Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

kirpan and kashera

kirpan and kashera

Gurpreet Singh · 13 Oct 2005

Gurmukho, should your kirpan and kashera ever come in contact with eachother, like if i walk around my house in just a kashera and a tshirt, short my kirpan ever come in contact with my kashera?

Re: kirpan and kashera

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Oct 2005

why not ?? is the kachherra something not touchable ?? dont be a bharmee ?? strictly MY OWN OPINION.

Re: kirpan and kashera

i hate paintballing :-( · 14 Oct 2005

well i walk around with my t-shirt and kacchere but my tshirt is quite long, so my kirpan jus touches my tshirt and not my kacchere :-)

Re: kirpan and kashera

JB · 14 Oct 2005

if it does come in contact, is it going to make you any less of a sikh? does it mean your a bad person? is God going to be angry with you? Come on Gurpreet! think about it yaar! these are all trivial questions...

Re: kirpan and kashera

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Oct 2005

teek ah, but than why do many people say that your dastaar should not touch the floor or your kashera while you tie it?

Re: kirpan and kashera

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Oct 2005

also, so if it is the case that nothing wrong with the kirpan touching the kashera, is their anything wrong with the kirpan being tucked into your pants??

Re: kirpan and kashera

JB · 14 Oct 2005

Singh, im jus a nobody, a random mona, so dont take my word as the truth, but ask yourself this: Is Waheguru bothered about these minor things? how is your kashera touching the floor a bad thing? who is it harming? this is jus my opinion mate.

Re: kirpan and kashera

A Singh · 14 Oct 2005

Dear All, Gur Fateh! It is a recorded fact that in puratan times, the Singhs would not actually wear "CHOLAS" as in the modern sense (for avoidance of doubt, as "some" people here can't understand simple English without getting upright and paranoid, I have nothing against Cholas!). The Singhs of old would in fact be dressed only in their Kacheras and Dastaars - this was owing to the fact that a Kachera was in fact a complete dress in its own right. Consider a Kachera as a sewn up and 'tyar bar tyar' version of say a Dhoti or other Indian dress forms, and this should be automatically visible. There are many accounts available of Singhs being dressed in this manner with only a Kachera, Dastaar and with a blanket to sheild themselves from the cold. As per the Kirpan, my comments below should sum up this thread and also the other thread query concerning Kirpan and kara. The official Kirpan of the Puratan Singhs was nothing like the SGPC, Taksali etc kirpans worn today - these are quite a recent innovation arising from the ban imposed across Punjab by the British from carrying all weapons, which when appealed, Sikhs were granted the right to wear 6'' kirpans. Hence the legacy of miniature kirpans we have now - to the extent that many 'movements' within the Sikh fold even recommend only wearing a 2" kirpan to initiates. The kirpan of the puratan Singhs would have been anything from 1 to 3" long and a whole variety of instruments would qualify (i.e. Tulwar, Tegha, etc etc). So today wearing a peshkab or Kard should not be an issue, and likewise, if it touches the Kachera, what's the big deal? It's like touching your trousers or t-shirt - i.e. just another piece of clothing. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: kirpan and kashera

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Oct 2005

my post is specifically for people who believe that tucking your kirpan into your pants, i just want to know why they say why it is wrong to tuck your kirpan into your pants, especially if there is nothing wrong with your kirpan touching your kashera normally

Re: kirpan and kashera

... · 14 Oct 2005

A Singh aka. voice of RSS, Your contributions are always aimed at undermining some Sikh practice or value. Who are you working for? Look at old paintings of Singhs. They mostly are shown wearing cholas. I'm sure that just like now in some circumstances Singhs did go down to a sheet and kacherra, but that's hardly the normal dress. Look at all the old paintings: are they all of Singhs walking around in only a kacherra? A kirpan has to be with a Singh at all times. To suggest that only a 3ft kirpan is the real kakaar is senseless. How do you bathe with that? I have seen small sri sahibs of Guru Gobind Singh and Baba Deep Singh. I am against the small 2" ones, but around 1ft has always been what Singhs have worn.

Re: kirpan and kashera

Iron Man · 14 Oct 2005

Lets not diss a singh here.. he does have a point.. and he didnt say anything against cholas... even bhai randhir singh in his autobiography only went around with kashera and dastar and a loee to shield from cold...

Re: kirpan and kashera

Ravinder Singh · 15 Oct 2005

A Singh >There are many accounts available of Singhs being dressed in this manner with only a Kachera, Dastaar and with a blanket to sheild themselves from the cold.< Thats fine.. in panjab a few centuries ago the weather was probably even warmer than it is now and the winter was probably not very cold at all. Nowadays in the UK, I'd like to see how many of us would walk around in december/january, wearing only a kachera and blanket.

Re: kirpan and kashera

JB · 15 Oct 2005

". . . ": mate, i think your a bit para... regarding your example talking bout paintings, i could then turn around and say there are paintings that show bibian without keski, therefore bibian dont need to wear keski (this is my view point ne way, i believe its a personal choice)

Re: kirpan and kashera

Gurpreet Singh · 15 Oct 2005

so is it wrong to tuck your kirpan into your pant or not?

Re: kirpan and kashera

Punjabi · 15 Oct 2005

>>>>>>>"Nowadays in the UK, I'd like to see how many of us would walk around in december/january, wearing only a kachera and blanket.">>>>>>>>> why not, Gandhi did it when he came to England. If a goat's milk drinking Guju like him can do it, then surely we Punjabi Shers can do it too. brrrrrrrraaaaaaa Chakdaaay!

Re: kirpan and kashera

CHAKA DI FAATA · 15 Oct 2005

well .. Lets not diss a singh here.. he does have a point.. and he didnt say anything against cholas... even bhai randhir singh in his autobiography only went around with kashera and dastar and a loee to shield from cold... That dont make sense? Maybe you have not seen pictures of bhai sahib..?