Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Partakh Darshan

Partakh Darshan

nandisher · 14 Oct 2005

I've reposted posts from the thread "Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh" concerning Partakh Darshan because I think starting a new thread would be better than muddying the other thread. So once this thread is posted as a new thread, hopefully we can carry this discussion forward and I can ask further questions on the points you have raised. Much obliged. ________________________ Original post: I am not a spokesperson for AKJ but as far as I know, Partakh Darshan as interpreted by Nanaksar, is not something we believe in. Khalsa believes in Nirgun Bhagti and as such seeks Nirgun, Jyot-vigaasi darshan of Vaheguru. ________________________ Question 1: What, in your view, is Partakh Darshan that Nanaksar believes in? You have mentioned this before, and I thought it was something that Baba Nand Singh or Baba Isher Singh did not espouse. But before I misinterpret you, could you layout what you think it is that Nanaksar allegedly believes in? Response 1: Partakh Darshan as far as I understand means the darshan of Guru Nanak Dev jee in flesh and blood i.e. in human body. Also, the Nanaksar maryada of getting actual bhog of Degh to the human form of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. ________________________ Question 2: In reference to the above, what is Nirgun, Jyot-vigaasi darshan of Vaheguru? Response 2: Nirgun Jyot Vigaasi Darshan of Vaheguru are the darshan of his real form, that is beyond the 5 basic elements and this creation. This is the form of our aatma too. ________________________

Re: Partakh Darshan

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 14 Oct 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Bhai Sahib Jee, partakh Darshan is not doing Darshan of anyone in flesh and blood but just their form as they were when they were last of earth but as a soul. Therefore partekh darshan acually means a reality darshan of someone in a spiritual form, meaning soul. Also, as far as I know partekh darshan can be of anyone in the hereafter. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Partakh Darshan

nandisher · 14 Oct 2005

My understanding of the "Nanaksar Maryada" *** is very different to the interpretation put by Kulbir Singh above. So are you implying that the sole aim of "Nanaksari Singhs" (for the sake of a better term) is to do darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Ji in flesh? In your opinion, is this the sole objective of their bhagti? I have seen you mention before that Nanaksar only does "Sargun Pooja". Can you explain what you mean by this? Can you please explain from which source you have come to the opinion (if this is what you mean) that Baba Nand Singh or Baba Isher Singh sought only darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Ji in flesh and bones? Have you spoken to senior associates of Baba Nand Singh or Baba Isher Singh to come to this conclusion? My understanding of the Nanaksar Maryada is based on doing sangat of Singhs who stayed with Baba Isher Singh. I will explain my understanding of it once I have clarified your view point. Many thanks. PS *** Nanaksar would argue that their Maryada is the true Gurmat Maryada, but for argument's sake, we'll call it Nanaksar Maryada.

Re: Partakh Darshan

puta nehi · 14 Oct 2005

what is Nirgun Bhagti Nirgun, Jyot-vigaasi ???

Re: Partakh Darshan

Govind · 15 Oct 2005

Many singhs get partakh darshan of guru sahibs. I dont think it means flesh and blood, rather it means in the physcial form they were in before they left their bodies. The nirgun darshan i think implies when u get darshan of say waheguru in terms of that its more light/ a feeling u have and there is no physical shape to it. I know a few singhs personaly who regularly get darshan of guru sahibs, sometimes the gurus come to them personally othertimes during amritsanchars or at kirtan smagams. Hope that helps Govind singh

Re: Partakh Darshan

agyani · 17 Oct 2005

nirgun is formless sargun is physical sargun at this time is sahib siri guru granth sahib ji maharaj vaheguru "isher" roop is sargun .... anyone that believes guru sahibs were made of "flesh and bones" is clearly mistaken, read jaap sahib where it clearly states that god has a roop but iti aint made frm the 5 elements.

Re: Partakh Darshan

nandisher · 18 Oct 2005

Can Kulbir Singh answer the questions raised above to further clarify his understanding of Nanaksar Maryada?

Re: Partakh Darshan

Bhopinder Singh · 18 Oct 2005

Nanaksar maryada What is the meaning of bihangam ? Who started it? as a marayada . Lots of women are being exploited by this bihangams dass has first hand info om that. I personally believe every body is free on this earth to believe what they want, But the incidents of sexual relations with women that to illicit and against their personal believe and against social peace as this causes lawlessness .Incidents of childrape and women rape by bhiangams are numerous. What is the stand of KHAlsa panth on this issue.