Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Inteligent replys needed

Inteligent replys needed

GUPT · 06 Nov 2005

No one has been able to reply to this person on the sikh sangat forum I know some inteligent Singhs come on this forum can you please help us give this person a proper jwaab Hello everyone, I just joined up with the site in search for some answers MY SPEECH FROM PERSONAL EXPERIENCE To criticize the Sikh faith on certain aspects is becoming ineffectual for me, nobody listens, especially the people on the far right (whom I’m afraid to say dominate this site), but I’m going to criticize anyways to reach out to the very few that understand. The reason why I criticize certain aspects of faith is certainly not to offend anyone, I believe that a liberal-minded and critical approach is lacking in our religion, this is offsetting serious religious doubts in the mind of youth such as myself. Those who believe criticism is a negative thing and breaks a religion are utterly wrong, criticism is the bases on which a religion EVOLVES (take note people from the far right) and comes out stronger and more resilient (the catholic church is but a prime example). THOSE OF YOU WHO BELIEVE SIKH CRITICISM HAS BEEN LEFT UNATTENDED TO GIVE ME A SHOUT! THE NEW YOUTH OF THIS GENERATION HAVE QUESTIONS THAT ARE NOT BEING ANSWERED BY THE CONSERVATIVES WHO CLAIM TO RUN THE FAITH! The HEGELIAN VEIW: All I’m saying is that the Sikh faith has no stance on modern relativistic socio-political issues (ie, abortion, euthanasia, evolution, genetic research, gene therapy, definition of death, etc) our faith continuously assimilates and accepts the Church’s stance as our own! Or we listen to the diehard conservatives that dominate the stages at our Gurdawara’s who are far from what we can call intellectuals (deny all you want I have witnessed this happening) THIS IS WRONG AND VERY DANGEROUS TO THE INTEGRITY OF OUR FAITH. So my Question now stands how do we rectify this issue? NOW THAT’S THE QUESTION WE SHOULD ASK OURSELVES. Lets work together to propel this faith into the 21st century. Citizens of the Sikh faith! Break your chains and PLEASE raise your voice, ask questions, criticize your faith, stretch boundaries and please for those conservatives, who are responding, do respond with clear and valid information. SIKH is derived from the sanskrity word of “sikhsa”, meaning the learner. If we are learner’s we should be applying the techniques of learning; passionate debate, constructive criticism, clarity and REASON! (do not undermine human reason) The conservatives say that we should turn to BANI whenever we are in doubt, but how? BANI doesn’t relate to current socio-political issues and drawing relations on our own is an unrelenting task, deciding whether to interpret the scriptures literally or contextually is already out of most peoples reach. BANI has a lot of underlying contextual meanings that we cannot interpret on our own. We need a Sikh institution that can lead the way (similar to the “Christian Research Groups”). IF YOU AGREE JUST GIVE ME A SHOUT OUT! I just want to make sure I’m not alone or the only person that sees this issue. SOME FOOD FOR THOUGHT: PUSHING THE ENVELOPE 1)Does divine inspiration seem any longer necessary when reason can provide what, in the granthical view, can be taught only by the prophet? 2)The Sikh religion emphasized the equality of men and woman, no doubt, why were then all the Sikh Guru’s MALE? 3)Did the Guru’s possess a political agenda? There is an evident power struggle. 4)After the first five Guru’s, did not the Sikh faith become a dynasty? 5)Why did the Guru Gobind Singh stop the line of Guru’s? Did he actually think the faith was complete? In a way didn’t Guru Gobind Singh inhibit and paralyze this faith to expand upon the gurbani? 6)What was the significance of Guru Harkrishan ji to Sikh scripture or for that matter Sikh psyche? Didn’t Guru Harkrishan ji pass away from the great small pox pandemic that struck New Dehli. The scripture says that he was out curing people of the disease but in the end contracted it himself? 7)Were our guru’s not men? Why does the majority of the Sikh population worship them as mythical heroes and non-human deities? (This is something we should definitely change in our faith; its an insult to our own reason) 8)Were not the guru’s products and derivatives of there own society? 9)Guru Gobind Singh used to hunt! Yet at the same time prohibit the consumption of animals, or was this tradition adopted after? Is there hypocrisy at hand? 10)Guru Gobind Singh practiced polygamy? Is there hypocrisy at hand? 11)Would the Guru’s have been more effective in implementing more peaceful measures with the Mughal rulers? (Someone only with a strong historical background should attempt to answer this question) Was such extreme Sikh militarization absolutely necessary? Was the militarization of the Sikhs part of Guru Gobind Singh’s political agenda? Again how was the 10th guru’s struggle any different from that of the struggles of elites today? Remember the Sikhs were considered liberal minded “back in the day”, which is why they suffered atrocities as our teachings conflicted with the teachings of the existing Islamic state. If you are a true Sikh retain your liberal mind and move forth this STATIC faith that has become detached from reality (we live in a free country now, there will be no more atrocities). Until we answer these questions and many more similar questions, this faith will continue to be detached from its very own base! If you would like to post responses to these questions above please try to do so without using hostility, even though that is predominately the “Sikh way” (lol just kiddin). MY NEXT THREAD WILL BE ON RELIGION AND SCIENCE: STAY TUNED CHEERS, Deep sinisters (sikh leftists) lets take some action ANOTHER TOPIC HE STARTED WAS THIS "Karmian Ideology My second question concerns our theories on karma! To say that you will be rewarded on how you perform in this life is lame! Is a child that is born into poverty deserve it? The ideology of Karma is an effective tool of social control: The Hindu culture used karmian ideology so that the elite could validate their position in society and preserve their power and the caste system. ”We are rich and we deserve to be rich because we were good in our past life” Our guru’s also implemented the karmian ideology for social control and OBEDIENCE but a different form of social controlà Do good or you will be punished,: “do good now and you will be rewarded in the next life” was the overall take home message of our guru’s. This was truly an evolved thought from the Hindu culture but nonetheless supports egoism. People do good not because they want to but because they have to, we were not given a choice. We either do good or suffer. This psychologically very burdening and expresses not the good nature in humanity but an egoistic one. Sikhs do good to fuel their own ego, to ensure themselves that they will be better off in the afterlife? Theories on Karma undermine current life, our “current life” is nothing more than a preparation for another life. GIVE ME A BREAK! This teaching should be abandoned if we want to preserve what is precious in this life, the one in which we are sure that we exist! Read some Marxian ideology to get a better view of what I’m talking about here! REALLy WOULD LIKE SOME INPUT ONW WHAT PEOPLE THINK RECCOMEND THAT PEOPLE READ MY FIRST THREAD! JUST TO GET AN IDEA OF WHERE IM COMIN FROM AND MY INTENTIONS!" HE is making me upset i'm just not smart enough to articulate a proper reply. maybe someone here can help. http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=14862

