Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra

SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra

Tribune India · 17 Oct 2005

SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra Tribune News Service Jalandhar, October 16 Opposing proposed supply of two crore gallons of more drinking water to residents of Chandigarh from the Bhakra through the recently completed fourth pipeline, the Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar) has threatened that farmers of Punjab would launch a statewide stir in case more water was supplied to Chandigarh by Punjab in accordance of wishes of the Adviser to the Chandigarh Administration. The SAD (Amritsar) also questioned the Chandigarh administration and the Punjab Chief Secretary why more water should be supplied to Chandigarh from Kajauli headworks on Bhakra canal when the water actually belonged to farmers of Punjab and when no agreement between Punjab and Chandigarh existed for supply of water?” The Adviser to the Chandigarh administration has reportedly written to the Punjab Chief Secretary to further ask the BBMB for release of 2 crore gallons of water for Chandigarh through recently completed fourth pipeline. Three such pipelines, each with two crore gallon capacity, were already reportedly drawing water from Kajauli and the Chandigarh administration was said to be envisaging construction of two more pipelines of four crore gallons capacity in the next phase of city beautiful’s development. Reacting to move of the Chandigarh administration to fetch more water from Punjab, Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, chief of the SAD (Amritsar) has written to the Punjab Chief Secretary. Mr Maan has asked the Punjab government to make it public if any agreement for supplying of water to Chandigarh from Punjab existed between Punjab and Chandigarh. “Punjab should learn a lesson from Mr Mulayam Singh Yadav, Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh, who, has refused to supply water to the Sonia Gandhi water works in Delhi, which, was completed a year back and was lying unutilised for want of water. Even PM Dr Manmohan Singh has spoken to Mr Mulayam Singh Yadav regarding this, but, he has refused to budge,” said Mr Mann. Expressing its concern over burgeoning migrant population in Chandigarh, where nearly four lakh slum-dwellers had already settled, Mr Mann alleged that the Chandigarh administration was encouraging slum-dwellers by providing them with unlimited quantity of free water. “As there is no water shortage, more and more migrants are coming daily to Chandigarh and they are being settled as a policy of the BJP, the Congress and the SAD (Badal) to change demography of the city just as the Chinese government was setting Han people in Tibet,” said Mr Mann, who, was accompanied by senior party leader Bhai Ram Singh and others. Mr Maan maintained that giving water to any state by the Punjab government was a legal and constitutional matter, but, it could not be given as per whims and fancies of any leader or government. “The Captain Amarinder Singh government has passed the termination of Water Act, but, kept Section 5 in the act, with the connivance of the leader of opposition Mr Parkash Singh Badal, to legalise what previous leaders have already surrendered arbitrarily to Rajasthan, Haryana, Delhi and Chandigarh. This clause in the Act is totally outside the scope of law and the Constitution and it is unacceptable to people of Punjab,” asserted Mr Mann.

Re: SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra

S Singh · 17 Oct 2005

On the one hand people like Mann claim Chandigarh as the sole capital of Punjab and then they want to deny it water. They also want Punjabi speaking areas of Haryana back but then want to deny the Sikh farmers in the same areas water.

Re: SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra

Singh · 17 Oct 2005

That is because he does not want a drought in Punjab. very soon there will be one.

Re: SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra

AS · 17 Oct 2005

doesn't it seem like history is kind of repeating itslef and the pressure is beginning to build up again in Punjab?

Re: SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra

Tribune India · 17 Oct 2005

UT does not use Bhakra water alone, say officials Tribune News Service Chandigarh, October 17 Chandigarh is not the lone user of the water supplied through the Bhakra Main Line from Kajauli in Ropar district. It is also shared by Mohali and Chandi Mandir. Senior officials of the Chandigarh Administration and the Municipal Corporation of Chandigarh have reacted sharply to the statement of Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, chief of the Akali Dal (Amritsar), who had opposed the allocation of another 20 million gallons per day to Chandigarh. The fourth phase of the Kajauli waterworks is complete and Punjab in consonance with the Bhakra Beas Management Board has agreed to release the water. A senior official said Chandigarh was presently drawing approximately 60 MGD through three pipelines between Kajauli and Chandigarh waterworks in Sector 39. Out of the total supply, the water was being supplied to Mohali and headquarters of Western Command Chandi Mandir. The pipeline between Chandigarh and Panchkula is not complete hence no supply is routed to Panchkula at present. While Chandi Mandir is paying for its share of water, Mohali gets it free and so will Panchkula. Both Punjab and Haryana are not paying the pumping costs which run up to Rs 18 crore annually as water is pumped against gravity. Mohali presently has a share of 7.5 MGD, Panchkula 7.5 MGD and Chandi Mandir 4.5 MGD. A senior official of the corporation said Punjab already had a number of natural water bodies. Instead of questioning the supply to Chandigarh, efforts should be made for better management of water to the deficient areas of Punjab. The good monsoon this year had left all water bodies full to the brim. Chandigarh had no source of regular supply of natural water throughout the year. Another senior official admitted that line losses were huge in slum areas dotted by migrants. Mr Mann and several Akali parties had been opposing the change in demographic profile of the city. About two years ago the National Commission for Minorities had rapped the Administration for providing free housing to migrants.

Re: SAD (A) against more water to UT from Bhakra

S Singh · 18 Oct 2005

>>Author: Singh Date: 10-17-05 09:24 >>That is because he does not want a drought in Punjab. very soon there will be one. How will Mann stop the drought ? 60% of farmland in Punjab has no access to river water for irrigation. I have not heard Mann proposing new canals. Unless new canals are built there will be problems. Unless schemes to recharge the groundwater are implemented the water level will continue to fall resulting in hardship for the farmers who own this 60% of land as they will have to get submerisble bores done at lower levels. There may be problems due to overfarming anyway. In China large areas of farmland have turned into desert due to overfarming. Water will not save this situation happening. People in Punjab are going the Chinese way with overfarming, many farmers are now going in for 2 paddy crops in one paddy season which only depletes the water supply further. In early April this year I saw farmers had planted satta paddy (ready to harvest in 60 days). They would have then planted the same again. Also drought is a long way off. In north Haryana water levels are a lot lower than in Punjab and their tubewells are still working fine albeit at a lower level.