cuz of caste) or should the girl marry the guy ............ keeping in mind that whatever decision she makes .. she iwll be leaving someone for the rest of her life.......... ..... also will it be fair to the new guy ............

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

hmmm · 07 Feb 2005

interesting....anyone ???

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 08 Feb 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. a very big thank you kulbir singh ji. this post really made my day. Love for Waheguru is the Real thing while this worldly "love" is as a reflection we see in the mirror...the "REFLECTION" looks EXACTLY REAL...in every detail..but it is NOT real..how sad that very few realise the truth. Gurbani also teaches us how to "love" in this world....our parents, brothers, sisters, wives, and friends...but on an entirely different level from the real love we must cultivate for Waheguru. Gursewa te sabh sukh upjeh...Gur sewa of the Shabad/vichaar of the Gurshabad....cultivates this Love. The Shaheeds you mentioned did so much Gurshabad Vichaar..antar samalleh... inside inside of them..they got in touch with their Sacha Pir...and that connection was so great that pain of the human body didnt affect them one tiny bit...because their SOUL antar atma was in such BLISS. Thank You. jarnail Singh

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Kulbir Singh · 08 Feb 2005

------------- If there are two gursikhs...... who have been going out for a while ... not too long but long enough to have strong feelings for each other and now they are unseperable....... ...... parents dont agree (well the girls).... both are amritdharis ..... what should they do ??? .... should the girl accept her parents wish of not marrying the guy (cuz of caste) or should the girl marry the guy ............ keeping in mind that whatever decision she makes .. she iwll be leaving someone for the rest of her life.......... ..... also will it be fair to the new guy ............ ----------------- First of all, as explained in my first post of this thread, Ishq-e-mizaajee is false and is very detrimental to one's spiritual well-being. An unmarried Gursikh getting attracted to opposite sex and wanting (dying to) get married to one particular person of opposite sex is a lost being. We can safely assume that such person has been deprived of Guru Sahib's kirpa. Many times previous life's bad karma cause this kind of situation and many times one's haume too can cause this kind of situation. The very fact that one is embroilled in such a situation should be enough to tell a Gursikh that he or she does not have kirpa of Guru Sahib and one has committed some paap. The situation that you are describing now is not easy to resolve. The best thing to do is to get your parents and elder gursikhs of your area involved and then taking the next step according to their advise. Such problems cannot be resolved on forums. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Premi · 08 Feb 2005

Kulbir Singh and Gyani Jee, So what is Gurbani Vichaar then? Is it trying to understand the meaning and then applying that to your life? Please explain. Whic h then I ask what is Jap? Or what is it to Japnaa Naam, is it solely the recitation? Please xpalin.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

khokkar jatt dharmi jodah · 08 Feb 2005

ishqk eh ishk putt jatta dey kardey mucha nu whisk

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

J Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Beautifully written Kulbir Singh! Just great! Kaash (wish) Vaheguru had made ishq-e-haqeeqi just as easy as ishq-e-mazaajee :-). Ishq-e-haqeeqi isn't possible without nader-e-mehar of Sache Patshah, but ishq-e-mazaajee for the most part is just simple biology,. a longing... a temporary intoxication to be with someone. Do you consider both to be selfish forms of love? Or is ishq-e-haqeeqi is selfless, done purely for the love of Vaheguru without any expectation? VJKK VJKF [%sig%]

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Kulwinder Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Nice post Dear Vir Kulbir Singh JI, also Dear "daaas" ji caste and Sikhi have nothing in common any objection related to that can not be an objection from a Sikh. and the rest I agree with Vir Kulbir Singh Ji entirely that, The best thing to do is to get your parents and elder gursikhs of your area involved and then taking the next step to solve the issue (open talk in humble and polite manner). Such problems cannot be resolved on forums. again Vir Kulbir Singh Ji you put smile on my face. Cool Man my Brother .