Re: Inteligent replys needed

siinghh · 07 Nov 2005

THere are some very nice replies posted on Sikhsangat now. Check it out.

Re: Inteligent replys needed

Confussed · 07 Nov 2005

Whats ur actual question?

Re: Inteligent replys needed

''' · 07 Nov 2005

"we live in a free country now, there will be no more atrocities" this is a funny statement, which planet does this gupt live on and i dont understand... gupt calls guru sahibs "our gurus" then refers to dasmesh pita as "the Guru Gobind Singh" , very offensive, gupt is no sikh of the guru, but i hope people feed some of his ignorance on sikhi dharam

Re: Inteligent replys needed

Inderjit Singh Dhillon · 07 Nov 2005

Our religion follows a postmodern paradigm we never have to use reason as a commone frame of reference as our basic category is spirit your own premise that we need to understand contradicts the ideas of stretching boundaries, the most authoritative scholar on the sikh doctrine is Dr Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia please relieve all your questions by studying his literature they answer all your questions and more, sikhism is not a faith which focusses on using the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji to mould your life the word is god the vehicle for the word was a human body today the vehicle is a peice of paper, gurshabad is our guru and also the temporal order of khalsa, please make this paradigm shift otherwise you will always be confounded I am posting an article here which may help you arrive at that point: http://www.punjabheritage.com/doctrine.html The Sikh Doctrine The Sikhism The Vision of Sikhism for a New Civilization Metaphysical Pillars Sikhism on the Eve of 21st Century The Sikh Doctrine Political Pluralism Sikhism as a Renaissance Movement The World Historical Mission of Sikhism Contributor: Dr. Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia Vice-Chancellor Punjabi University, Patiala(INDIA) The Sikhism Over 500 years ago in sub-continental India arose Sikhism - one of the five major world religions - as a unique renaissance and resurgence of the human spirit. The spirit of man, realizing afresh its kinship, its integral bond, with the Spirit Divine, liberated itself out of the obsolescent, dogma-encrusted existence and came into its own, efflorescently, as a dynamic force, a creative impulse. The elan vital of Sikhism had great potential for ushering in a new civilization qualitatively different from the earlier Indic and Hindu civilizations. Thereby raising humanity to a new level of cultural and civilizational progress. In its universal dimension Sikhism introduced a new concept of man, of society and state and in its historical dimension, this religion awakened medieval Indian society out of its collective amnesia, its inertia, and shook it out of its bondage to the dead past. The Vision of Sikhism for a New Civilization But the vision of Sikhism for a new civilization, for a new post-feudal, trans-capitalist, socio - politico - economic dispensation could not be realized owing to the feudalization of the Sikh movement soon after the Banda Bahadur period, with the correlative processes of the Brahminization of Sikh society & Vedanticization of the Sikh doctrine. The futuristic vision of Sikhism has become all the more relevant and significant for humanity in the 21st century and the third millennium. Sikh religion with its holistic world view can and should play a leading role in evolving the ideology of the global civilization and in shaping its institutional super-structure with the Khalsa as the embodiment of the Spirit-in-history - a concept introduced by Sikh philosophy for the first time in the world's speculative and sociological thought, as we shall see later.Modern Western civilization which, in a sense, gave rise to a particular kind of 'modern' world view and vision, was based on certain fundamentals that made it different from medieval and ancient civilizations on the one hand and would, hopeably, distinguish it from the post-modernist 21st century and the third millennium global civilization on the other hand. The ideational postulates of modern Western civilization, evolved in different ways, involved the dichotomy and dialectic of the noumenal and the phenomenal; of the spiritual and the terrestrial; of mind and matter; of soul and body; of value and fact; and of subject and object. The sociological correlates of this world-view, humanism, secularism, unitarian polity, cultural hegemony and homogenization etc., refer back to the same dichotomy and dualism. Empiricism asserted that the sensory, phenomenal world was the only (knowable) reality. Humanism (distinguishable from the post-modernist kind) made man the measure of all things, without any reference to any transcendental reality or principle. History asserted that values were of a relative nature. Existentialism postulated the priority of individual existence over essence, over transcendental ideals and ideas. Secularism which in the form of so-called secular nationalism became the ideology of modern nation-state, was again based on the separating division of the secular and the religious domain. This kind of secularism, or secular nationalism, conceded no conceptual room to religious minorities, religious identities and religious institutions. Metaphysical Pillars The dualism under reference was based on the following metaphysical pillars : Metaphysically, it was held that reality is of material nature, with a rational structure, having an atomistic composition; independently existing (material) objects and phenomena could be known, independently of the subject through reason with its analytic-reductionist methodology.The all-powerful, mighty reason reigned supreme in nature, history and society during the past few centuries of the modern era, uptill the first half of the 20th century when it faced an impasse which, in a sense, was the impasse of modern Western civilization and its dichotomous world-view and dualistic ideational postulates. The necessitated a paradigm shift, a new way of thinking, a post-modernist vision. This does not mean going back from reason