Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

confused Singh · 01 Nov 2005

I never really knew if we celebteated Halloween, but i guess this is the new way for Khasla to celebrate halloween! My favortie is when the Singhs treated bana for ninja turtles tights and their kirpans for wooden sticks. http://www.mrsikhnet.com/

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Kulbir Singh · 01 Nov 2005

Sikhs don't celebrate Halloween. It's against the spirit of Gurmat to participate in this festival of bhoots and Churails. And to beg house to house is no Gurmat. Whoever you beg from will be payable karmic debt from you. Kulbir Singh

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

DDT · 01 Nov 2005

i agree with kulbir singh ji but i wanted to no wat a Churail is, ive never heard the term before

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Gurpartap Singh · 01 Nov 2005

churail(ਚੁੜੈਲ) means a witch(ਭੂਤਨੀ,[i]bhootni[/i]) ਮੈਂ ਵੀ ਕੁਲਬੀਰ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀ ਨਾਲ ਪੂਰੀ ਤਰ੍ਹਾਂ ਸਹਿਮਤ ਹਾਂ। -- ਗੁਰਪ੍ਰਤਾਪ ਸਿੰਘ

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

harpreet singh · 01 Nov 2005

hahaha Just something for kids to have fun, relax.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

ekta · 01 Nov 2005

haha i know harpreet is rite.... how ignorant are u ppl. kids can't have fun ne more? my kids will ball on halloween with the best constumes.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Gerk · 01 Nov 2005

Congratulations, the first post in this thread is a perfect example of why people are running away from Sikhi. It's a fun day for kids to dress up and play with other kids and eat candy. Sikh kids should have fun and go trick or treating.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Fun? · 02 Nov 2005

If its something for kids to have fun about then isnt it fun for us to celebrate our own festivals first? Its a western joke!! Same with Christmas!! Its about the BIRTH OF CHRIST!! not A guy in a Red Suit with bigg belly!!!! If its about love and caring shouldnt this be practiced in our daily lives anyway??? If you celebrate xmas then do it coz u remember the day a great religious person was born on the earth and pay your respects. thats it! I agree, halloween is anti-gurmat!! although when i was going to Gurdwara, i had ucha bunga on and all the shastar on!! including barsha!! alot of the little kids in my street though thought i had the "best costume"!! lol Still, anti gurmat! WJKK WJKF

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Baldeep Singh · 02 Nov 2005

>> Just something for kids to have fun, relax. Same as lighting candles in sikh homes during the hindu festival of diwali... isn't it intriguing how we compromise our beliefs just to fit in with the norm, yea "relax", "take a chill pill". Isn't it strange how so-called Sikhs celebrate Diwali with so much flare with fireworks going off at the Gurdwaras and homes. What about the remaining Gurpurbs? You only see 3 or so sangat attending these. Even coming upto Guru Nanak Dev Sahibjeees birth how many of his 25 Million Sikhs will be full on, if there is 25 Million sikhs on this planet? Yea its OK "Relax". I have seen "Sikhs" celebrating Christmas, celebrating the birth of Isa on the so-called day of the 24/25 dec or whatever. With Christmas tree and presents. Yea thats right "relax, its all a bit of fun for the kids".

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Gupt Singh · 02 Nov 2005

Celebrate halloween by doing simran!!

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Zorawar Singh · 02 Nov 2005

Fun is fine, but at some point you do need to think what the deeper meaning is. Just compare vaiskahi, Bandi Choor, Gurpurbs, even Christmas, Easter, Ramadhan, etc. All have a positive meaning to make humanity better. But then look at Guy Fawkes Night, Halloween, and in UK there is mischievious night aswell. Hardly something profound!

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

stranger · 02 Nov 2005

Where does it state in Bani that an individual cannot enjoy local customs of the land he/she resides on? Just because some kids go around houses offering trick or treat does not mean they are breaking any spiritual values. Besides they are not always looking for money - often they are given sweets and goodies..........:-( I suppose next thing you bunch will be saying is that children should not be given birthday presents because it encourages materialistic style of life!!!!! Give everyone a break!!!

