Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

jatha vs. deras

jatha vs. deras

gurpreet singh · 13 Dec 2005

I was just wondering how jatha, following the rehits of bhai sahib randheer singh jee is not the same thing as deras following the rehit of their sants or babas

Re: jatha vs. deras

... · 13 Dec 2005

What is dera culture? It is a personality cult with heavy influences of brahminvaad with no justification from bani or any rehitnama or any historical evidence. Sant Babas are worshipped and the Dera then has a line of Sants, following one after the other. The Sant's followers all look up to him for advice and he is the leader. The Sant Baba gets matha tekked to and gives lectures to the sangat. Often they do dharna kirtan. What is the Akhand Kirtani Jatha? There is no dera associated with this Jatha. There is no Sant and no line of Sants. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh never called himself a Sant and stopped people from bowing to him. The rehit followed in the Akhand Kirtani Jatha has a historical basis in rehitnamas and historical documents. There are no lectures by any Baba or anyone else. The Akhand Kirtani Jatha only has keertan. Maybe this discussion would go easier Gurpreet Singh, if you let us know what makes you think that the AKJ is the same as Dera-culture.

Re: jatha vs. deras

gurpreet singh · 13 Dec 2005

for clarity sake, the main similary is see is: -following the rehits that the gurmukh that started the jatha/dera followed for example---dera followers wearing all white or lighting a dhoof or doing a specific ardas (nanaksar for example) just because the gurmukh used to do it. Many of the youth in AKJ do not know why they believe raag mala is not bani, why keski is a kakkar, why they are eating in sarbloh. In both cases the members of the groups are doing things which they cant justify why. Another example would be the Gursikhi Ishnaan posted by another gurmukh on this forum. How people that follow that rehit know why the right leg is taken out of the kachera before the left leg? Although bhai sahib jee never called himse;lf a sant or let others call himself a sant, is blindly following his beliefs similar to what deraewalae singhs to their sants? Another point is that with the opening of Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib, has another dera not been created where the rehit being followed is the same rehit that was followed by Bhai Sahib at the gurdwaras where smaagams were held? Deras follow the rehit their Sant followed, correct me if im wrong but isnt Tapoban Sahib following the rehit started by bhai sahib? i will post more points as i remember them. please dont take this as an attack on the jatha, as i am just adressing a concern of mine. gustakhi maaf

Re: jatha vs. deras

... · 13 Dec 2005

I’m not sure I agree with your argument here: You said, “Many of the youth in AKJ do not know why they believe raagmala is not bani, why keski is a kakkar, why they are eating in sarbloh”. To that point, my reply would be that I find a lot MORE people not in AKJ who don’t know why they DO believe in raagmala (despite extraordinary evidence to suggest it clearly is not bani) or why kes is a kakaar(when no old source lists kes as a kakaar while they do list keski as one). In general though, even in Sikhi there are people that don’t know exactly why they do certain things. I’m not sure you would call this a problem specific either to Jathas or Deras. What makes something like this a dera issue is if someone is doing something or believes something only because their Sant or “Brahmgyani” told them to do it and there is no other explanation to support the practice or belief. This is very dangerous because it’s a personality cult. An example could be the Neelapanthi Jatha believing that the body of their Sant (still stored) is going to come back to life. This is faith based only on the word of the baba and nothing from any history or rehit. On the other hand what we see in Jatha is a set of rehits that are all very solidly backed by rehitnamas and historical references. Believing keski is a kakaar and ragmala not being bani isn't some idea created by Bhai Sahib, it is something he believed in, but it is also supported by scholars like Piara Singh Padam, Shamsher Singh Ashok and many others. So relying on Bhai Sahib's writings or example is not the only support for these practices and thus can't be called the same as dera-ism. Blindly following isn’t really the issue. You’ll find that in all of Sikhi and in every Jatha. What makes it dangerous is that if someone wants to find a reason they can only cite their baba as the source. This is definitely not the case in Jatha. Next you bring up the point of Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib following the rehit “started” by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. The Gurdwara follows tat-Gurmat rehit. Find something that the Gurdwara does that is only based on what Bhai Sahib has said and doesn’t have any other basis in rehitnamas or history. There isn’t any such practice. Bhai Sahib is a great example to follow because he didn’t have any rehit or practice he created himself (if there is, please identify it). All of it is supported by tradition, rehitnamas and other sources. So even if the point is conceded that the Gurdwara follows the example of Bhai Sahib only (which it is not), there would be nothing wrong, because Bhai Sahib followed tat-Gurmat rehit and not his own creation. So to summarise my post, I think your argument is flawed because it’s based on the premise that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh created a maryada, when this simply isn’t true. He followed tat-Gurmat, which is the creation of Guru Sahib and these practices are supported not just by what he said or did, but by many other independent sources as well. Dera-ism in contrast is a personality cult, where all rehit is dictated by the Baba without any other justification. The Sant has a lineage that goes from one Sant to the next. The Sant gives his own interpretation of bani in sangat and is given a special spot in the sangat. All questions to dera-followers are answered, "because Sant jee says so and he's a brahmgyani" and have no other rationale. None of these criteria apply to the Jatha.

