Nirmalas
Singh · 19 Dec 2005
There is a discussion going on an egroup about whether the words "Amrit" should be used or whether "khande ki pahul" should be used. It this discussion one poster has made the following post about nirmallas. I thought it was very interesting. There are some youth on the internet who base all their sikhi on the nirmallas, instead of mainstream sikhi. I was wondering what the rest of the sangat makes on the below post? Date: Wed, 14 Dec 2005 09:00:08 -0800 (PST) From: Adsm Subject: Re: Amrit vs Khande di Pahul Gur fateh , Panth Parkash was written by Giani Gian Singh whose bansavali is linked with Bhai Mani Singh Ji . He was a Nirmala Sikh and Nirmalas have been famous for distorting the Sikh History and traditions .Gian Singh worte his Book in 1880 i.e 39 years later than Rattan singh Bhangu. One Panth Parkash was witten by Rattan Singh Bhangu of Village Bharee near Khanna Luchaina and his fathers name was Rai Singh . He wrote as the explaination of Capt.Murrey in , but Gurmukhi in poetic form after some ammendments ( additions and deletions). Means he has given the source of his information which is very necessary to mention from reseacrh veiw point . It is one of the oldest episode of sikh history written around 1841 during the reign of Maharaja Ranjit Singh . Rattan Singh Bhangu expired in 1846 . He was grand son of S.Mehtab Singh of Meerankotia therefer need not verify his sikh faith .The Nihang Jathebandis respect this Granth too much and Baba Santa Singh Akali Budha Dal of Nihangs has made a Teeka of this granth .Bhai Bhangu clearly writes that " jihn bidh kahee Angrejan sang , rakho uthaanka sou sang " . Therfore its well evident that the contents are as per the version of some English persons .Where as Giani gian Singh singh did not mention his source of information . Some history about Nirmalas here looks a necssity.What is "Nirmal" , 'Sadh naam nirmal ta kai karam' and ' maya mamta tann te bhagi , upjio nirmal gian' (Basant M :9) . The person who does all deeds with a pure understanding without any game playing is Nirmal. But guru Gobind singh Ji used the word "Khalsa" in Jaagat joyte Sawaye and fixed this word of Khalsa in the fateh also . We never call any body "Nirmal ji" but bid fateh of guru .Guru Gobind singh Ji called the Khalsa Panth and not the Nirmal Panth any where .Otherwise the Nirmal is without any dirt as said "Ahnas navtan nirmala , maila kabhun na hovayee" and "sabad ratey sou Nirmaley" . Keeping such words into consideration a Nirmala Sect was started , which was against the ideology of Dasam guru . It is said some five sikhs were sent to study sanskrit from kanshi , does not mean that they five were assigned to start a new sect among sikhs . These five sikhs when came back brought so many Hindu rituals and bases which they tried to infilterate in Sikhism also. Some people(Nirmalas) at that time left the 5Ks and took the Langoti attire . Most of them were quite literate and wrote so many granths .But it all gave a big loss to the Sikhism . They used to call them Nirmalas and stated quoting the gurbani Tuks on the subject of Nirmla and Nirmal Panth .For some time the Nirmalaas kept the principles of 10th guru except 5Ks . The system of Guru Chela was started again . Due to having bhagvaan clothes they started mixing themselves with Hindu saints .Even upto 1940 they used to keep the parkash of SGGS at their deras and Matths and there after left it .The senior most was called Sari Manaht ji and mixed most of the rituals of hindu philosophy also in their Gurdwaras .So many Hindu grnnths were also respected equal to sggs in their deras . They established Gurdawras at hindu tirath and the innocent sikhs were misguided there .The Udasis are also the similar tyle of mahants .Around 1938 one Pt Niranjan singh started an other Branch and the followers were known as " katchu kateye" . They used to wear Silken clothes and used various types of scentes for good flavour . The states Sikh Rajas in 1918 gave them a recognition also and some Akhadas were installed and gave them Jagirs and big cash amounts .They framed their own 30 rules and the wearing of Kakars was negleted alsmost .because the rajas were afraid of Sikh Sabhias The sikh Pujaris/takhats/granthis prohibited their entry which gave them a big set back . Giani Gian Singh was one of the pioneer of Nirmalas whose foot steps are being followed by some followers of Bai Kala Afgana these days . I try to quote some of the gurbani refereces in which it is very clear that Amrit is a physical form of substance and is required to be taken : 1.nanak Amrit manney mahey , paeeye gurparsad ! Tinhi PEETA rang sion , jin kau likhia aad !! (Var sarang M:2 P 1238) 2.Gurmukh Amrit naam , jit KHADHEY sabh bhukh jaey !! (Var sarang M:3 P1250) 3. Amrit har ka naam hai jit PEETEY tikh jaey !! (Var Malhar M:1 P1283) Nanak Gurmukh jin PEEA tin bahud na lagi aaey !! 4. har amrit PEEVAI sadaa rang raatey , haumai trisna maar !! (Var Malhar M:3 P1281 5. Gur kai bhanai vich Amrit hai sehjey pavai koe !! jinah parapat tin PEEA humai vichu khoey !! (Siri M:3 P31) 6. Amrit naa, NIDHAN hai mil PEEVAU bhai !! (Var gaudi M:5 P318) 7. Sur nar munn jan amrit khojdey so amrit gur te payea !! ( Ramkali M:3 P918) 8. Tikha nivari sabad mann , amrit PEEA bharpoor !! (Ramkali Dakhni Onkar M:1) 9. vin chaakhai suaad kisey na ayea , gur kai sabad amrit PEEAYEA !! (Maru M:3) amrit PEE amrapad hoey , gur kai sabad ras taha re !! 10.Amritsar satgur satvadi , jit nahtai kaua hans hoey !! ( Gujri M:4 P493) Keeping all these order of guru sahiba the 10th master devised the Amrit to bw prepared with the help of Khanda and Bata and replaced the charan pahul system which were never in vogue and it was a brahamanical story of Bhai Gurdas as he has mentioned many Pope-leehla stories in his varan . adsmangat