Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

practical amritdharees

practical amritdharees

vichar · 23 Oct 2005

i would like to consult sanghat on this issue, please correct me if im wrong when you take amrit, you offer guru ji youre head you accept death, and give up all hope of worldly life because you give youre head to guruji, you are part of a contract, where you try youre upmost to follow gurujis every hukam youre aim in life is to keep guruji happy, in doing so he will show you the way to god - the goal in life speaking to some amritdharees recently, i have been told i am an extremist, and my views are extreme. i have been told, we have to be practical about life, as we have to live in this world my response to this is that we are supposed to be dead while alive, yeah we live in this world, but we are 'dead' and remain unaffected by worldly happeneings this discussion started with consuming foods which contain alcohol, i dont understand how you can say i sacrifice my life and give my head to you guruji, but im not going to stop eating foods containing alcohol. should gursikhs be 'balanced', or should gursikhs take an all out approach where they put in 100%effort to please guru ji, regardless of practicality? eg, should a gursikh try and fit into his workplace, by eating out at restaurants with workmates, or adhere to a strict code of rehit bibek where all food eaten is prepared like prashad, by amritdharees?

Re: practical amritdharees

agyani · 23 Oct 2005

most western sikhs live in utter darkness, sikhi is not to be modernised with the times this is all aload of rubbish coming from people who have no rehit and bend sikhi to suit themselves. To "pass" in guru nanaks house u gotta be 100%

Re: practical amritdharees

Jasmin · 23 Oct 2005

I believe you are right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!So I have to do more to compley. VVVVAHEGURUVaheguruuuuuu

Re: practical amritdharees

singh · 24 Oct 2005

certain jathe bandhe preach practicality, and not hurting peoples feelings above khalsa rehit. they come out with excuses like, its more important to get rid of 5 chor, then worrying about eating out at restaurants/going cinema. but without rehit you will fail in defeating 5 chor, its rehit which is key to defeating the mind. improve rehit, which allows improvement in naam simran, which allows a reduction in panj chor, which allows an increase in nam simran, which allows an improvement in rehit which allows an improvement in nam simran etc etc going cinema will not help you reduce panj chor.

Re: practical amritdharees

akji · 24 Oct 2005

mmmmm not sure..............

Re: practical amritdharees

admin cut · 24 Oct 2005

shouldnt sikhi become more modern, especially if we live in the west, like shudnt we abide law like wearing 2 inch kirpans?

Re: practical amritdharees

A Singh · 24 Oct 2005

I'd like to understand more about the 'line' that people draw for this requirement (re: bibek). Firstly, I know bibek is an important practice, so I'd like our Veers and Bhains who live this lifestyle to respond in particular to the last point raised by Vichaar Sahib: <<>> This is not only a social requirement, but increasingly a work requirement in many fields, client discussions, political conventions etc are all held across or will involve some form of lunch or dinner (food afterall is an extremely important binding customs in all relations). How does one then propose to work with this whilst maintaining "100%" as outlined above? Should we simply give up our occupations because they require us to occasionally dine with non-Amritdharis or eat non-(sarabloh) bibek food? If so, is the way forward for us to be business owners such that we dictate our own terms for our livelihoods (since employed work in an office or political role will at some stage result in the above). How do we intend to making "Sikh" presence felt in areas of politics, finance, commerce etc without being part of these institutions? Is all this 'presence' even required? Are we better off having Navdeep Singh Bains in politics in Canada or having Manmohan Singh as PM of India, or would we be best off as a Panth living life in a commune existence where we could practice all maryada fully...although the question of income does arise, but then again, perhaps its possible to be self-sufficient if enough people pull together? Sounds extreme? Well is it really? What are the experiences of those who do life a committed and bibeki lifetyle 24-7?

