Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

sort my life out · 21 Sep 2005

Considering some of the recent discussion on here; I thought the following posting from The Learning Zone might be of some interest. Please focus on the substantive issue and not nit pick over any particular comments in the posting per se. Posting follows: "There is a growing problem of finding suitable matches for Sikh boys wearing even symbolic turbans. It is not unusual to see Sikh mothers coming to the Gurdwara with turban wearing cute little sons but with bare-headed daughters with cut hair-styles! (So, more scarves are kept outside the Gurwaras to cover heads.) First immigrant generation Sikhs cut their hair because they could not get jobs. I saw youngish Sikhs in the early sixties weeping day and night after cutting their hair, ("I ca'nt bear to look at myslef in the mirror; what will my parents say back home?"). Today, I see young Sikh boys in a similar situation because they feel Sikh girls reject them outright as marriage partners. They start cutting their hair much against their own or their parents' wishes. They feel that it is the only way to get married. The question is, what sort of life partners would such girls make, whose pre-condition is the giving up of Sikh identity and, presumably, related family values and responsibilities? It should not come as a surprise that an increasing number of marriages break up within 6 months or one year. Just look at the matrimonial advertisements these days. This should be a wake up call to Sikh girls looking for stable marriage partners. Please reflect: those turban wearing Sikh boys at least have the courage to announce their Sikh identity and hopefully, related family values to the world. Do not reject their Sikh identity without at least taking a closer look and comparing notes for compatability. Either you want a successful married life or you do not. There must be a good reason why sometimes even a clean-shaven Sikh fathers, and many Sikh mothers want their sons to keep Sikh identity and values. Are they giving the same 'sikhia' to their daughters? " Gurmukh Singh

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Zorawar Singh · 21 Sep 2005

The problem here is a lack of parchaar of keski. These young girls have no role models that stand out to look up to. So many boys see Singhs in bana and are inspired. Bibian with keskis are rare, especially young ones who speak english. Look at many young girls today, they have cut hair and also do not wear karas. You will see every boy, even a mona wears a kara. This shows the difference in pride of sikhi between mona boys and mona girls. So girls have lost their identity. Their mothers have cut hair, so they copy. The problem is further increased by sant baba followers, Uk nangs and others who are actively doing parchaar against keski. They complain that girls who wear keskis are not feminine enough. I do think these people want their wives to singhnis and also be bollywood. Until we do not actively promote keskis for all Amritdhari bibis, more and more young punjabi girls will grow up knowing nothing about identity. Muslims girls prey on this when they approach punjabi girls for convertions. I hope those sad people who are so anti-keski think about this, before they continue on their missions.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Confused Khalsa · 21 Sep 2005

I share very similar views to yourself jee. If a person is willing to give up their Sikh identity, and go against their Guru in order to appease the opposite sex - what type of role model will they make for the couples children. what religion will they follow? the one were you go to the gurudwara on sundays? - this reminds me of Guru Nanak Dev ji were he constantly denounced ritual worship. Doing something because everyone else does it, not really understand anything about it. Simply to save face.... Hopefully the next generation wont make the same mistakes that the older sikhs did, and sacrifice their sikhi for their wallets. Sir Javay Ta Javai - Meri Sikhi Sidkh Na Jaavai

for the sake of Maya...

jugroop singh · 22 Sep 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, when Singhnis wear just a chunni, it is forever falling-off. when they tie a patka, then their Joora is not sitting upon their Dasam Duaaar. for the sake of worldly fashion, they are doing the following: - becoming bare-headed in the presence of Siree Guru Sahib Ji and not being tyaar-bar-tyaar generally. - not understanding the significance of Kes as the sanctified bodily part which sits upon the thrown of the Dasam Duaar. Kes is a supreme nishani of Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa - therefore his Nishani should sit upon the highest point of our body; why are we relegating it to 'behind the back of our head somewhere'? VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Legolas · 22 Sep 2005

Zorawar Singh, a person with such a beautiful name you do come out with some real ****. <<< The problem is further increased by sant baba followers, Uk nangs and others who are actively doing parchaar against keski. They complain that girls who wear keskis are not feminine enough. I do think these people want their wives to singhnis and also be bollywood. >>>> I have never heard of any Sant Mahapursh doing "parchaar" against keski, infact all I have heard actively promote it, so stop with your idiotic lies!

