Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

... · 03 Dec 2005

This is the Indian Army's "Sikh Regiment". I don't see a single Sikh in it. [%sig%]

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Jasmin · 03 Dec 2005

They don't allow beards, maybe.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Dec 2005

TOTAL SHAME

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

j · 03 Dec 2005

That maybe a diff battalion? Heres some pics: [%sig%]

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

... · 03 Dec 2005

must be the Bhaiya company of the Sikh regiment. Very odd.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

S Singh · 04 Dec 2005

They do not look like the Sikh Regiment or the Sikh Light Infantry Regiment to me. Other regiments do wear turbans for official funtions and parades so it need not be the Sikh regiment.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

... · 04 Dec 2005

I'm pretty sure it's the Sikh regiment. Only the Sikh regiment have the chakars around their dastaars. The colours are the same as well.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Bhagwant Singh · 04 Dec 2005

Khalsaji Maybe someone tech savvy could blow up the image and check what it says on the shoulder badge etc. Could provide a better clue - because I think Sikh regiment will have Sikh and Sikh LI will have Sikh LI. I am still pretty sure that to join the Sikh/Sikh LI regiment's you have to be full keshdhari. Maybe a serving or recently retired Sikh soldier could help us on the facts or if the regiment has been merged WJK,WJF [%sig%]

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Iron Man · 04 Dec 2005

I think its more disgraceful that these "sikhs" are in the indian army.. and whats with the hair nets in the dhari??? can u imagine baba deep singh fighting with his dhari tied like that? LOL!

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

unreal · 04 Dec 2005

Dear Iron Man, Who said anything about these Sikhs being on a level comparable to Baba Deep Singh ji? The topic of tied and untied beards has been discussed before. In the end, it came down to a matter of opinion only with one side saying tying beards doesn't make one less of a Sikh and the other side saying tying up beards is un-sikh like. There was nothing backing up either side, only opinion. As for serving in the armed forces, there are other Sikhs helping Indian economy through business, other Sikhs helping Indian society via their medical expertise, other Sikhs helping India through their farms etc. I do not think service in the armed forces is such a far cry from serving India in all these other functions. If it is helping India which is considered disgraceful, then all Sikhs in India should immediately stop paying taxes, stop recognizing any government representatives, stop making use of anything remotely related to government service. Better yet, all Sikhs should make a mass exit from India by any means necessary, peacful exodus or violent war. Maybe you can take on the seva of organizing all this? If not, then stop judging those Sikhs who actually live in India and have little choice about it.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

:P · 04 Dec 2005

well said "unreal" ji

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

S Singh · 04 Dec 2005

Good post - unreal. People do not join the army for the fun of it. Many come from poor backgrounds and with all the Biharis doing farm labour, joining the army is a way to provide for the family. Westerners cannot provide anything for the 1984 widows and orphans, so they should put up or shut up when it comes to such criticism.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Manjot Kaur · 04 Dec 2005

Hmm... The gold-ish thing on their shoulders says Sikh in the second picture shown......... The first picture has the men wearing an orange thing instead. True the dastaar/pagh/turbans are the same stature but that part of their uniforms is different. The first picture also has the men with plaid stripes going diagonally across their paghs underneath the chakkar. Just some observations =)

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

45th Rattray's Sikhs · 04 Dec 2005

As a collector of Sikh Regiment medals, i hope i can shead some light on the matter. As of 1922, the 1st, 2nd, 3rd battalions( of the 11th SIKHS) were to be all Jat Sikhs, the 4th and 5th battalions were to be 50% Jat Sikhs and 50 % Punjabi Mussalmans, while the 10th battalion would have 4 Sikh companies and 1 Punjabi mussalman company. Before the re-organization in 1922 the following regiments were made-up of entirely Jat Sikhs. 14th Sikhs 15th Sikhs 45th Sikhs 36th Sikhs 47th Sikhs 35th Sikhs 23rd Sikh Pioneers 32nd. Sikhs Pioneers 34th Sikh Pioneers (after the 1947 partition, The Sikh Light Infantry) were comprised entirely of Mazhbi and Ramdassia Sikhs. And then their were the 51st, 52nd, 53rd, and 54th Sikhs, which were "sikh" only in name, they were 75% musselman and 25% Sikh.... often confused as Sikh Regiments. on a side note, are their any other collectors out their of Sikh Regiment Medals or militaria. 45th Rattray's Sikhs.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

ekta · 04 Dec 2005

there is no more sikh regiment...its the punjab regiment. and i know its sad that sikhs are a part of the indian army, but hey thye gotta make a living 2.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

S Singh · 05 Dec 2005

I am sure there is still a Sikh regiment based at Ramgarh. The Punjab regiment also exists with their regiment centre also at Ramgarh (Bihar). The Sikh Light infantry used to be centred at Fatehgarh (UP).