Re: practical amritdharees

Kuljot Singh · 24 Oct 2005

************************************************************ eg, should a gursikh try and fit into his workplace, by eating out at restaurants with workmates, or adhere to a strict code of rehit bibek where all food eaten is prepared like prashad, by amritdharees? ************************************************************ Our rehats are the very thing that makes us distinct and who and what we are. And it's because of our committment to our rehats that we have not been swallowed up by religions like Hinduism just as many other religions have. As long as we stick to our Guru given rehats we will have Guru Sahib's blessings, and we can preserve our identity in this rotten dirty kaljug. We can pass these rehats orally down to our children ect. just as they have been passed down for centuries before. So no, don't get soft on your rehats! [gurbani]jblg^wlswrhyinAwrw] qblgqyjkIaumYNswrw][/gurbani] ************************************************************ speaking to some amritdharees recently, i have been told i am an extremist, and my views are extreme. i have been told, we have to be practical about life, as we have to live in this world ************************************************************ I congradulate you on your "extremeism". You should keep in mind that opinions are like padhs (farts), everyone makes them and they usually stink. Especially when they are comments that encourage you to keep less rehat and not more. -kuljot singh [%sig%]

Re: practical amritdharees

Kulbir Singh · 24 Oct 2005

------------ eg, should a gursikh try and fit into his workplace, by eating out at restaurants with workmates, or adhere to a strict code of rehit bibek where all food eaten is prepared like prashad, by amritdharees? --------- I personally have been working in an office environment as an accountant for about 10 years now. In my early years of occupation, I used to go out with my co-workers and manager few times a year but I did not used to eat anything from the restaurant. I would frankly tell them that I am joining only to socialize and not to dine. This was almost always followed by a session on Sikh faith and why we don’t eat from outside. I never had any problem for not eating from outside. Later on, I decided that I did not want to even go in the restaurant. No body objected. A few Sikhs who used to dine with them were embarrassed since goray people asked them how come they were eating from outside but Kulbir Singh does not. They too stopped eating from restaurants (sharmo-sharmee). I have worked for many companies and never had any problem for not eating from outside. I don’t have any urge to please these goray or kalay people. If I can please Siri Dasmesh jee, that would be good enough for me. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: practical amritdharees

pnchain · 24 Oct 2005

i think its more important to have a clean heart, whats the point of rehit?

Re: practical amritdharees

Iron Man · 24 Oct 2005

In this world, how can your heart stay clean without rehaT? rehat is your only line of defense... without that, you surely cannot have a truly pure or clean heart.

Re: practical amritdharees

seaside kaur · 24 Oct 2005

We have a few people at my office with strict diets. A few people have some problematic food allergies. Two eat only strict kosher. One of these people I have worked with before at another company...he was just as respected there as he is here. These people's diets have not hurt their career at all. At work, we generally socialize by playing basketball or indoor hockey. If we go out, we'll plan on going and actually doing something like playing mini-golf. One of the managers (not one with strict diet) has said that he would prefer that it is not about food and more about something we can all do together. Most people with corporate jobs don't rush to a bar when they leave. Movies may say otherwise but it is not true. Most people with corporate jobs rush home to be with their families or friends.

Re: practical amritdharees

Sohagani · 24 Oct 2005

Kulbir Singh Jee, I've noticed that in many of your posts you refer to other's as goray or kalay, and I know that in no way at all are you being even the slightest bit racist. But on a linguistic level, since language directly influences thought, I think you should refrain from that use of language. I don't believe in white or black race classifications, but most of the world does. My advice (humbly) is to make use of words that emcompass race classification as part of a more general classification such as 'westerners' or even 'non-sikhs'. [%sig%]

