Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Ever since the 1960s when master Tara Singh Ji and Sant Fateh Singh ji began their "war" for the control of SGPC/Akali Dal...they began to MISUSE the Jathedars of the Akal Takhat for theri Personal use... Ever since then for any "MISCONDUCT"..the Jathedars will call you up, ..and the PUNISHMENT will always be..wash the dishes in the Guru ka Langgar, sweep the Gurdwara Premises, Clean the Shoes of the sangat...and READ this Gurbani ( example Japji sahib...for so many days..or do DEGH for 51 rupess or pay for an Akhand paath..etc. My question is since when is READING GURBANI..a seva or punishment ?? Isnt a Sikh supposed to read/vichaar...and follow GURBANI just for being a SIKH ?? Guru Ji says seva is... [gurbani] pauVI ] syv kIqI sMqoKIeéØI ijn@I sco scu iDAwieAw ] En@I mMdY pYru n riKE kir suik®qu Drmu kmwieAw ] En@I dunIAw qoVy bMDnw AMnu pwxI QoVw KwieAw ] qUM bKsIsI Aglw inq dyvih cVih svwieAw ] vifAweI vfw pwieAw ]7] {pMnw 467}[/gurbani] Bhai Gurdass Ji says.. [gurbani] guris`KW guris`K syvw lwieAw...swD sMgq kr syvw suK Pl pwieAw[/gurbani]...and goes on to say this seva is tapparr jharreh, bring water, wash bhandeh etc etc.....and ALL this is doen NOT as PUNISHMENT but genuinely as SEVA.. There is NOT a single Tuk in the entire Guru Granth ji sahib that says..READING GURBANI is a PUNISHMENT....but then why do our Jathedars IMPOSE this "read Gurbani" as a form of PUNISHMENT and ONLY on those who appear before them as WRONG DOERS ?? Millions of SIKHS all around the World Give money for DEGH...and Karrah parshaad... since when does this become a PUNISHMENT ?? The HINDU BIPPARS were the FIRST to PUSH down the GENUINE HARD WORKING CLASSES.... the farmer who feeds everyone is LOW CASTE..the WEAVER who weaves clothes to Cover up everyones nakedness and shame is LOW CASTE..the Water carrier who serves humanity by bringin in water over long distances..is LOW CASTE... the Scavenger who serves the community by cleaning and sweeping is LOW CASTE...BUT the GOOD FOR NOTHING LAZY PARASITE BRAHMIN who FEEDS off the hardwork and toil of EVERYONE ELSE..is HIGH CASTE ??? Now sadly we have our own Home Grown BIPPARS....in disguise as jathedars and sants and babas and gyanis...who FEED off the hardworking SIKHS.....and who DISH out SEVA done with PYYAAR all over the Sikh World as PUNISHMENT...and say reading Gurbani is also TANKHAH/PUNISHMENT ?? How the Pavittar Gurbani and Guru nanak ji'sahibs hukms and adesh are being trampled underfoot....

Re: is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

Oye Moorka · 09 Oct 2005

wat do they give as punishment in amrit sanchars...... they give u extra bani and seva. y do they give u extra bani u say? hmmmm maybe because bani and seva are the 2 things that wash away ur sins. Your perspective is that its punishment, mine is that its a higher body forcing u to cleanse ur innerself. but maybe ur different...maybe takin a shower washes ur sins. stand down from ur hankar and stop writing giani in ur name. If someone gives u respect then u arent responsible for it but if u try to give urself vudiaee then wat kind of impression do u think your makin to the ppl that look up to u. aaps ko jo janai neecha..so-ooo guneaaih sab thay oocha.

