Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

is Keshki a kakar

is Keshki a kakar

R Singh · 22 Sep 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh! is keshki a kakar? guru gobind singh jis hukamnama......... 35)Dastaar bina nahi rehnaa - Wear a turban at all times. i think that this states that keshki is a kakar because its says that you shoudnt stay without your dastaar! bhul chuk maafi waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh! [%sig%]

Re: is Keshki a kakar

REAL R Singh · 22 Sep 2005

yo dont use my ID..... i never posted this... someone posted under my name

Re: is Keshki a kakar

kabadi · 22 Sep 2005

guru ji says 2 wear 2 dastars.. so is the outer dastar a kakkar to? we should alwyas have our gatra, is that an kakkar?

Re: is Keshki a kakar

nothin · 22 Sep 2005

it says you shouldn't stay without your *DASTAAR* not your *KESKI *

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Maybe · 22 Sep 2005

sure. happy now?

Re: is Keshki a kakar

rsingh · 22 Sep 2005

look at Gurmat section http://www.tapoban.org/keski.htm

Re: is Keshki a kakar

BirRaas Singh · 23 Sep 2005

here we go again.........

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 23 Sep 2005

http://www.tapoban.org/keski.htm

Re: is Keshki a kakar

A Singh · 23 Sep 2005

R Singh Please present something a little more tangible than your interpretation of a single line – see the following link and read in full the comments at the end: http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=279&t=279 For the information of the Sangat: 1. "Kes Hamesh Paanch Jo Raakhe. Tis Ko Darso Oothh Sabhaakhe." (page 232, 'Panth Prakaash', - 'Gyani Gyan Singh',) 2. "Kachh Kripaan Kes Trai Mudra, Gur Bhagataan Raamdaas Bhaye". And also 3. "Gur Updes Sikhan Prat Bhaakhan, Mudra Trai Kachh, Kes, Kripaanang". (Sri Sarabloh Parkash – Guru Gobind Singh). 4. “Raakhoh Kachh, Kes, Kripaan. Singh Naam ko eho nishaan. Kachh, Kripaan, Kes te mundree. Jo pahre so Gur Singh sundree". (page 233, 'Panth Prakaash', 'Gyani Gyan Singh') 5. "Kes, Kachh, Karad Guru Kee Teen Mudra Eh Paas te naa door Karoh, sadaa ang sang dhar". (Stanza 9, page 5060, 'Gur Prataap Sooraj Granth', by Kavi Bhai Santokh Singh). Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Singh · 23 Sep 2005

it is impossible to live according to this and Bhai nand lal jis rehitnamas, without keeping a keski as a kaakar.

Re: is Keshki a kakar

agyani · 23 Sep 2005

lol...kesh is the kakaar not keshi.

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Singh · 23 Sep 2005

i'm taksali so i dont belive keski being a kakkar but i still try and wear a keski at all times because i think u cant be tyaar bar tyaar without it.

Re: is Keshki a kakar

akjgreat · 23 Sep 2005

if kesh is kakkar, then we dnt have to keep it on before we are baptised right? this make sense to you? dont to me. cutting kesh is a kurehit, then what s the point of making it a kakkar? as we have to keep it wether we are amritdharee or not. calling kesh a kakkar is very BELITTLING, it DOWNGRADES its IMPORTANCE KESH is FUNDAMENTAL in SIKHI.........Guru Nanak Dev Ji told us to keep KESH way before dasm patsah started KHALSA. 5 kakkars are given to us to WEAR kesh cannot be WORN, if you didnt notice ITS PART OF OUR BODY!!!! all you can do is quote from youre CORRUPTED SOURCES............KESH AS KAKKAR MAKES NO SENSE NO SENSE NONSENSE

Re: is Keshki a kakar

..... · 23 Sep 2005

whether one believes Keski to be a kakkar or not... one things for sure.. wearing a dataar for both men & women is essential IMHO keski is NOT a kakkar

Re: is Keshki a kakar

vichar · 23 Sep 2005

yes of course it is, you really think KESH is a kakkar? funniest argument i heard for kesh being a kakkar - " keski cant be a kakkar because turban begins with 'T'" HAHAHAHAHAH...im serious, this is the reasoning followers of 'kesh the kakkar' have.

Re: is Keshki a kakar

vichar · 23 Sep 2005

recent history, those who prefer sikh women without dastars, aswell as "hindu-sikhs" have decided kesh is the 5th kakkar by saying this, it (1) excuses women from dastar, and (2) makes it easier for sikh women and hindu women to mix. thus strengthening ties between hindu's and sikhs, have you not noticed the growing number of people calling themselves "hindu-sikh"? i find it scary, remember what the indian government wants.........to get rid of sikhism, and replace it with hinduism...........much corruption of sikhi has been activly encouraged. also be people like justifying their actions, many 'sikhs' cut their hair.....when you ask them why do you do that, they reply - "im not amritdharee why shud i wear a kakkar" what theyre missing is kesh is MORE FUNDAMENTAL then a KAKKAR. its more practical to several groups of people(, some i have described above) to say KESH is KAKKAR, so what has happened is that over the years these ppl have spread there manmat causing confusion on the panth now what you hear in an attempt to cover up the all the points against kesh as kakkar, is ppl saying kesh is kakkaer but i still wear keski this just brings further corruption into the khalsa panth, its only when people start seeking the truth, that we will get panthic unity rather then IM TAKSAL, my SANT BABBA says kesh is kakkar. SEARCH THE TRUTH [%sig%]