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

singh rathore · 09 Feb 2005

daas do not marry the guy who is adifferent caste it will hurt your parents. It is easy to do what your mann says and let the heart be ruled by love. But it usually is best to not hurt parents because they are the ones who bought you up into the world. They are not stopping your sikhi right? you are still allowed to marry a rehetvaan sikh but for them they may have many reason they do not want you to marry out of caste which is what you need to sit down and establish why. BUt because it will really hurt them it is sachi advisable to to, i am not saying that because i am into caste but because i know how hurt parents will be and when it gets to that stage, there could be no turning back, ie stress related diseases developing, parents being heartbroken everyday till their gone, would you be able to live with that? Then you will try to fit in with this new man and if his family see some cracks they will probably blame your caste for it, and the truth of the matter is in amritdhari families such as jatha families there is not a major difference but if the boy adopted sikhi and you will still have to accomodate the boys family too and live around that for the rest of your life coupled with your parents being hurt. This becomes something that cannot be undone after. So please out of of the situation you are in do not marry out of caste, youwill end up more hurt. Some parents i have seen just cut off with their children because they cannot take it. Is it worth it just for the guy? I want to clarify to you i did not marry out of caste and yes it felt like a sacririce because you cannot always choose who you want but thats the situation we are in we have to face it and balance sikhi around it. If we all went ahead and did mix caste marriages that will hurt a lot of parents. Do not listen to these so called sikhs who advise you to marry out of caste for sikhi, life does not work like that. You try cutting yourself off from your parents, is it even worth it or thinkable? i have seen this happen a ramgharia derkaan woman did a love marriage in 1992 to a katri sikh and her father never accepted it, and cut her off. Then he had a heart attack and other problems and because of her family not not in contact she didnt go to see him. She was ripped apart in two worlds and blamed her husband because when they came to blows she was like " i put everything into this marriage by leaving my family". These kind of things can strain things long term. Sikhi and positive punjabi values ( no drinking, no gidda, no bhangra, no touching women) i mean family values, progressing forward, helping each other economically settle, keeping connections alive, and having our ground roots mean a lot. A lot of these few mix caste marriages i have seen the people just lost the plot their like gorey what will they teach their kids? their kids have no identity, no roots, no connection their whitewashed. You cannot just bring up a kid alone and say sikhi sikhi sikhi. That child will need affiliation with his her homeland jithe raj singha da chalonah, that child needs his her mothertongue, attributes, traits developed at early stages and keeping their positive side of punjabiat alive. you will not get that in mix caste marriages well what i have seen to date anyway. Please do not marry out of caste it will ruin people around you who have bought you up. Because it has aleady begin in certain places now the children say whats the difference in marrying out of religion? The consequences are far reaching. The more people change the more problems we will find. [%sig%]

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

singh rathore · 09 Feb 2005

sorry daas i read it wrong my post is for the person who is in the situation my apologies

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Kulwinder Singh · 09 Feb 2005

Singh rathore are you a Sikh ? do you have any understanding of Sikhism, Never mind mix marriage ? we have even more, much more then anybody can comprehend relationship with our Guru and can you tell me if you have any answer, what Caste is Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji ? and would you object to marring somebody from that Caste ? Having caste and Sikhi are just two things oil and water they do not mix does not mater what you do ? that is not my dicsion by any standard, that is the decision of my Real Father Guru Gobind Singh Ji, Do you have any other Real father then Guru Gobind Singh ji ? if not then what caste have to do with your thoughts ? What you are permoting is real Brahminvad and Guru Gobind Singh Ji want us to not even go near to that philosophy, Who you going to obey ? Guru Gobind Singh Ji or your worldly Parents, ( I am not saying you abandon them, but if they abandon you for listening to Guru then the Choice is not that difficult for any Sikh, Bhagt Prahlad ditched his worldly father Harnakash , I hope you remember that.) Parents are very valuable, and need to be respected for their status and kindness they show you throughout their life, but If parents ask you to do something morally wrong then you need to oppose that in the least hurtful way, Other wise what is the point of listening to Guru Ji if you are not going to change ? By no mean I am saying disrespect your parents to anybody, but if tomorrow your parents says do something unethical then you should just do it ? I am afraid no way. What else is unethical telling your children not to listen to the Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Even if you do not agree with me, even then I would strongly suggest you should stop permoting brahminvad .

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Manpreet Kaur · 10 Feb 2005

very nicely put veer kulwinder singh ji...gooo you!

