Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

H · 10 Dec 2005

ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS???

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

amarjeet singh · 10 Dec 2005

no

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

LionKing (LK) · 10 Dec 2005

Depends on waht you're going to watch :|

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

H · 10 Dec 2005

are you allowed to watch tv??? same thing really but i know some people who dont do either, no tv in the house at all, main reason being for all the crap that shows on tv. it is one of kalyug's best tools!! some people are too weak and become engrossed in the tv. depends really, to what extremes you want to take your sikhi.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

bus stop · 10 Dec 2005

if your too weak and easily engrosed by kalyug then dont watch tv.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Harkirat · 10 Dec 2005

i dont find tv or cinema to hve affect on my sikhi u just be carefull on what u watch i mean mostly cartoons 4 me lol

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

uksingh · 10 Dec 2005

if you read 'anhad shabad - dasm duar' by bhai sahib you will find he specifcally criticizes those amritdharees that go cinema and restaurants. if you take amrit from akj-uk, you are usually told not to go cinema.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

handy · 10 Dec 2005

no ur not

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Iron Man · 10 Dec 2005

in india? no in the west? yes

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

akaal singh · 10 Dec 2005

can u get a copy of anhad shabad - dasm duar' by bhai sahib in english, ive been looking for it [%sig%]

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

... · 10 Dec 2005

A Singh shouldn't be seen in a cinema. It does not seem appropriate to me.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

akaal singh · 10 Dec 2005

can u get a copy of 'anhad shabad - dasm duar' by bhai sahib in english? ive been lookin for it. _/\_ uksingh is it possible if u can scan a article frm the book.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

bibek daan... · 10 Dec 2005

iron man, why is it ok in the west? but not ok in india? shouldnt it be the same?

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

ekta · 10 Dec 2005

I must say that You guys (not sikhs) but tapobaners (sorry 2 say that ) are fast to isolate them selves from society...becoming hermits....talking within and only wtihin themselves....regarding everything out side ur box one of the bad Ks....guess what its not true. For example as with this situation movie theater? why is it bad? does this mean one cannot induldge in tv and movies at home? and if one can at home why not outside? JEEZ PPL> LIGHTIN UP

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Harcharan Singh · 11 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Dear all, Are you not all using the internet at this exact second? The internet can be classed as a tool for kalyug the same way a public library, a tv or a cinema can. The truth is that kalyug is all around us in everything, in case most of you have haven't noticed it is in Gurdawai to. - Giani singing manmat bollywood kirtan for the sangat and raag kirtan for waheguru - Men and women wearing besharam clothin in fornt of Guru ji - Women completing ignoring Guru ji and treating the Gur-darbar like a social club and talking - Commitee members not even Khalsa, most eaters and drinkers - Jaath or Jaatha based Gurdwarai..... We should all use the common sense Parmatma has given us and use any appropriate environment for positive use. In a cinema you can watch historical/educational films i.e. Troy, Alexander, Hotel Rwanda, Rabbit Proof Fence, Malcolm X etc etc.. Although facts are not 100% accurate it is an excellent way to learn or create an interest in history, we can learn a lot through others peoples achievments or downfalls. Our Guru's were avid historians. Cinema can also be good to occassionally entertain children with moral boosting and imaginative films like Lord of the Rings or Narnia... All we need to do isbe selective. For anyone who disagrees, then I would ask them why they are using the internet, there is 1000000000 times more kalyug on here than a selective knowledge/morale boosting film in the cinema. Personally I watch TV, I don't watch soaps, dramas, etc, but I watch the news and watch practically all types of documentaries, I have learnt a huge deal through the effort made by truely amazing people in giving us a glimpse and understading of wildlife, world faiths, cultures, history, medicine, science, war, politics etc etd.... This is not to say our life should revolve around TV, life should revolve around Guru (Bani, Nitnem, seva, kirtan and simran). But as a source of education all the modern tools are excellent inventions. All things invented for good use i.e. advanced music was originally used in the Vedic period for the praise of God only. It only became a source of entertainment when the Mughals took over, it then moved to brothels. Today we have music which is 90% used or filth, does that mean we should stop using it? All martial arts were invented for defence and self preservation, many in a faith protecting context i.e. Shaolin Kung Fu (to protect Buddism), Shaster Vidya (not Gatka) to protect Sikhi (and through Sikhi to protect all). Hope these examples give you another way to look at this topic. Satnaam Harcharan Singh

