Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

undergroundsingh · 02 Oct 2005

i have learnt that bhai fauja singh was once outsted from akhand keertaini jatha,before his shaheedi. the jatha at that time said to bhai sahib that we r keertaini singhs and we do not want to involve in any kind of voilence activities we just want to do keertan and naam japana.at that time bhai sahib was in bir jas roop. i have seen a video in uk ,of a chardi kala, singh of akj and close aide of bhai sahib quoting these words. we do all respect the shaheedi of bhai sahib.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

singh · 02 Oct 2005

This question has a lot of angles I want to cover. The first being that I've never heard that Bhai Sahib was "ousted" from akj. Afterall, Bhai Fauja Singh was attending the AKJ Amritsar Vaisakhi smagam at the time of the incident. The Singhs that went with him were all attending the smagam. So it seems unlikely that he was "ousted" At the same time, it is true that some Singhs in the Jatha were uncomfortable with Bhai Sahib's embracing both miri and piri. A lot of Singhs thought that he should just do bhagti and leave his persuit of justice for Sikhs. But that doesn't mean being "outsed" from the Jatha Finally, what is the Akhand Kirtani Jatha? Is it a name? Does anyone have a monopoly on this "brand"? Of course not. The Akhand Kirtani Jatha is a group of Gursikhs who do kirtan together, keep strict rehit, and believe in the supremacy of naam. This rehit was recorded and practiced by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. If a group calls itself "AKJ" but doesn't do the above, they are AKJ only in name. At the same time, if there are Singhs that aren't called AKJ but do the above, then they most certainly are AKJ; even moreso than the kind I mentioned before. So if Bhai Fauja Singh was, even hypothetically, removed from the "Akhand Kirtani Jatha", I would say it doesn't matter. He was still a Jatha Singh living those principles and that lifestyle. The AKJ is more of an ideology than a label. If someone has the label but doesn't practice the ideology, then they are a fake. And at the same time if someone is practicing that ideology, it doesn't matter what anyone says, they are still a Jatha Singh.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

Singh · 02 Oct 2005

No it is ridiculous to suggest that Bhai Fauja Singh was removed from AKJ. In the 80s/90s AKJ was essentially treated as a militant organisation. The only people uncomfortable with the Bir Ras of Bhai Fauja Singh was Panchain and they are not associated with AKJ any more.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

Singh · 02 Oct 2005

This is not true. Bhai Sahib has always been in the mainstream, so much most of the youth refered to him as Jathedar Ji. Especially after the incident at Bhai Salo ji and the Khalsa Farm camps. I have done sangat of many Singhs who were close to Bhai Sahib, and also Bibi Amarjit Kaur. This never happened. However those of us who do support the jatha do have to accept there is a group who was within the jatha who want the Jatha to be just keertan, and not miri and piri as Gurmat expects. Now this group is openly called the Panchain. This is why they were rejected by the mainstream sangat in India and worldwide, when they tried to take over or divide the jatha. But this all happened after Bhai Sahib shaheedi. Infact the conversations happened in 1996-2000, which is almost 20 years after Bhai Fauja singh jis shaheedi.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

A Singh · 03 Oct 2005

I have heard the same - that Bhai Sahib was ousted from the Jatha on account of his radical nature and also that he later had certain views not in concurrence with the mainstream Jatha (re: Raagmala etc). The validity of these claims however I don't know, so the individual who started this thread, please could you present some factual info for these assertions. Others, simply saying this is nonsense is perhaps not enough - there's never smoke without fire, let's get to the bottom of this before drawing any conclusions however. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

suki singh · 03 Oct 2005

The truth is that the weak willed urban Sikhs of Amritsar did not like the shock to the system bought by Bhai Sahib. Bhai Sahib was a shining example of a Saint-Soldier. By setting up Khalsa Farm and aiming to bring the lost youth to the Sikhi path, Bhai Sahib was seen as radicalising the youth-this is something that the Urban Sikhs thought was unneccessary as they just wanted to concentrate on making money and being pals with the local admin.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

.1.1.1 · 03 Oct 2005

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Finally, what is the Akhand Kirtani Jatha? Is it a name? Does anyone have a monopoly on this "brand"? Of course not. The Akhand Kirtani Jatha is a group of Gursikhs who do kirtan together, keep strict rehit, and believe in the supremacy of naam. This rehit was recorded and practiced by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. If a group calls itself "AKJ" but doesn't do the above, they are AKJ only in name. At the same time, if there are Singhs that aren't called AKJ but do the above, then they most certainly are AKJ; even moreso than the kind I mentioned before. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Well Said!!! EVERYONE DRILL THIS ONE IN!