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

pppreshie power!!! · 10 Feb 2005

its easy for some of you to turn this debate into "brahminvaad". What about the ramgharias insistance on opening theuir own gurdwaras? excluding people from other castes? allowing HINDUUUUUUUU IDOL WORSHIPPPPERSSSSS called VISHWAKARMISS on their board group and not even one sikh from another caste? making the committee sign their legal forms they only work for ramgharia upliftment ?NOT SIKH? Who will talk of brahminvaad then?? So why do they keep marital relations with darshan dasis and namdharis? you seriously expect sikhs to give their daughters away to families like that? where their daughter will be forced to live side by side like this everyday. When it comes to the different situation as it is mentioned by the lady that sadly no one can change without hurting a lot of elders then you try to put the majority of sikhs in a position where they are made to feel bad about it and force some kind of change that would result in our elders getting emtionally hurt. So kulwinder singh what are you trying to say that just follow your heart and screw your family over? dont worry about mum dad let them suffer their problem. I seen people like you talk before follow your heart and such people have this opinion its ok to date, and the person they gave the advice to his dad died of a stroke 8 months after with depression but people like you run away because you achieved what you wanted. All you do is say thats brahminvaad. so parents are like harnakash? well if you are successful in getting this girl to marry out of caste and rip her parents world apart i hope you will take responsibility for the consequences. See thats where our mentalities conflict. The masses of sikhs are in a situation where they have to make do with the situation and be smart, They love and respect their families even Guru Granth Sahib says respect your parents in one place at least. But people like you and especially i seen with these kenyans is you dont care who you hurt, you have your objective and thats it parents dont matter, let them die off. Its the reality the way it is get used to it. Its these little caste groups who have insisted on differences and did not fully adopt khalsa even in 1984 the ramgharias were against the singhs, post 1984 they follow hindu customs. So now we are supposed to marry our daughters off to such? As a brother i would not allow my sisters to marry off into houses that will stand against the panth and follow half hindu customs. Its not about two people being happy alonne you take families into consideration. So how many ramgharias will marry their daughters off to chamars? How many chamars will marry their daughters off to black or white sikhs? YET when it comes to the masses of sikhs everyone is dieing to add their little karchi in to make us sell our daughters in the name of brahminvad. So spare bringing the Gurus into your argument (even i can do that but i did not) let us first see how many of you "casteless modern sikhs" will put into practice what you preach. [%sig%]

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

pppreshie power!!! · 10 Feb 2005

the terkaan guy who told the singh to follow his heart and marry out of caste, after he did that, the guy himself 2 years later sowed what he had reaped. (NOTE I USED THE WORD TERKAAN BECAUSE IT HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED THE PERSON WAS A ENVIOUS CASTIST WHO DELIBERATLY MISLED THE SINGH BECAUSE OF THE CASTE HE WAS BORN IN ) The same problem came into this terkaans house. His sister now wanted to do a love marriage with a chamar guy both amritdhari. Now the guy was saying " well if it was another caste i would allow it but not chamar" so it was stopped. So when he whitewashed the siddah singh to "follow his heart" (eventhough the singh did not date his spouse but wanted to marry out of cast) it was fine and that finished his whole family off now when it came to the whitewashers own family his sister cannot even meet her poitential spouse let alone marry him. So be careful before setting someones house on fire the wind may blow the other way. This is about how things are, learn from them and wake up. If someone gets hurt because of these selfish actions will a misled person be able to live with it? DO NOT GET CARRIED AWAY WITH THESE MODERATES THEY WILL NOT BE THERE WHEN YOUR PARENTS EFF UP. ITS YOU ON YOUR OWN DEALING WITH THE GUILT AND HURT FOR THIS THING CALLED TEMPORARY LOVE ( AND THAT TOO YOU WILL LEAVE YOUR SPOUSE AFTER YOUR LIFE BREATHES HAVE ENDED). CAN YOU WATCH THAT LIFE SLOWLY EBB AWAY FROM YOUR PARENT AND THEN LOOKING INTO YOUR PARTNERS EYES AND SAY I DID THIS ALL FOR YOU? DONT YOU THINK THERES A KARMIC BALANCE TO PAY FOR HURTING PEOPLE WHERE THEIR HEALTHS MESS UP? MARRIAGE IS NOT ENDLESS BLISS EVERY COUPLES HAVE BARNIES AND THIS WILL BE SOMETHING THAT LIVES INSIDE YOU SOMWHERE THAT WILL COME OUT WHEN YOU LEAST EXPECT IT. BY THEN TO LATE TO CHANGE ANYTHING. [%sig%]