but going beyond reason to the realm of spirit. This means a shift from the old concept of reality in the sense of static being to the new concept of reality in the sense of dynamic becoming. The new concept, termed "post-modernist view", discards static categories of dualism -- both ontological and epistemological; for the new vision reality is of the nature of an organism involving integral bonds, linkages, inter-connections from the terrestrial to the transcendental. Reality is not an assortment of unrelated objects or coincidentally related phenomena; it is, rather, a web of relations, a network of systems nesting in systems of wholes-within-wholes. Reality is, thus, knowable through "systems thinking" replacing the analytic-reductionist methodology of reason. On ontological level, the new conception envisions reality as Spirit which instantiates itself in organismic relationships between (the earlier categories of) the noumenal and the phenomenal; between the individual and society, and between man's religious and secular life -- all seen as interwoven into distinct configurations, all interlocked in wholes-within-wholes in a network wherein the identity of each component is recognised, while being a part of the whole. This is not merely an abstract metaphysical concept but a holistic viewpoint that has revolutionary implications on social, political, economic, religious and cultural levels. This constitutes the ideational founding of a new global civilization of the future which would be based on the notion of spirit in the same way that modern Western civilization was built up on the concept of reason. Sikhism on the Eve of 21st Century On the eve of 21st century and the third millennium, mankind is turning to religion in a new way, as the Spirit has manifested itself from time to time in religious revelations. In this context, Sikhism, with its futuristic vision, can play a leading role in evolving the ideology of the coming global civilization. Sikhism is distinct among world religions in that its basic category is spirit and not being; its vision is holistic and not dualistic. For the Sikh religion, God is the creative Spirit (Karta Purakh) distinguishable from, say, the Vedantic and Vedanta-based religions for which Brahman is Sat (Being), Chit (Consciousness) and Anand (Bliss), but not Creator. Before Nanakian speculative throught, whenever the notion of Spirit appeared, it was seen as manifesting and revealing itself in space (nature), in the Word and in the human soul. With Sikh thought comes, for the first time in the history of speculative thought of the world, the concept of the Spirit descending, through the Guru-medium, in (historical)time, in history. The spiritual aspect of the Spirit (spiritual sovereignty)becomes immanent in the Word (Guru Granth) and the temporal aspect (temporal sovereignty) becomes determinate in the societal category known in Sikh parlance as the Khalsa Panth, Guru Panth. The Khalsa is my determinate form I am immanent in the Khalsa -Guru Gobind Singh The Khalsa is, verily, the Spirit-in-history created by the Divine Will in order to usher in a new dispensation on earth : religious, social cultural, economic and political. This, verily, is the phenomenal form of the time-transcendent Spirit manifest in the corporate being of the Khalsa -Prahilad Rai This new dispensation which can provide a blueprint for the emerging global civilization is characterised by liberalism, (new) humanism, universalism and pluralism (religious, cultural and political) - these being the four pillars of the edifice of Sikhism in its institutional form. Liberalism means liberation from dogmatised belief, and from rites and rituals, from static, never-changing code of conduct: The fetters around the feet are sundered The Guru has emancipated me. -Guru Arjan Dev The Sikh Doctrine It is significant to note that in the Sikh doctrine, there is no institution, comparable to the Roman Catholic Church, with an inherent right to interpretation of the Bani; prescription of code of conduct and excommunication from the community of faith-followers. There is no clergy, no theocrat in the Sikh religion. A Sikh has a direct, unbreakable, integral linkage and communion with his Guru and God (Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa). He has the inherent right to seek for himself the enlightenment from the Guru Shabda and mould his life accordingly. He is a free, sovereign spirit, as he partakes of the Divine sovereignty. This is the meaning of the archetypal self-surrender of the first five Sikhs at the creation of the Khalsa. From here also flows the second postulate of Sikhism : humanism (radically different from the old conception). The first Prophetic message of Guru Nanak was: "No Hindu, No Muslim " Here, the first Prophet of Sikhism was stressing the primacy of the human spirit, being the primary identity, that partakes of the essence of the Divine Spirit. The secondary identity (or identities) depending on the variables of time and space are significant, as the primary essence becomes determinate in and through a network of secondary identities - religious, ethnic, cultural, regional, etc. For the same reason, these secondary identities should not be homogenised into a single all-embracing identity. The new humanistic approach of Sikhism, stressing the primary human identity of man, provides a new basis for the equality of men and women and of communities whether in majority or minority. Guru Gobind Singh expresses the essential humanism of the Sikh religion in its sociological form in these words : Recognise all humanity as one in spirit. Universalism is another cardinal value in Sikhism. Sikhism is a universal religion in two senses of the expression. First, it is not bracketed with a particular ethnicity (Punjabiat), or a particular region (the Punjab). The whole earth having been revered as "mother earth" by Guru Nanak in his Japji, there is no particularised promised or holy land. The different ethnicities of the first five Sikhs (Panj Pyare), baptised by Guru Gobind Singh while creating the Order of the Khalsa, imply that Sikhism is