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Respected A Singh Ji, You quote many texts that mention "Kes", along with Kirpan and Kach, But where is the "Kakkaar" part? Where is the "Kara" and "Kangha"? And furthermore, how do you substantiate the huge assumption that the "Treh Mudra" (3 seals) have anything to do with the "Panj Kakkars" (5 K's) - Unless of course, you subscribe to the camp that the Panj Kakkars never originally existed and were made up later. The fact is, "Kesh" and "Kakkar" or the 5 Ks, including Kesh, do not come together, until the late 1800s. Please refer to Guru Kian Sakhian for a text which explictly quotes "Keski" as one of the 5 Kakkars.

Re: is Keshki a kakar

A Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Singh Veer, Guru ki Sakhia, I am very familiar with and is related to the Bhat Vahies, this is a another subject, however for the purpose of Sikh history and reference, I will refer to Sikh texts and references. The treh mudra are exactly the same as the 5 kakkars - the "phrase" 5 Kakkars did come later and is the work of poets, the Treh Mudra has been stipulated in all of the texts I quoted and including the works of Guru Gobind Singh (Sri Sarabloh Parkash) which I personally place above any "Sakhia" or "BHAT vahees".

Re: is Keshki a kakar

... · 23 Sep 2005

Interesting stuff A Singh. No Punj Kakaar but Treh Mudra. Sarbloh Granth is written largely by a Patna Sahib Granthi. This is pretty much acknowledged by all scholars. The mention of Treh-Mudra comes very regulary in time span of Giani Gian Singh, Kavi Santokh Singh, but not in the older rehitnamas. I think it is a latter creation. the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism saysj of Sarbloh Granth: "The authorship is however questioned by researchers and Scholars of Sikhism on several counts. First, the work is marked by extraordinary effusiveness and discursiveness of style over against the compactness characteristic of Guru Gobind Singh's composition as collected in the Dasam Granth. Qualitatively too, the poety of Sarbloh Granth does not match that of Guru Gobind Singh's Chandi Charitras and aar Durga Kee dealing with the same topic of wars between the gods and the demons. Profusion of metaphor and superb imagery of the latter compositions are missing here. Second, the author of Sarbloh Granth often uses his name, "Das Gobind" or the phrase "Das Gobind Fatah satigur ki" which is generally contrary to the style of Guru Gobind Singh. Third, the Sarbloh Granth contains, quite out of context, an account of the Sikh religion, which also includes a reference to the devolution of guruship on Guru Granth and Guru Panth (stanzas 3159-66). This would be out of place in a work of Guru Gobind Singh's own composition. Lastly, there is also a reference in it to Rup Dip Bhasha Pingal (stanza 2938/8) a work on prosody written by one Jaya Krishna in 1719, i.e. eleven years after the death of the Guru. According to Pandit Tara Singh Narotam, a nineteenth century Sikh scholar and researcher, Sarbloh Granth is the work of Bhai Sukha Singh, a granthi or priest at Takht Harimandar Sahib at Patna Sahib, who however claimed that he acquired its manuscript from an Udasi recluse living in a forest near Jagannath (Orissa)." The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism ed. Harbans Singh Punjabi University Patiala, Vol 4, pg. 57

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Singhni MiriPiri · 23 Sep 2005

WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh Yes, Keski is a kakaar not kesh. The 5 kakaars is meant to be something you wear, you can't wear hair! Read this, ----------------------------------------------------------------- http://www.destinationsaachkhand.com/Keski.html ------------------------------------------------------------------ WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: is Keshki a kakar

A Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Dear "..." Please re-read my quotes, you'll find many of the ones mentioning "treh mudra" are pre-Gyani Gyan Singh. If Sarabloh Granth is not the works of Guru Gobind Singh, then please could all the pro-Keski supporters STOP quoting it (Khalsa mero roop hai etc) as part of their supposed evidence. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Singh · 23 Sep 2005

3 K's does NOT = 5 K's KESH KIRPAN KACH does NOT = KESH KIRPAN KACH KANGHA KARA If you believe Treh Mudre is what Guru Ji set up, fine. But you cannot attempt to say that Treh Mudre is the same as 5 K's because it isn't. Either Guru Ji made the Kara and Kangha compulsory, or he didn't. The Treh Mudre may be a old or even Guru-made concept but it cannot be passed off as 5 K's. We cannot say Kesh is the 5th Kakkar if we think the idea of the Kakkar in the first place was made up by poets. We can only say it is one of the Treh Mudre.

