Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

TribuneIndia · 21 Sep 2005

Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women Women groups enter into verbal duel Varinder Walia and Pawan Kumar Amritsar, September 21 Tension prevailed in front of Akal Takht today when two groups of Sikh women entered in a verbal duel in front of Akal Takht on the issue of alleged gender discrimination. Members of the coordination committee of Punjab, Haryana and Delhi Sikh women assembled here in large numbers demanding grant of permission to Sikh women to participate in the “Amrit Sanchar”, performing of “kirtan” and “seva” of cleaning sanctum sanctorum of Harmander Sahib. However, they were confronted by another jatha of women who were opposing any move of the SGPC to give such “Seva” to women. The Sikh women, carrying placards, quoting holy hymns from Guru Granth Sahib, presented a memorandum to the Akal Takht secretariat here. On this, a group of Sikh women, led by Bibi Kulwant Kaur and Bibi Baldev Kaur of the Shiromani Akali Dal opposed their stand. Women workers belonging to the SAD said they won’t allow women to change the age-old Sikh “maryada” which did not allow women to participate in these ceremonies. They wanted proof from the Sikh history to substantiate their stand. Meanwhile, a jatha of a section of the Sant Samaj, including Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi , Baba Harnam Singh Dhumma, chief of the Damdami Taksal, submitted a memorandum to the Akal Takht Secretariat, opposing any move to allow women to participate in “Amrit Sanchar” , performing “kirtan”, etc in the sanctum sanctorum at Darbar Sahib. The SGPC has also taken serious notice of rejecting the Nanakshahi calendar by the Sikh conclave, held at Chowk Mehta yesterday. The SGPC has said that nobody would be allowed to reject the Nanakshahi calendar or Sikh “maryada” at any cost. The SGPC spokesman said the Sikh “maryada” was approved by representatives of various Sikh bodies about 60 years ago after marathon discussions. The spokesman said as per this “maryada”, the baptised Sikh women, too, were allowed to participate in the “Amrit Sanchar” or performing “kirtan”. The SGPC alleged that yesterday’s Sikh conclave was part of a deep-rooted conspiracy hatched to harm the Sikh panth.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Maybe · 21 Sep 2005

Thank God there is still some sanity in the Panth....i guess not everyone jumps on the feminist bandwagon.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

* · 21 Sep 2005

If by giving bibiyaan equal rights, one becomes a "feminist", then your Gurus were all feminists and I'd be glad to be one too.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

confused · 21 Sep 2005

Mr. Maybe you should realize what is good and whats not cuz feminism in this case si good

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Maybe · 21 Sep 2005

>>If by giving bibiyaan equal rights, one becomes a "feminist", then your Gurus were all feminists and I'd be glad to be one too.<< Spoken like a true feminist...shabaaash!

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

ekta · 21 Sep 2005

word to astrix.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Zorawar Singh · 22 Sep 2005

I have to say Sant samaj has not got a clue about sikhi. Dhumma in just a drama queen. All the Taksali youth that follow him despite him grassing taksali youth to the police, need a wake up call. This reminds me of their conference on 15th September 2004, against the nankshahi calender. In there they quoted Mahakavi Sontokh Singh, Bhai kahn Singh nabha, Macauliffe, & Sadhu Gobind Singh, as they presented arguments for anti-nankshahi stand. Then they said on stage, anyone who does not read raagmala is not a Sikh. Funny really, because the people they used to back their anti-nanakshahi stand, all of them state that bhog should be on Mundhavni. So according to their own interpretation they are not Sikhs. So why are they using them. Sikhs went is suits them, and non-sikhs when it does not. Blind worship, un-educated, sexist, morally corrupt. This is the sant samaj of today, no different to the Akali dal is opposes.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Liongking · 22 Sep 2005

yep "*" I'm a feministic with you. And According to encarta your Guru too, was a feminist - http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_/feminist.html ------- 1. belief in women's rights: belief in the need to secure rights and opportunities for women equal to those of men, or a commitment to securing these 2. movement for women's rights: the movement committed to securing and defending rights and opportunities for women that are equal to those of men -------- First Mehl: From woman, man is born; within woman, man is conceived; to woman he is engaged and married. Woman becomes his friend; through woman, the future generations come. When his woman dies, he seeks another woman; to woman he is bound. So why call her bad? From her, kings are born. From woman, woman is born; without woman, there would be no one at all. O Nanak, only the True Lord is without a woman. That mouth which praises the Lord continually is blessed and beautiful. O Nanak, those faces shall be radiant in the Court of the True Lord. ||2|| http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=1748&Format=2 Guru ji is CLEARLY Defening Womens rights and giving oppertunities by Guru Amardas ji giving women hukam to do Parchar manjeeia! So you better watch the tone you're usign when talking to/about Feministis!