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

singhee laad · 22 Sep 2005

Legolas u said.... "I have never heard of any Sant Mahapursh doing "parchaar" against keski, infact all I have heard actively promote it, so stop with your idiotic lies!" Pehova vala saad on his first visit to UK, at southall gurdwara spoke against jatha and keski, he said " these poeple (AKJ) want women to wear dastars, its equality they say, ok then for equality will the akj men wear suits and banga as well?" and "these people (akj) say you shouldn't do joth (diva) hindus do it, i say to them hindus do tutty (go toilet) why dont you stop that?" He was challenged after the programme but would not talk to us....i heard this for myself not 2nd hand information.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

sort my life out · 22 Sep 2005

I did say "Please focus on the substantive issue ..... " Would that be too hard to do now? Pretty pretty (pun intended) please!

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Jasmin · 22 Sep 2005

Dear Singhee laad- I cannot comprehend the second paragraph of your post. Can you please try to write more clearly? I resently read about a Gurdwara that will not allow couples to marry if one or both partners has short hair. I believe this is a step in the right direction. Counter points- A person with long hair may still be trimming.- sure or someone may grow their hair just to get married and cut after- sure, but why bother? Or a person with long hair can have other faults- sure or it's not fair to people with short hair- well, they can still attend gurwara, maybe they will stop cutting. Or maybe the person had a sickness, like cancer, and he/she is in recovery. -fine, you can either wait to get married, or try to ask for special dispensation. I believe this ban sets a minimal standard, which is reasonable. It is a reminder of khalsa tradition. If a couple doesn't want to comply, they don't need to marry in a Gurdwara. Also I think that images in the media can go a long way to influening people. I remember last year Curb your Enthusiasm featured a turbaned Sikh man. We need more of those images. We need them of singaes too. If we had those images, we would have many more Gursikhs. On a personal note, when should a person who wants to come into Sikhi start wearing bana. Were might one get it?

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Zorawar Singh · 23 Sep 2005

no lies here! one example has already been given. Others include in some universities girls are told them AKJ lot (i.e. keski wale girls) are fanatics, stay away from them. Uk nangs - everyone knows what they say about shaving kesh, wear keskis with lengas, so lets not even go there. Lastly the sant baba followers who go ape just at the mention of a keski. If you are not going to promote the Khalsa Roop of a Bibi, then how do you expect young girls to be proud of being Sikhs? Legolas wrote: > Zorawar Singh, a person with such a beautiful name you do come > out with some real ****. > > <<< The problem is further increased by sant baba followers, Uk > nangs and others who are actively doing parchaar against keski. > They complain that girls who wear keskis are not feminine > enough. I do think these people want their wives to singhnis > and also be bollywood. >>>> > > I have never heard of any Sant Mahapursh doing "parchaar" > against keski, infact all I have heard actively promote it, so > stop with your idiotic lies!

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

kaur · 25 Sep 2005

sikh girls are pretty and get attension from a lot of men out there. Put the sikh saroop aside for a second they are not even choosing punjabi moneis but instead handsome european middle eastern and black mixed race guys in uk at least. Its just a matter of time before a serious imblanace will set in give it 5 10 years. Along with that loosening ties to desiness