not an ethnicity-specific, region-specific religion. Guru Gobind Singh says that God cannot be bound to a particular creed, place or era (Jaap Sahib), nor can He be bracketed with any particular ethnicity ( Akal Ustat ). He is the Lord of all the peoples of the world. This makes Sikhism a truly universal religion, unicentral on religious level, while being pluricentral on cultural, ethnic and social levels. Sikhism is "universal" in another sense also. Its primary essential concerns -- social, political, cultural economic -- are of a universal nature, embracing humanity as a whole. Unfortunately, during the last hundred years or so, the universal concerns of Sikhism have become subordinate to and eclipsed by the existential concerns of the Sikhs in Punjab. The time has come to demarcate the two sets of concerns so that the universal concerns of Sikhism - such as human rights; eco-system; depletion of natural resources; effects of value-neutral technology; sustainable models of growth and development; equitable distribution of wealth; terrorism, particularly state-sponsord terrorism, etc. could come to the centrestage. Pluralism - both political and religious - is another characteristic of the Sikh vision of social reality. Monolithic, unitarian polity cannot ensure co-equal participation and partnership of different layers of hierarchised societies and of the minorities in particular. Political pluralism alone can realise participation and partnership of all sections of society on an equal footing in a truly representative dispensation as envisioned by Guru Arjan, the fifth Prophet of Sikhism. All are co -equal partners in The commonwealth Political Pluralism Political pluralism is correlative to religious pluralism, which simply does not mean the co-existence of different faiths and various religious communities, or even equal respect for all religions. What is more important is the conceptual basis of religious pluralism. Here again, the distinctiveness of Sikhism - which should not be interpreted as it superiority in theomachy-needs to be highlighted. Sikhism does not claim to be the full and final revelation of God, the full and final determination of the Spirit, the full and final revelation of all that is known and knowable; such absolutist, exclusivist claims lead to religious fundamentalism and intolerance. The infinity of the Divine attributes and aspects, the relativity of different revelations and the limitations of human cognition- as stressed by Guru Nanak in his Japji-leave no room for the concept of " full and final relvelation." Hence the co-validity of all revelations in their respective contexts, and of different paths to God, as proclaimed by Guru Gobind Singh . Same are the temple and the mosque And same are the forms of worship. Sikhism as a Renaissance Movement Sikhism, which once arose as a mighty renaissance movement, a revolutionary force, a dynamic praxis, for paving the path of self-sublimating, self-realizing salvation of the soul in the world hereafter, as well as a new dispensation on earth (halemi raj in the language of the fifth Prophet of Sikhism, Guru Arjun), is today in need of an internal reformation and renaissance. The first Sikh reformation arose in the last quarter of the 19th century in the context of a deep crisis after the loss of political power in the year 1849 coupled with the correlative processes of feudalization of the Sikh movement, Brahminization of the Sikh society & the Vedanticization of the Sikh doctrine. At that time the very physical survival of the Sikhs was overshadowed by a question mark. No wonder, then, that the existential concerns of the Sikhs -- social, cultural economic, political -- took precedence over the universal concerns of Sikhism. This lopsidedness that has continued for over 100 years has to be rectified so that the universal concerns of Sikhism, referred to earlier, come back to the centrestage. The first Sikh reformation also led to a symbiotic relationship between religion and politics, between the religious and political institutions, resulting in exploitation of the one by the other and vice versa, depending upon the exigencies of the given situation. This symbiotic relationship, forged on a mistaken, distorted concept of miri - piri unity, needs to be immediately brought to an end, so that the religious and the political praxis operate, autonomously, in their respective domains. The concept of miri - piri unity in essence means that Sikhism embraces the other-worldly spiritual concerns of the soul as much as the this-worldly temporal concerns of man, society and state, but without coalescence of the religious and the political power, authority and institutions. The miri - piri unity does not mean a monistic unity but a differentiated unity. The trend towards emergence of clergy in contemporary Sikhism, including the Takht clergy - appropriating unto itself authority, power and jurisdiction which do not doctrinally and historically vest in it - needs to be forcefully countered. The clergy( There being no anointed clergy in Sikh religion, there is no Church-like authority or institution with inherent right to interpret the Scripture, to excommunicate a Sikh from the community and to prescribe a code of conduct for a Sikh who is directly responsible for his deeds to his Guru and God. There is no theocrat, no clerico-cracy. The Akal Takht jathedar is not a theocrat or a vice-deity presiding over the temporal affairs of this sacred institution of Sikhism; he is a sewadar, or at best of spokesman of the voice and will of the community articulated through intra-community deliberations in different forums, particularly the democratically elected Sikh institutions.) as a mediatory class or institution is not envisaged in Sikhism, there being a direct relationship between a Sikh and his Guru and God (Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa ). The growing role of the clergy, particularly of the Takht clergy, is leading not only to ritualization of contemporary Sikh society but also to suppressing and repressing the essential liberalism of Sikhism. Sikhism blended a spiritual vision