What is Sikhi?!
Gurpreet Kaur · 23 Sep 2005
Fateh
After reading posts on the thread about Naam Drirh by learned Sikhs such as A Singh and Kulbir Singh, I am confused. I have no idea what are sources are for the wearing of the 5K's and keeping Kesh, I wouldnt be able to explain it. If this is in the Rehatnaamey, then can we really rely on them, even though people say some of them were made up by Brahmins? How do we anything is true anymore? Where do you take your sources for keeping Kesh and wearing the 5K's, and which book or reference/source is fully accepted 100% by the whole panth, regardless of which jathebandhi you belong to?
Please answer, thanks.
Fateh Jee
Re: What is Sikhi?!
Gurpreet Kaur · 24 Sep 2005
Thanks, I guess you are right, Im probably doubting too much as usual. Can I ask however, if the Bhatt Vahis mention the 5 Kakkars in detail? Where would I be able to find them?
The reason I was looking for some sources is because there are people who tell me the Khalsa was created as a fourth order and isnt the only sect within Sikhism (others being Udhasis, Nirmale etc), and some people tell me thats all rubbish. Each side has their own sources and references, doesnt seem to be a set rule or foundation everyone agrees on.
I have spent a lot of time with Muslims, and they have the tradition of always knowing their sources down to the smallest detail with regards to their hadeeth. They have passed down their knowledge of the sayings of the Prophet orally also, and they know exactly who said what and what that person was like in great details. So, I wondered if we had a similar system and if not, maybe someone should research into this and develop something to avoid the youth being confused so easily by people preaching their own Sikhi every 5 minutes.
Re: What is Sikhi?!
Gurpreet Kaur · 24 Sep 2005
Wow, thanks for that information, I had no idea of some of the things you mentioned.
>>I personally have had a very Western approach to the study of Sikhi. I was always wanting to know "sources" and actually ended up doing the research to find them. I've made notes and written articles. I found the sources and they helped me find a "rehit" that I'm comfortable with (yes, it may shock you that my research led to Akhand Kirtani Jatha). But overall, these documents and sources don't really help much beyond clearing doubts. No one becomes a brahm gyani after reading them.<<
This is exactly what I want to do. I cant just accept things for the sake of it and I need something to back up my rehit too. My parents may even understand because right now they dont know why I feel strongly about certain issues as they know I have no actual proof, or no research. I guess its out of laziness, but I just didnt know where to start believe it or not. With the help of your replies Il read these two texts if I can find them and work from there.
Just something else that came to mind, Singh Jee mentioned both texts list Keski as a Kakaar, is there other texts around that time which mention Kes as Kakaar? If not, how long after did someone mention Kes and not Kesgee is a Kakaar? Would be interesting to know.
Sanatanists also claim that the Khalsa was predominantly full of men, men joined the ranks because of their physical strength etc as this was important for battle. I thought about this and came to the conclusion that it could be true as women have feminine qualities which seem to be seen as wrong and weak by a lot of Jathey, especially AKJ, why is this?
If these sources mention otherwise then it totally contradicts this.
Lastly, in some Sanatan sites there are paintings which depict Nihangs with their wives, who are dressed in jewellery and beautiful clothes, if the Nihangs are amritdhari then its likely their wives are too yet they wear feminine type dress, what are your views on this?
Thanks again for the replies, you have no idea how much it has made me think again about a lot of things.
Re: What is Sikhi?!
Gurpreet Kaur · 24 Sep 2005
Sorry, forgot to add something. You do realise that the sanatan Sikhs although believe Keski is the Kakaar by listing the sources you mentioned on their sites, also believe that the Khalsa was an order of 4 orders within the Panth predominantly for MALES, as women could not always fight due to having periods etc. T
They also ask how its possible for women to wear a Kachera when they are having their periods without wearing any other underwear. Im sorry for mentioning this in detail but these issues need to be discussed to be sorted out. Fateh.
Re: What is Sikhi?!
Kulbir Singh · 26 Sep 2005
First of all, I must commend "...." and Gurpreet Kaur for carrying out absolutely fantastic vichaar. I enjoyed reading this thread.
As for Lionking, the shayer that you have quoted is from late 1800s and is not contained in any of the old texts. Even in many printed Dasam Granths it is not there.
Kulbir Singh
Re: What is Sikhi?!
Gurpreet Kaur · 26 Sep 2005
GurFateh
Kulbir Singh Jee, I have enjoyed it far more and learned so much, especially from '...' Jee's posts. One point he/she made which was so beautiful was to my question on the feminine qualities of a Sikh woman, he/she says:
>>The Khalsa doesn't kill feminine qualities. What qualities are you referring to? Is wearing jewellery and fashionable clothing a feminine quality? Or was the sweetness and gentle nature that Guru Jee asked Mata Jeeto Jee to add to the amrit a part of those feminine qualities? <<
That is a crucial point, I NEVER looked at it this way and it really has made me think. Who decides what is feminine anyway? mostly society, and we are not slaves of society as Sikhs. The other points were excellent also.
I am now looking at all these points and finding a lot of answers, obviously I need to do more research on everything myself also.
People often make the excuse of women not joining the khalsa as being fine because on the day there were no women chosen to be part of the Punj, I'd like to see what ... Jee, Kulbir Singh Jee, and Singh Jee's thoughts are on this. A lot of people ask me this and I usually say that women were not used being at the forefront of public meetings/gatherings/religious events and this conditioning was so deep that perhaps women didnt see it fit to stand up to offer their heads on the day.
Re: What is Sikhi?!
Gurpreet Kaur · 27 Sep 2005
Yeah, thanks for your advice Veer Jee, your posts have really made a big difference, Im glad I posted here.
Thanks to everyone who contributed, I have lots to do now, hopefully this thread will help others through the advice given to me. GurFateh.