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

member · 25 Sep 2005

Getting back to the original substantive issue. The original post (which was copied from a post by Gurmukh Singh in case the quoting did not make that clear); talked about how parents were bringing their son's up in Sikhi saroop but these exact same parents were not necessarily imbibing the same respect for kesh in to their daughters - and this was from a very early age. He also said: "This should be a wake up call to Sikh girls looking for stable marriage partners. Please reflect: those turban wearing Sikh boys at least have the courage to announce their Sikh identity and hopefully, related family values to the world. Do not reject their Sikh identity without at least taking a closer look and comparing notes for compatability." His premise was: "There is a growing problem of finding suitable matches for Sikh boys wearing even symbolic turbans ..... I see young Sikh boys ..... feel [that] Sikh girls reject them outright as marriage partners" From various discussions and I've read on Tapoban and observations elsewhere; it would appear that there is a similar situation for some Sikh girls[1] but my (admittedly unscientific) 'research' is that the situation is worse for Sikh guys, From some simple queries on various Sikh matrimonial sites I observed that there were many more men with kesh looking for partners; the number of women who preserved kesh was much less. Hence the "rejection" issue. The result was broadly similar across all the countries I looked into: UK, Canada, US and India. Interestingly there were also women who did not preserve kesh but were looking for guys who wore turbans. *shrug* I'm not even going to go into that. So is the situation that women are more prepared to give into "societal pressures" and to capitulate to these pressures then men; relatively speaking? And if so why? I recall a conversation a friend was relating that he had had with a Christian. The Christian was moaning about how hard it was to get people into their religion as they found it too hard to cope with; they even found going to Church on a Sunday a chore. My friend pointed at his beard and turban and said "thats without even getting into the rest of it; you guys have it easy." ;-) The point of relating the latter is to ask whether, when considering societal pressures; do girl's find's it harder to keep their hair uncut (lets not go into keski or dastaar for women and keep it to preserving kesh and girls wanting to marry Sikh guys in saroop) than guys do to keep a beard and wear a turban? Are we finding that having to deal with societal norms is more difficult for Sikh women and that more women then men are prepared to give in when it comes down to it? There are many who would point the finger of blame at Gurdwara's, committees's etc but surely before any of this kicks in we should consider the role of the parent. If there's already a denial of Sikhi saroop while very young then there's probably more of a chance of that thought developing with age. Is dealing with an "enemy" within us that much more difficult to deal with than an "enemy" that is external? Just how exactly are we do deal with this problem in the short term; if we wait for the long term it might be too late. I'm not saying that everyone in Sikhi saroop is necessary an ideal character; but thinking aloud for a moment; if you had to make the choice between a caring guy, who was willing to provide uptmost support at all times, would help out with the children, household chores, and in general be a loving and careing husband and father who wouldnt run out on you with another woman or let you down at times of immense difficulty [any similarity to my own personality is entirely coincidental ]; would rejecting that person on the basis of Sikhi saroop be the most sensible thing in the world to do? You wouldnt have thought so would you? Sorry for the long rambling, incoherent posting [I know, never write a long post on the hoof] and all the questions. I have no answers to the problems but I would appreciate a serious debate on it. GurFateh [1] We have plenty of men who don't portray a Sikh identity as well but let keep this discussion to women not wanting to marry guys with kesh. I don't think such "Sikh" guys are finding it as hard to find "Sikh" women. Sikh women who are finding it hard to find decent Sikh guys in saroop might want to start a new thread to discuss their issues; then again they might not ;-)

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Jasmin · 26 Sep 2005

In my observation I'd say its like this, generally their two varies of ''Sikh'' men on matrimonial sites. Either they cut their hair, often very short, in which case they are really monay, or they wear a turban and generally honor their hair. In the case of women, it is more complex. Women rarely wear turbans. In my observation most "Sikh" women do have long hair, but they don't often wear turbans. Thus, split ends are noticable, and they get tempted to trim their hair. They go to a salon, and with the encouragement of the hair dresser this could lead to bangs, or layers. Now as to why men with turbans are less favored, I don't know. Maybe the women fear that turbaned men are too religious for their taste. If the women in question are very modern prehaps they want to have relations before marriage, and thus don't care for a religious husband. On the other hand maybe some of the women that trim their hair are doing it under family pressure, and want to marry a Gursikh that will help them stop all their bad habits. Women are socialized to be very concerned with what other people think and and feel and thus give in more easily to pressure. Having said that looking at matrimonal sites, or at least the one on Sikhnet-the vast majority of men are cut surd. Actually, of the two , their are a lot more long haired women vs. men which is understandable because in general, a women can get away which having long hair much more easily then a man. WkjkWkjf

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

A Kaur (London) · 26 Sep 2005

WkKWkf I have cut hair but I would like to meet a Keshdhari guy. I have met 3 to date and all 3 of them have acted and behaved irrationally not the way in which I would have expected. In actual fact, all 3 behaved worse than monay guys. The question is - has this meant I am not interested in Keshdhari guys? The answer is no, I maintain an open mind. Conclusion - why do we constantly have the pigeon hole people into boxes? WkKWkf

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Jasmin · 26 Sep 2005

Dear A kaur- Maybe if stopped cutting Keshdarhari men would be more receptive? Just a thought. : )