of life with the spirit of enquiry and a liberated state of mind. This catholicity of outlook -- an essential element of Sikh liberalism - is threatened by the growing clout of the clergy which, as a class, breeds on self-appropriated authoritarianism with inherent tendency towards intolerance, sectarianism and dogmatism. Recognition of and respect for difference; acceptance of the Other; co-validity of multiple viewpoints - these are essential aspects of the Sikh value pattern. Another aspect of the internal Sikh reformation and renaissance relates to the evolutionary relationship between the universal and the historical dimension. A living religion, particularly of institutional type, has to, synergically, develop in both universal and historical dimension. Without the universal dimension developing simultaneously, an institutional religion dries up as a sect; and without the historical dimension it ends up (at best) as an abstrtact thought-system. In the case of Sikhism, after the Guru-period, the synergical, evolutionary unity of the universal and the historical dimension broke down. This break-down leads to an agonizing question : Has the universal in Sikhism exhausted itself in one particular historical determination - ethnicized Sikhism in its contemporary Punjabi form ? Or whether in future, t here would evolve many more historical determinations of the universal in Sikhism ? This question relates to the historical variables of region and ethnicity. As stressed earlier, Sikhism, essentially, is neither a region - specific nor an ethnicity - specific religion. The Punjab is the natural habitat of the Sikh community but not in the sense of the ' promised land ' or (exclusively) the holy land. De-regionalization of contemporary Sikhism is an essential aspect of the second (internal) Sikh renaissance. The World Historical Mission of Sikhism Sikhism is also not an ethnicity - specific religion. De-ethnicization of contemporary Sikhism is also essential for the second Sikh reformation, if this religion is to really become a universal religion. The mere presence of the Punjabi/Indian Sikhs in different countries - the Sikh diaspora - does not mean that it has already become a universal religion. De-ethnicization of contemporary Sikhism is also necessary for it to become a universal religion. Christianity arose within the Jewish milieu, Jewish tradition, Jewish ethnicity. But St. Paul took Christianity beyond its original Jewish milieu, tradition and ethnicity. A similar development is required for Sikhism. In this context, the historical role of Siri Singh Sahib Bhai Sahib Harbhajan Singh Khalsa Yogiji in implanting Sikhism in American milieu and ethnicity is, in a sense, comparable to that of St. Paul. The American Singhs -- the American followers of Yogiji - constitute a historical experiment towards universalization of Sikhism, in contemporary context. The Punjabi/Indian Sikhs in North America also, transcending their nostalgia about the Punjabi Sikh identity, should culturally contribute towards the making of the American Sikh identity. Religiously unifocal, but culturally multifocal : that is how contemporary Sikhism would have to evolve to realize its World historical mission. In realizing the World historical mission of Sikhism the present state of Sikh studies would also have to be kept in view. Over the past few decades Sikh studies abroad by Western scholars have been done from the Christian perspective which has also conditioned the approach and methodology of the Indian Sikh scholars overawed by the Western scholars. In fact, the intellectual agenda of the meta-narrative of Sikhism has been set by the Western scholars with the indigenous Sikh scholars remaining bogged down in reacting to the Sikh discourse of the Western scholars. The Sikh scholars would have to go beyond their present reactive role to a really pro-active role in setting the ideational agenda of discourse about Sikhism. This is essential for two main reasons. The Christian and the Sikh perspective constitute, epistemologically, two different frames of reference, the categories of which are not symmetrical (For instance, the Sikh conception of the Word is qualitatively different from the Christian view. In Sikh thought, the Spirit, besides becoming immanent in the societal category Khalsa, also, becomes determinate in the Word (bani) which, as such, is elevated and revered as the eternal 'living' Guru in the form of Sri Guru Granth. Christian thought holds that "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God and the Word was God. " The Word became 'flesh', that is, incarnate in the person of Jesus Christ who, as such, is the focal point of the faith and worship and not the Bible, the Scripture. That is why the Western studies of the Sikh Scripture are so off the tangent, for the concept of the Divine spirit becoming determinate in the Word (bani) is incomprehensible in the Christian perspective in which the process is reversed : The Word becoming embodied in the person of Jesus Christ.). Secondly, a religious tradition needs to be approached in terms of its own self-definition, in terms of its self-defined identity. This, epistemologically, requires an unmediated experiential insight-through socio-religious osmosis - which is not possible in the case of the ' outsiders ', whatever be their cerebral brilliance or methodological novelties. There are some of the urgent issues that contemporary Sikhism would have to address, before it re-starts on the path of realizing its World historical mission. It is imperative for the Sikh renaissance today to re-discover its essential values, to re-focus its vision, to update its praxis. This is how Sikhism would be able to impart its futuristic vision to the ideology of the new World civilization in the offing. This is how it would be in a position to play its role in the evolution of the institutional web of the 21st century society and the third millennium civilization. This is how the Khalsa once again would become the motor force of history : the Spirit-in-history. Editor-in-Chief Dr.Satnam Singh Sandhu Punjabi University, Patiala.INDIA