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

pppreshie power!!! · 10 Feb 2005

kulwinder singh "what Caste is Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji ?" none. but that is no excuse to do your parents over who put food on your plate, helped you grow, nurtured you, loved you. So do not divide it into anti and pro THIS IS ABOUT WHAT WE ARE THROWN INTO AND LEARNING TO DEAL WITH IT INSTEAD OF MAXIMISING HURT TO OUR FAMILIES. whats a lover (bf gf) gonna do? there for your body sake? if your not so gud looking beautiful or if looks departed wud that lover have pcked you? how sure wud you be of that? if your position was a roadsweeper instead of posh accountant would that partner have chosen you? or had zero acc? if you had half the hair falling out of your head and face would that lover have chosen you? of course they will say yes but wake up get real ask yourself inside dont listen to passions, your heart can lie and screw u up But your parents are still there for you even when these bfs and gfs come and go. So try to get it through its more to do with the given scenario individuals are thrown in rather than equating that with brahminical caste pride. Talking about brahminical pride i want to see these caste gurdwara constitutions changed that is the supreme epitome of brahminism not marrying your daughter where you want for her future and well being. How can you expect doors to just open by following alien rehats? [%sig%]

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

yo · 10 Feb 2005

the different castes have made up their own matt, and walked away from khalsa, open new gurdwara and then say ok to have cut hair, trim beard, dastaar not required, open wedding hall where serve meat and shraab bhangra right 15 20 feet away from Guru sahib seated in adjoining bulding they openly support brahmin poona. Singh sabha has stuck to khalsa and the change cannot take place until other castes actually start following khalsa way and take their own matt off. when they follow one rehat then i think sikhs will have no intercaste marriage problems. So we should not accuse each other of being castists as this is a result of others breaking off to form their own thing. they must make amendments then this will create a whole new social process as was intended in 1699.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

yo · 10 Feb 2005

and yo we do not choose our parents they are given by vaheguru. this means we must fulfill our duty and also dating someone is not sikhi even if its amritdhari. We are not doing a service to Guru Gobind Singh Ji by dating someone of a different caste for marriage. The whole thing is wrong. Caste will go when we all follow Guru Ji hukum and abide by rehat. Marriages are written on our foreheads by dating we are breaking the will of God. If dating was ever right then our Gurus would have told us but a chapter in dasam bani does tell you the result in charitar what happens if you date outside marriage its very very wrong in sikhi. dating is therefore wrong, and outside caste means hurting your family which is also wrong in bani. Unless you have a problem where you cannot find a partner then i suggest in that case talk to panj they will help you.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

To Kulbir singh....... · 10 Feb 2005

The worldly aashiqs too are of two categories - ones who are inspired by kaam (99%) and the ones inspired by love for soul e.g. Ranjha, Majnoo etc. Looking at 'Trai Gunn' would you say people inspired by Kaam are in Rajo Gunn and People inpired in each others love is Sato Gunn?? meaning if we don't reach Turia Gunn we come back to give back our karams in another life.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Kulbir Singh · 10 Feb 2005

---------- The worldly aashiqs too are of two categories - ones who are inspired by kaam (99%) and the ones inspired by love for soul e.g. Ranjha, Majnoo etc. Looking at 'Trai Gunn' would you say people inspired by Kaam are in Rajo Gunn and People inpired in each others love is Sato Gunn?? meaning if we don't reach Turia Gunn we come back to give back our karams in another life. -------- I agree with most of what you have written. In my humble opinion, people inspired by Kaam are in Tamo Gunn and not in Rajo Gunn. It depends on number of relationships they have and whether this relationship is in out of wedlock or after marriage. If it is fornication then it is definitely Tamo Gunn and if it is after marriage then it seems to be Rajo Gunn. People inspired by each others love seem to be on the borderline of Rajo Gunn and Sato Gunn. Sato Gunn is defined as doing such stuff that is of high moral value or doing religious rituals. And yes as you stated, if we don't reach Turia Aastha which is also called Chautha Padd in Gurbani, we have to come back for another life. Naam Abhyaas is beyond Rajo, Sato and Tamo. Only Naam Abhyaas can lead us to Turiya Avastha. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 10 Feb 2005