Re: is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

LionKing · 10 Oct 2005

OM - I agree 100% with the first part of your posts - Instead of seeing it as a Punishment, we see it as you know GUru ji is giving us an extra oppertunity - It's the Seva and Bani that is going to cleanse you..... SO rather see it as a higher body forcing you to cleanse yourself liek above said.. stand down from ur hankar and stop writing giani in ur name. If someone gives u respect then u arent responsible for it but if u try to give urself vudiaee then wat kind of impression do u think your makin to the ppl that look up to u. Bhaji/bhenj, if BHaji has worked for the tittle Giani - allow him to have it.. Whether he ahs hankar or not is none of our Business. I don't alaywas agree with him, neither does anyone else- same way as no1 ALWAYS agrees with me.... So just allow him to have it.. jsut because you don't agree with him doesn't make him less of a Giani - he says it himself too, that he's not always right.. and ends it with bhull chukk maaf... Let's not attack the person himself. You don't liek his post refute it -no need to discourage and be angry at any other Gurmukh Pyaarey... I hope you guys (Gurmukhs) accpet this beanti of this manmukh... aaps ko jo janai neecha..so-ooo guneaaih sab thay oocha. Vaheguru =)

Re: is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Oct 2005

then why do some people always condemn badal, tohhrra, jagiro, buta , Sarnba, bahnno mortee, chandok....and all those others as "bad" because as far as this procedure is concerend their SINS have been WASHED away..THEY are PURE as SNOW ?? Badal has appeared before the panj and done what seva they told him to do....all the others have DONE this Many times so they should be PURER than Me and You ?? OI Moorakha...do you consider Badal Tohhrra etc to be SNOW WHITE ?? and PURE as their sins have been washed away ?? I consider the Punj to be supreme...i do take a shower to wash my body but not my soul....BUT i still consider badal etc to be panth Dusht !!! " this comment from you...stand down from ur hankar and stop writing giani in ur name. If someone gives u respect then u arent responsible for it but if u try to give urself vudiaee then wat kind of impression do u think your makin to the ppl that look up to u. ...just has no VALIDITY...so I am IGNORING it as an outburst...aaps jo ko janneh neechah will NEVER give such advise to others. Thats all

Re: is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

A Singh · 10 Oct 2005

I have to agree to an extent with "Oye Moorka", Surely the purpose of the "bani" for so many days as "punishment" as you call you is to inspire the person with those shabds and the "seva" to make them humble. This is the house of Akaal, the most merciful and compassionate, naturally one would expect this type of "punishment" rather than the 'jail' sentence worldly punishment, which only produces animals when they are finally released. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