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Sehajvir Singh · 02 Nov 2005

The best halloween i ever spent was last year i believe or maybe the year before. It was in Abbotsford the local singhs set up a day with fun for the kids. Some mini rides and stuff. ALONG with a full on kirtan program and youngsters i mean like 11 or 12 doing kavishiri about the attack. They also had never before seen pics set up in the parking lot which were huge. At the end they gave away prizes and bags of candies for all the kids. Then fireworks and a gatka displaying. They attached burning coals to the chakar so it was glowing when the singh was spinning it. IT WAS AMAZING. The kids had a blast and the older singhs and singhnis loved it a well. The singhs did something so amazing. They used this holiday to get kids to come out and learn about 84. The parents didn't have to go trick or treating so the kids didn't feel they missed anything and they had a chance to learn about sikh history. I think this was a brilliant idea. Oh and the firworks were wicked.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Jasmin · 02 Nov 2005

Halloween might lend to pranks, so of course thats questionable, as is begging. However if you are going to give candy, or money(for unicif) why not hand out some religious literature with the goodies? As far as decorating the house, its possible to find many decorations which are merely seasonal, like a plain pumpkin, or tree decorated with snowflake ornaments, if you wish. I can't see anything offensive about a seasonal floral display. You could also have a New Year party as that is, essentially, secular, or a solitice party, which is only about the time of year.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

SSingh · 02 Nov 2005

I bet you can correlate reht, amritvela and kami with Gursikhs who don’t celebrate to Gursikhs that celebrate these foolish western cultural festivals. But than again, there is always going to be someone out there that says they celebrate these foolish festivals and still have crazy reht, amertivela and kami. But one question, if you can’t translate most of bani that you read than how much Kami do you have? A talking parrot doesn’t count doesn’t count as kami. Also reading English translations doesn’t count. So now lets hear all peronsal experiences from all those Brahimgyanies who celebrate mammat.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

we all got names · 02 Nov 2005

we too busy celebrating the western world celebrations but no one remembers gurpurabs or days to remember shaheeds no one talks about it most sikhs in the world know when they celebrate when christ was born but dont have a clue when it comes to Sri Guru Nanak Dev ji

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

RoopKaur · 02 Nov 2005

The initial problem is that some people's idea of having "fun" and "relaxing" is to dress yourselves up as bhoots and churails, and than go begging for candy to everyone's house. There are SO many problems with this scenario. 1. Firstly, Sikhs are sons and daughters of shahen shah Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Does it look right when we pathetically go begging for candy to everyone's house when we are of such high parentage? 2. A Sikh is supposed to keep bibek, eating candies does not equal bibek. Feeding this filth to your kids does not equal bibek. And giving away that stuff also does not equal bibek. 3. It is surprising how much people have problems wearing guru jis bana because of self consciousness or whatever other reason, yet we find no problems in dressing up as fools by painting our faces and becoming various types of namooney. 4. A Sikh is supposed to eat from their dasaa nauhaa dee kamaee. The candy that is begged off of other people does not fit into this category. Think back to the Sakhi of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Malak Bhago. Now compare it to Halloween. 5. THere is nothing spiritually gained from this waste of time, and actually puts your Sikhi behind. If your idea of fun does this, than what is the point of enjoying this fun? Is it not more fun to do keertan where you actually get lahaa out of it too? Its funny how we can find time for this weird idea of fun, yet do not find time to do paath or keertan. Someone said that the reason why so many Sikhs are running away from Sikhi is because of these kinds of attitudes. But your statement does not hold. I have heard this comment before but the numbers do not support your claim. If what you say was true, than why were Sikhs more pakey in their beliefs in puraatan times, when more Gurmat was followed, and less Sikhs today, when everything is becoming lax in the name of "fun" and "relaxing"? If Sikhs were running away from following pakey gurmat asools, then we should have more Sikhs today, when so many dhills have crept into the panth, which is not the case.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Gurpartap Singh · 02 Nov 2005

ਮੈਂ ਰੂਪ ਕੌਰ ਜੀ ਨਾਲ ਪੂਰੀ ਤਰ੍ਹਾਂ ਸਹਿਮਤ ਹਾਂ।

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

MS · 03 Nov 2005

I think this is a perfect time for Sikhs. Singhs shoul get their bana and shaster on in full force and use this as an opportunity to chase these jamdoot wannabees!

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

singhni wannabe · 03 Nov 2005

but isnt halloween a celebration which cristians celebrate! our kids can have fun celebration our festivals nt christians! WAHEYGURU JI KA KHALSA! WAHEYGURU JI KE FATEH! [%sig%]

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

JB · 03 Nov 2005

i aint really feelin the whole halloween thing myself, load of bukwaas. but if u wana dress up n have a laugh, go for it... next ppl are gona be sayin we shouldnt watch TV, or go bowling, themeparks etc... to mans who are slating any1 who does halloween: let ppl live their own lives, no 1 is forcing anybody else to do anything. not everybody has reached that stage in their lives where they can give up these kinda things... if u've reached that stage, its good for you, but try to understand ppl that aint reached that stage...

