Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

clarification · 07 Oct 2005

Jarnail Singh Arshi said... "For your INFO i am NOT "anti sant baba jarnail singh ji"..He is a GREAT Shaheed and Sant Sipahi...but your other pet babas told lies about his shahedeee and reduced it to their own level."(Post on Ranjit Singh's done it again) __________________________________________________________ OK, Sant ji did an ardass in front of the Akhal Takht and said if the GOI army/tanks entered the Durbar Sahib complex he would give shaheedi. It is well known he said this.. but if Guru Ji in the roop of the Panj Pyare commanded Sant ji to leave the Durbar Sahib complex, could he have said no...yes he may have thought.. but iv done an ardass but the Panj had commanded... thats it i've heard Radhoswamis says why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji leave the Quila in his Singhs clothes(disguise) he shoulld have laid down his life, but even Guru Ji had to accept the command of the Panj, Sant ji was no exception. The Panj that commanded Sant ji to leave would not have been like me but true Gursikhs... for they were there defending the sanctity of the Darbar Sahib. So Jarnail Singh are you saying that there is no chance the Panj told Sant ji to leave.. and if he did, then in your opinion he's wrong.. whose opinon counts more YOURS or the Panj Pyare. Jarnail Singh is there no possibility this could have happened, and if you still don't agree then was Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrong to take the roop of one of his Singhs? Some may say that we can't compare the Panj that asked Guru JI and Singhs of today.. & your right, what Karam somone must have had to be a Khalsa at the time of Guru Ji... but if that reasoning is taken then no one today would ever beable to recive the gift of Amrit because no-one would be considered worthy of the Panj Pyare. PS the 'Ranjit Singh does it again' has been closed so i hope admin allows this post to be posted because the statement maybe seen offensive.... ("but your other RET BABAS told lies about his shahedeee and reduced it to their own level")...yes everyone is entitled to have their opnions & this instance in no expection.... but if a statement is made... it should be clarified.

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

UKSingh · 07 Oct 2005

Doesn't matter what my personnal views on Sant ji being shaheed of not are but if as it keeps being said the Panj Pyarie told him to go and leave Darbar Sahib, then why can't the Panj Pyaraie in Taksal today do Ardas and give order for Sant Ji to come back :)))))))))))))

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

daas · 07 Oct 2005

pyario let waheguru take care of everything. the bachans of great singhs are never reduced. the stature of sant jarnail singh was to obey gurmat, waheguru jis hukam and the panj.

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

yup · 07 Oct 2005

UK Singh its so nice to see that you've completely gone off the topic

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

Lionking · 07 Oct 2005

Just a side note - I was reading A.R Darshis book - The Gallant Defender, where the Author is completly convinced that Baba ji is Shaheed, however before publishign it he decided to talk to Baba Joginder Singh about Baba Ji's Shaheedi. He says that the response he got is similar to the one Baba Thakur Singh Ji Gave- "Baba ji are in Chardikala!" THe Author being completly convinced Baba ji is Shaheed says that PERHAPS they say this due to the fact that it highlights the fact that Sikhs believe their martyrs to be immortal... I havn't quoted him in this post, but if it's essential it can be done .. Just though I'd ad some interesting info which I wasn't aware of before..

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

who · 07 Oct 2005

So who were these punj that gave the hukam? Are there any witnesses to this?

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

hmm · 07 Oct 2005

wat is chardikala??? isnt a state of sachkhand?

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

DDT · 07 Oct 2005

those punj prolly got shaheedi in 84. if Bab Thakur singh ji bhinderawale says sant ji is not shaheed then we should all belive him not some new guy who comes to taksal.

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

il vostro padre · 07 Oct 2005

haha ddt your a joker, thakur singh also sed that sant jee will be back b4 his death, what about that claim? and why wud sant jee hide like a criminal?

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

M Singh · 07 Oct 2005

Baba Thakur Singh Jee was a true Sant Mahapursh, In many peoples eyes he was a Brahmgiani and he spoke on a different level that maybe us manmukh mooraks don't understand. Baba Jee could have meant anything - they were always very quiet and spoke very little, always very humble and head down. Daas was able to do much sangat with them in the UK on thier tours and one could feel the power that was with them all the time of Naam. Everything Baba Jee said was very powerful and on a different level - they could have meant anything when they said Sant Jee is in Chardi Kalaa - isn't a Shaheed ALWAYS in Chardee Kalaa - afterall, this life is the fake - the real thing is after death - a Shaheed is always in Chardee Kalaa!!! They have become Sachkhand Nivasee's - more Chardee Kalaa than anything on earth!!! When they said Sant Jee will once again come and lead the Sikhs, how do we know Sant Jee has not taken birth again as someone else who is preparing or is going to prepare the Sikhs once again?? It is all in Akaal Purakhs Hukam and we fools do not know what has happened, is happening or going to happen! One who has BrahmGiaan speaks at a different level - they have Kamaee and speak as they wish!!! Sant Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale - Shaheed or not IS and always WILL be in Chardee Kalaa!!! Any mistakes I have made or offended anyone - please forgive this ManMukh!!! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsaa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Guru gobind Singh Ji.....Sarbans Daani....Sacha Patshah....is INCOMPARABLE. Guur Ji had Waheguru Ji's HUKM to carry out and He had certain principles to "teach" us....hence the KAUTAKS with Panj and also bowing to a Grave with His Teer etc. The PUNJ are PUNJ and their HUKM is Sir Mathhe te for EVERY SIKH. PERIOD. Guru Gobind Singh Ji's departure from Chamkaur dee Gharree are WELL DOCUMENTED and provable even when there was no body to record our history....this is acceptred History and no one doubts it. No one asks..Who were the PUNJ that ordered Guru ji ?? what really happeend ?/ etc GURU JI took along TWO of the PUNJ with Them out of Chamkaur Bhai Daya Singh was alive and took the Zafarnama to Aurnga much later on... I think it is very very wrong to compare CHAMKAUR and GURU JI to 1984 and Jarnail Singh Khalsa. The 1984 incident....a whole lot of "maybes"... thats why such questions arise..Who were the PUNJ..why no body knows them ?/ what happened to them.. MANY TRAITORS came out of 1984 ALIVE...yet no one has said anything about such an order ( although i wouldnt bet anything on a traitors word) PERSONS are not important So I would rather we LEAVE the PUNJ out of this. They have nothing to do with it. Dragging in the PUNJ just degrades their Stature.( thats when you get comments like ...so ok..why dont the DDT PUNJ now recall Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa back from wherever they are ??..etc...IF the PUNJ were not dragged in to such a debate that wouldnt happen !!. Anyway the PUNJ that ordered Guru Ji to leave Chamkaur..DIDNT have to ORDER Guru ji to COME BACK !!! see the difference ?? Bhul Chuk maaf karnee jee. Jarnail Singh Jarnail Singh.

Re: Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???

Gupt · 08 Oct 2005

Well said Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi"