Amritdhari Surgeon
Vignesh Singh · 06 Nov 2005
I am completing my residency and wish to become a surgeon. However, when i talk to my advisors, they say i must take off my kara when performing surgery. Please help me. Can i still become a surgeon and take off my kara only for the safety of my patients? Is there another way around this? I would really love to be an amritdhari surgeon as it would give all members of the Panth a pure option for medical help.
Thank you for your help.
Re: Amritdhari Surgeon
jashen kaur · 07 Nov 2005
I am a student nurse only a few months ago I had the same problem. i was told to take my sarboloh kara off during a maternity placement in the name of health and safety. They threw many different issues my way such mrsa and handwashing tecniques. However i didnt bow down even when my uni or my union didnt provide enough support. I took the matter to the top ppl in my local trust. who informed the mayor of london on the issue. And now to cut a long story short iv not had a problem since. All i can say i know your matter is alittle different, but do make all right ppl aware of whats being asked of you. And if that doesn't work im sure you could get some backing from your local sikh organasations to provide some re-education on why we wear a kara. Good luck!!!
Gurfateh ji
Re: Amritdhari Surgeon
*******(or Jasmin) · 11 Nov 2005
Heres another angle:
Is it really important to be both an amritdhari and a surgeon at the same time in one's life?
I understand wanting to take amrit, but maybe taking it as you are preparing for a life in the surgerical or nursing field makes little sense. One could still be a Gursikh, but prehaps you will have to take Amrit when you retire.
If anyone asks why you are not Amritdhari you could say " my job is an important one.-----I'm able to save lives and genuinely help people with serious medical conditions. This job, as we all know, can involve the removal of
hair. This action, even for the best of reasons,------- is a kurehit generally, and a bujjer kurehit for amritdhari. I'm sorry this happens as part of my job.
However, sometimes an operation is a matter of life or death.
Even so----- I can't be Amritdhari,----- and commit bujjer kurehits left and right! Image how absurd that would be! Really it's laughable! I admit it. I'd like to retire early, because I would love to pesh and take Amrit as soon as I can!!!
Re: Amritdhari Surgeon
raj_karega_khalsa · 11 Nov 2005
I don't think you should EVER shave YOUR hair, even if it's to save your life, it's only temporary, would you rather die a gursikh, or shave your hair to save your life and eventually die neway! n on top of that get beat by jamdooths.....Sir Jaavay Ta Jaavay Mayree Sikhee Sidq Naa Jaavay
BUt if u a surgeon, n the ppl you operatin on are ok with shavin their hair, then u aint doin ne paap........
n wuts wit every1 bashin bibek? On one hand evry1's yellin bout "EKTA" n "UNITY" then bashin KHalsaa Rehits that som Gursikhs keep, n it IS basically jus bashin AKJ n sum Nihangs cuz they the majority of the Gursikhs that keep this rehit....good step towards unity
Bhull CHak MAaph
Re: Amritdhari Surgeon
ukmedstudent · 12 Nov 2005
does anyone know if its likely i will have to shave a patients hair during the three clinical yrs of the course?
after i have my degree i could let some1 else cut the hair, but i wnt be able to to that before i graduate.
Re: Amritdhari Surgeon
Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005
I have not read the whole of this posts.But it is a load of rubbish to suggest that a kara be taken off.I work with the NHS and initially trained as a RGN, then RMNH andlater RMN before I worked my way to the Forensics.
I have worked in all departments before reaching to be a Senior Borough Sector Manager,I never took my kara off ever, and it is still there whn I do my C & R periodically.
Jashen kaur ji can you provide me the details of which union you approached or belong to and which Trust this is.
I will take the issue up, and to the NMC.This should not be happening.I have just completed some guidelines based on NICE guidleines on how to deal with Sikh patients when operating or about to operate.
However, one solution is to offer to cover the kara and kirpan with sterile bandage as an band. for the time in the operating theatre or sterile area.This a compromise meeting them half way, without compromising on the rehat.
I know I will get some flaake flying , but the reality is we also need to be seen to be proactive.
At least you do not take the kara off, or the kirpan off as some have compromised at airports.
I recall one individual blaming me for suggesting tying his beard up.I only gave information based on standing orders of the army and police.
It is better than abandoning kirpan,at airport, and then starving yourself with some brahminical ritual like some one has suggested on this net elsewhere until one gets the kirpan back.The simple task is to just do an ardas, instead people are comming up with some of their own brand rehat!!Please refrain.
Someone asked my email address..it is Chaan [address removed]
Re: Amritdhari Surgeon
akjrocks!!! · 14 Nov 2005
vjkk vjkp
coming bak 2 da topic!!!
my friend plays basketball and hes not aloud to wear his kara,
so he takes it of and puts it around his jura
vjkk vjkp
Re: Amritdhari Surgeon
Gurcharan Singh · 16 Nov 2005
Jashan kaur Ji, I am still waiting to hear from you, so that I can take this issue up with the NMC and also the Union involved.
You have been victimised and let down by the union.I am in the field, I know what should have happend, and I will take the issue up if you care to tell me which NHS trust and union it was .It could only be UNISON and RCN as most likely unions in the NHS.