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

stranger · 03 Nov 2005

Well done JB - you hit the nail on the head Very soon we will be told that watching TV is the door to hell and reading novels is a definite golden ticket to hell

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Jasmin · 03 Nov 2005

Halloween is a remnant of a Celtic festival celebrated in Ireland long before Christianity. It signifies the death of summer. A time when the world of the living and the dead would come together. So I suppose you could veiw people dressing up as wanting to be juboots. Guru Fateh

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

** · 03 Nov 2005

Baldeep Singh Date: 11-02-05 02:05 >> Just something for kids to have fun, relax. Same as lighting candles in sikh homes during the hindu festival of diwali... isn't it intriguing how we compromise our beliefs just to fit in with the norm, yea "relax", "take a chill pill". Isn't it strange how so-called Sikhs celebrate Diwali with so much flare with fireworks going off at the Gurdwaras and homes. What about the remaining Gurpurbs? You only see 3 or so sangat attending these. Even coming upto Guru Nanak Dev Sahibjeees birth how many of his 25 Million Sikhs will be full on, if there is 25 Million sikhs on this planet? Yea its OK "Relax". I have seen "Sikhs" celebrating Christmas, celebrating the birth of Isa on the so-called day of the 24/25 dec or whatever. With Christmas tree and presents. Yea thats right "relax, its all a bit of fun for the kids" i thawt on the same day in India Guru Hargobind got realeased and many candles were lit around india 2 rmember this wonderful time? > > I never really knew if we celebteated Halloween, but i guess > this is the new way for Khasla to celebrate halloween! My > favortie is when the Singhs treated bana for ninja turtles > tights and their kirpans for wooden sticks. > > > http://www.mrsikhnet.com/

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

SSingh · 03 Nov 2005

JB said " if u've reached that stage, its good for you, but try to understand ppl that aint reached that stage..." If you cant sacrifice that much, than maybe you shouldn’t have given your head to Guru ji. The problem is that we try to accustom Sikhi into our lives, whereas, we should accustom our lives into Sikhi. Unlike all other religions, Sikhi is a marg, (path), and a very difficulty one, which we have to follow. The rules are set and if you don’t follow the rules, it called manmat. Thus "live their own lives" would be considerd manmat.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

moorakh · 03 Nov 2005

re: Confused Singh's post ------------------------- He is just informing us of the way people have made a joke of their bana. Dressing up is not wrong, but dressing up and doing beadbi to your kakaars is against gurmat. Bhai Kulbir Singh ji is right, that Sikhs don't beg door to door. "Trick or Treat" - we don't want nor need either of these. Harpreet Singh and "ekta" - I can understand your point of view, but what do kids do on halloween? Think about it: 1) Dress up in costumes 2) Go out into the street with friends 3) Walk house to house and ask for candy 4) Light firecrackers 5) Play pranks Do any of these activities help the kids in any way? What cultural values do they learn? Do they learn about their neighbours, or their selves? Do they become less racist, less prejudiced? So then, what type of cultural or spiritual value does it have? You can get the enjoyment of 10 Halloweens at One Shaheedi Smagam. Sehajvir Singh is right. The Abbotsford Singhs have created a great concept of organizing the Shaheedi Smagam in honour of Bhai Beant Singh ji. It is the best way to give kids enjoyment of the day, and spiritual inspiration. [%sig%]

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

JB · 04 Nov 2005

reply to SSingh: i get your point, but i dont think you've understood what im saying. just because you (and others on this site) have reached another level and dont find giving up certain things hard (not just bukwaas like halloween, but things in general) , doesnt mean every1 else is ready to give these things up... every1 is at different stages in their sikhi. its a hard mountain to climb, so shouldnt you try n help them up, or should u push them down? all im sayin is try n be a bit more understanding... ps: i think halloween is a load of crap ne way...

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

HS · 04 Nov 2005

If Sikhs "celebrate" halloween then so what? Its just a laugh! Then someones post about we should only be eating from our kamai, well in that case suppose i prepared you a bibek meal at my house, would you refuse to eat it purely cos u hadn't paid for it? GIMME A BREAK! Stop being so extreme, Sikhi is about tolerance. If other customs and traditions didn't mean anything then i don't see why our Guru Sahib gave His Head for the cause of the Hindus! Be tolerant, and be part of the community you live in as long as it doesn't lead to anything bad. So suppose some sikh kids went out for halloween, they got some sweets etc and thats it, theres nothing wrong, but if these kids started playing around, damaging properties or getting greedy about how many sweets they could get then that goes against Sikhi, then it should be avoided.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Khalsa · 04 Nov 2005

This is good for kids to assimilate in society. you cannot tell them no you cant celebrate Halloween as this would make them outcasts at school and among friends. Its just fun like lorhi u can say. This is a dumb topic anyways guys why even bring this up. Its not against sikhi in any way.

Re: How do Sikhs celebrate Halloween??

Khalsa_Force · 07 Nov 2005

Some very good replies hv been given, theres no need to add anything else, but will this change thinking of so call MODREN SIKHS? NO, it wont.