Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Patriarchy in Sikhism

Patriarchy in Sikhism

* · 21 Sep 2005

Does Sikhism reflect or challenge a male patriarchal system? Is patriarchy accepted or rejected?

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

Maybe · 21 Sep 2005

accepted.....don't let the feminists tell you otherwise

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

honest · 21 Sep 2005

Lets be honest. In Sikh families, although there is an equal partnership between the Singh and Singhni, I think it's accepted in general that the Singh is the "leader" of the family and is responsible for making the big decisions. This is not to say that he does this without his wife. She has a major say, but I think it's accepted that last word goes to the Singh. I'm not sure there's anything wrong with that either. Western Feminism is not Gurmat. Western Feminism is maha-manmat and in my opinion leads to man-hate and even lesbianism.

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

Sikhi is perfect equality. The Sikhism practised by particular people may reflect their particular prejudices. [%sig%]

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

manjit · 22 Sep 2005

Wgjkk wgjkf Does sikhi say that equality is important ? Does sikhi say it is required ? when? between who? why? Does sikhi say the above, but that in some circumstances it's ok to say the man is high than the woman. Did guru ji say this? I am a manmuk but I always thought that guru ji treated men and women equally; I always thought that guru ji said with out exception that both were completely equal. Please forgive me if I have said anything wrong or offended anyone. Wgjkk wgjkf

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

Ek Kaur · 22 Sep 2005

Interesting question... would be nice to know what stance Gurbani takes on this. In the way that feminsim is seen as a separate system to Sikhi, is patriarchy not a seperate system to the religion...? Patriarchy is unfair in that women bear there fathers surname and then their husbands after marriage. Women are expected to leave their homes and join their husbands families after marriage even though their own parents may not have a son to support them. No intentional bias but ovbiously a natural one :o)

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

sikh · 22 Sep 2005

ek kaur guru jis wife left her home to be wit them, so if it is ok for them why have other women got a problem?

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

... · 22 Sep 2005

On the other hand Guru Ram Das left his home to be with his wife's (Bibi Bhani jee's) family.

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

--- · 22 Sep 2005

On the other hand Guru Ram Das left his home to be with his wife's (Bibi Bhani jee's) family. ---- Bhai Jetha ji (future Guru Ram Das ji) did not have any home as he was orphaned. When he heard about the Satguru, he came from Lahore to Goindwal Sahib, which was a thriving commerical city on the main route from Lahore to Delhi. After doing seva for many years along with the other Sikhs, Guru Amar Das ji wed Bibi Bhani ji to Guru Ram Das ji. They stayed for some time time in the city. Guru Amar Das ji then commanded Guru Ram Das ji to go to the site of Amritsar, where Guru Sahib stayed in a kacha (temporary) house before a real one could be built. But why do you say Bhai Jetha ji came to live in the family of Guru Amar Das ji? Guru Amar Das ji had his own sons. [%sig%]

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

* · 22 Sep 2005

Anyone opposing patriarchal norms is a feminist? Feminism is not the opposite of patriarchy. What is patriarchy? It is a system of social relations that privileges males over females, and is supported by societal institutions including language, science, laws, government, family structure, etc etc etc. Feminists aren’t set out to claim all power and privilege for themselves the way that male patriarchy perpetuates male privilege and domination. In three or four other threads, people have been quick to label this and that “feminism”. Feminism isn’t what a lot of us make it out to be. Without it in the West, no female here would be able to vote, have a voice in government, or tread whichever career path tickled her fancy. No female would be able to attain post-secondary education, or choose when to marry or have much say at all in her own life. Whereas a lot of us see it as a bunch of lesbians complaining about nothing, feminism is giving women here the rights and privileges that Guru Sahib gave his daughters centuries ago.

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

... · 22 Sep 2005

What do Sikh "feminists" hope to accomplish? What are their goals? How are these goals separate from the goals of the Sikh community in general? Or are they at all separate?

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

ssingh · 22 Sep 2005

* your thread will be fly over this forum

Re: Patriarchy in Sikhism

Ek Kaur · 23 Sep 2005

What is Sikhi's stance on Patriarchy and what is Sikhi's stance on womens rights to equality? Is there anything in Gurbani that categorically supports or rejects partiarchy?