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

... · 11 Dec 2005

Some people on this board are funny. They ask "is it alright to do X" and the Gursikhs reply that it's not and they find that offensive. If you don't like the advice, don't follow it. Watch movies as much as you want, it doesn't really effect any but you. The fact is that Gursikhs on the spiritual path avoid theatres and avoid wasting time on TV and movies. You say that there is something to be learned from TV. Sure. There's something to be learned, but at what cost? You want to know about Malcolm X, then read his autobiography. If you want to learn about Alexander the Great, read it in a book. If you watch the movie, you're going to get nudity and dirty scenes. In a movie you may get some information, but at the same time I can't think of many movies that don't have at least one objectionable scene in them. The fact is that a lot of us aren't strong enough to avoid the lure of the manmat on TV and in Movies. If an objectionable scene comes, some of us may not be strong enough to turn away. You can justify watching Bollywood romance by claiming you're learning about worldly love. You can watch anything and claim to learn something. So if you want to watch TV and movies, go for it. Gursikhs don't reccomend it, but if no one is physically stopping you. If you don't like that advice, then that's frankly your problem. Don't ask for it or read it in the future. Sikhi is a very serious path. It requires limitless dedication and commitment. Someone who wants to walk on this path has to give his/her head and be ready to make any sacrifice. Each decision boils down to, "will I get closer to Vahiguru and get kirpan of Guru Sahib through this or not?". If something seems like it may take us away, then it's best avoided. Once you start watching movies and claim they are "educational", you start a slippery slope. Anything can be called educational. You can say that

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Mehtab Singh · 11 Dec 2005

hmmm...are GurSikhs allowed to use public toilets in case of an urgent call of nature?

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Where to stop · 11 Dec 2005

At that rate you should not go outside into the world, the world is full of sin. What it comes down to is that you should be strong enough to resist the lure of sin. "..." mentioned reading books instead, so books cannot have anything wrong/sinful in them? I have to disagree with that. What it comes down to is that if you want to ban going to movies and watching television, you should also not go online, read books, go to work, go to the store, etc. You will just have to remain inside your house, competely disconnected from the world. Where do you stop? Maybe we should all just leave our homes and go into the mountains...then Guru Ji will be happy with us, right?

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

... · 11 Dec 2005

Not going to the movies, in your eyes, is equal to withdrawing from the world and heading to the mountains? Wow. Must be a big movies fan. Use your bibek budhi. If you think there is something that can help your Sikhi in a movie, go watch it. I personally saw the movie "Khalsa" and "Sahibzade" and found them informative. I won't randomly go and watch movies in theatres and hope to learn something from them. Same thing in terms of books and internet: if you use them to educate yourself and learn the right things, then it's fine. People that avoid watching movies in theatres and spending time in front of the TV do live fairly normal lives. I'm not anywhere near a mountain.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

LionKing (LK) · 11 Dec 2005

Ofcourse not Mehtab Singh!!! - Ofcourse you can't use Toilets used by hair-cutter, tobacco smoking, alcohole drinking people!!!! Sarcasm level: HIGH

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Where to stop · 11 Dec 2005

OK, I am confused now, at first "..." you said that you should not watch any movies, not even ones that are aimed at being educational. Now you are saying that some movies are good? Where do you stand on this topic? If its with the latter, I agree with you. That was the point of my post, you cannot apply a certain rule to this, some movies are good and some are bad. Its a grey area. I think that answers the question, right?

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

... · 11 Dec 2005

where to stop, what I'm saying is that it's best to have a general rule of "no movies", but occassionally making an exception if there is something worthwhile. I still don't think going to theatres is right though. The type of exception I'm talking about is pretty special. Not, "oh, I think that movie may teach me about the relationship between humans and moh, and so I'll go watch "just friends". Usually the exception is for directly Sikhi related stuff.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

pow · 11 Dec 2005

simple answer is no, i dont know why the easiest questions are the most debated

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

gurpreet singh · 11 Dec 2005

bhae prapat manukh dahureea, gobindh milan kee eh teree bareeaa dont forget the point of your life when thinking about topics such as these

