Immigrants bringing ethnic woes here, Canadians say
Zorawar Singh · 31 Oct 2005
Headline in Ottawa Citizen - The terrorist threat is purely from the Islamic groups, not any Sikh groups. But are Sikhs is canada doing enough to vioce their separte identity so that they do not get tarred with the same brush? Ottawa Citizen Monday, October 31, 2005 Nearly two-thirds of Canadians think our peaceable country is increasingly threatened by ethnic problems imported by immigrant groups. Even more support tougher immigration standards to screen out terrorists. But we also worry that measures to combat terrorism could violate the rights of innocent Arab and Islamic Canadians. Those are some key findings of a wide-ranging public opinion survey called The World in Canada: Demographics and Diversity in Canadian Foreign Policy. It was commissioned for the annual Ottawa conference of the Canadian Defence & Foreign Affairs Institute today and tomorrow at the National Arts Centre. Prompted by the dramatic shift to non-traditional sources of immigration to Canada, the Innovative Research Group poll seeks to gauge ethno-cultural differences on foreign policy issues. It found that Canadians generally agree on the country's foreign policy direction. Where differences exist, they are the enduring divisions between French and English Canadians, not new fractures between newcomers and established Canadians. "Immigrants are just as likely to believe in strong military and foreign affairs policy for Canada," says Rudyard Griffiths, executive director of the Dominion Institute, one of the poll's sponsors. Historian David Bercuson says new Canadians are more likely to share the views of English-Canadians than those of French-Canadians. "If there's a major division in this country on an international question," he warns, "that could be very dangerous." Among those surveyed, 63 per cent agree that Canada is having increasing trouble with ethnic groups bringing problems from their home countries to Canada. First-generation Canadians -- those born here to immigrant parents -- were the most concerned, with 70 per cent holding that view. Though 19th-century groups like the Irish Fenians carried their old-world conflicts with them to Canada, Mr. Bercuson says the import of ethnic disputes is new to recent Canadian experience. "In the post-9/11 world, it strikes a lot of people as being somewhat dangerous." The World in Canada poll found a whopping 83 per cent of Canadians think the country needs stricter immigration standards to control the presence of known terrorists. "The survey shows a hardening of Canadians' stance towards new Canadians in the context of public fears, largely unjustified, that increased levels of immigration represent a security risk," says Mr. Griffiths. But with ethnic voters gaining ever greater influence, Mr. Bercuson predicts political parties will be reluctant to act. "Politicians will walk there only with great trepidation." Despite the sentiment favouring tougher immigration standards, 63 per cent of Canadians say they are worried that concern about terrorism could lead to abuse of the rights of Canadians from Arabic or Islamic countries. This fear probably arises from the publicity given to cases such as that of Mahar Arar of Ottawa, where human rights appear to have been flagrantly abused. "You sort of say, if they can do it to him, would they do it to me?" says Mr. Bercuson. The fact that Canada has thus far escaped direct terrorist attack has helped keep the balance of public sentiment on the side of preserving civil liberties, he says. "Canadians don't see a clear and present danger to their own lives and security of property." But that will likely change if Canada comes under attack, Mr. Bercuson says. "I don't think Canadians are any more or less immune from fright than anyone else in the world." Nearly three-quarters of those surveyed think the United States has been an "unreliable and unilateral trading and security partner." Partly for that reason, they endorse the government's new focus on shifting trade from traditional partners such as the U.S., Britain and France and to emerging countries such as China and India. Nearly two-thirds think that's a good idea, though barely half of French-Canadians agree. The findings disappoint Mr. Bercuson. "Canadians are being completely unreasonable and unrealistic," he says, "because it's not going to happen. "I think Canadians are mad at the United States right now, so they want to strike back. This looks like a way of striking back." But Canadians should ask themselves whether China would be more reliable, he says. "They haven't been such a good buddy either in international trading circles." The World in Canada poll was commissioned by the Canadian Defence & Foreign Affairs Institute in co-operation with the Dominion Institute, the Woodrow Wilson International Centre for Scholars and five universities -- Carleton, Laval, Queen's, McGill and the University of Montreal. The Innovative Research Group surveyed 1,141 Canadians between Sept. 16 and Sept. 20. The margin of error is plus or minus 3.1 percentage points, 19 times out of 20. Other findings: - While two-thirds of respondents think Canada needs an effective military force to play a significant role in international affairs, only 49 per cent of French-Canadians agree. - Paradoxically, 81 per cent of French-Canadians are confident the military could respond in a timely way to a major natural emergency in Canada. Just 66 per cent of newcomers and 68 per cent of English-Canadians agree. - Despite skepticism about U.S. reliability among Canadians of all backgrounds, 59 per cent think Canada has found the right balance in its co-operation with the Americans on foreign policy and security issues. - Canadians are evenly split on whether Canada should increase its foreign aid to failing states such as Haiti, Somalia and Afghanistan if it means spending less on health and education here. - Fifty-six per cent think Canada should direct foreign aid to countries where there has been a significant loss of life. Only one in five think it should be focused on important trading partners, and one in ten believe it should go to countries where our allies are involved in military operations. - Just less than half think Canada should give priority to promoting democratic elections in unstable countries, even if it increases short-term instability. Thirty-nine per cent believe Canada should give priority to stabilization and recovery efforts, even if it means supporting undemocratic rule in the short term. Arbitration: Leave religion out of it, Canadians say, page A3 © The Ottawa Citizen 2005