Re: Inteligent replys needed

Khalsa_Force · 07 Nov 2005

I m not intelligent enough to reply these TARAK BHARPOOR questions.

Re: Inteligent replys needed

Satnam · 07 Nov 2005

Piare Sikhs, To the person who posted their message it is very good you have posted this, I also had similar questions. I used to be a Mona but after I started researching into true Sikhi (i.e. what is in the Bani) then i realised that Sikhi is nothing but the truth itself. For me, Sikhi as what you see with say at the gurdwara or specific jatha conferences are not always TRUE Sikhi as preached by our Gurus. We have been taught to be open minded yet the limited human thinking means that we strive to have a set of rules and regulations that in reality Sikhi does not provide. What the Bani tells you is how to gain oneness with God Himself and thus provides you with advice on how to do so. For example, many a Gursikh will think they are Gods gift for not eating meat, yet Guru Nanak Sahib states Himself that only fools debate whether you should or not, not eating meat does not actually get you anywhere in itself, it will definately help your cause but it is nothing to be proud about, for example, when you build a house and you lay the foundations, just by laying the foundations, you are nowhere near completing your house, you still need to lay the brickwork and only then will you start coming to your goal -u don't see people thinking their summin special just cos they laid the foundation to their house. In the same way, not eating meat is the foundation and therefore is no means to become proud over it. You need to understand the our Gurus had Gian we can never understand which is why they may have done things that we would see as hypocrisy. The polygamy thing - i have yet to see evidence of this but i would to state that a lot of anti Sikh and anti Guru propoganda has been going around, especially during the British Raj to discredit us. Guru Ji went hunting as he had made promises to the souls of the animals he killed. He had to fulfill his word, the difference between say you, me and Guru Ji is that Guru Ji was able to handle the Karmic consequences of killing the animals but we can't! About the poor kid scenario, maybe its a blessing in diguise as a poor kid will never be consumed in material wealth and can concentrate on Nam Simran, the Kid may have asked for these circumstances! You need to lose the idea of right and wrong from your mind once you have achieved this, the whole world falls into balance. I could continue this but I know no1 will read this but i can explain myself further to help you understand if you request.

