Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

PERSON · 25 Oct 2005

HEY I FORGOT WHAT THE OTHER 1S R... BUT U KNOW WHERE CHICKENS R STUCK IN CAGE AND THEN U GET FREE RANGE EGGS MY Q IS.. WHATS THE VIEW ON THIS IS IT REALLI BAD 2 EAT FREE RANGE?

Re: EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

... · 25 Oct 2005

I've thought about this issue. What is the purpose of eggs? It's not food. It's to reproduce. In nature, do herbivores eat eggs? No, not at all. Who steals and eats eggs in nature? Meat eaters. Contrast that to milk which is specifically meant to be a food item and is used by herbivores. Eggs are not food.

Re: EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

moorakh · 26 Oct 2005

eating eggs is like eating the placenta from a newborn baby or eating a newborn baby's umbilical cord

Re: EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

JB · 26 Oct 2005

think abt it, eggs do not have souls, they're not going to hatch, they dont have the potential of becoming a chicken (unless there is a cockrel around). so whats wrong with eating them?

Re: EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

....me.... · 28 Oct 2005

why does this question always come up? 'why can't we eat eggs?' Eggs are not made for us to eat its made by chickens to have babies we have been told by our Guru not to eat eggs fullstop. y are u questioning this?

Re: EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

singhni wannabe · 28 Oct 2005

i agree with "....me...." we have been told by the guru that we cant eat eggs doesnt matter if there free range or not! waheyguru ji ka khalsa waheyguru ji ke fateh.

Re: EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

JB · 29 Oct 2005

valid point, but one could turn around n say "milk is made for the calf of the maaj"...

Re: EGGS- FREE RANGE N THE OTHER 1S

Novtej Singh · 31 Oct 2005

JB, a clever point but have you ever considered in the light that milk is a product from the cow as is an apple from a tree. Apples are the flower of the tree and once they fall degrade and nourish the soil from which the tree obtains its nutrients. So should we stop eating apples? Eggs have the potential to live, so no need to go on a tangent and start a debate about milk.