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

singh · 03 Oct 2005

A Singh, as usual you just love to create doubt and questions where none exist. You said, "I have heard the same - that Bhai Sahib was ousted from the Jatha on account of his radical nature and also that he later had certain views not in concurrence with the mainstream Jatha (re: Raagmala etc)." Like I asked before, if he was kicked out of the Jatha, why on earth would he be attending the Akhand Kirtani Jatha smagam at Vaisakhi? Why would the Singhs at the smagam follow him in the procession (he was the leader of that march)? Why would he have been in the LANGAR of the smagam??? Does any of that even make logical sense to you, if you say he was out of the Jatha? Bhai Fauja Singh is thankfully not some obscure historical figure that we can't verify anything about. Otherwise God knows what falsehoods you'd attach to him. His Singhnee, Bibi Amarjit Kaur is still alive. Ask her what you want. Bhai Sahib did not believe in Ragmala and yes, he believed in Keski as a kakaar and naam driR too. Bhai Sahib Fauja Singh was a heera of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

A Singh · 03 Oct 2005

Singh, As usual, paranoid folk like you feel I have some sinister agenda, if that was so, I would be the one starting this thread - which I didn't. I see you have conveniently ignored my comment: "The validity of these claims however I don't know, so the individual who started this thread, please could you present some factual info for these assertions" whcih clearly show that these are NOT my thoughts/views and call for the individual suggesting these notions to provide something more tangible. I have no business as if Bhai Sahib was or was not part of the AKJ - all I know is that he was most certainly part of the Khalsa Panth. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

Singh · 03 Oct 2005

A singh, where did raagmala come from? This is how people start baseless rumours, like all the silly ones spread about Bhai Randhir Singh. It is not a case, there is no smoke without fire, but more a case of People are intentionally creating smoke so they pretend there was a fire!

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

Singh · 04 Oct 2005

Bibi amarjit Kaur spoke agianst raagmala in the raagmala debate at the World Sikh Sammellan in the 1990`s.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

khalistani · 04 Oct 2005

many peple in the akj do not read raag maala does that mean they r not akj? naw anyone who does unbroken keertan, non stop, is a part f the akhand kirtan jatha UNBROKEN kirtan singing of one shabd AND THAS IT bhula chuka maf

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

khalistani · 04 Oct 2005

btwwww i think i shud clarify im not sayin bhai fauja singh read raag maala im jus sayin SOME akj did and do read it jus like some taksalis keep bibek and some dont bhula chuka maf

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

amarjeet_singh · 05 Oct 2005

some akj read raagmala?????????????????????????????? next you'll be saying some taksalis believe keski as the fifth kakaar

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

undergroundsingh · 05 Oct 2005

there is mentioned in some messages,akj is a organisation who does akhand keertan,then why they just follow bhai randhir singh ji's message. propogate just keertan,not to read raag mala. why akj show bhai fauja singh as from their group only.there were 12 other singhs who equally laid their lives for the panth.why just to propogate bhai fauja singh out of the 13.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

MS · 05 Oct 2005

A Singh, I think people jumped the gun on you due to your strong links with the nangs as a result quite naturally would be deeply suspicious of your motives. I have met many Jatha Singhs who were with Bhai Sahib and I'm 100% sure they will testify that the claim is rubbish

