Baba Bulleh Shah
Learner · 23 Oct 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! What was Baba Bulleh Shah's stance in Sikhism? Did he ever meet with Guru Gobind Singh Ji and are any of his writings in Guru Granth Sahib Ji?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Learner · 23 Oct 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! What was Baba Bulleh Shah's stance in Sikhism? Did he ever meet with Guru Gobind Singh Ji and are any of his writings in Guru Granth Sahib Ji?.... · 23 Oct 2005
i don't think his writings appear in the Guru Granth Sahib Ji... i heard he praises Guru Gobind singh Ji, anyone have those verses? could those who have please share them...!! · 23 Oct 2005
i'm not sure but it was something like this "jab ki na kahoon tab ki na kahoon batt kahoon maiin abb ki agar na hote gur gobind singh to sunat hotee sabh ki" [%sig%]..... · 24 Oct 2005
"jab ki na kahoon tab ki na kahoon batt kahoon maiin abb ki agar na hote gur gobind singh to sunat hotee sabh ki" can anyone do a translation of this...thankyouno one · 24 Oct 2005
the translation: jab ki na kahoon, tab ki na kahoon i won't speak of that period batt kahoon maiin abb ki let me tell you of the present agar na hote gur gobind singh if it wasn't for guru gobind singh to sunat hotee sabh ki all would have been circumcised - please do correct me if i have made any mistakes... [%sig%]member · 24 Oct 2005
Bullah Shah, though a very good Sufi Poet himself is not in SGGSJ. His work is more of social side than spiritual(at least that is what I find). No disrespect to him, in my opinion he is not Bhaktee as Sikhs know it. It is either him or someone else who said. "Baat Kahu Na Ab Ki Na tab Ki Agar Na Hotey Guru Gobind Singh tau Sunnat hote sabki" Above verse often quoted by Sikhs, was not written to support the Guru, but rather written to state a Historic Fact in negative light. None of Sufis were friendly to the Sikhs(exception being Mia Meer of Lahore). Note: Baba Farid Jee lived long before Guru Nanak Dev Jee.* · 24 Oct 2005
"Above verse often quoted by Sikhs, was not written to support the Guru, but rather written to state a Historic Fact in negative light" thats a good point..i never thought of it like that... anything else Bull Shah wrote to support this view that Bull Shah saw sikhi in a negative light?. · 25 Oct 2005
Yeah SArvjit can you prove that Bulleh Shahs view on SIkhs was negative?A Singh · 25 Oct 2005
<<>> Perhaps you have overlooked others like Pir Buddhu Shah, a Muslim Sufi saint, who pledged his allegiance and that of his followers for the Guru. For this act they were later tortured and killed by the Mughal authorities and also Dara Shikoh, a disciple of Hazrat Mian Mir Sahib who, in turn, was a close friend of Guru Hargobind Ji. Gur Fateh! A SinghSingh · 25 Oct 2005
I cannot vouch for other things that Bullah wrote about Sikhs that are in Negative light. At that I have with me now to prove. But have often heard from my elders that some Sufis tried to submit their works in Adi Granth when Guru Arjan was compiling it. But Guru refused their work because it was not in true spiritual sense(as per Sikhi Rehat Maryada), that is not in the same calibre as Baba Farid Jee. This event probably created some tension in their minds(Shah Inayat, Bullah Shah) etc. In fact one of the famous Sufi(Data Ganj of Lahore) was actually openly professed Gay, and if I am not mistaken Bullah Shah was his shagird(I am not 100%sure of this). The verse in question(Agar Na hotey .....) was written to describe simply an obvious Historic fact. Sufis did want everyone to convert into Islam(their version), Sikhism was a thorn in the Muslim empire always. I haven't read anything else by any Sufi that shows any Non Muslim religion or school of thought in positive light.