Re: Inteligent replys needed

Jagjit Singh · 07 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, clearly you are deep thinker. With Guru jis kirpa, I will answer what I can. The HEGELIAN VEIW: I diagree with your assumption that Sikhism has no view on specific subject, yet chooses to copy the Church, Possibly more of a case that you have yet to meet articulate Sikhs who can debate these subjects with Gurbani. Abortion - Sikhism does not believe in it, except in rape cases at the decretion of the Panj Pyares, which is extremely rare. Euthanisa - a suicide of sort. Again Sikhism does not accept this. Physical limitations do not affcet the mind, which never has a limit in bhagti. Definately against gurmat. Evolution - Gurmat accepts of evolution of cells amd matter, but does not accept Darwinism thoeories of man coming from apes. Human life has a specific path and mission, which animals cannot achieve. We are to leave the cycles of life and death through spiritual enlightenment. Genetic Research - Acceptable within distinct boundaries. We are not Jehovahs witnesses who chose not accept any medical help. Guru Shiabaan themselves gave medicines based on herbs and healed those with diseases. However to change or alter generations through genetic modification is completely against Gurmat. Definition of death - Gurmat is based on a code of conduct called the rehit Maryada, which means the code by which you remember that death is close. I would argue Gurmat has the most detailed denition of death. Its explanation of death and karam Philospohy is far more detailed than any other religion. Each of these subjects are huge and we can discuss each in detail. Above is an extremely simple response. Gurmat does not copy or base itself upon any religion. Sahib Guru Nnanak dev states, "jaise me avee kasam ki bani", which means as the truth was revealed so he sang. Gurmat is not based on fables, epic battles, bargianing with God, as are most religions. Gurmat is based on a direct conversation with your mind, and introducing it to a Realm of Spiritiual consciousness of Waheguru. Tomorrow I will adress the next section of your mail, if other Gursikhs have not. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Inteligent replys needed