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

A Singh · 05 Oct 2005

Dear Veer/Bhain-Jee “MS” You wrote:- <> Thanks for the message. As stated above, my personal view is simple, whether Bhai Sahib was part of the “Jatha” or not is irrelevant, he was nonetheless a part of the Panth. The Jatha issue is more an academic discussion for assessing wider topics of AKJ, BKI, Sikh militancy etc during the dark period of the 1980s Punjab and the impact this has had politically and socially on the Sikh Diaspora subsequently. As per your earlier point concerning my “strong links with the nangs” please could you expand – is this something you base on knowing me personally (if so please clarify how, as I seriously doubt it from such a conclusion) or something you’ve picked up from ‘selective’ discussions on this forum? You are probably not the only person to have labelled me as such, perhaps you are the first to have done so with comparative politeness, however it’s interesting as the very people you consider me to have “strong links” with, consider me to have “issues” with them and to “disrespect their maryada”. However, please explain this as I would like to understand what exactly leads people to believe I have ‘strong links’ with any group of people other the sangat of Sikhs in general, which include the whole spectrum of non-amritdharis, keshdharis, amritdharis, nihangs, AKJ, Taksalis, staunch SGPC types, Sant-followers, , mainly Nanaksar and Baba Jaswant Singh chelas, Nirmalas and other “sanatan-sikhi” types and even more questionable groups in some people’s view such as Namdharis? Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

oh · 05 Oct 2005

Taksalis believe that Keski must always be kept on the body (even in shower etc)...but beleive that the 5th Kakkar is Kes...just to clarify to those people that think Taksalis walk around in their homes seperated form Keski, its NOT true.

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

MS · 05 Oct 2005

>>Thanks for the message. As stated above, my personal view is simple, whether Bhai Sahib was part of the “Jatha” or not is irrelevant, he was nonetheless a part of the Panth. The Jatha issue is more an academic discussion for assessing wider topics of AKJ, BKI, Sikh militancy etc during the dark period of the 1980s Punjab and the impact this has had politically and socially on the Sikh Diaspora subsequently. Oka thanks for that, but not really relevant to what I was saying, my only point was to explain why people would be hostile to you due to your nang links. >> please could you expand – is this something you base on knowing me personally (if so please clarify how, as I seriously doubt it from such a conclusion) or something you’ve picked up from ‘selective’ discussions on this forum? No idea who you are other than from the forums and your promoting some of your work. That punjab archive site is really good stuff. I'm quite fasinated by the whole research and things you guys do and find out really useful stuff. The only sad thing is the nangs use that research to say for example say some research shows the majority of sikhs in the past eat meat. So they would use this historical 'evidence' to justify a view that eating meat is according to sikhi even though guroo sahib is clearly saying no. >You are probably not the only person to have labelled me as such, perhaps you are the first to have done so with comparative politeness Didn't mean to be labeling you as anything, just pointing out what i belive based on my observations. The only reason I have not been rude is because I belive your not one of the anti sikh dirty nangs, you just associate with them and probably out of the best of intentions. I once had a nang friend who was pretty good guy but when I found out he was one of the nangs I feel im morarly bound not to associate with somone who keeps company of those who activly are anti sikh. >I would like to understand what exactly leads people to believe I have ‘strong links’ with any group of people other the sangat of Sikhs in general, I think we have reached the circle, as I have already said your association with nangs and how some of your research might be used by the dirty nangs to put their anti sikh view fwd has lead to this. Also you probably do keep sangat of Sikhs in general, but you forget that the nangs are not Sikh but anti-sikh or do you dispute this?

