Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

kirtanis being paid money

kirtanis being paid money

pk · 10 Dec 2005

what does sanghat think of kirtanis being paid large amounts of money to do kirtan can a kirtani be in ras, if he is being pad large sums of money? will the kirtan be chardi kala if the kirtani is doing kirtan for money? shouldnt kirtan be done with prem for gurbani? and do please guru not satisfy ones greed? one group in uk often pays kirtanis to do kirtan, i dont find ras in their programmes so i dont go.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

bibek daan... · 10 Dec 2005

kaur/singh if you didnt know they were being paid do you think you would find rass in their keertan? one thing to consider is that there are often jathe that just do kirtan...what better way to live than to live your life doing keeran. however, then you cant have another "job" and i think it is important for the sangat to realize that and provide some financial support. it is just a way to look at it. it may be a question of necessity more than greed. i visited india once and had a chance to spend time with some great singhs...some of whom made their living as kirtaniee...but they were some of the best and more rass-ie - they actually loved gurbani. another thing to consider is how this differs from our parcharaks...often times they are paid...why? same goes for the head giani ji at any gurdwara...why are they paid? b/c they have devoted their lives to sikhi and the sangat is just trying to help them in their grist life as a sort of payback. at least that is one way of seeing it. fateh ji!

Re: kirtanis being paid money

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Dec 2005

It is not "bad" per se to "earn" a living through kirtan/parchaar/gyan-ghottnna /katha/dhadee varaaan/kavishree/doing paaths/akhand paaths/whatever.. You may be surprised that THE GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB is the DIRECT REASON for FEEDING/Giving a LIVELIHOOD to at least a MILLION such people throughout the world ( also counting those who depend on Gurdawras for a living as in Committee members/pardhaans/sewadaars/etc etc... The Basic question is Personal INTEGRITY.....and that is present in EVERY OCCUPATION or human activity. A DOCTOR also earns through his profession....BUT IF a Doctor IGNORES apoor man and lets him die becasue he couldnt "afford" his services then there is an outcry against him...SAME OUTCRY will go up AGAINST ALMOST EVERYONE...who shows GREED. Here the kirtaniya who DEMANDS..so much so much..etc is at fault....a person who says ..give me so much or i will not do your ardasss/paath/akhand paath..whatever is inviting such an outcry simply because a "poor family" may not be able to pay him a single cent !! There are DOCTORS who spend their entire lives in Jungles/outback/underdeveloped areas of Africa/India etc serving the POOR...and there are DOCTORS who have POSH OFFICES and CLINICS in uptown New York/London who wont even let a "poor man" PEEP through their Glass Doors for free...BOTH are "DOCTORS"....and whose "medicine" has more "rass" or "Healing power"..you decide for yourself ??? SAME goes for kirtaniyas..paathis...granthis..whatever.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

Geo Metro · 10 Dec 2005

people usually pay me to stop singing...

Re: kirtanis being paid money

pk · 11 Dec 2005

if you didnt know they were being paid do you think you would find rass in their keertan? No i wouldnt, one particular singh who i first heard, i didn not like before i found out he was being paid huge sums of money, yet he did kirtan moving his head as if he had nam ras, the kirtan was empty and had no weight.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

singh · 11 Dec 2005

Well said Giyani Ji. If someone is singing with piyaar and does not have one eye on the money and who is in the sangat then they I see nothing wrong with giving money. Often keertanees are untrained and and their eyes wonder too much in the Gurdwara Sahib.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

ummmm · 11 Dec 2005

"the kirtan was empty and had no weight." this is a big statement, but from your point of view you may feel this, but, a big but, only GURU JI can decide whose kirtan is emapy and whose isn't. This is an individual thing, you view is this and fair enough thats your view, but less not get too judgemental about who kirtan is parvan and whose isn't, only GURU JI will decide as he is the knower of hearts and minds, leave it at that.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

singh · 11 Dec 2005

ummm i disagree, its easy to tell between kirtanis with kamai and those without go to a bibeki kirtan programme then feel the waves of energy