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 12 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh I feel really sorry for the ones that think there's nothing wrong with watching movies/TV. Do you know that you're only coming to this conclusion because of the demons inside you, the body village. The demon, such as the demon of worldly attachment, uses the body organs and the 5 senses to entangle with any sort of attachment, as in this case TV/cinema/movies, as these body organs and senses are slaves of the demon. Your soul is there in the body but the demons are too strong for the soul to control the body, as the mind is evil and the soul is good, thats where the name manmukh comes in. Furthermore, gurbani also states that manmukhs are like demons, the reason for this is because we agree with what ever the demons do and we don't try to resist them and follow what Guru jee's told us to do. Instead of watching movies and all that, you could be doing Naam Bhagti, Kalyug uses any small attachment and weakness that fulfills the hearts anxitey. Also, to conclude, if any of you are using the excuse 'I want to gain knowledge from watching movies', if you worried about obtaining less knowledge then perform Naam Bhagti is this is the jewel of Knowledge. To elobarate even more, this life we're in is just a dream of drama being played on stage, it's like a magic-show, and by watching movies and all that you're living in an illusion, wake up and realise reality and the only truth in life, which is what Guru Jee's wants us to do, the truth is our Sikhis. We only obtain this precious human life once, life is short and just a dream, the reality is held in the hereafter. After these demons use you when you die, they escape the body and instead you get captured by the Yama (messanger of death). you can also tell where and out of what hole the Yama pulled the soul out of, as it usually the eyes as they opened on the human body, but every other trace of existence of spirituallity is kept secret. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

guruji's_student · 12 Dec 2005

wiked shabad and so true we have been given this human body.. and this is our time to meet the lord waheguru!!

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Harcharan Singh · 12 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Can the people with the "problem" please explain to me why they are therefore using the internet. Asked this before there was no answer, I don't expect there will be one no. I spoke of films based on History, we should learn about history, not just ours but everyones. And we should watch documentaries if they educate us. The book example is funny, if you want see how a lion hunts, are just supposed to read a book, close your eyes and imagine, or perfhaps create a series of images in a book, then flick through it really fast to see the motion???please. Please don't judge other people on your own weaknesses. Harcharan Singh

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Dharam · 12 Dec 2005

The purpose of a Sikh's existance is to Jap Naam. Going to a cinema will probably hinder this objective without any good reason. You can very easily avoid this hinderance by not going. It all depends on how difficult you want your task to be.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

observer · 12 Dec 2005

have you noticed how none of the MAIN singhs reply to these threads? None of the posters that people really respect. I think most people have figured out that people put questions up, others reply, then they points fingers at each other depending upon the opinions. Then just blame tapoban for being Kattar. Then the same people go on other messagebaords and say anti AKJ or tapoban things. In reality, no Tapoban Singhs probably post. Neither most other respected posters. They get blame for nothing, but do not mind, coz the ninda washes their souls. The answer to all these posts. USE YOUR COMMON SENSE TO FIND THE BEST WAY TO GET TO YOUR GURU.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Kulbir Singh · 12 Dec 2005

Our opinion on TV is not hidden. We preach against watching TV. It is true that some TV programs are good but the package that we get along with these good programs is not worth it. For average individuals its hard to restrain themselves from not going further and watching other TV programs. What may begin as an innocent entertainment ends up with corrupting a person’s mind and ruining one's spirituality. Even the advertisements in news and other good programs are full of manmatt like nudity, suggestive stuff and violence. While TV affects ones spiritual life, TV watching also hurts one’s family life. The whole family sitting in one room but not talking to each other and not even looking at each other is a common sight at modern homes. The whole family sitting in one room is sitting quietly and watching TV. What a gloomy sight this is. Children who should get love of their parents in the evening by hearing stories and communicating, have to settle for video games and TV programs. In olden days, families used to sit together in the evening and talk and laugh for hours. Especially in winters, everyone used to sit around fire, eat peanuts and do healthy communication with each other. Now a days, still the whole family sits together but it sits in front of TV watching some program and not talking to each other. What a gloomy sight! Afsos!! Several Westerners have given up watching TV and gone back to way of good old days. They read books and interact with each other instead of watching TV. May Guru Sahib do kirpa on Panth and save it from Kanjarwood and TV watching. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

uk singh · 12 Dec 2005

Agree with Kulbir Singh 100%. I personally do not have the drive to live without TV or Cinema and find it entertaining as well as informative. If Guru Sahib does kirpa then of course we will receive all the entertainment we could possibly need from naam.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

troubled · 12 Dec 2005

how about internet? what about watchin/listenin to the sikhi programmes/kirtan/broadcasts from harmandir sahib on alpha panjabi, sukh sagar, panjab radio, asian network in the mornings?? (i know some are radio stations but they still have filthy songs)

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

... · 12 Dec 2005

Use your bibek budhi! If it's something clearly Sikhi related then it should be fine. Not many rules are absolute. This is relative as well. Even Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib showed the movie Sahibzade to their children's class. As a general rule: no tv or movies. Then there are occassional exceptions. Radio to listen to Darbar Sahib is so clearly OK, it boggles the mind to think someone might have doubts.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

unreal · 12 Dec 2005

Kulbir Singh's reasons re family interaction are the most prominent reasons for not having a t.v. With a t.v. on, there is NO family interaction - what a waste. And its not that hard to live without one. I grew up with a t.v. at home but when I moved out for school, I didn't buy one - no time. And now that I'm working, I purposely didn't buy one because if I had one, I'd sit at home and do nothing. Not having a t.v. forces me to get out of the house and do something. Although, I must admit, I do enjoy going to the theatre every now and then. Anybody see Charlie and the Chocolate factory :) What a great movie to take the kids to watch.