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

A Singh · 05 Oct 2005

Dear Veer MS, Thanks again for your prompt response. I think there are some misunderstandings here: <> Please could you elaborate here, as I do not run any ‘punjab archive site’, perhaps you have me confused with Amandeep Singh Madra, who is currently being grilled for his supposedly “nang-links” by some folk hiding behind pseudo-names on another thread. <> As stated I do not run the site you make reference (however please provide a link to it). On the subject of diet, I’m sorry to disappoint you, however my views on this subject are clear on other threads – I myself maybe a vegetarian, however the Sikh Rehit Maryada (SRM) is conclusive on this topic and that is what I will promote, as mentioned several times elsewhere, whilst the SRM permits the eating of non-Halal meat, it doesn’t however require that Sikhs HAVE TO eat meat. Simple choice and simple directive, let’s not make a mountain of this one little mole. To continue arguing on this rather minor point is typical of fools who live in a fantasy blinkered world oblivious of far bigger issues – which they can only cry about. <> Thanks again for your honesty. The term “anti-Sikh” can by use of argument be VERY EASILY applied to all groups including the Nihang, AKJ, Taksal and SGPC and so on…I really do not wish to get into this discussion here, as there are plenty of threads discussing the individual items elsewhere. How well someone is established in Sikhi and their Jeevan is in the hands of Maharaj (as per the “Akhan Jor…” pauri of Jap Ji Sahib), it is not my place to be casting such judgement, yes it is down to me to ensure that my mind remains focused and that I exercise the utmost bibek upon myself in this respect – the only groups we are advised to remain aloof from are the Punj Mel (as per the advice of the Punj Pyare) and in addition to this Guru Sahib only mentions for us to “run away” from “shakats” – lovers or worshippers of power, this can apply to many people. Gurbani <> I believe my point above should spell this out. Anti-Sikh movements are clearly those within the Punj Mel which I treat with the necessary caution. How anyone’s research is used by another is not a reason for not undertaking that research – that would be simple cowardice. If one’s faith is strong, then nothing should be able to shake that – let’s end on this note and keep this in our minds for individual and collective progress. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

MS · 05 Oct 2005

> Amandeep Singh Madra, Oh dear, guess I got the wrong guy all together. I'll shut up >. Simple choice and simple directive, let’s not make a mountain of this one little mole. sure but please note I wasnt talking about the SRM at all but simply what guroo sahib says, SRM/Akal takhat is temporal authority, guroo sahib is ultimate authority. >To continue arguing on this rather minor point is typical of fools who live in a fantasy blinkered world oblivious of far bigger issues – which they can only cry about. agreed, but i wasnt arguing at all but using this as an example to illustrate my point about the mentality of the dirty rotten nangs >VERY EASILY applied to all groups including the Nihang, AKJ, Taksal and SGPC and so on… arguable, the clear difference is that nangs in particular are fundamentally anti-sikh in their belives in the leagues of radaswami/rss whereas non perfect jathabandis at least attempt to be panthis. dirty rotten nangs are trying to destroy panth. >How well someone is established in Sikhi and their Jeevan is in the hands of Maharaj agreed, and again not being disputed and not related to dirty rotten nangs who have no sikhi in that they being anti-sikh. > How anyone’s research is used by another is not a reason for not undertaking that research once again and as i clearly said earlier i was pretty pleased with some of the research done. >If one’s faith is strong, then nothing should be able to shake that – let’s end on this note and keep this in our minds for individual and collective progress. again agreed, shame dirty rotten nangs prey on those with such weak faith and little knowledge of sikhi

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

UKSingh · 06 Oct 2005

amarjeet singh You made a comment about akj and rag maala i found it 'interesting' I wi llstart another topic on this Gurfateh ji