Re: kirtanis being paid money

bibek daan... · 11 Dec 2005

"pk" ji maaf karna, i must just be an idiot, because i usually get raas out of all kirtan. i wish to one day be able to discern between those who are manmukh and manmukh and then stop listening to the manmukh kirtanees. SARCASM LEVEL: VERY HIGH

Re: kirtanis being paid money

man · 11 Dec 2005

hahahahaha dont make me laugh you can tell, why what can you tell, person does load of saas griaaas, quotes a lot of bani etc, for a fact i know that there have been so called bibiki singhs who have turned out not to be bibeki at all, read ranglea sajjan and learn something from bhai swaran singhs story, no one knows the inner mind of anyone other than guru ji, the rest is just perception from your point of view....

Re: kirtanis being paid money

jss · 11 Dec 2005

i believe that someone who is a naam rasssiaa will always get raas from kirtan...no matter who is singing the kirtan...because the naam rassiaaa doesn't care who is doing kirtan...he just cares for his guru's ilaaahi bani.. doing kirtan is a huge seva...of singing guru ji's bani....if done with nimrata and piyaar and sharda...you get full fruit of the kirtan... if done with ego and greed, you will be like a simple empty karchi.... but the rassiaa sitting in sangat will always take away something from gurbani...

Re: kirtanis being paid money

... · 11 Dec 2005

When Bhai Sahib Disrupted A Panthic Divaan… As told by Col. Piara Singh jee to Bh. Manmohan Singh In Jeevan Chritar Bh. Sb. Randheer Singh Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org In the first decade of the 20th Century, there was a very big gathering to commemorate the Shaheedee of Sree Guru Gobind Singh jee’s younger Sahibzaaday at their martyrdom place at Sree Fatehgarh Sahib. Officials from Patiala State and British Government officers were organizing the event. The whole event was planned under the leadership of Patiala State’s Maharaja. There was a very big crowd. Thousands of Sangat were in the tent that the Divaan was being held in. The Maharaja of Patiala along with his officials was also present. I, along with five or six of my fellow soldiers had come to see the festival as well. It was morning. In the Divaan, keertan of Sree Aasaa Dee Vaar was being sung by one of the Panth’s most famous ragi jathas. When we arrived, we had the idea that before sitting in the Divaan, we would go visit Mata Jee’s Burj [another nearby Gurdwara/tower where the Sahibzaaday and Mata Gurjee were imprisoned] and then we would enjoy the rest of the program worry free. With this thought all us soldiers went to the Burj. Upon entering, we saw an amazing sight: A young man, dressed in Khalsa clothing and shastar was sitting alone in deep meditation. He was singing Sree Aasaa Dee Vaar with a harmonium and his consciousness was so deep that it was as if he was in a deep trance. His eyes were closed. He was singing keertan with profound reverence and love in a spiritually intoxicated way. At that time, the Aasaa Dee Vaar had almost concluded. Seeing his amazing love and hearing the unique keertan, we were so moved that we went and sat behind him. Very soon the keertan ended and that young man, with the same spiritually intoxicated, half-shut eyes, rose to perform ardaas. We also stood to join him. But perhaps he did not know we were there. He performed the ardaas with a unique faith. Remembering that time now and recalling that young man’s face even today touches the heart. All of us joined him in the ardaas and the words that young man spoke were like this: “Oh protector of the Khalsa Panth, Dashmesh Pitaa jeeo, At this sacred place you accepted the Shaheedee of this Daas’s two brothers. The beloved Sahibzaaday at such a young age had the great opportunity to embrace martyrdom here. Today, at this sacred place, this younger brother of the Sahibzaaday also presents himself to ask for Shaheedee. Whatever is happening at this place, Daas is unable to bear it. There will be a confrontation with the pleasure-loving and political power-wielding Maharaja and the officials of the English government. I have no hope that they will pay attention to my request. And so Pitaa jee, it is my Ardaas that my life may go but may there be no disrespect of this holy place as it is happening now. To complete this task, I appear here before you to ask for Shaheedee.” The words were something like this, but the faith and determination with which they were said is not expressible. At the conclusion we all bowed. When that Singh (Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee) turned around, we gave him a Fateh. With his half-closed