Kulwinder Singh · 07 Nov 2005

Dear Gupt Ji, Bhai Sahib Jagjit Singh Ji has given his very valuable answers, In my opinion you have not looked around serious enough to find out if You questions can be answered, If you want to read Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji to understand why your Windows XP need new patch form Microsoft then you are certainly be disappointed. How ever if you are looking for answered to make your life a success in terms of humanity then you are at the right place, A … Sikhs choose to suffer the torture of Evil Rulers rather then committing suicide (One Example: Banda Bahdur Singh You can search the net for his history), So life is very sacred in Sikhi, B….Akal Takhat : which is the highest court of Sikhs do not give capital punishment to anybody even to the most grave crimes. A and B Should give you clarity on Abortion and euthanasia as it is life we are talking. Evolution : Sikhism accepts changes comes in life and things can change, Even Sex change is mentioned in the Sikhism. Genetic: Sikhism is accept the medical understanding and importance of medicine but like the rest of the intelligent world, we have valid concerns, but we are not obstruction in the development any treatment as long as intentions are to cure illness. Death: Bahi Jagjit Singh have said enough. Yes I agree with you on the meaning of Sikh and need for sikh to be on learning path rather then being static. I also agree with you that we need structured platform to address the questions raised by anybody in relation to anything. 1)Does divine inspiration seem any longer necessary when reason can provide what, in the grammatical view, can be taught only by the prophet? My Ans: if you looking for divine the Divine is required. 2)The Sikh religion emphasized the equality of men and woman, no doubt, why were then all the Sikh Guru’s MALE? My Answer: There is no restriction on most countries head to be a woman how come even in 2005 the number of woman being head of countries even in the west in almost less then 5%, Dear Gupt ji it is not important to have a symbolic female as head( As India did had Indira Gandhi but still most of the women in India are still treated less then equal) but to have a culture and system where if some woman want to be head and have merits then they can be , If for some reason they have not been woman head do not think it as a weakness of the culture or system. Dear Gupt Ji Do not get into just symbolic equality think of change in the physic of Indians which Sikhs Gurus did with their influence example Sati ( Bride Burning), Killings of Girls, Parda( Covering of women), Positioning of Ladies as head of Regional and local Institutions by Sikh Gurus, Freeing Slaved Girls from Muslims and then adjusting them as honourable wife’s, daughters and sisters, Remarriage of Widows, 3)Did the Guru’s possess a political agenda? There is an evident power struggle. My Answer: Read the Jafar Nama of Guru Gobind Singh Ji you can find out your answers for political Agenda and power Struggle, Sikh Gurus never in their life time establish Sikh State or Attacked any state. Read the facts and then make these kinds of remarks. 4)After the first five Guru’s, did not the Sikh faith become a dynasty? My Ans::::::Again you are just sticking to very shallow view, After fifth Guru Sikhism went into direct conflict with Evils of state and it was lot of sacrifices were made it is pointless to think that their was something Guru Ji wanted for his Dynasty , when he was well aware of all the hardship rest of the Gurus went through. Yes may be if Guru Ji was going to give blood for others then it is much better if he start giving blood and suffering by himself and through his family then asking anybody else, that is the Sikh way lead by example. 5)Why did the Guru Gobind Singh stop the line of Guru’s? Did he actually think the faith was complete? In a way didn’t Guru Gobind Singh inhibit and paralyze this faith to expand upon the gurbani? My Ans: Sikhism went though process of going though a framework from 1 to 10th Guru and All the basic principles are configured and tuned by then, 10 Guru completed the formalisation of Sikh Philosophy and as planed by earlier Gurus finished the process. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the philosophy of Sikhs which can not be modified or changed. That philosophy was valid , is valid and till there is intelligent life which can read that philosophy it will remain the shining gift of Sikh Gurus for Humanity and Sikhs. 6)What was the significance of Guru Harkrishan ji to Sikh scripture or for that matter Sikh psyche? Didn’t Guru Harkrishan ji pass away from the great small pox pandemic that struck New Dehli. The scripture says that he was out curing people of the disease but in the end contracted it himself? My Ans: The whole idea of Guru Harkrishan Ji’s time in Sikh history is to make sure everybody understand that intelligence is not a monopoly of older people, A child can have intelligence of highest form. 7)Were our guru’s not men? Why does the majority of the Sikh population worship them as mythical heroes and non-human deities? (This is something we should definitely change in our faith; its an insult to our own reason) My Ans: When somebody on the TV taking about Mohammad Ali ( Boxer) they always says that he is the best of the best, the legend and Super star Hero of many . What that mean is in that field of Boxing he was very good, but people call him their hero, the legend. That is just for his Skills in supports. Do you know, Guru Gobind Sing ji is still Unparallel in Kindness till this day, He was Fantastic Poet, Brilliant rider, Amazing Sword fighter, Exceptionally Fine Shooter with Arrows and guns. Astonishingly Multiple language expert, Brave like no other man ever lived on the planet till this day and THE LEADER WITH FARSIGHT NOT EVER SEEN IN ANY HISTORY TILL this day these are the few qualities of My Dear Father, And you tell me what I or other should call him ? I have only included the things which you can check with history. 8)Were not the guru’s products and derivatives of there own society? My Ans: What do you think, Born in a Hindu dominant Society where Caste system and ritual were the key to everything and first thing First Guru Nanak Dev ji did was dismissed the Jenu as a useless ritual and pointless thing to have and made friend with Muslim Mardana ( even today in India many Hindus do not even like touch of Muslims). Guru Nanak Dev Ji also called Babar ( Muslim Ruler) a Jabar ( atrocious )in open with astonishing bravery. As they were their to lead the right path they obviously would criticised the current evils of the time. 9)Guru Gobind Singh used to hunt! Yet at the same time prohibit the consumption of animals, or was this tradition adopted after? Is there hypocrisy at hand? My ANS: Guru Gobind Singh Ji hunted the wild animals which were problem for the humans, also it was exercise for solders. Consumption of Ritualised kill is prohibited in Sikhism. Sikh Langar is for everybody and most Indians are vegetarians. 10)Guru Gobind Singh practiced polygamy? Is there hypocrisy at hand? My Ans: Guru Gobind Singh Ji did not practiced Polygamy, Mata Jito Ji and Mata Sundri are both same woman, one name before marriage and another one after marriage ( common practice in India). 11)Would the Guru’s have been more effective in implementing more peaceful measures with the Mughal rulers? (Someone only with a strong historical background should attempt to answer this question) Was such extreme Sikh militarization absolutely necessary? Was the militarization of the Sikhs part of Guru Gobind Singh’s political agenda? Again how was the 10th guru’s struggle any different from that of the struggles of elites today? My Answer again same: Read the Jafar Nama of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, you can find out your answers for political Agenda and power Struggle, Sikh Gurus never in their life time establish Sikh State or Attacked any state. But many states did attach Guru Gobind Singh Ji Many times, Read the facts and then make these kinds of remarks. Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Inteligent replys needed

GUPT · 08 Nov 2005

For the record i'm not the one asking these questions. Its this weirdo from sikh sangat goes by the alias sinister

Re: Inteligent replys needed

Kulwinder Singh · 09 Nov 2005

I am very sorry Gupt Ji, I have written this reply in late night as I though this was required and I made mistake of took your Pen name as the message originator. I have posted my message now on the sikhsangat.com as well. Sorry again. Kulwinder Singh