Re: jatha vs. deras

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Dec 2005

I am not an AKJ ( yet)..but i have to agree 110% with above post. Whatever the AKJ are they are NOT a DERA/SANTWAAD/BABAPANTHI..etc.

Re: jatha vs. deras

Singh · 14 Dec 2005

AKJ only does keertan in its diwans, no sant stories. So I thought it followed the Guru Granth sahib, not a sant or any personality.

Re: jatha vs. deras

_ · 14 Dec 2005

Everyone just does their duty given by the same Guru. There are some deras that have done a lot of good for the kaum. And then there are places like nirankaries. The guru does not look at associations. There can be greater sikhs at deras than in jathas and there can be other sikhs greater that are in jathas then at deras. chardikala

Re: jatha vs. deras

Singhstah · 14 Dec 2005

jatha follows, guru gobind singh jis rehat and so shud all else

Re: jatha vs. deras

DMX · 14 Dec 2005

The main difference is that AKJ gives Pardhaangi to the 'Panj Pyaray', where as a Dera gives Pardhangi to an individual known as 'Sant'. In AKJ, the Panj Pyaray are chosen from amongst the Sangat by the Sangat, where as in a dera a Sant Jee chooses the Panj Pyaray. In AKJ when a decision has to be taken, it is taken by the Sangat as a collective, where as in a Dera the decision is taken by the Sant Jee. The concept of Sangat and Panjpryaray are very strong in AKJ. If I am wrong, then please forgive me

Re: jatha vs. deras

Karnail Singh Barshi · 15 Dec 2005

Let me please give an example. Take a Sant Mahapursh like say, Baba Nand Singh Ji or Sant Ishar Singh Ji. They had reached Satch Khand and their Dasam Dwaar was open. They knew TRUE rehit and maryadha, how could they not…If they have reached Satch Khand then they know the truth……………………………agreed? Now, say you choose panj pyiaray, they are Guru saroop no question there, but it does not follow that any of them have reached Satch Khand or have had their Dasam Dwaar opened. It does not follow that they will know the TRUE rehit maryadha. Sure they will have abhiaas, read “books”, have dicussed on forums and so on , but the knowledge that the above Sants have, no way can these five have that knowlwdge, how can they, if they have not walked along the path, how do they know what pitfalls there are, how do they know which direction not to go and which to go. If you asked them how to reach satch Khand how could they possibly tell you? Only a person who has travelled along the path and have experienced first hand can tell you what it is truly like. So, this lofty ”Hoity-toity” attitude of “those” Sant over there appoint this and that and appoint there own panj and the chelay follow them, while we over here are Oh so enlightened that we all choose the panj together and so we shall look down on them poor souls following a dera walla Sant is a total fallacy. I applaud the AKJ for their rehit and maryadha and the path they follow but to put down Sant Mahapursh as if they know nothing is your lose. [%sig%]

Re: jatha vs. deras

Virdee · 15 Dec 2005

AKJ do better samagams than Sant Deras. Sant Deras play the dholki, AKJ do better Kirtan and are more advanced and educated. AKJ also dress better than the Sant Deras and have better looking Dastaars.

