Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

MILK?!?!

MILK?!?!

sardaro · 10 Nov 2003

Why is milk used to clean nishan sahibs? why is milk used to clean darbar sahib? milk is full of bacterias etc.. how is milk clean? soap and water is clean, milk is not. It is a hindu beleif that cows are sacred and milk is "pure"... how many poor people in india could be fed with all that milk that is used to "clean" darbar sahib? we all know at one time darbar sahib had hindu statues and all sorts of rituals etc.. is milk one of the remnants of this? if so, why do we still do it? just because its tradition doesnt make it right. remember its also "tradition" to read raag mala.. it was also "tradition" to read rattan mala.. go back even further.. it was "tradition" to throw water at the sun at hardwar.. it was "tradition" for wife to burn at the stake with her husband. tradition is not always good.

Re: MILK?!?!

Kulbir Singh · 11 Nov 2003

> Why is milk used to clean nishan sahibs? why is milk used to > clean darbar sahib? milk is full of bacterias etc.. how is milk > clean? soap and water is clean, milk is not. I don't think milk is used as a detergent. The whole panth uses kachee lasee (not milk, though referred to as milk) to clean nishan sahib, and other sacred places. Just because milk has bacteria does not mean that it is not good. Everything including soaps and detergents contain micro-organisms. I personally don't find it against Gurmat to use kachee lasee (dilluted milk). To be honest, I don't have a strong opinion for or against using kachee lassee. I don't think there is great deal at stake if we use milk or not use it. We use milk to cleanse Nishan Sahib or Darbar Sahib out of respect for Guru Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: MILK?!?!

hjhjhjh · 11 Nov 2003

in many parts of the world for a long time now, rich people, such as royalty, use milk to bathe themselves becuase its good for hte skin. i guess if its good for us, why not use it for the guru...i dont know, im just trying to justify using it i guess.....

Re: MILK?!?!

mmmilk · 11 Nov 2003

I have heard that kachee lasee was also used to wash kes back in the day when there was no shampoo, kachee lasee along with a treatment of oil did a good job of keeping hair in good health. Milk must have been a precious substance way back when milk was not pumped out of cows 24 hours a day which could be a reason that it was used to clean such sacred places. I could be wrong. [%sig%]

Re: MILK?!?!

NJ Khalsaa · 11 Nov 2003

I have heard that Sevadaars used to use milk because that was a replacement for soap. In older days, Soap was not around, chemicals were not used to clean as far as i know. For kesh ishnaan, people used to use Dhain (Yogurt) becuase they used to refuse putting chemicals in their kesh... to avoid side-effects.. (i.e. loss of hair). But there is no excuse to use dairy products now since pharmaceutical advancements make the chemicals perfect for all uses. We shouldnt use milk or dhain or even lassi. Sikhi is about practability and truth.. There is nothing truthful or practical in using MILK for cleansing. Just my 2 cents.

Re: MILK?!?!

sardaro · 11 Nov 2003

>>>>Sikhi is about practability and truth.. There is nothing truthful or practical in using MILK for cleansing. <<<< I agree.. and I again ask.. how many people could have been fed in langar? how many people could have drank that milk in langar hall every day that darbar sahib is washed.. yet they kick the poor out of the langar after three days? what is that? is this what our gurus stood for? highly doubt it. bahmans think cows and milk are sacred, we do not.. why not use goat milk then?

Re: MILK?!?!

JUST DON'T ARGUE · 11 Nov 2003

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH i humbly submit that milk's importance and cow's importance could be an influence from hindu and brahmin control in india of our gurdwaras. but beyond this, i do not think we need to make this an issue. if somebody uses milk, fine. if somebody doesn't fine. using soap for cleaning and milk for feeding is practical in my opinion, and gurmat. beyond that if others uses it - who cares - don't argue, just practice your sikhi and fight against injustice. using milk is not an injustice against anybody, so it is not a HUGE wrong - let's just leave it at this. admin please close the topic, we do not need to open up crack number 4890273810751234 in the panth. first fix the 4890273810751233 cracks in our panth. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH.

Re: MILK?!?!

Sardaro · 12 Nov 2003

I agree that we shouldnt argue.. but this is a basic foundation of sikhi. Guru Nanak Dev Jee set about to get rid of empty and useless rituals, such as throwing water at the sun. Washing things with milk which could be used to feed the poor is a HUGE injustice. What if sikhs decide they want to start throwing water at the sun again? will you say, dont argue, its not a huge issue, lets work on more important things, before you know it we will be hindus! Things like this should be confronted as there is no practical or common sense reason for this to happen, its ridiculous.

Re: MILK?!?!

- · 12 Nov 2003

the same argument can be used for soap. Look at how many poele could have been bathed with the much soap or look at how many people's thirst could be quenched with the water that would accompany that soap. Besides, why would you want to use fake chemicals that could contain stuff like alcohol in it when you can use natural ingredients?

Re: MILK?!?!

Sardaro · 12 Nov 2003

how is milk a cleaning agent? just because hindus say its pure? why not use goat milk then?

Re: MILK?!?!

sardar singh · 12 Nov 2003

Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 9 goras gaaee(n) vaekhadhaa ghio dhudhh vichaalai|| Lord Himself is there in the milk, cow and ghee.

Re: MILK?!?!

Gulzar Singh · 12 Nov 2003

WJKK WJKF "how is milk a cleaning agent? just because hindus say its pure?" My mother happened to know some Muslims back in africa. She said that Arabs and other muslims use milk as a cleaning agent, especially the women... They take milk baths and do so even today (no, Arabia isnt a poor country... they could by soap etc but some still use milk...) Apparently, the milk is good for the skin or something... My mother has actually tried it and she says its really good... so i dunno, jst my personal experience with the topic... Now onto my sikhi views: I think milk is perfectly ok, and i wouldn't ever want it to go because it's in our sikhi Gurduara tradition and culture... Also, you hear terms, such as for Egypt / Israel "the land of MILK and honey..." in the Bible or something, i.e. milk is associated with prosperity, wealth, sweetness...? More importantly, the sakhi of guru nanak and how he wouldn't eat from a brahmin but would from a low caste... he got the food of the brahmin and the food of the low caste, squeezed it, and blood came out of the brahmins food; MILK came out of the low caste dude's food... again, this would seem to suggest that milk is clean/pure (not because hindus say it is, but from example of this sakhi)/sweet/humble etc... The milk flowing from the poor dude's food in the sakhi would also suggest that the "Lord Himself is there in the MILK, cow and ghee" (thank-you veer Sardar Singh ji for that post...) Just my opinion / views... anyway, i don't really think this is a big deal; pointless discussion (i'm at skool bludging atm, so i got nothing better to do, hehe)... WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: MILK?!?!

- · 12 Nov 2003

milk has been used as a cleaning agent for sooooooo long. Not jsut becuase hindus used it. What else do you think they used before soap?