eyes he replied with a Fateh but seemed not to notice or care about our presence. He began to walk towards the main Divaan. We now understood that his ardaas was related to the Divaan and certainly something was about to happen. We all decided that we would help this Singh and followed him thinking that perhaps he was going to go do something in the Divaan that the organizers would try to stop. We were soldiers and made a strategy to spread ourselves amongst the Divaan so that the cry to hear what the Singh wanted could come all directions. When that Shastardhari Singh bowed before Guru Maharaj, instead of turning around and trying to find a place to sit, he just stood there. He began to bang the two heavy kaRaas on his hands and in a very loud voice began to sing some Gur-Shabad. The Asa Dee Vaar Keertan was interrupted. A commotion erupted. The organizers loudly began to tell that Singh to sit down and be quiet. But no one was listening. That Singh was facing Guru Sahib and not mindful of anyone, was doing keertan. He had such a loud and echoing voice that the Ragis had to stop their keertan. After the organizers moved forward to stop that Singh, we (soldiers) began to call from all sides that this Singh should be asked what he wants and the entire Sangat should hear him. Many others joined our voices and this request became the entire Sangat’s request. The organizers were hesitant but saw that they had no choice and asked the Singh what he wanted and what his real purpose was. The Singh came to the stage and said with great sprit: “Sadh Sangat jee, I regret that I am guilty of having broken your consciousness from the holy keertan of Sree Aasaa Dee Vaar. I, with folded hands, request your forgiveness for this offence but would like to say that I have done so under a special compulsion. Before taking this step, I had spoken with the organizers but they did not pay attention to my request and acted as though I had said nothing. At this sacred place, Dashmesh Pitaa jee’s beloved Sahibzaaday spilled their blood. It was here that jagat-mata, Mata Gujree jee sacrificed herself for her faith. GurbaaNee, Dhur kee BaaNee, supreme BaaNee is the greatest of all. At such a sacred place, for such sacred baaNee to be sung, and that too on such a sacred occasion, by such a keertanee jatha which has been kicked out of the Panth by the Akaal Takhat for patit-karams (is unacceptable). According to the orders of Sree Akaal Takhat Sahib, this keertanee jatha does not have permission to sing keertan in any Gurdwara Sahib or Divaan until it appears before the Punj Pyaaray, has its mistake forgiven and then re-takes amrit to become Singhs again. Ask the leader of this Jatha whether it is true that at the town of Amokay, did he not violate an innocent and pure-souled young girl with his unholy and disgusting actions? And is it not true that because of his disgusting act, has he not been ordered to stop doing keertan? In such circumstances, it is intolerable that such a patit Jatha be doing keertan amongst thousands of faithful Sangat and that too at such a sacred place and at such special occasion. Perhaps this jatha is associated with the organizers and because of this my requests were not heeded earlier, but now I turn this issue over to the entire Sangat.” These words were like magic. The entire Sangat of thousands was silent. These words were said in an unspeakable spirit and determination. The organizers were sitting embarrassedly. That Ragee Jatha, even before the speech had finished, had taken its insturmetns and gone who knows where? The Sangat began to call out “Shame! Shame!” and asked that very Singh Sahib (whom they had heard doing keertan just now) to sing the rest of Asaa Dee Vaar. With enthusiasm he sat down and with great happiness and love, with a feeling of thankfulness, sang such keertan that the Sangat was intoxicated. This was how I first met Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

just me · 12 Dec 2005

A singh at manchester rainsbhai on saturday said it cost £25-30,000. Is this true? If it is. That makes £10,000 a day. £30,000 can pay for Khalsa camp and Sikhi camp with all youth going for free. £30,000 can also pay for two full-time youth workers doing seva in universities, school, hospitals, prisons for a whole year. How many Shaheed families could that support? Most UK smagams cost no more than £5,000 on tickets and langar. It was a great rainsbhai! I know this is Kohlis personal thing. He has loads of money and does alot in India. I just think it is alot of money to spend on a rainsbhai and two days of keertan.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

