Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

Manjit kaur · 22 Oct 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. a friend brought up this at a funeral recently. A Singh who passed away recently DONATED ALL his organs, bones, joints etc to Science and to various living reciepients who were transplanted with his organs. Now there is a Shabad in Gurbani that says.."when an animal dies..he is useful in ten ways...we can use his skin as leather, etc etc. BUT when a HUMAN DIES..his BODY is USELESS to anyone else and is Cremated/buried intact. Now we all ( myself included) believe in GURBANI being ETERNAL TRUTH...but can anyone explain to me what is the actual menaing of this shabad vis a vis the HUMAN DEAD BODY. Clearly a dead person who Donates his organs is performing a SERVICE to Humanity/Science...so HE is "USEFUL"..just like the dead animal ?? Or is Gurbani saying something else ?? or does thsi Tuk only apply to Genral humans who die and are cremated/buried as useless and not those who like this Singh Ji who donated his organs to the living as a service to mankind...even after his death he is still useful.

Re: a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

Truth · 22 Oct 2005

1. can you reference the shabad so we can actually read it in gurmukhi....and read the rest of the shabad to understand the context. cause the way you've quoted it sounds more like your own translation than what would appear in the shabad ( i don't think gurbani uses "etc") 2.in Indian culture, the dead human body is considered unfit for usage....meaning there is a "pollution" attached to it. you could very well pull off the skin of a man when he dies, but nobody does it! you could pull out his vocal cords also, but no one does it! when alive, you could use human feces as fuel and for plastering walls, but it's not! you could take human bones to make tools, but they are not! no one wants to touch the dead human body, let alone use it's parts, becuase there is a pollution attached to it. point to note is, the stigma lies in the fact that any part of the human that one will have to physically touch, is considered a big no no. if you pulled the skin off of a human to make leather, then that leather will have to be touched....and no one in their right mind preferrs to do that. same applies to using human feces as fuel or wall plastering (in india they use cow dung for these purposes with no stigma)....no one will do it. no one wants human crap as even fuel. internal organs are different as you will notice...you won't have to be in any contact with them (even though they lie inside you, lol). hope that helped somewhat.

Re: a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Again I must "protest" that we MUST NEVER take out inidivdual TUKS from the Shabad...that will lead to MISREPRESENTATION/MISINTERPRETATION..even serious error. Also always please Provinde the Shaabd Number, AAng number etc. This shabad is on p 870 of SGGS in raag gaund by bhagat kabeer ji. To understand any shabad it is important to see rahau (kendri bhav- central idea) tuk of that shabad. in this shabad rahau tuk says,"apne karam ki gat, mai kia jaanoo. mai kia jaanoo, baba re". ie he baba!, mai kade sochda hi nahi ke mai har roz kindan de karam kari janda haan, mai mande paase laga rahinda haan, mainoo hor khial hi nahee aunda. ie the moto human life is to do good deeds. pride will result in a fall. this body will be of no use after death. tuk under consideration is,"naroo marai, nar kaam na aavai. pashoo marai, das kaaz saavaare". ie when a person dies the body is cremated?buried because it is of no use. but when an animal dies the body is not cremated. all body parts are useful for various uses for human welfare. (eg skin for shoes, flesh for feed etc). we can donate body or body parts(organs) for transplant/research only as per the last will of the person otherwise the human body is always disposed of {cremated eg sikhs, hindu etc or buried in case of moslems, christian etc. or thrown in water}. also that time science was not that advance to transplant body parts/organs. for some body parts/organs can be transplanted that only with consent/last will. the doctors are to see the compatibility also. If we stick to the limit to which Guru ji takes us, and stay superficial (level of right sense of interpretation) and try not to go unnecessarily deep, beyond the right limits, no doubts arise. We have to think casually as to what purpose mostly this body serves. How many are organ donors? What is generalization , and the general truth? Animal dies in any circumstance, and we run to search out its dead body to take out what ever possibly we can use. What is usable in the human body, just a few organs, and for that we have very limited time, and mostly organs of person are taken when still he is not physically dead. For this too, living will is required. Then how many get benefit of organ transplantation, limited number. How many persons a dead animal serves? It is another thing if we get after Guru to falsify what he said. There is no limit or end to it. This coveres different aspects of dead animal v/s dead man. The Guru era was not of organ transplants. It will not be justified if we start question as to why Gurbani does not make mention of rockets, atom bombs, duplicating an animal from its body cell etc. etc. no end. We need to keep in mind limitations of the time period in which Gurbani was written. Now to the way this question is asked. I feel very hurt by its wording. The question is equivalent to starting an argument, and I wonder if that can be builder to the minds of young readers of thsi Forum. Rather the chances are that such questions are prone to fill the young minds with doubts and this can be non productive. We should try to make young one's minds firm and free from doubts. Doubts created in the young minds can be anti-productive. They can likely jump to the conclusion that Gurbani is not truth! OR start doubtring it..as the very TITLE of this Mail suggests ??? Question Mark ?? Rather than direct hitting questions, we may represent them indirectly such as, "What Gurbani says about organ transplantation?" When questioning, we should maintain dignity of the Guru and his Words. Please dont take offense..GURUBANI is ETERNAL and TRUTH. It is we who are INADEQUATE...and cannot fully fathom or understand what gurbani si saying. Jarnail Singh