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

stats · 26 Sep 2005

> observation most "Sikh" women do have long hair, but they don't often > Now as to why men with turbans are less favored, I don't know. Maybe the > women fear that turbaned men are too religious for their taste. If the > women in question are very modern prehaps they want to have relations > before marriage, and thus don't care for a religious husband. I'm sure you meant 'modern' ie in quotes ;-) I'm fairly modern, can use a phone, eat with a spoon when necessary, I even have flowing water in the taps in my house - I think this is all quite modern. There's nothing modern about cutting one's hair. I know what you meant but I just wanted to labour that point. I think apostate is a better word to use - don't call them modern - as it's nothing of the sort. > Having said that looking at matrimonal sites, or at least the one on > Sikhnet-the vast majority of men are cut surd. Actually, of the two , their > are a lot more long haired women vs. men which is understandable > because in general, a women can get away which having long hair much > more easily then a man. Again labouring a point - it's not long hair - it's uncut heair. But I suspect that's what you meant. I don't cut my hair but it's still naturally quite short - and naturally curly - looks like an afro after a keshi wash. The comments about SIkhNet made me look into it a little bit deeper. The following are results as of a few hours ago (the search function has a few oddities - but the general point holds): Total number of all Sikh men = 3180 Sikh Men with uncut hair = 1317 Therefore 41% of men advertising on SIkhNet have uncut hair. Total number of all Sikh Women = 2072 SIkh women with uncut hair = 597 Therefore 29% of women advertising on SikhNet have uncut hair. So there are more men with uncut hair looking than woman. Also it's noticeable now many more men than woman are looking for partners. Sure this is not an indepth statistical analysis but the point holds. MORE men than women looking for partners DO NOT cut their hair. A general look around when I'm in the Gurdwara or at a wedding or somewhere seems to bear this out. So back to the original point I think.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

stats · 26 Sep 2005

Dear A Kaur, > Conclusion - why do we constantly have the pigeon hole people into > boxes? Well to a certain extent you are pigeon-holed - but seeing as that is not the appropriate word to use; let me phrase it this way - you consider yourself a SIkh so others (non Sikhs for instance) may well consider you have put yourself into a particular identity; or using your terminology put yourself into a pigeon hole. Also (nicely - not in a rude way) were you the A Kaur who started the thread about the inappropriate use of the Khanda? If not then no need to read on. The thread was http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=54783&t=54783 In that thread A Kaur (London) said: "I respect the Sikh Khanda as being one on the many identities which GuruJi gave us as Sikhs. However, I recently came across a website where the Sikh Khanda is displayed on the front page but the website is not devoted exclusively to Sikhi but is open to muslims. I feel that it is not right to use to Khanda in such a fashionable way.. what do you guys think?" Maybe you want to re-read that posting and reflect on the subject under discussion under this thread. Attention to the words "respect", "identities", "fashionable" and "not right" might be appropriate. It's not so straightforward now; it is about identity; it is about protecting it and it is about the enemy within. There is a problem and maybe we would be better placed as a community if the words you used above had Khanda replaced with Kesh (in context of course). Why would you feel one way about the Khanda and differently about Kesh - in the same context? Maybe you can see where Keshidari guys are coming from now?

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Jasmin · 26 Sep 2005

I've just took a longer look at Sikhnet matrimonials. Sure, a lot of these women trim their hair, and a handful actually have cut hair above shoulders. I found about four, often approaching middle age, that have a short haircut. I found one who wants her own salon. (such Sikhi, just kidding) Another who insists her suiter should have his hair cut. I even don't think she means trimmed, I think she means cut as in short. (obscene) Even so, most of these women are not truly adverse to kesh. Generally, I believe that most of these women just need a keski, a turban, and an encourageing husband. WkjkWkjf

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

A Kaur (London) · 27 Sep 2005

Stats and Jasmin I have no issue with the fact that I cut my hair - and to be frank, I am not asking your opinion to whether I should or should not. If you read properly, you shall see that I have stated that keshdhari men are not necessarily all sincere and innocent as they 'purport' to be. I have come across 3 whom all have lead 'dis-tasteful' lives and that has NOTHING to do with the fact that I cut my hair. Finally, the way I follow the religion does not make it inappropriate for me to comment upon the usage of the Khanda. Rather than make curt comments to me - and by the way, how can you two make comments about me when YOU do not even know me... TRY to focus on subject topics and grow up. Thanking you for your useless input.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

singhni · 27 Sep 2005

'stats' i really thing your posts above are great...keep typing (and japping)