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Joke · 22 Sep 2005

I guess we will be fighting this issue for the next 10 years! What a waste of a Sikh's time! What about the baydbi of Guru Maharaj's saroop or the meat issue.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Bhopinder Singh · 22 Sep 2005

After lying to panth for twenty yeare regerding the shaeedi of Sant Jarnail singh.THE BIGGEST GADARI OF THE TWENTIETH CENTURY. Now opposing the Nanakshai calendar And now opposing guru ji

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

shocked · 22 Sep 2005

women are the biggest enemies of women. Apnee Lat`je apay hi KohaRee Mardee`ya nay Is it any wonder that it is usually women in Punjab who are the first and most adamant to demand an abortion when they find out it is going to be a girl. How the heck are guys like us going to fight for them when they themselves are working against their rights and freedoms? We need some strong Sikh bibis following rehet strictly and who are willing to stand up for themselves even when the world is against them. Who the heck cares what these derawalas of the Dinosore era think. When Guru Sahib is with bibis and supports their cause, it doest matter what any other 'Mahpursh' or 'Mahatma' thinks of them.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

098 · 22 Sep 2005

Whay can't women do Seva ? Sikisim preaches equal rights.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Zorawar Singh · 22 Sep 2005

Can even one of these Taksali youth or baba followers who support this rediculous stand opposing bibian show one gurbani line which says bibian are unpure, inequal, or should not be allowed to do seva? I can produce many that state bibian are special, equal and every humans soul is female. All the youth on this forum must accept that they are only opposing this because the baba or group are against it, just like they did with Sant jarnail singh shaheedi. There is no basis in Gurbani for it. The more taksal pushes this, the more we youth lose respect for this jatha.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

ekta · 22 Sep 2005

produce bani to bak your anti-bibian Point of View.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

jhamka · 22 Sep 2005

vaheguru the ppl who create these issues no ones looking at them(jagir and her dogs), u live in a fools world if u r going to follow the sgpc any one who got any respect for Sant ji will know he opposed women in the panj, simply i wud go by what sant ji rather than a bunch off nutters in the sgpc the Taksaal will not lose any thing its got the basksh of Guru ji time will tell where the other jathas stand, plus what about the hukam namma for Khalistan no one seems to follow that apart from the Taksaal and the karkkoo singhs and singhnias akaal

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Maybe · 22 Sep 2005

>>The more taksal pushes this, the more we youth lose respect for this jatha.<< We "youth" aren't losing respect for Taksal whatsoever. We remain on our side of the fence and you remain on your's.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

confused · 22 Sep 2005

taksal has sanity in its youth its older generation has lost it all...if they claim they have the best knowledge of reading and understanding bani they wouldnt debate this....and Maybe your worse then my dad at least he knows and understands women have equal right in thsi position even he doesnt give it to them any other time

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Baba Ji Wake Up Call Wale · 22 Sep 2005

how is the taksal following the hukamnama for Khalistan? Dhumma is out there getting singhs arrested by the punjab police. He got many taksali youth arrested by saying they are connected with Bhai Jagtar Singh Ji Hawara because they opposeed him (dhumma) being the jathedhar. Taksal has not done much for Khalistan after Sant Jarnail Singh Ji became Shaheed in 84, in fact they have hurt the movement if anything by lying to the panth for the last 21 years. They totally ruined the Shaheedi of such a great soul. No one besides the indian government gained anything out of this lie. The taksal has not gone forward to reach the goals that Sant Jarnail Singh Ji had, you can see the proof of this by looking at the past 21 years of history of the taksal. How can we beleive what the organisation that has lied to the entire Khalsa Panth for 21 has to say? There can be no bigger papp than this. I came toward Sikhi because of Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh Ji and because of this i came to have alot of respect for the Taksal but seeing the practices and actions of the Taksal after Sant Jarnail Singh Ji and them lying about his Shaheedi has practically taken all that respect away. Now this opposing of bibian doing seva just eliminates the small amount of respect that i had left. Note: This doesnt mean i dont respect certain individuals in the Taksal and I will forever have the greatest respect for Sant Jarnail Singh Ji.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Singh · 23 Sep 2005

no Gurbani to back up their views, just the usual Baba ji says this and that, so I am with him rubbish... Mr Maybe, who are you kidding. Check out all forums, youth are question DT big time!

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Bhopinder Singh · 23 Sep 2005

What Taksal ? ARE you living in dreamland? It is finished with the lie of keeping sant ji alive for 20 years not to mention your statement of him hoisting a flag on RED`FORT. True KHALSA IS STILL above lies and will always be so..........................

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

khalistan_zindabaad · 23 Sep 2005

Singhs yu lot are just funny, firstly, when guru sahib j asked for 5 heads, he id not specifically ask for men to volunteer, however the sacred panj pyare were all men, therefore i dnt see hw bibia can do seva of the panj, secondly why does every toic on this site end up wth taksal bashing, ur just pathetic, i had respect and too some extent still do for the singhs from gurdwara tapoban sahib, however weneva i visit this site theres always something new cussing off taksalis. great stuff anyway keep it up, as ur creating ur own karam.

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

agyani · 23 Sep 2005

I am not a taksali BUT have great respect for Taksal and the maryada they follow. I ALSO have lots of respect for the gurmukh katha vachiks they produce........

Re: Sant Samaj, Taksal oppose ‘seva’ by women

Singh · 23 Sep 2005

this is not about taksal and what we think of them. It is about how can they even justify their stand of being anti-women?