?????? · 12 Dec 2005

'Pk' I think what u hav said is very bold statement.... nf u cant jus go round throwin stuff like that around! i agree with 'bibek daan', u shud find ras in all kirtan.... its all gurbani from our guru ji at the end of the day... if u dont go 2 certain programs 2 not hear guru jis bani then i think this is a big sin! it shudn't be the way the kirtani is movin their head or how much money their gettin... but what the shabad the kirtani is doin is about! its the gurbani not what funky tune or how cool the head movements r..... nd even if this kirtani does move their head? whats wrong wiv that? u CANNOT judge who is gettin ras out of kirtan nd who isn't, u cant say that this kirtani did kirtani 'as if' he had nam ras... how do u n he hasn;t? forgive me but unless ur a bhramgyani... then u dont no! or unless u can tell the way ppl r feelin which i highly doubt 2. plz dont go round sayin this about kirtani, guru ji has blessed them 2 provide us wiv the gurbani nd the strength 2 go up there nd do kirtan and i must say that it is very bad 2 say what u hav said! its slander nd merely sayin that you think you are better than this kirtani! You should go 2 kirtan programs because of the kirtan not because u dont like a particular kirtani, or they move their head too much! how does that affect u... will that affect ur sikhi? no! so why r u worried? I dont no bout where u live, by here in the uk, all the rainsbhais/ kirtan programs i go 2 are gud, no matter if the kirtani is movin their head! I just think that guru ji has blessed them, cos not every1 can go up there nd get the sangat going! jus my opinion, im sorry if i offended u in anyway, i jus think it is wrong 2 say what u did! wjkk wjkf

Re: kirtanis being paid money

Kaur · 12 Dec 2005

I herd covkhalsa.org take money when they do kirtan. Or is that just the jathehdhar of the covkhalsa?

Re: kirtanis being paid money

agyani · 12 Dec 2005

bottom line is that if we want our panth to have great parcharaks...kirtanis and kathavachaks and the rest - we have to take care of them financially. no one knows what is in someone else' heart (and if you think you do, please post the formula so i can apply it too) but assuming that kirtan is the SHABAD, we should rejoice in it's singing and appreciate those who have taken the time to learn it (gurbani and musicology). as for the story about bhai randhir singh ji, he had a perfectly legit point...those kirtanie had been excommunicated by the Akal Takhat and therefore they were asked to stop. The situations you all are talking about are not the same - these are not people who have been excommunicated, but who make thier living doing guru sahib's seva. waheguru!

Re: kirtanis being paid money

No one · 12 Dec 2005

A lot of kirtanee's fly from the other side of the world, and also have to stop working for the time the spend in travel and overseas. These kirtanees all have families, It is sometimes very very hard for them especially when they have mortgages and bills and have to support families. Its ok to pay them in terms of compensation and maybe a little bit more. If you have to pay them huge amounts then theres something wrong with it. But regardless, go to kirtan and get raass from it. If you think you have the ability to judge someones jeevan at a first glance, then your a better gursikh than myself and others i know. Dhan Dhan Guru maharaj ji Dhan Dhan Guru ki piyare Gursikh gursikh poojta!