Re: practical amritdharees

A Singh · 25 Oct 2005

Veer Kulbir Singh, Thanks for sharing your experiences, I guess the point concerning socialising etc is well made – I don’t think this really should be an issue to break one’s bibek, as you indicate quite clearly, it is simple to work around this and explain your stance (i.e. if you are vegetarian, bibeki, sarablohi etc). The case is more complicated for say a travelling executive or business person where one has no access to their own cooking utensils or applications (i.e. staying in a Hotel over an extended period etc) with many client meetings or conferences held over lunch. Here the case is not so much socialising or joining one’s colleagues let alone trying to please anyone, but a part of one’s job and also food intake. In cases where it is one or two meetings one can still make do and work with the time (i.e. have some pre-prepared food in between), but in the case of all-day conferences or sessions etc, things are not always as clear cut and as simple to work around, and on these occasions, whilst one can ensure before hand that they line up say vegetarian or vegan food etc with the caterers/venue, actually maintaining strict bibek becomes a slightly tougher challenge - this is something I’ve personally found difficult. The only suggestions I have seen in the past is to pre-prepare solid foods such as pinnea, however this is not really going to suffice for a period of more than a day or so – any alternative suggestions here? Thanks and Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: practical amritdharees

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 26 Oct 2005

Veer Kulbir Singh- I've got to say we need more Singh's like you in the panth. May Waheguru keep you in chardi-kalla. Bole so nihal, sat sri Akaal!!!!

Re: practical amritdharees

singh · 26 Oct 2005

rehit followed depends on jathabandhe, even akj have different versions, in the uk the majority follow quite a strict rehit, there is a minority who encourage practicality and have a different name. im not saying which is right or wrong, just acceptin ppl have different views, some are right some wrong.

Re: practical amritdharees

G Singh · 26 Oct 2005

Good questions A Singh...I'm in a similar situation and would like some suggestions from the sangat. Wjkk Wjkf!

Re: practical amritdharees

RoopKaur · 26 Oct 2005

To A Singh, Why not pack your own pre cooked food and eat that, instead of dining out? Take your own food with you. I am sure if you explain that it is for religious reasons, there will be accomodations made for you.

Re: practical amritdharees

Seaside Kaur · 26 Oct 2005

A Singh and G Singh, Please forgive my mentioning of brand names here, but I can't think of a better way to describe this. If you are going to be away from home for a day or more, can you stay in a reasonably-priced "suites" style hotel such as Candlewood Suites? The benefit is a room that is like a studio apartment (with a kitchen) where you can cook fresh food every day. They are not expensive. Candlewood is at the same rate as other business-class hotels (such as Hampton Inn), and cheaper than the full-service hotels (such as Mariott). While "Suites" sounds like an expensive name, it is a very reasonable place to stay.

Re: practical amritdharees

singhni wannabe. · 27 Oct 2005

Does it matter if you socialise at work? does it matter what others think of us? i didnt think so. Keeping a strict rehat is more important than socialising with work collegues isnt it? Wahey ji ka khalsa wahey ji ke fateh. P.s sorry if i have affended anyone this is just my opinion.

Re: practical amritdharees

Gangu · 27 Oct 2005

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH What about us people who depend on our parents? It will be very hard for us to be bibeki especially if our parents aren't amritdhari. Also, if we have close family n stuff i think it could cause hatred :S

Re: practical amritdharees

A Singh · 27 Oct 2005

Singhni, Please re-read people's statement, no one is arguing about 'socialising' but seeking advice ("Practical" advice if you pardon the pun!) from those like the Veers and Bhains above who do keep strict bibek on particular situations that arise with the nature of one's employment and lifestyle. Regards, A Singh.

Re: practical amritdharees

Manj · 02 Nov 2005

Wgjkk wgjkf Can I ask, how and what is the best way to explain to someone why you don't eat out ? I some times try to explain certain things about sikhi to people but my words come out wrong or I end up making people confused. Thanks Wgjkk wgjkf

Re: practical amritdharees

sukhvinder singh · 03 Nov 2005

wen we give our heads to guru ji, we GIVE OUR HEADS, if gona give ur life u cant give bit or say ill give my life but, u give your life thats it, u follow gurus hukam 100% no matter what, whats the point in being sikh if u not gona be proper one, simple

Re: practical amritdharees

RoopKaur · 03 Nov 2005

To Manj, The best way I think is to use the phrase you are what you eat and use it to explain how everything a Sikh does he has to assess how it affects him or her spiritually. Likewise, food also affects spirituality and in order to insure that we are not negatively affected, we do not eat from just anyone and we pray when we make our food.