Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Amritdhari Surgeon

Amritdhari Surgeon

Vignesh Singh · 06 Nov 2005

I am completing my residency and wish to become a surgeon. However, when i talk to my advisors, they say i must take off my kara when performing surgery. Please help me. Can i still become a surgeon and take off my kara only for the safety of my patients? Is there another way around this? I would really love to be an amritdhari surgeon as it would give all members of the Panth a pure option for medical help. Thank you for your help.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

jashen kaur · 07 Nov 2005

I am a student nurse only a few months ago I had the same problem. i was told to take my sarboloh kara off during a maternity placement in the name of health and safety. They threw many different issues my way such mrsa and handwashing tecniques. However i didnt bow down even when my uni or my union didnt provide enough support. I took the matter to the top ppl in my local trust. who informed the mayor of london on the issue. And now to cut a long story short iv not had a problem since. All i can say i know your matter is alittle different, but do make all right ppl aware of whats being asked of you. And if that doesn't work im sure you could get some backing from your local sikh organasations to provide some re-education on why we wear a kara. Good luck!!! Gurfateh ji

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

siinghh · 07 Nov 2005

You will also be shaving people to operate on them?

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

UKSingh · 07 Nov 2005

Tie a kara in your darstar if you must remove the one form your wrist, nut like bhenji said, fight it all you can first

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Jasmin · 07 Nov 2005

I wonder why so many Sikhs seem to work in the medical field. It's hard to imagine an enviroment less gurmat. We have cooks working in the kitchen area, who may be smokers, who cook nonveg. We have medicines developed with animal testing, and most distrubing we have surgery performed, which often violates the kes. I can't image any gursikh comfortable with this, even if the victim/patient is a non-Sikh, and even if the assistant does the dirty work----- especially, God forbid, brain surgery. Personally the more I think about it, the more uncomfortable I become. I suppose it's because it's a seva to save a life. Still, it seems an odd match.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

MOW · 07 Nov 2005

when i do dissection i take my big kare off and put them in my pocket, and keep a smaller one on, and push it all the way to the top of my arm so it stays there and doesnt fall down and get dead body cadaver juice all over it.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

stranger · 07 Nov 2005

WHohey Jasmin so you suggest we should not excel in the field of medicine cos its anti gurmat? Next time you or a close relative needs to visit the hospital or have surgery remember how lucky they are that someone is able to help them!!!!

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

vichar · 07 Nov 2005

dnt you have to shave off patients hair? paaap

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Jugdeep · 07 Nov 2005

Regarding shaving off patients hair, if it is something like brain surgery where one must have an operation to save their life, would sikhi allow for the shaving of the hair. They would also have to remove the dastaar as well. I guess we must ask ourselves, what does Sikhism value more, life or the absolute strict adherence to Gurmat without exceptions....personally, i think sikhi allows for an exception when it deals with saving a life.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

singh · 08 Nov 2005

Because you hafta shave hair off someoen during a surgeory to SAVE their life is no reason a sikh should not be a surgeon. Stupidest thing ive ever heard. So because of this their cant be one amritdari surgeon in the world? This is a very respectable field and more sikhs should be encouraged to get into it. On the kara issue what you can do is put the kara around your gatra or were the sri sahib and gatra meet. You could sew it like this or if you ahve a button around the top part of the kirpan just attach it there.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Signh, · 09 Nov 2005

Vignesh Singh , where are from s=Singh?? I know a Singh who is a surgeon in Ontario who fought for his right to keep his kakkars while operating and also helps others to fight for the same right. If you leave your email i could get him to contact give me your email I can get him to contact you.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

??????? · 09 Nov 2005

I dont agree with you jasmin kaur.... I think that it is excellent that many sikhs are going into the medical field as a career. If they can help people... why condemn them???? Thats more than most of us are doing and i respect them for working so hard and saving peoples lives... im not saying that u should compromise your sikhi etc.... im just saying that i think that it is a very good thing that sikhs are going into medical careers. It also portrays sikhs in a very good way, as people that help others and save lives. Keep up the good work people..... dont let people like jasmin kaur condemn you when you are doing an amazing job in society!!! bhull chuk maaf wjkk wjkf

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Kaur · 09 Nov 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh! Like briefly mentioned before...you could wear two kare.. one----your normal one (can be thick thing..whatever) two--- a small slim on that will be able to push up your arm and stay there with out falling down. Your normal one can then come off. and if also....just smat to think about what is more important....saving a life or worying about if you have a kara on or not? Even if you do have to take it off... guru ji will understand and will know that you are doing it for a good cause Good Luck Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh!