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

A Singh · 06 Oct 2005

<> Ok, glad to have cleared that up. <> This is my point, you have the choice to make under the SRM, which should be respected. I myself am vegetarian and hold certain lifestyle choices to promote this, however, I have no issue with an Amritdhari Sikh eating meat, it is fine as per the SRM – call it a day. The same goes for Raagmala, the SRM is clear, read it or not, up to you – however neither side can respect this, they choose to labour on and on about this one thing and cause a split in the panth through their actions. Similarly all the hum drum about Keski being the kakkar, the SRM does not forbid you from wearing a Keski (I always do personally and a blue one too, yet my views on the “neela bana” and all the hum drum created about it by certain zealots are clear elsewhere on this forum). In short the SRM is a simple to the point document, which serves to keep Panthik Ekta, yet the very topics that aid this are the ones that everyone wishes to argue to death about and destroy this potential to be united (re: Raagmala, Meat, Mool Mantra, number of banis, length of banis etc). The SRM sets the “minimum” standards, if a Sikh is following them, let them be – why not spend your efforts focusing on getting the herds of increasing patits across the diaspora to adopt Sikhi saroop and lifestyle as per the SRM rather than fighting amongst existing Amritdharis! Then we wonder why there is no ekta! <> MS Veer, I indicated above I do not want to start nitpicking, however to illustrate the point very quickly, just about any group can be thought of as anti-sikh on account of the following items: 1. Akal Thakt followers – they abide by the SRM, BUT that means they accept meat eating, reduced/shorted banis and don’t consider Keski a Kakkar (well, folks you’ve shot yourself in the foot already, since effectively if you can’t agree with the Akal Thakt yet claim to be Sikh and ‘support the Akal Thakt’ …just go back to school and learn to understand what you are saying!). Often confused as being the same thing as the SGPC and as a result have their name further muddied with the likes of Badal and Tohra. 2. DDT – great institute, great heritage, but has many questionable items in their maryada (re: Pati-Parmeasur, reading Jap Ji Sahib during the Akhand Paath and keep jyot and other paraphernalia etc), causing some to believe they have been ‘infiltrated’ by the RSS. Key role in 1980s politics is considered by some to have resulted in the splits that are now evident and contributed to the further weakening of the Panth. 3. AKJ – great movement, inspiring many to Gurmat Jeevan, however have hit the height of beadbi on account of their repeated anti-raagmala stance (consider by some to be tantamount to ripping out the tongue of the Guru), Keski is a Kakkar etc (challenging the very foundation of the SRM), general partisan attitudes (Sarabloh / Bibek) have them perceived as “schismatic” by many including scholars. Again, their political role has left many considering their various off shoots to be contributing to the current spate of disunity. 4. Nihangs – historic sampradha with much in the way of both shaheeds and mahapurakhs. Upholders in the main of authentic Sikh battle arts and the majestic bani of Guru Gobind Singh. Extremely disciplined in their rehit – however largely maligned by their use of Jatka (despite this being acceptable under the SRM) and Bhang. Again the events of the 1980s have left them extremely marginalised, however their main detractors still seek to adopt many of their customs (Neela Bana, Dumalas, Sarablohi Bibek, Keski etc) in the belief that these are the ‘original’ and ‘tat’ practices inaugurated by Guru Sahib during the vaisakhi of 1699. These are just some highlights, one could spend days on each institution and spell out blatant items that go against Sikhi or Panthik Ekta, but what would that achieve. So in short, until we get over our personal fears and ego – leave those to Maharaj to take care of, we can kiss the “dreams” of Ekta and Khalsa Raj goodbye. <> MS Veer, the above should spell this out… <> In my experience in the UK, the large body of Nihang recruits come from the following backgrounds: -Very strict AKJ (and some Taksal) backgrounds – in fact the leading members of the UK Nihang Jatha all have previous links with the AKJ, either through sangat (i.e. being part of the Kirtan Jatha and studying Gatka) or being even more involved as personal drivers for the late Bhai Rama Singh. Moreover most of these people are in their late 20s or early 30s – hardly at an age to be “manipulated” -Jat families, usually with ties to the AKJ (which are usually quite sour afterwards) and here one finds many non-amritdhari or non-keshdhari youth joining the ranks and seeking to be Nihangs. But this is a section that has increased in the last 12 – 18 months, are usually junior students and interested in the martial arts. None of the ‘clashes’ that one witnesses on the net or physically have tended to involve this group – in the most part it has always been the section above. -Girls, the vast majority of whom are in fact adorned with Keskis and again usually in it for the martial arts aspect. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: was bhai fauja singh outsted from akj?

singh · 08 Oct 2005

******************** Author: Singh Date: 10-02-05 13:18 This is not true. Bhai Sahib has always been in the mainstream, so much most of the youth refered to him as Jathedar Ji. Especially after the incident at Bhai Salo ji and the Khalsa Farm camps. I have done sangat of many Singhs who were close to Bhai Sahib, and also Bibi Amarjit Kaur. This never happened. However those of us who do support the jatha do have to accept there is a group who was within the jatha who want the Jatha to be just keertan, and not miri and piri as Gurmat expects. Now this group is openly called the Panchain. This is why they were rejected by the mainstream sangat in India and worldwide, when they tried to take over or divide the jatha. But this all happened after Bhai Sahib shaheedi. Infact the conversations happened in 1996-2000, which is almost 20 years after Bhai Fauja singh jis shaheedi. ******************** It seems this poster has some anti panchain agenda there are documents available on akjinternational.org as to how panchain was formed try justifying ur claim in light of those