Re: kirtanis being paid money

vichar · 13 Dec 2005

thankyou for that '...ji' this shows a very important point it DOES matter who is doing kirtan.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

pk · 13 Dec 2005

'???????? sed' - u shud find ras in all kirtan read ...ji's post, do you want and try find ras from a patit? how about a nirankaree kirtan programme? kirtan should be done by gursikhs who do kirtan out of prem, if the kirtanee is only getting money out of kirtan and no ras, how do you expect sanghat to get ras? "if u dont go 2 certain programs 2 not hear guru jis bani then i think this is a big sin" i can here gurbani at home, i dont have to join those who bend the rules (rehat) to listen to kirtan, i beleive in quality not quantity. its a sin to join a kirtan programme which is being run according to manmat, and not gurmat. eg- its a sin to go to a nirankaree kirtan programme and support their manmat actions. 'u CANNOT judge who is gettin ras out of kirtan nd who isn't, u cant say that this kirtani did kirtani 'as if' he had nam ras... how do u n he hasn;t?' how do you know i dont know? who are you to judge me?

Re: kirtanis being paid money

gabroo · 13 Dec 2005

is leading the sangat in kirtan not seva? like langar seva? or any other seva for guru sahib? if it is, remember that sevak of Guru who brought the wood for the langar fire? Guru sahib said if you do this all day, how do you eat? He says from langar. So Guru sahib said So you don't earn your own food do you? The Sikh then brought wood for langar as well as bringing extra wood to sell to earn his own living. someone should reiterate the above saakhi in detail for us all. point being... if Guru sahib didn't want that sevadaar to take ANYthing whilst performing seva, perhaps kirtani should look at that when considering 'earning' off of kirtan. i don't know if it's wrong, but it can hardly be considered seva then can it.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

Bundha · 13 Dec 2005

Agyani / No One - well said. We certainly need to look after our kirtanis and parcharaks, morally and financially. There is so much hot air from those who "find no rass" in kirtanis who do it for aliving. There are kirtanis pure of mind who do great kirtan but due to the life dealt out by their karam they need the money to feed their families, and how we look down at them. And there are those kirtanis who do nishkaan sewa and don't they let everyone know about it, and how we adore them for their selfless sewa. Pyiario, no one knows how this khade is being played out, the dirtiest of the dirty may turnout to be the purest of the pure and the kirtani who has so much rass that we swoon every time we see him may not turn out to be who we thought he was. [%sig%]

Re: kirtanis being paid money

vichar · 13 Dec 2005

reply to ?????? - you would know the kirtani doesnt have ras if he refuses to do kirtan unless paid a ceretain amount a kirtani who gets ras from kirtan would do kirtan for the ras. read ranggle sajjan theres a bit about kirtanis doing kirtan for their own ras in their.

Re: kirtanis being paid money

trying to be a Kirtaniya · 13 Dec 2005

Kirtan should be done from the heart. the person doing Kirtan should have the following: SIMRAN & SEWA. Kiertan should be done out of devotion and most importantly NISHKAAM