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

JS · 05 Dec 2005

There is a Sikh regiment in the Indian army, but they find it hard to recruit Keshadhari Sikhs as nearly 80-90% of youth in the Punjab are cleanshaven. This link gives an overview of the Sikh regiment http://allaboutsikhs.com/warriors/sikhregt.htm

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Nishan E Khalsa · 10 Dec 2005

I believe this pic is fake. Or May Be part of some movie where Bhaiya - Bihari Pose as Sikhs and destroy our culture.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

turbocharged · 10 Dec 2005

the british army, back in WW2 said a sikh keeping full rehit was mandatory in their regiments period. The indian army encorages hair trimmings in the sikh regiments. if you dont believe me, join the indian army yourselves and find out. and if you do decide to join the indian army, just watch out when the government oraganises another country wide massacre like the pograms in 1984, as on orders, unarmed sikh soldiers where taken out of their baracks and put to death by firing squad.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

harpreet singh · 10 Dec 2005

This is to the person who has knowledge of sikh rigements. I was wondering approximately how many sikhs abdicated from the indian army after 84 or durin the tension between the govt and the sikhs? If not an exact number maybe an approxmiate percentage. Thanks wjkk wjkf

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Sikh Regiment · 12 Dec 2005

Wahiguru JI Ka Khalsa Wahiguru Ji Ki Fateh above photo could be of Punjab regiment. In Jahrkhand we have Sikh regimenatal cetntre and in UP Fatehgarh Sikh li is there among various formation all over India. Turban and Beared and 5ks aree allowed in Indian,British and Canadian Armies and recntly in swedan also. more and more of our childern must join Army at least Terotroial Army. Some parts of Sikh Regiments may have upto 40% of non Sikh which were injected by Gen Vaidya but now things are changing. Officer of Sikh regiment is mostly non Sikh. somer part of Regiment also needs Sikh only and non Sikh has to give conversion to Sikhism certificate to join those part of reigement if recruitment is to be done at Ramgarh. Irony is that often many Patits temoraryly keep hairs or tie turban and after joining again remove them.Govt. can not do much as in India there is no ban to prevent Sikhs from cutting hairs etc.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Gurcharan Singh · 12 Dec 2005

Please do not count out that Kesadhari turbanned and GurSikh youth serve regularly in the armed Forces of Singapore, Malaysia, and Thailand for almost over one hundered years.Turbanned Sikhs have also served in the Fijian Forces, though not many now. The practice to integrate the regiments in India has ceased on realisation, some kaums are more martial than others.The climate too has changed. Most of the commanding officers of Sikh regiments are ussually non Sikhs, and most other non Sikh regiments have Sikh officers.This was a practice from the colonial times.All Sikhs joining all Sikh regiments were expected to be amritdharis.But that changed later, though they are still expected to be turbanned Sikhs, an hallmark for Sikh presense in thebattle field. The exception being the Rajindra Sikhs of Patiala, or commonly called Patiala Sikhs, who were the prime factor- that Kashmir was saved from Pakistan.This lone Sikh Regiment was in the fore for saving Srinager.The Srinager landings in October, 1947,not only saved the valley of Kashmir, but the whole state of kashmir. The Srinager Landings wre briliantly excuted air moves involving the 1st Battalion of The Sikh Regiment of The Patiala Rajindra Sikhs. This lone battalion unit ,unsupported,unquestionably saved Srinager against all odds.The battle of Zozila was fought by the 1st Rajindra Sikhs (1st Battalion of the Patiala State Forces -both battles were fought with such heroism against even though the larger numbers of enemy-the enemy choose best to flee in such fear that they nick named the Rajindra Sikhs as the" kalui damela "-the devils in black turbans!! Lord Mountbatten -Governor General of India said :- "In all my war experience I have never seen or heard of a small number of troops comming in by air,onto the tiniest peice of landing strip and turning the tide in 24 hours , and causing the enemy numbering well over 20,000 men to flee in fear!These Sikhs were truly magnificent and hansdome men in their black turbans they all stood at over 6 feet, would have put the german army to shame , luckily they were on our side!" want to know know ? Gurcharan Singh -SikhEkta