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Scientific · 27 Sep 2005

This is an interesting debate. I was a monay before a Sardar and so have seen both sides. I get quite tired of this 'poor me , i am a keshdhari and cant find a girl' attitude. Its quite pathetic. I think alot of sikh girls indeed do shy away from the orthodox sikh guy who is keshdhari. We need to understand what is going on here. A sizeable number of people who adopt the identity (or have it from the start) transform their behaviour quite drastically. From previously socialising with people who arent religous, they segregate themselves and become quite intolerant of their non-keshdhari peers. Such extreme attitudes have resulted in a poor stereotypical image for Sardars. Instead of sikh girls percieving sardars (and particularly amritdhari guys) as easy going, fun and NORMAL they see them as extreme, intolerant and quite SQUARE. I am sorry to say this but i think that alot of Sardars simply dont make enough of an effort. Image is everything in this world. Marketing determines consumer behaviour. This is a fact of life. Sardars need to market themselves as being 'cool'. There is no reason why they shouldnt be smart, articulate and well presented. I have come across so many sirdars who walk around dressed pretty badly, do not socialise with non-amritdharis, have poor motivation for careers, feel that wealth should be shunned, dont want to talk to girls etc. If this sounds like you then what do you expect???????????????? How does this compare to the sensitive mona who is well groomed, articulate, makes an effort to impress others with his charisma etc. The image of the 'fat giani' at the temple needs to be shaken off. The fact of the matter is that there are Sardars in power positions everywhere. We have to drop this poor me attitude and get with the show. It has to become a stereotype that these guys with turbans are successful, affluent, extravagant, educated, smart people. This idea needs to be marketed to the masses. The image of turbaned sikhs can be changed. The situation is not helped by scaring away the girls with fundo attitudes on everything. You only have to look at the Sardars who do make an effort to realise that there is no shortage of girls wanting to marry them. S

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Really? · 28 Sep 2005

'poor me , i am a keshdhari and cant find a girl' attitude. Its quite pathetic I hate self pity also. But the same could be said about "poor me , i am a MONA and cant find a girl' attitude". As far as I am aware ALL people are finding it difficult to find matrimonial partners - Keshadharis, Monas, Hindus, whatever. No self pity required as this all depends on SANJOG. When Waheguru has written for your sanjog to happen it will. The difficulty in finding a match wouldn't be there in a Gursikh environment as people wouldn't be discriminating against castes, wouldn't be too fussed on looks and other material issues. Scientific paaji, I disagree with your suggestions on improving matrimonial attractiveness. You are making way too many generalisations. Issues such as dress sense, socialbility, career motivation etc are in no way specific to kesadharis and Amritdharis. It seems that you feel some Sikh characteristics to be a problem, I don't. I think it is a gunn (praise worthy) if you are not chatting to the opposite gender without reason, I think it's good if you don't become vain about personal appearence and are more concerned with inner beauty, I think it's great if you're not obsessed with making riches and actually creating the correct balance - remember there is naam jaapna and vand shakna besides kirat karna. Also don't we ask in Ardas that may we be united with people that make us recall Wahegurus name? So surely it's good to socialise with fellow "orthodox" people. By giving into Maya, it may be easier to find a partner for this lifetime but you'll get a hard time from dharamraj. Focus on becoming a better Sikh and Waheguru will sort your affairs (in this lifetime and the next) himself. [%sig%]