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Amritpal Singh · 12 Dec 2005

Have you ever seen a singh in bana at a movie theatre?? try this experiment...go put on bana...big damala...khanda... Tyaar bar tyaar... then go to a movie theatre. You tell me yourself how u feel. I personally would feel as though im out of place and not suppose to be there.. specially when the classic nudy scene comes or the dirty dialoge scene... yeah great! thats exactly what khalsa needs to do.. I remember when i was not a singh, i went to a theatre with a bunch of people to watch some movie... one singh we dragged into the movie and then not even 15 mins into the movie..the singh had this sad face....and then just quietly himself walked out of the theatre and waited outside for us. At that time i thought he was an extremist and just plain crazy. I mean what can a simple movie do to you!? It affects your aavaasta. After watching a movie, one doesnt feel like doing paat, feels lazy to pick up a gutka and do sukhmani sahib. To put this frankly, the people who are defending TV and movies, probably dont have much of an amrit vela or do much paat. Because if they did, they would realize how hard it is to maintain rehit with the distractions of movies

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 13 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh Bhai Sahib Amritpal Singh Jee, gave out a lot good points, as before when I used to watch TV programs, it really began to make me lazy as well, but now instead of doing that I get much work done and naam bhagti in the evening done as well. Additionally, through the demon of worldly attachment comes laziness, what the person has to really remember is that without Naam the mind never becomes stable, but instead weakens even more to emotional attachment to maya. The shabad below elaborates on the statement made above. shhodd shhodd rae bikhiaa kae rasooaa || Give them up - give up the pleasures of corruption; ourajh rehiou rae baavar gaavar jio kirakhai hariaaeiou pasooaa ||1|| rehaao || you are entangled in them, you crazy fool, like an animal grazing in the green fields. ||1||Pause|| jo jaanehi thoo(n) apunae kaajai so sa(n)g n chaalai thaerai thasooaa || That which you believe to be of use to you, shall not go even an inch with you. naago aaeiou naag sidhhaasee faer firiou ar kaal garasooaa ||1|| Naked you came, and naked you shall depart. You shall go round and round the cycle of birth and death, and you shall be food for Death. ||1|| paekh paekh rae kasu(n)bh kee leelaa raach maach thinehoo(n) lo hasooaa || Watching, watching the transitory dramas of the world, you are embroiled and enmeshed in them, and you laugh with delight. shheejath ddor dhinas ar rainee jeea ko kaaj n keeno kashhooaa ||2|| The string of life is wearing thin, day and night, and you have done nothing for your soul. ||2|| karath karath eiv hee biradhhaano haariou oukathae than kheenasooaa || Doing your deeds, you have grown old; your voice fails you, and your body has become weak. jio mohiou oun mohanee baalaa ous thae ghattai naahee ruch chasooaa ||3|| You were enticed by Maya in your youth, and your attachment for it has not diminished, one little bit. ||3|| jag aisaa mohi gurehi dhikhaaeiou tho saran pariou thaj garabasooaa || The Guru has shown me that this is the way of the world; I have abandoned the dwelling of pride, and entered Your Sanctuary. maarag prabh ko sa(n)th bathaaeiou dhrirree naanak dhaas bhagath har jasooaa ||4||6||127|| The Saint has shown me the Path of God; slave Nanak has implanted devotional worship and the Praise of the Lord. ||4||6||127|| Basically, time shouldn't be wasted with useless pleasures of illusion given by TV, but instead that person should realise that the life is just a dream, remain dead to the world but yet alive to your rehit, everything else in this world is an illusion, even though you may think it gives you pleasure. Clear your doubts and realise the truth. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh

Re: ARE U ALLOWED 2 GO CINEMAS?

Bhopinder Singh · 13 Dec 2005

Foxking Whome are you poking,your own brethren ,we should be proud of such singhs .If we cannot do this, why criticise those who can.Nobody is forcing you to do anyhting. This is the difference between old singhs and the new ones.They are following rehat of Guru ji to the best of their abilities .