I don't see how anyone can call themselves an Amritdhari if they pay attention to caste. What if your parents drank alcohol or smoked marijuana, and keep trying to push alcohol or pot on you? Is it then OK to give in and do the drugs or have some drinks? What if your parents murdered a couple of their infant daughters along the way...simply because girl babies are inconvenient...and your parents start pressuring you to dispose of a girl baby or foetus. Is it then OK to abort or kill your baby daughter? What if your parents are monays, but you are Keshdhari...and your parents are trying to pressure you in to trim up your hair or shave your beard. Does that make it OK to remove your hair? What if your parents were lavish meat eaters, but you are a vegetarian. Your parents pressure you to eat meat. and prepare very rich meat meals for you when you visit. Should you give in to them to make your parents happy? Guru Nanak's position on the caste system is very clear. Sikhs should pay no mind to it, period. On this board, I have read about several quasi-Sikh groups that believe in, say, the first 9 gurus but not the 10th. THAT IS NOT SIKHISM, I hear over and over again. In my opinion, the same with supporters of the caste system. Sri Guru Granth Sahib is not a buffet table. It was not written for those to take what they want and ignore what they don't want. Sri Guru Granth Sahib was meant to be followed in its entirity. Yes, its tough. Yes, it takes courage. Courage is hard. That is why it is precious and valued. But...I am not the one to be convinced on this matter. It is Waheguruji that is watching.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

hey · 11 Feb 2005

redwhiteblue kaur i agree but what are we supposed to do then? its complicated to turn against parents.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

khalsa · 11 Feb 2005

Sri Guru Nanak dev jee turned against his parents Brahmin belifs.....he set the example we should all follow. always uphold gurmat principles, regardless of the wordly consequences you might encounter. The saaki when Guru sahib gave money to all the saints, when he was suppose to spend it elsewhere comes to mind. when he came home his dad scolded him, and i even think he slapped him But Guru Sahib didnt talk back or get angry. He accepted that his parents have different wordly views and still respected them to the highest degree, BUT he didnt bend on his gurmat beliefs. lets take the examples of Guru Sahib on how to uphold gurmat and still respect our parents

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

waheguru · 11 Feb 2005

could you send me your e-mail Pajee I would like to keep in touch with you and ask you a few questions.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 11 Feb 2005

It takes courage to face one's parents with news that one fears that they will not appreciate. It is a difficult thing to do. But it can be done. I empathise with anyone that is struggling with such a conflict. It was not easy...and still is not easy...for my own family to accept that I am a Sikh and not a Christian. Believe me, I completely understand. But being Sikh requires courage. Courage is not something just to be bragged about, courage must be lived. Courage is not simply donning a kirpan, courage is defending Gurbani. Outward appearance has meaning in Sikhi. But the value of that outward appearance greatly diminishes if one simply attains the gurmat look, but shies away from making gurmat choices in life. Wahguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

castispastraisedamast2last · 18 Mar 2005

ok we all agree caste must go. This can only happen if everyone makes an effort from all quarters. It is interesting to note punjabi sikhs will always be picked out for this cast bashing. The focal point always being "punjabi culture", this i have noticed more than once picked on by european sikhs. Now i love my sikhs europeans desi or any, each sikh reminds us of our Guru. But if the gorei sikh want to pick on punjabi sikh and blame panjabiat, then please lead by example. I look fwd to sikhnet marriage section the picture heading looked nice. But where are all the white sikhs? its full of indian, punjabis asking for marriage. Why do white sikhs not marry indian sikhs then? is this not a form of caste or race difference too? If i could id marry a gori singhani anyday. so let us all contribute and work together but first understand how these things affect people.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

LK · 13 Nov 2005

Author: J Singh Date: 02-08-05 09:31 Beautifully written Kulbir Singh! Just great! Kaash (wish) Vaheguru had made ishq-e-haqeeqi just as easy as ishq-e-mazaajee :-). Ishq-e-haqeeqi isn't possible without nader-e-mehar of Sache Patshah, but ishq-e-mazaajee for the most part is just simple biology,. a longing... a temporary intoxication to be with someone. Do you consider both to be selfish forms of love? Or is ishq-e-haqeeqi is selfless, done purely for the love of Vaheguru without any expectation? VJKK VJKF ********************************* Sikhi was never meant to be easy. Khaneyo thiki Valo Niki eet marag Jana. Kaun ja sakde ne eh ra te? Bohat virle.

Re: Ishq-e-Haqeeqi Vs Ishq-e-Mizaajee

INDERJIT SINGH DHILLON · 13 Nov 2005

Love is the blueprint for oneness with god, if you have never loved in your life (not necessarily marriage or sexual) you can never love god "jin prem kiyo tin hee prabh payo", anand karaj is not about reproduction or anything else we learn to love one another and on that path learn to love god and aid one another on that path, finally we learn that we do not need love because love is a part of our eternal self, ie the soul is pure love and thats when we recognise a oneness in spirit with god and all others. Love between to people regardles of their sex is not worldly beauty love is a property of spirit in itself, sexual lust is called an infatuation there is a clear difference.