Re: jatha vs. deras

Singh · 15 Dec 2005

"Take a Sant Mahapursh like say, Baba Nand Singh Ji or Sant Ishar Singh Ji. They had reached Satch Khand and their Dasam Dwaar was open. They knew TRUE rehit and maryadha, how could they not…If they have reached Satch Khand then they know the truth……………………………agreed?" How do you know who reached Saach Khand? How do you know whose Dasam Duar opened? There are so many Sants and Babas who were at high spiritual avasthas but not all of them had identical Rehat. There were differences. The problem is we elevate the levels of certain individuals and "assume" they were Brahmgyani. We do not have a "Brahmgyani-o-meter" to see who was Brahmgyani or not. People just label certain individuals Brahmgyani. Once a label is associated with someone, it tends to stick.

Re: jatha vs. deras

Bhopinder Singh · 15 Dec 2005

Akj is anthak and has its contributions in every sikh struggle . Deras at such times become agents of the oppossing force.

Re: jatha vs. deras

Karnail Singh Barshi · 15 Dec 2005

Singh Bhaji, <<<< How do you know who reached Saach Khand? How do you know whose Dasam Duar opened? There are so many Sants and Babas who were at high spiritual avasthas but not all of them had identical Rehat. There were differences. >>>> No one really knows who is brahmgiani - a term which I have not used - but I think that the general consensus would be that Baba Nand Singh Ji and Sant Ishar singh Ji were of the highest avasta and many times had darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. I am not making a generalised statement for all Sants, as we know that not all have the same level. Virdee <<< AKJ do better samagams than Sant Deras. Sant Deras play the dholki, AKJ do better Kirtan and are more advanced and educated. AKJ also dress better than the Sant Deras and have better looking Dastaars. >>> Childish statements. Sant Deras play the dholki - what is wrong with this ? AKJ do better Kirtan - Is whose opinoin. yours ? and are more advanced - in what way? and educated - when was conventional education a measure of avasta? AKJ also dress better than the Sant Deras - a person dressed in tatters may have a higher avasta and jeevan then one who is in a fresh neela bana. and have better looking Dastaars - A person who looks disgusting in your eyes may have the most spiritual avasta. But YOU cannot get past the dress, the dastar, the education and the dholki, what does that say about YOU ??? [%sig%]

Re: jatha vs. deras

Karnail Singh Barshi · 15 Dec 2005

I think this is just another example of jathabandis that we all seem to be stuck in. Very much an us–and–them mentality, which is causing wide and deep divisions in the panth. Okay, so we all follow a slightly differing or modified version of the rehat marhadha but the essentials are there, the essence is there. If one wears a bana and another does not does that mean we do not follow the same Guru? If one has a damalla and another has not does that mean we are not brothers of the same father? I do not wear a damalla, but I feel very pleased when I see a Singh with one, I feel good inside when I see a Singh in bana, if they do not feel pleased to see me in all my inadequacies then that says more about them then me. [%sig%]

Re: jatha vs. deras

singh · 15 Dec 2005

depends what dehras are being talked about. its pointless to say dehra and thats it full stop as if every single one is a brahmin agent. Good ones and bad ones. khadkoos also had dehre after 1984, sikh revolutions were lead by sikh dehre all the way to the 18th century.

Re: jatha vs. deras

Singh L · 15 Dec 2005

Virdee Jee, those are some childish arguments. I'm a Jatha Singh, and I still think that the statements you made were a little childish. Not the kind of arguments a Jatha Singh would make, in my opinion.

Re: jatha vs. deras

unknown geezA · 15 Dec 2005

WJKK WJKF ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Childish statements. Sant Deras play the dholki - what is wrong with this ? AKJ do better Kirtan - Is whose opinoin. yours ? and are more advanced - in what way? and educated - when was conventional education a measure of avasta? AKJ also dress better than the Sant Deras - a person dressed in tatters may have a higher avasta and jeevan then one who is in a fresh neela bana. and have better looking Dastaars - A person who looks disgusting in your eyes may have the most spiritual avasta. But YOU cannot get past the dress, the dastar, the education and the dholki, what does that say about YOU ??? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ great relpy totaaly agree n whats rong with dressing in white [%sig%]

Re: jatha vs. deras

Gurpreet Singh · 15 Dec 2005

back to the original topic.......... many jatha rehits are based on oral history for example......sarbloh bibek.........bani/simran while cooking........gursihki ishnaan.......keski should be kesri or blue........sarbloh kirpan...........only people in bana doing kirtan......and thers more now dera waley singhs, give the same reason for following what they follow a lot of the time, oral tradition.................look at rehit in nihang dals, lots of oral history in there, or look at taksal and others who dont wear green, or light dhoofs so how can jatha say their oral traditions are right while others are wrong?