Re: a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

LionKing · 23 Oct 2005

Are you sure it says ORGANS, cause If im not mistaken it specifically says SKIN, but I could be wrong.. CAuse it's the skin of the animal that's useful not it's actual organs, as it can be used for instruments, shelter, food, clothes etc But Human Skin is pretty much useless after death as it begins to "die" haha

Re: a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

Jasmin · 23 Oct 2005

Well human skin isn't normally used after death. But the nazis did make those lampshades so it can be done, but not for the most part. Also, it can be used for burn victims. The main question here is does Gurbani allow it??????? No one seems to want to answer that. Yet that is the prime question. Prehaps it does not. Even if that seems nonmodern. We are to be guided by Gurbani, or we are lost!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! We are without help, lost in the desert, adrift at sea. When I am more personally familiar with Gurbani, I will have a more definite opinion. Yet I rejoice, because that I suspect it is in my heart already. I am sure I was a Gursikh before, somehow got lost, and now am nearly home. (admin. please note the following is only for dramatic effect, it is not to be taken as a serious suggestion by anyone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) So if donation is so good why don't I prepose the unthinkable and suggest that gursikhs, I really don't want to say this, cut their kes and donate it to kids with cancer. I mean chew on that suggestion. ; 0 VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHEeeeeeeeegggggguuuuuuuuurrrrru

Re: a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Oct 2005

author Jasmin: (admin. please note the following is only for dramatic effect, it is not to be taken as a serious suggestion by anyone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) So if donation is so good why don't I prepose the unthinkable and suggest that gursikhs, I really don't want to say this, cut their kes and donate it to kids with cancer. I mean chew on that suggestion. ; 0 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> What do you mean ?? Are KESH of any use to a Cancer Patient ?? I mean will the kesh SAVE his/her life ?? like a Donated Kidney/Heart/Liver etc will do.... A WIG can be used to cover a cancer patients bald head...that also IF he/she feels really BAD about his / her baldness..apart from thsi BEAUTY (HAUMAII) thingy kesh serve no purpose in saving LIVES... BTW who would "want" ones "cut NAILS"....??? surely you are not advocating that as well ?? chew on THAT ...

Re: a "contradiction" ? or Etrnal TRUTH ??

Jasmin · 24 Oct 2005

O.K - I'm just saying I've heard of it, in fact it's in the news a lot and it makes me feel guilty sometimes. It's for children so obviously a tug at the heart strings- It also creeps me out- and I worry what I would do if I had children in elemently school, or high school. I've read articles in my local paper were sometimes people working for Locks of Love, as they call it, will go to such places to hit on students for donations. Of course it would not save a life,as would a kidney. Or a well placed blood donation, or bone marrow that come along just at the right time. Which I don't see a problem with.