Re: is Keshki a kakar

Gurpreet Kaur · 23 Sep 2005

A Singh, you make some really interesting points, I have to agree with your post, could someone however translate the following line "Kes Hamesh Paanch Jo Raakhe. Tis Ko Darso Oothh Sabhaakhe." Thanks.

Re: is Keshki a kakar

A Singh · 27 Sep 2005

Bibi Gurpreet Kaur Sidhu, "Kes Hamesh Paanch Jo Raakhe. Tis Ko Darso Oothh Sabhaakhe." This is taken from the Naveen Panth Prakash and refers to the "Punj Kesh" -Hair on the head, face, chest and under the armpits (clearly the "punj kesh" are referring to a man in particular). Singh Sahib, You wrote: <> I am surprised at your statement, on one hand you aknowledge that the treh-mudra may be a "Guru-given concept", yet have trouble accepting it and on the other hand, you agree the term "Kakkar" could have been constructed by Poets and to prove your point on Keski, indirectly are placing the words of "Poets" above Guru Sahib??? Here is the story to clarify everyone’s doubts and misunderstandings about the Treh Mudra and Punj Kakkars. 1. Before going into details, let’s get one thing clear – the ‘treh mudra’ are not the works of Brahmins, Snatanists, ‘Sikhs only in name’ and other such groups that many of today’s ‘chardikala rehitvaan Singhs’ like to think about anything that (albeit on face value) doesn’t tally with their own views. 2. Just because ‘Treh’ (3) doesn’t tally with ‘Punj’ (5), doesn’t here mean that the two are referring to different things. Pyara Singh Padam in his book “rehitnamae” does a similar analysis of the references to the Punj Banis – very few of the rehitnamas mentioned actually mention the Punj Banis in full, however as Pyara Singh Padam adequately demonstrated, the nuances of poetry by implication DO refer to all five of the daily Banis. 3. So is the case for the Treh Mudra – one needs to understand that the concept of ‘treh mudra’ is not necessarily a uniquely Sikh one, there are many religious groups, sects, cults within South Asia which have their own ‘treh mudra’ – i.e. 3 distinguishing marks. For the Khalsa, these were visibly Kesh, Kirpan (given it was in those days worn outside the clothes at all times & invariably 3ft long) and Kachera (which in those days was a complete dress in its own right – Singhs would not really wear Cholas, if they did, then these would not cover the Kachera nor would Singhs wear a set of Pants on top of their Kachera as one may do today). The point being that these were the VISIBLE (from a distant) features of the Khalsa – the Kangha would be covered within the Kesh and Dastaar (although the Dastaar covers the Kesh, the topknot of the Singhs would also be visible and distinguish them from the other communities who wore dastaars, some who were also Keshdhari, hence why we have more than just Kesh as one of the Mudras). The Kara, although visible from up close, is not something that would be a noticeable as the Kirpan or Kachera or Kesh (whether in the form of a top knot or long and flowing). In addition, by implication reference to Kangha exists through mention of Kesh (as the Khalsa is not to have matted hair and are civilised, hence keep their Kesh unshorn and well groomed) and to the Kara through the mention of the Kirpan. Hence ALL 5 items are part and parcel of the Treh Mudra. 4. The “term” that came into vogue was ‘Punj Kakkar’ once poets realised that the 5 items within the Treh Mudra all begun with the letter “Kakka” – this again is not unique to Sikhi, within Tantra there are the Punj Makkars (the 5 M’s) which are named as such for similar reasons. As this term came into vogue, Sikhs took to it and the use of ‘treh mudra’ fell away – later, as we see now 2 things occurred: (i) people ignorant of their history and linguistic terms of their wider Indian region, began to argue foolishly that the Punj Kakkars were different from the Treh Mudra and a latter invention, when in fact, all that happened was a change in terminology and (ii) certain schismatic groups began to argue for a change in the items that make up the kakkars to suit their political bias. One good example is the view because “Guru Kiya Sakhia” indicates Guru Sahib himself tying a “keski” on Banda Singh Bahadur, surely this indicates that Keski, beginning with “kakka” is also a Kakkar. This shows the ignorance of the person with respect to the custom of “Dastaar Bandan”. Moreover, using this line of argument, tomorrow someone could argue that Rattan Singh Bhangoo’s Panth Parkash indicates Guru Sahib tied a Kalgi to the dastaar of Bhai Sant Singh, so presumably the Kalgi, which also starts with the letter “Kakka” is a Kakkar. The Sikh Rehit Maryada is clear on this topic of what constitutes the Kakkars and is based on the readings found in ALL Sikh texts. It does not bar anyone from wearing a Keski if they so desire. Even the puritanical Buddha Dal rehit maryada indicates Kesh as a Kakkars, yet in a latter point concerning clothing, mentions the need for keeping a Kesgi to hand alongside items such as Kamarkasas (again, tomorrow someone could argue this to be a Kakkar as well!), Neela Chola etc. Trust this clears and settles this matter – the rest I leave to you and the forum for your own pursual, it is not for me to convince anyone of my view/argument, the references speak for themselves and all are capable of interpreting these as they see fit. Gur Fateh! A Singh