Re: jatha vs. deras

Jatha??? · 15 Dec 2005

Most of the Youth thses days do not know the reasons behind Raagmalla and Keskis stance the Jatha has and this is partially down to the youth who think they know stuff but are very far away from any knowledge at all. Some would come on forums and write with all humilty posts as long as the mahabahrath itself. Old Jatha members never criticised a Sant, they never bowed to Sant or acted like a chela, they treated them like normal Gursikhs and gave them the due respect they deserve. I used to have a picture with a lot of Gursikhs on the wall at my house. They had Bhai Sahibs picture on it with 20 other Gurmukhs. As I learnt who they were I began to read the life stories of these Sants as Bhai Shaib was also treated like a Sant after he left Jail not by Jatha members but members of the general Sangat, no one can deny this. Panth held Bhai Sahib as a Great Sant, and Bhai Sahib himself praises Sants not in our narrow minded ways but in the way of being who can see Sants ride chariots to Sachkand. We must as Jatha never ever put Sants down as some Sants love the committment Jatha Gursikhs have to Guru Jee and to Bhagthi. I know of several Gursikhs who were helped in their Bhagthi by Sants. To us they are Gursikhs to other they are sants why make a mountain out of a molehill. Anyone who strives on the road of Bhagthi should be respected. When your a child in Bhagthi you have hard time understanding this but when you meet a master or Gursikh who is far on in the path you will realise that Guru Jee has planted his best flowers in all corners of the Panth, we must respect those who do Bhagthi no matter how they do it and what Dera they are in. If they are not Sants Guru Jee Himself will expose them as he has over the last few years. If your Jatha or in a Dera it does not matter as long as you follow Guru Jee only and not Bhai Sahib or Sant ...... [%sig%]

Re: jatha vs. deras

H · 15 Dec 2005

i think all our jatha's need to start doing is respecting each other as sikhs and students of guru maharaj ji, and not thinking that becuase the way they do their sewa/their rehat/their appearence/whether they have a mahapurakh within the jatha or not, differs them from another jatha and what they do is wrong and incompletely against sikhi. hopefully others agree. bhul chuk maaf

Re: jatha vs. deras

H · 15 Dec 2005

excellent!!!! i've been waiting for somebody to say this. been wanting to say this for a long time but didn't know how to write it without offending anyone. hit the nail on the head bro/sis. TOP STUFF bhul chuk maaf ***************************************************** Author: Jatha??? Date: 12-15-05 14:17 Most of the Youth thses days do not know the reasons behind Raagmalla and Keskis stance the Jatha has and this is partially down to the youth who think they know stuff but are very far away from any knowledge at all. Some would come on forums and write with all humilty posts as long as the mahabahrath itself. Old Jatha members never criticised a Sant, they never bowed to Sant or acted like a chela, they treated them like normal Gursikhs and gave them the due respect they deserve. I used to have a picture with a lot of Gursikhs on the wall at my house. They had Bhai Sahibs picture on it with 20 other Gurmukhs. As I learnt who they were I began to read the life stories of these Sants as Bhai Shaib was also treated like a Sant after he left Jail not by Jatha members but members of the general Sangat, no one can deny this. Panth held Bhai Sahib as a Great Sant, and Bhai Sahib himself praises Sants not in our narrow minded ways but in the way of being who can see Sants ride chariots to Sachkand. We must as Jatha never ever put Sants down as some Sants love the committment Jatha Gursikhs have to Guru Jee and to Bhagthi. I know of several Gursikhs who were helped in their Bhagthi by Sants. To us they are Gursikhs to other they are sants why make a mountain out of a molehill. Anyone who strives on the road of Bhagthi should be respected. When your a child in Bhagthi you have hard time understanding this but when you meet a master or Gursikh who is far on in the path you will realise that Guru Jee has planted his best flowers in all corners of the Panth, we must respect those who do Bhagthi no matter how they do it and what Dera they are in. If they are not Sants Guru Jee Himself will expose them as he has over the last few years. If your Jatha or in a Dera it does not matter as long as you follow Guru Jee only and not Bhai Sahib or Sant ......