LionKing · 11 Oct 2005

then why do some people always condemn badal, tohhrra, jagiro, buta , Sarnba, bahnno mortee, chandok....and all those others as "bad" because as far as this procedure is concerend their SINS have been WASHED away..THEY are PURE as SNOW ?? Badal has appeared before the panj and done what seva they told him to do....all the others have DONE this Many times so they should be PURER than Me and You ?? OI Moorakha...do you consider Badal Tohhrra etc to be SNOW WHITE ?? and PURE as their sins have been washed away ?? I consider the Punj to be supreme...i do take a shower to wash my body but not my soul....BUT i still consider badal etc to be panth Dusht !!! __________________________________________________________ No, Due to several reasons - Badal & Co might have gone Pesh - but has he regretted "andro" - from the inside? Badal & Co might have gone Pesh - but how much has their Jeevan Change, have they stopped doing Havans and all other manmat things they do to get votes? Badal & Co might have gone Pesh - But how much Bani and SEVA have they done after that (I mean kar seva, not "$$$$££££€€€€" Seva- but REAL KAR SEVA - Washign Bhandey, cleaning Sangats JoRey, Doing an extra amoutn of Paath My theory is that, by doing what Panj told you to do, and changing your Jeevan is what takes away your "Apraad", not anything else.. As "A Singh Said" - Even the Punishment Guru Ji gives, Peeta Jee, gives us is Love, Pyaar, and more Pyaar. - He's not going to beat you (Or? May'be... Considering the Considering Akali Phoola SIngh's punishment for Raja Ranjit Singh.. But again that's not the Guru......that's the Jathedar.. but nto the Guru...) For some reason this thread reminds me of this Shabad - http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=2874&Format=2 [gurbani]rwgu sUhI AstpdIAw mhlw 4 Gru 2 <> siqgur pRswid ] koeI Awix imlwvY myrw pRIqmu ipAwrw hau iqsu pih Awpu vycweI ]1] drsnu hir dyKx kY qweI ] ik®pw krih qw siqguru mylih hir hir nwmu iDAweI ]1] rhwau ] jy suKu dyih q quJih ArwDI duiK BI quJY iDAweI ]2] jy BuK dyih q ieq hI rwjw duK ivic sUK mnweI ]3] qnu mnu kwit kwit sBu ArpI ivic AgnI Awpu jlweI ]4] pKw PyrI pwxI Fovw jo dyvih so KweI ]5] nwnku grIbu Fih pieAw duAwrY hir myil lYhu vifAweI ]6] AKI kwiF DrI crxw qil sB DrqI iPir mq pweI ]7] jy pwis bhwlih qw quJih ArwDI jy mwir kFih BI iDAweI ]8] jy loku slwhy qw qyrI aupmw jy inMdY q Coif n jweI ]9] jy quDu vil rhY qw koeI ikhu AwKau quDu ivsirAY mir jweI ]10] vwir vwir jweI gur aUpir pY pYrI sMq mnweI ]11] nwnku ivcwrw BieAw idvwnw hir qau drsn kY qweI ]12] JKVu JwgI mIhu vrsY BI guru dyKx jweI ]13] smuMdu swgru hovY bhu Kwrw gurisKu lµiG gur pih jweI ]14] ijau pRwxI jl ibnu hY mrqw iqau isKu gur ibnu mir jweI ]15] ijau DrqI soB kry jlu brsY iqau isKu gur imil ibgsweI ]16] syvk kw hoie syvku vrqw kir kir ibnau bulweI ]17] nwnk kI bynµqI hir pih gur imil gur suKu pweI ]18] qU Awpy guru cylw hY Awpy gur ivcu dy quJih iDAweI ]19] jo quDu syvih so qUhY hovih quDu syvk pYj rKweI ]20] BMfwr Bry BgqI hir qyry ijsu BwvY iqsu dyvweI ]21] ijsu qUM dyih soeI jnu pwey hor inhPl sB cqurweI ]22] ismir ismir ismir guru Apunw soieAw mnu jwgweI ]23] ieku dwnu mMgY nwnku vycwrw hir dwsin dwsu krweI ]24] jy guru iJVky q mITw lwgY jy bKsy q gur vifAweI ]25] gurmuiK bolih so Qwie pwey mnmuiK ikCu Qwie n pweI ]26] pwlw kkru vrP vrsY gurisKu gur dyKx jweI ]27] sBu idnsu rYix dyKau guru Apunw ivic AKI gur pYr DrweI ]28] Anyk aupwv krI gur kwrix gur BwvY so Qwie pweI ]29] rYix idnsu gur crx ArwDI dieAw krhu myry sweI ]30] nwnk kw jIau ipMfu gurU hY gur imil iqRpiq AGweI ]31] nwnk kw pRBu pUir rihE hY jq kq qq gosweI ]32]1][/gurbani] Perhaps this is the thinking one should go with when being Pesh - rather than "mai Rs 500 dey ke Paap la danga".. How far will you get by thinking the latter? Gyani Sahib - I see what you're trying to say, but I disagree, because Pita Jee loves us so much, that perhaps, even his Punishment, is Love =) Dhan Guru Dhan Guru Pyaarey Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa

Re: is READIN G GURBANI..seva ? or PUNISHMENT

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Oct 2005

Gyani Sahib - I see what you're trying to say, but I disagree, because Pita Jee loves us so much, that perhaps, even his Punishment, is Love =) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> I see. You are definitley on the dot about Pita Jees LOVE for US....cant argue with you on that. What i am trying to say is that....the "system" has been tampered with by the likes of Master tara Singh sant fateh Singh and now Badal and Co have destroyed it utterly. Perhaps the Sikh panth got to pull them up...they are making a mockery of the entire Punj System...and getting away with it scott free.. Thank you all for the valuable comments....esp A Singh Ji and Lionking Jio. Love to all....... Jarnail Singh.