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

GSinngh · 10 Nov 2005

I agree with Jasmin Kaur. Naam is the cure of all pains and diseases. What good is it if we "save" someone when in that person is a sinner? They will only be beaten in hell again and all our efforts would be wasted. If we really want to help people we shall do simple work which lets us concentrate on naam. How can we forget the sakhi of Raja Janak? He was a king and yet he japped naam and lived his life so frugally! When he went to Sach Khand he cleared four naraks (hells) with his naam kamai and gave everyone mukhti! He really did SAVE people's lives, MANY people's lives.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

******* · 10 Nov 2005

The situation is challenging. On the one hand, we have genuine situations in which people are in need of medical help, which can mean surgery. It is admirable to what to help people and save lives. On the other hand, and just as -------IMPORTANT-------- we have situations in medicine that clearly should be of CONCERN to Gursikhs especially, Amritdhari. It is a challenge, and prehaps an opportunity. If at all possible, might there be ways to modify procedures so that surgery, and indeed the clinical enviroment generally, could be less offensive? Sure, it many never be 100% Gurmat, but------ less offensive. Lets face it, sometimes doctors and nurses do the convenient----especially were bibi to kes,--- is concerned. Believe me, to the extent this could be possible, more then Sikhs would appreciate it. So I think if a Sikh is going into that field, thats what he, or she, should work on at every possible chance. In that case, I would be very happy about Gursikhs going into the surgerical field.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

A Singh · 10 Nov 2005

Nay, Sikhs should according to most people here on this topic and others seek to live in a little confinement much like the Amish and other cults/sects in the world do, so that they can keep their 'purity' and 'bibek' and blah blah... ...oh! golly! I forgot, we are not supposed to run away from the world...dare I say it, that would be Hindu!!! and we wonder where the dreaded, dare I say this, "brahminvad" is coming from!!!

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

jss · 10 Nov 2005

HAHAHAHA...this is the funniest crap i've read in a long time... we shouldn't be doctors???? so should i go do peshi at the next amrit sanchar as soon as i get a break from med school??? people need to grow up a little...

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

stranger · 11 Nov 2005

Lets not limit the restriction to doctors....letes include in the prohibited list the following: City Traders - because they are playing with money which equates to gambling.....naughty naughty Accountants - because they are taught on how to play with money and find ways to scam the system - again gambling and cheating.....naught naughty Nurses - because the help the doctors prepare a person for surgery ...... ie shave the hair ...... naughty naughty Engineers - because they have in general helped man kind create weapons of mass destruction .... as well as useful tools....... Bankers - because they lend money to people and get people into debt........money games again IT - because you help all the above in their professions Scientists - because they create drugs - naughty naughty - we don;t need them - they are against sikhi because they produce drugs - bad for you ...... Why not lets all become jungly jaanbar that way we can maintain this pre-ordained order called 'bibek' and avoid kuraithan.......but then again jaanbars don;t have any moral stand........ come to think of it lets just hide in the caves and like 'A Singh' said become hindus which goes against the grain of sikhi.........whohey we have no where to go pretty messed up eh!!

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Amardeep · 11 Nov 2005

--Stranger-- You are right. Guru Nanak always taught to live a practical life, to do your job, and to devote your other free time to prayer. Sikhism is a modern religion that is based on tolerance and rationalism. How can anyone argue that Guruji is against scientific advancements? WJKK WJKF

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

*******(or Jasmin) · 11 Nov 2005

Heres another angle: Is it really important to be both an amritdhari and a surgeon at the same time in one's life? I understand wanting to take amrit, but maybe taking it as you are preparing for a life in the surgerical or nursing field makes little sense. One could still be a Gursikh, but prehaps you will have to take Amrit when you retire. If anyone asks why you are not Amritdhari you could say " my job is an important one.-----I'm able to save lives and genuinely help people with serious medical conditions. This job, as we all know, can involve the removal of hair. This action, even for the best of reasons,------- is a kurehit generally, and a bujjer kurehit for amritdhari. I'm sorry this happens as part of my job. However, sometimes an operation is a matter of life or death. Even so----- I can't be Amritdhari,----- and commit bujjer kurehits left and right! Image how absurd that would be! Really it's laughable! I admit it. I'd like to retire early, because I would love to pesh and take Amrit as soon as I can!!!