Re: jatha vs. deras

singhz lets unite · 15 Dec 2005

man stop this these conversations about jathebandhis!! doesnt matter if ur "part" of AKJ,DDT,etc. man we're disgracing the religion even if we think we follow full rehit and we're true gursikhs!!!! man we're all supposed to be part of khalsa panth but "sikhs" are against "sikhs" u guys consider urself sikhs by being proud of these jathebandhis and being racist to ur own relion people? now i know many of u would find this post offensive but take a minute to relize that Guru Gobind Singh Ji did not split Khalsa into jathebandhis i mean so what if an AKJ member is part of DDt member?? we all are Guru Ji's sikhs!!!

Re: jatha vs. deras

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 16 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh AKJ rely, take advice and listen to whatever the Panj Piayray say, as they know that Guru Gobind Singh Jee abides within the Panj Piayray. In the past, in Bhai Sahib Randhir SIngh Jee's time, whenever the sangat were to make a decision they used ask the Panj Piayray (bhai sahib jee was also in the panj piayray) and not Bhai Sahib Jee as an individual. Even a special Panj Piaray in the future will establish Khalsa Raj (said in Bhai Rama Singh Jee's book), and finally even gurbani states that VAheguru Jee is held within Panj piaray. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: jatha vs. deras

Gupt Singh · 16 Dec 2005

AKJ don't attach sant to Gursikhs names, unlike these sant baba deras. Furthermore, these dera having ashrams, it is so bhamanfied!!

Re: jatha vs. deras

_ · 17 Dec 2005

what happen if there is a sant in a jatha? or sants that make a jatha? then there would be no one left to fight.

Re: jatha vs. deras

Some guy · 17 Dec 2005

"VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh AKJ rely, take advice and listen to whatever the Panj Piayray say, as they know that Guru Gobind Singh Jee abides within the Panj Piayray. In the past, in Bhai Sahib Randhir SIngh Jee's time, whenever the sangat were to make a decision they used ask the Panj Piayray (bhai sahib jee was also in the panj piayray) and not Bhai Sahib Jee as an individual. Even a special Panj Piaray in the future will establish Khalsa Raj (said in Bhai Rama Singh Jee's book), and finally even gurbani states that VAheguru Jee is held within Panj piaray. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ So only AKj follow the Panj Piare and no-one else does?

Re: jatha vs. deras

Ehmi.. · 17 Dec 2005

LOL, this thread is amusing at first with people from each 'team' having a go at each either, actually what a sad state of affairs.. A Sikh is a Sikh is a Sikh – get over all your manmade labels and get over yourself.. [%sig%]

Re: jatha vs. deras

Frosty Singh · 18 Dec 2005

AKJ is more of a family, who like to jaap naam together. It's just a few who have to ruin it, who always boost AKJ.

Re: jatha vs. deras

some geezA · 19 Dec 2005

WJKK WJKF i dnt c wats rong wid saintly people n attachin saint t there names. wat if they r saints then is it rite to call them sants. also if sum1 is considered a sant by people and is lyk bhai Randheer Singh ji thn y cant we call em sants???????? bhul chuk maaf WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: jatha vs. deras

jugroop singh · 19 Dec 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer 'Some Guy', You wrote: "So only AKj follow the Panj Piare and no-one else does?" Veer Ji, Bhain Ji gave a very nice reply and directed us to the Panj Piyare. this is the most perfect reply. however, instead of finding the positive and the positive Gunns within her reply, you chose to assume she meant something she obviously didn't. please ask yourself why this was the case. bhul chuk maaf. ps - Dear Bhain Ji, could you tell me which GurShabad refers to Panj Piyare as VahiGuru; would be very interested. first i thought you may be referring to the pankti in JapJi Sahib (...panch parvaan panch pardaan , pancheh paveh dargah maan)...then wasn't sure. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: jatha vs. deras

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 19 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Jugroop Singh Jee, i'm a male and not a female, just so that you all know. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: jatha vs. deras

jugroop singh · 20 Dec 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dear Veer 'Shaktishali Sha Soora' Ji, apologies for my misunderstanding. Veer Ji, any info regarding the Pankti/GurShabad? VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!