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

keepin it real · 13 Dec 2005

Nice post Gurcharan Singh Ji Reagrding earlier post- I heard the reason the darees were tied up was so that they dont get caught up in the in the gun whilst firing. Not sure if it is a viable comment but thought i might jus add it in.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Jang Vijay · 16 Dec 2005

This is somewhat off topic but since the past few years, every year on the Indian Repuplic Day, there is a picture of the Sikh Regiment (with turbans) on the front page of the Times of India... It is surely the most elegant regiment of all... Makes me really proud.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

fly fast · 16 Dec 2005

"It is surely the most elegant regiment of all" Yea sure, shame they are persuaded to go against their rehit (sikh code of conduct of trimming their beards) Well, that brahmanization for ya!

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Gursikh · 02 Feb 2006

( I beg to differ) It is very sad that we people start commenting out without knowing anything in real. Do you know that in India some Regiments are based on caste and creed for eg Sikh Regiment, Garhwal Regiment, Kumaon Regiment, Maratha Light Infantry etc. These Regiments have General Duty(Soliders) Person belonging to that Caste or Creed on which regiment is based and in Clerical and Trademan job cadre they can have anybody from any caste in serving that regiment. A person can join the army at very early age of 17 yrs but he should not be more than 21 yrs of age according to the recuritment rules of Indian army. The person being seen in the photograph (without beard) is of young tender age , he is not having his natural beard or he may be person who is recurited as an person for clerical job of another caste , why you people atart shouting hoarse without knowingthe truth . I tell you the truth about the Sikh Regiment. Sikh in the Sikh Regiment are the most practising Sikhs in the whole world better than us and I can Bet on it. They live their live with all the marayada and rehit of the sikh religions. In Sikh Regiment it is compulsory for the Sikh to have unshorn hairs and long flowing beard. They tie their long flowing beard in net. When a person is going on leave he his given strict instruction to not to cut his hairs and beard and if not reporing back to the Duty the person is found that he has cut his beard and shorn his hairs .He is given the stringest of possible punishment . While going to the Gurudwara Sahib they remove their leather belts and socks also, which we so called sikhs wear proudly inside the gurudwara sahib. They get up early in the morning to offer morning prayers Japji Sahib and also they assemble in the evening for Rehraas Sahib . They have never retreated from the Battlefield always faced the enemy head on with bravey and courage. The Sikh Regiment is still the most decorated regiments of the Indian Army they won many theatre honours and Battles for their country. The Sikh Regiment was the worst affected Regiment in the Kargil war (8th Sikh Participated in it). They are "Bravest of Brave" . If you have any doubts about the bravery and rehit Maryada of the Regiment , Go and ask Pakistani Generals and Chinese Troops who have faced them in the Battle-field I am sure your doubts will be cleared .

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

LS · 02 Feb 2006

The current Indian Sikh regiment DOES allow Sikhs to cut their Kesh. There was an odd photograph released a few days ago in the newspapers with soldiers wearing beard nets, but had no beards or moustaches. Sikh soldiers are often used as cannon fodder in Indian wars.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

PTE SINGH · 15 Mar 2006

I think its disgraceful that people with no understanding of what it means to join the service feel free to comment upon it so brashly. I am turbaned Sikh with an uncut beard and a recruit in the British TA. Every respect is given to my religous code and i in turn respect the army code. The same respect is extended to every Sikh in the Indian Army. In the same way that our Gurka regs have non Gurkhas in it and our Highland regiments and Irish Dragoons have non Scots and Irish personnel, i except that the modern Sikh regiments (distinguished by the red in their uniforms) will have non Sikhs. We no longer group people on the basis of caste,creed, religion or region in the armed forces. The reason that soldiers in the Sikh regiment wear beard nets is to give uniformity to all the different lengths of beards and to those who may be too young to even have a beard. The chap who gives the example of BABA DEEP SINGH should be ashamed of himself and is the exact type of person who would never join or be able to commit to the service of others, something which is a fundamental part of being a 'SIKH'... > This is the Indian Army's "Sikh Regiment". I don't see a > single Sikh in it. > > > [%sig%]