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

stats · 28 Sep 2005

Dear A Kaur, > I have no issue with the fact that I cut my hair - and to be frank, I am not > asking your opinion to whether I should or should not. Yes we get that. You didnt get my opinion on whether you should or should as I didnt offer an opinon on that to you. You should try reading the actual post. What you did get was a reply to your point of pigeon holeing. This was then followed by an discussion on the use of the Khanda and comparing it to kesh in light of the context of the posting by A Kaur that referring to "the inappropriate use of the Khanda." > If you read properly, you shall see that I have stated that keshdhari men > are not necessarily all sincere and innocent as they 'purport' to be. I have > come across 3 whom all have lead 'dis-tasteful' lives and that has NOTHING > to do with the fact that I cut my hair. Yes there bad keshidari men. No one said there wasnt. Welcome to the world. For everyone of your 'unsavioury' keshidar's I'll introduce you ones that aint. The discussion was bout keeping kesh - and whether that was a factor in finding marriage partners. not about good or bad keshidar men. > Finally, the way I follow the religion does not make it inappropriate for me > to comment upon the usage of the Khanda. If you are the same A Kaur (which you haven't denied) who started the discussion on the khanda; then the orginal post included the line: "I feel that it is not right to use to Khanda in such a fashionable way." So you (if it is you) was offering a very definitive comment; "I feel that it is not right ...." In relation to that Khanda post I asked for a re-reading of that posting but bringing kesh into the context; no more no less. Trust you have done this. > Rather than make curt comments to me - and by the way, how can you two > make comments about me when YOU do not even know me... TRY to focus > on subject topics and grow up. None of my comments were curt and in fact I even said "Nicely - Not in a rude way". Also none of them were about you - they were too you. A completely different thing. You are posting to a public forum; where discussion (sometimes) take place. Thats what is going on. If that is too much to deal with then just read without contributing. > Thanking you for your useless input. Pot. Kettle. Black. By the way feel free to respond to the actual points raised and not any perceived imaginary attacks you see.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Jasmin · 28 Sep 2005

Dear- A Kaur I really only want to be helpful. I understand how nerve racking it can be to read these posts. Sometimes their is criticism, we often face our own failings. You call your Kaur, and you want to meet Keshdhari men. You seem to care about Sikh history. Yet you are facing a disconnect when it comes to honoring your Kesh. Maybe it's as simple as trimming split ends, or maybe it's a more extreme form of abuse. The real problem is you don't seem sorry. If you were sorry their would be hope for you. You seem to have a righteous indignation over your right to cut. Fashion is a funny thing. Once my mother told me about an operation some women have because they have a Roman toe. The bone is cut to make the toe shorter. I was reflecting on fashion today, and I was thinking fashion isn't freedom, it's slavery. It's tells people, especially women, that the way God made them isn't good enough. So it urges them to abuse kesh with chemicals, and cutting and paint their faces with grease, often made from the rendered carcass of dead animals found on the side of the road. I find the term make-up interesting. What deficiency are we trying to make-up for? Someone once wrote on this forum the Khalsa is a super-special army. If your really interested in Sikhi, then Khalsa should be your goal. You should view taking Amrit as your "wedding day" with the Waheguru. The coil and the turban is a beautiful, special, symbol of you marriage. (whether or not kesh is a kakker, it is a symbol of your marriage.) Sikhi is wonderful, because it is the only religion I know that does not hate, but indeed loves, the kesh. Look at other religions. The Bible states men should not grow long hair, and says that women are better of bald. Catholic nuns have to cut their hair when they initate. Buddhist shave off all hair as monks. Orthodox Jewish women have cut hair and or wear a wig to cover. Hindus are obsessed with mundun, for both sexes, even adults. I have also read that Muslim men will sometimes shave their heads. Honestly, I genuinely believe that Sikhi is the only religion that truely, completely, excepts Kesh. That's what makes it so wonderful. I have no idea what happened with these three men you speak of. I can say, with certainty that your cut hair, combined with your attitude, would have offended these men, "first cracker out of the box". Please learn to see why. Maybe this will lessen your smugness. You will learn love, rather then contempt. Maybe you will come to be happy with what God made. Prehaps you will come to love Guru ji, and you will have more respect. When this happens, prehaps you will find a keshdhari man that will take an interest in you. WkjkWkjf

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

A Kaur (London) · 29 Sep 2005

Jasmin Ji I respect that you are so religious and think you are have the right to suggest that I am 'smug'.... and that Keshdhari men may take an interest in me IF I were to change my ways? and my attitude may have offended these guys? What planet are you on? I am not even going to respond back to a person like you. To make such shallow, pathetic comments.. you are clearly trying to win 'brownie' points... Let me be the first to congratulate you!!! Well done Jasmin!!!!! A

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

A Kaur (London) · 29 Sep 2005

Stats Ji Thanks for your long reply back. The only comment I would make is that, this particular thread was about the Khanda NOT kesh or Keshdhari men. Yes, this is the same A Kaur (London).... I can face the heat in the kitchen so I won't shy away from comments which I percieve as unjustified. [%sig%]