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

RoopKaur · 11 Nov 2005

There is manmat in every field out there. Why, because this world is full of manmukhs! It would not make sense living in this dark and dirty age of Kaljug that we would have "clean" jobs. Even in the teaching career, we are taught to teach wrong things and accept other wrong things. However it is up to the individual to decide how to perform in their profession. If a surgery requires you to shave that person's head, obviously a Sikh cannot do it. If it requires you to take off your kara, you have to fight for it, like many people have done. You cannot keep the attitude that all accomodations will be made for you in this often racist and discriminatory world. In the end, you have to use your bibek budhi and decide what is more important to you, paisa or Guru Ji?

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

raj_karega_khalsa · 11 Nov 2005

I don't think you should EVER shave YOUR hair, even if it's to save your life, it's only temporary, would you rather die a gursikh, or shave your hair to save your life and eventually die neway! n on top of that get beat by jamdooths.....Sir Jaavay Ta Jaavay Mayree Sikhee Sidq Naa Jaavay BUt if u a surgeon, n the ppl you operatin on are ok with shavin their hair, then u aint doin ne paap........ n wuts wit every1 bashin bibek? On one hand evry1's yellin bout "EKTA" n "UNITY" then bashin KHalsaa Rehits that som Gursikhs keep, n it IS basically jus bashin AKJ n sum Nihangs cuz they the majority of the Gursikhs that keep this rehit....good step towards unity Bhull CHak MAaph

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

VSK · 11 Nov 2005

"What good is it if we "save" someone when in that person is a sinner? " we shouldnt discriminate who we help just because some ppl are bad.... think of bhai ghanaiya jee....

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

MOW · 11 Nov 2005

if an amritdhari surgeon is not allowed to shave hair to operate, is an amritdhari doctor allowed to prescribe medicine in capsules (which contain small amounts of gelatin/other animal products)?

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

ukmedstudent · 12 Nov 2005

does anyone know if its likely i will have to shave a patients hair during the three clinical yrs of the course? after i have my degree i could let some1 else cut the hair, but i wnt be able to to that before i graduate.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Jasmin · 12 Nov 2005

Excellent post by RoopKaur, really hits the nail on the head! Well--- raj-karega-kha how do you know how the person feels about shaving in the event that they are unconscious? I would guess that your assuming a non-Sikh wouldn't mind, it seems like a big assumption. The question may be somewhat nebulous. Though, I'd be tempted to make an educated guess based on how much kesh a person keeps. In any case family members,------if their monas, (I use that term to describe anyone who does not keep kesh, regardless of religion) generally want that life saving operation.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

GSinngh · 12 Nov 2005

WJKK WJKF Dear VSK! Sorry i think you misunderstood me on this line :) "What good is it if we "save" someone when in that person is a sinner? " What i mean by that is that to cure physical diseases doesn't "save" a person in the gursikhi sense. To clean off the sins off ones head "saves a life" in the truest sense, because that person will not be beaten or go into churasi lakh joon. E.g. sajjan thug, the theif, guru ji saved him, showed him the right path and his sins were cleared. The other example I gave was of Raja Janak. After he died he cleared the occupants of 4 naraks (hells) with his naam simran. So the impression I have is that all efforts that go into curing peoples physical diseases through medical means are in the end are fruitless if those people are still affected by the punj doots. In the end these people will die anyway and perhaps be punished! So, if we really care for others, we will put our sikhi first and recognise that Naam is the cure of all pains! Sorry for any wrongs said, please forgive me! WJKK WJKF

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

ekta · 13 Nov 2005

listen, 2 cuts the patients hair is a safety procedure, your doing it for their benifit and yours. Don't be so backwards. Any ways most ppl comming in won't have kesh, so your cutting hair not "kesh" so it does'nt reallly effect anything. jeez louis.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Pritpal · 13 Nov 2005

I have a younger brother studying medicine right now. He hasnt come across any discrimination, but he is only in the very early stages (studying the sciences). However, i fear when he truly gets into the medicine and residency, he may do things like take off his kara or shave someone's hair. What should i do? Should I stop him from becoming a doctor.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

VSK · 13 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Sorry Ji, my bad I misunderstood u. I agree you have brought up a good point, sumthing most of us dont think about...