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

LS · 15 Mar 2006

From the message by PTE Singh, 'In the same way that our Gurka regs have non Gurkhas in it and our Highland regiments and Irish Dragoons have non Scots and Irish personnel, i except that the modern Sikh regiments (distinguished by the red in their uniforms) will have non Sikhs. We no longer group people on the basis of caste,creed, religion or region in the armed forces.' From the Sikh Regiment by DS Sandhu 'Following Operation Bluestar, a large number of recruits at Ramgarh mutinied. They shot and killed the Commandant of the Sikh Regimental Center, Brigadier S.C. Puri and wounded some other officers. They then got hold of a number of trucks and started to proceed towards Punjab, but were stopped by army men in Bihar and U.P. A large part of 9 Sikh which was in the Ganganagar area of Rajasthan mutinied. This battalion was disbanded on April 1, 1985 [15]. Following Operation Bluestar, the then COAS, General Arun Vaidya wanted to have more mixed battalions, so he passed an order that single class battalions should begin recruiting other classes as well as their parent class. These mixed battalion came to be known as "Vaidya's Battalions". Regarding the Sikh Regiment, 13 Sikh is the Vaidya battalion and its class composition consists of a company each of Sikhs, Dogras, Garhwalis and South Indians [15]. When General K. Sundarji took over as army chief, one of the first orders he issued was to put a stop to the formation of more "Vaidya's Battalions". Now-a-days most of the regiments have started to switch their Vaidya battalions back to original regimental class composition.' The mixing of battlions was oppossed by the Sikh regiment . Under the British the Sikh regiment recruited Sikh's ,while the Punjab regiment was mixed.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

gsay · 16 Mar 2006

These are not Sikhs. To uphold the Maharaja Ranjit Singhs thought they do this. Maharaj Ranjit Singh had many muslims and hindus in his army. In fact his main gun battalion was dominantly made up of muslims and hindus made a lot of the light infantry. However, there was a common dress and a dastaar was part of it. THis is just a historical thing and its called the sikh regiment for that reason. Jus to let you know I am not here to defend the indian army but i think we should always look at something from one point of view. I am aware of Indias many human right violation and the Hindutva movement led against us. I do feel Khalistan is a necessity although we may not get it physically we need to get our rights and become spiritually khalis. If we all are khalis we will all unite in sangat and our Khalistan will be made. But even before Khalistan we need to become united and individually khalis (through sangats help of course its a cyclic relationship). I know I am going off onto a tangent but just trying to let you know I am not in the Indian Governments defence.

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

LK · 16 Mar 2006

"Author: Bhagwant Singh Date: 12-04-05 05:33 Khalsaji Maybe someone tech savvy could blow up the image and check what it says on the shoulder badge etc. Could provide a better clue - because I think Sikh regiment will have Sikh and Sikh LI will have Sikh LI. I am still pretty sure that to join the Sikh/Sikh LI regiment's you have to be full keshdhari. Maybe a serving or recently retired Sikh soldier could help us on the facts or if the regiment has been merged WJK,WJF" ------------------------ If you look carefully, the badge does say 'Sikh' As for dhari, it's complete common sense that the Sikhs in the army wil tie their beard. Can't understand how anyone can ever condemn a Sikh in the army for tying their dhari :S Isn't there a quota imposed on Sikhs of 2% of something?

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

Raviraj Singh · 16 Mar 2006

I found out that they would pay you more If you trimmed your beard.. My nana ji was in India's navy and his Brother was in the army in the 60s and he told me he got a chance to be promoted and paid more but they told him to trim his beard he did not and never got the position. Also his brother was put in a similar situation where they confronted him and told him if he trimmed he would get paid more, did not happen and he did not get the money. Just something to think about? Perhaps this is another clue? Who knows...

Re: Disgraceful "Sikh" Regiment

jaspal · 16 Mar 2006

i strongly disagree with gsay who is saying that this is not the SIKH regiment. My father is presently serving the SIKH regiment and i know most about this regiment then anyone of you right here on the this forum. In the Sikh regiment the general duty cadre which comprises of the fighting squad only SIKH are recruited and in the non fighting squad like clerk grade, cooking, sweeper other person from anywhere from India can be recruited regardsless of his religion. Once the person is recruited he has to wear turban whether he is sikh or not. But if the person recruited is SIKH and before getting recruited he has cut his hair he is then forced to grow his hair after joining the regiment and also he has to follow the complete SIKH rehit . In the Indian army usually a person gets recruited at the very young age of 16.1/2 yrs only . and at that time some of the sikhs do not have beard at all and the SIKH Infantry man seen in the picture is one of them . I think i have made much clear to you regarding this and if you have still have doubt you can visit their training centre at RAMGARH Cantt., JHARKHAND it is established along with the Punjab Regiment.