Re: kirtanis being paid money

trying to be a Kirtaniya · 13 Dec 2005

Quotes from Gurbani The Sikh Gurus gave huge importance to Kirtan and this can be concluded from the following Shabads. On 107-8 Guruji says that illnesses of countless lives are eroded by singing Kirtan, thus: Your humble servant, who obtains the Medicine of the Naam, is rid of the illnesses of countless lifetimes and incarnations. So sing the Kirtan of the Lord’s Praises, day and night. This is the most fruitful occupation. ||3|| On page 178, Guruji says that mind becomes peaceful when Kirtan is sang - Singing the Kirtan of His Praises, my mind has become peaceful; the sins of countless incarnations have been washed away. I have seen all the treasures within my own mind; why should I now go out searching for them? ||2|| On Page 196, Guruji says, Kirtan can only be sung by good fortune, thus: By great good fortune, the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises are sung. O Supreme Lord God, as You give, so do I receive. ||1||Pause|| On Page 199, the SGGS advices that Kirtan keeps the mind awake and alert: Do only that, by which no filth or pollution shall stick to you. Let your mind remain awake and aware, singing the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises. ||1||Pause|| On page 208, Guruji tells us those whose hearts are alight with God, sing Kirtan: Between the Lord and His Saint, there is no difference at all. Among hundreds of thousands and millions, there is scarcely one humble being. Those whose hearts are illuminated by God, sing the Kirtan of His Praises night and day with their tongues. ||3|| Also on the same page, Guruji says that ‘Kirtan is my treasure’: To sing the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises is my treasure. ||1||Pause|| You are my delight, You are my praise. You are my beauty, You are my love. O God, You are my hope and support. ||1|| On page 214 Guruji tell us that by singing Kirtan we will be saved, thus: As the Guru has taught me, so have I spoken. Says Nanak, listen, people: sing the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises, and you shall be saved. ||4||1||158|| On page 297, Guruji tells us that even death is overcome by singing Kirtan: One is saved from hell, suffering is destroyed, countless pains depart, death is overcome, and one escapes the Messenger of Death, by absorption in the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises. Fear departs, and one savors the Ambrosial Nectar, imbued with the Love of the Formless Lord. 'On page 322, Guruji says ‘lives of those who sing Kirtan are approved’, thus: Those who are attached to the hem of the Lord`s robe, do not suffer birth and death. Those who remain awake to the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises - their lives are approved. Guruji on page 363 tell us by singing Kirtan, Naam (God’s remembrance) is instilled in the mind thus: Without the Shabad, no one is approved. Singing the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises, the Naam abides within the mind. He Himself gives His gifts, without hesitation. ||2|| Guruji on page 454 tell us that all sins and sorrows depart when Kirtan is sang: Sing the Kirtan, the Praises of the Lord of the Universe, and all sins and sorrows shall depart. Says Nanak, chant the Hymns of the Lord, the Lord of the Universe, O mind, and enshrine love for the Lord; love the Lord this way in your mind. ||1|| On Page 642, Guruji tells us that singing Kirtan is the ‘highest of all actions’ that we can perform: Singing the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, is the highest of all actions. Says Nanak, he alone obtains it, who is pre-destined to receive it. ||8|| Guruji on Page 683 tell us clearly that ‘All desires, power, pleasure, joy and lasting bliss’ are found by singing Kirtan: All desires, power, pleasure, joy and lasting bliss, are found by chanting the Naam, the Name of the Lord, and singing the Kirtan of His Praises. That humble servant of the Lord, who has such karma pre-ordained by the Creator Lord, O Nanak - his efforts are brought to perfect fruition. ||2||20||51|| On page 1300, Guruji say by singing Kirtan, all Evil-mindedness is removed: Whoever speaks and listens to the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises is rid of evil-mindedness. All hopes and desires, O Nanak, are fulfilled. ||2||1||12|| On Page 1337, Guruji advises us that singing Kirtan is equal to bathing at 68 sacred holy places, thus: Listen, O mind: the Kirtan of the Lord`s Praises is equal to bathing at the sixty-eight sacred shrines of pilgrimage. Listen, O mind: as Gurmukh, you shall be blessed with honor. ||1|| On page 1356, Guruji tell us how by singing Kirtan, the entire world and Pride, Attachment, Greed, Anger and Lust (PAGAL, the five thieves) are conquered, thus: They walk fearlessly through the armies of their enemies; they attack them with the Kirtan of God`s Praises. They conquer the entire world, O Nanak, and overpower the five thieves. ||29|| And finally, on page 1075-6 Guruji tell us that in this era of the ‘Kal Juug’ Kirtan is supreme, thus: In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, the singing of Kirtan (Lord’s Praises) is the most dominating force. Become Gurmukh, chant and focus your meditation. You shall save yourself, and save all your generations as well. You shall go to the Court of the Lord with honor. ||6||