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Jasmin · 13 Nov 2005

GSignngh----- I understand what your saying, I've enjoyed your posts. Nothing wrong with what your saying. It's just that the topic is surgery. On the other topic, of drinks - I don't see any reason to work directly in the drinks industry. It's certainly not saving a life in that case.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Jasmin · 13 Nov 2005

Seems like it could be an issue, but doesn't seem as serious as removing hair. On this post, it is even mentioned, here on this message board---- that some Gursikhs, such as those in Kabil, do eat meat. Best to warn all patients if medication contains gelatin, in case a patient is vegetarian.---------- Even better only recommend medications that don't contain gelatin or other animal products.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

# · 14 Nov 2005

A very technical definition. Dark gray verses black, very dark gray verses black, smokey black verses black. Smokey black isn't really black. Only offical black is black. No one expect me can understand black. Queasy, your opinion makes me queasy.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005

I have not read the whole of this posts.But it is a load of rubbish to suggest that a kara be taken off.I work with the NHS and initially trained as a RGN, then RMNH andlater RMN before I worked my way to the Forensics. I have worked in all departments before reaching to be a Senior Borough Sector Manager,I never took my kara off ever, and it is still there whn I do my C & R periodically. Jashen kaur ji can you provide me the details of which union you approached or belong to and which Trust this is. I will take the issue up, and to the NMC.This should not be happening.I have just completed some guidelines based on NICE guidleines on how to deal with Sikh patients when operating or about to operate. However, one solution is to offer to cover the kara and kirpan with sterile bandage as an band. for the time in the operating theatre or sterile area.This a compromise meeting them half way, without compromising on the rehat. I know I will get some flaake flying , but the reality is we also need to be seen to be proactive. At least you do not take the kara off, or the kirpan off as some have compromised at airports. I recall one individual blaming me for suggesting tying his beard up.I only gave information based on standing orders of the army and police. It is better than abandoning kirpan,at airport, and then starving yourself with some brahminical ritual like some one has suggested on this net elsewhere until one gets the kirpan back.The simple task is to just do an ardas, instead people are comming up with some of their own brand rehat!!Please refrain. Someone asked my email address..it is Chaan [address removed]

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

unreal · 14 Nov 2005

Thats right - Let us forego all academically challenging work, tell our kids to forget being doctors, lawyers, engineers, physicists, etc and advise them to pursue "simple work". Simple work being what? Garbage collector, sanitation worker, taxi driver? Note, there is nothing wrong with being a garbage collector, sanitation worker, or taxi driver; however, there is nothing wrong with being a doctor, lawyer, engineer or physicist either. Naam is the cure of all pains and diseases but God works through man as well otherwise why have the concept of MIRI in our faith at all. We are a part of this world and not a part of this world - like a lotus in filthy waters. For the same reason the very substantial steel of a kirpan was needed along with Naam to fight oppression, the very real steel of scalpels is needed in certain medical situations. GSinngh wrote: > I agree with Jasmin Kaur. Naam is the cure of all pains and > diseases. What good is it if we "save" someone when in that > person is a sinner? They will only be beaten in hell again and > all our efforts would be wasted. If we really want to help > people we shall do simple work which lets us concentrate on > naam. How can we forget the sakhi of Raja Janak? > > He was a king and yet he japped naam and lived his life so > frugally! When he went to Sach Khand he cleared four naraks > (hells) with his naam kamai and gave everyone mukhti! He > really did SAVE people's lives, MANY people's lives.

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

akjrocks!!! · 14 Nov 2005

vjkk vjkp coming bak 2 da topic!!! my friend plays basketball and hes not aloud to wear his kara, so he takes it of and puts it around his jura vjkk vjkp

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

A Singh · 15 Nov 2005

Yes yes yes!!! Please let me know when we have developed that little cave in which ALL the "proper" Sikhs are to live in purity and ritual cleanliness!

Re: Amritdhari Surgeon

Gurcharan Singh · 16 Nov 2005

Jashan kaur Ji, I am still waiting to hear from you, so that I can take this issue up with the NMC and also the Union involved. You have been victimised and let down by the union.I am in the field, I know what should have happend, and I will take the issue up if you care to tell me which NHS trust and union it was .It could only be UNISON and RCN as most likely unions in the NHS.