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

stats · 29 Sep 2005

I'm really sorry but my previous reply had a number of typing errors in. So I feel I should resubmit it without so many errors. Just simple typing errors - the message is basically the same. Here goes again. Hopefully I have the text wrapping sorted now as well. Dear A Kaur, > I have no issue with the fact that I cut my hair - and to be frank, I am not > asking your opinion to whether I should or should not. Yes we get that. You didnt get my opinion on whether you should or should not as I didnt offer an opinon on that to you. You should try reading the actual post. What you did get was a reply to your point of pigeon holeing. This was then followed by a discussion on the use of the Khanda and comparing it to kesh in light of the context of the posting by A Kaur that referred to "the inappropriate use of the Khanda." > If you read properly, you shall see that I have stated that keshdhari men > are not necessarily all sincere and innocent as they 'purport' to be. I have > come across 3 whom all have lead 'dis-tasteful' lives and that has > NOTHING to do with the fact that I cut my hair. Yes there are bad keshidari men. No one said there wasnt. Welcome to the world. For everyone of your 'unsavioury' keshidar's I'll introduce you one that isnt. The discussion was about keeping kesh - and whether that was a factor in finding marriage partners. not about good or bad keshidar men. > Finally, the way I follow the religion does not make it inappropriate for me > to comment upon the usage of the Khanda. If you are the same A Kaur (which you haven't denied) who started the discussion on the khanda; then the orginal post included the line: "I feel that it is not right to use to Khanda in such a fashionable way." So you (if it is you) was offering a very definitive comment; "I feel that it is not right ...." In relation to that Khanda post I asked for a re-reading of that posting but bringing kesh into the context; no more no less. Trust you have done this. > Rather than make curt comments to me - and by the way, how can you > two make comments about me when YOU do not even know me... TRY to > focus on subject topics and grow up. None of my comments were curt and in fact I even said "Nicely - Not in a rude way". Also none of them were about you - they were too you. A completely different thing. You are posting to a public forum; where discussion (sometimes) take place. Thats what is going on. If that is too much to deal with then just read without contributing. > Thanking you for your useless input. Pot. Kettle. Black. By the way feel free to respond to the actual points raised and not any perceived (imaginary) attacks you see.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

stats · 29 Sep 2005

Dear A Kaur. > Thanks for your long reply back. > The only comment I would make is that, this particular thread was about > the Khanda NOT kesh or Keshdhari men. Just to be clear. *That* thread was about the Khanda and was referenced with regard to your comment as to it's [The Khanda's] "inappropriate use". *This* thread is about the matrimonial threat from within; with respect to kesh and marriage. > Yes, this is the same A Kaur (London).... The point was about context and was very much focused on kesh. It made due reference to a point you made in *that* thread (the Khanda discussion) but was entirely in the context of Kesh in this discussion. The question asked previously was: "Why would you feel one way about the Khanda and differently about Kesh?" Would appreciate your input to the point. No need to worry if your reply is long. > I can face the heat in the kitchen so I won't shy away from comments > which I percieve as unjustified. Good. Look forward to you actually responding to the discussion in that case and not imaginary 'attacks'.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

A Kaur (London) · 29 Sep 2005

Stats Ji Apologies – I realised whilst at lunch that I got the threads confused! Yep, shoot me down with an arrow (that was a joke). Q: "Why would you feel one way about the Khanda and differently about Kesh?" This is really a good question to me. It is really valid in sofar as from where you are sitting you probably see me as either a) confused or b) a walking and talking contradiction or c) stupid!. To be perfectly honest, I do respect the Khanda and Kesh with the same principles. However, as I have chosen to cut my hair, I do not think that this removes the right for me to have objections to the Khanda being depicted on non Sikh websites, off licence stores etc. As I am typing this, I really don’t have a valid argument either way and so I will not comment any further. I know you and others will view this as cowardly but I will not rant and rave unless I have a plausible explanation. WkKWkf

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

stats · 29 Sep 2005

Dear A Kaur, Glad the point got across this time. > As I am typing this, I really don�t have a valid argument either way and so I > will not comment any further. Fair enough. It's an honest reply.

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Scientific · 29 Sep 2005

A kaur You shouldnt feel guilty about making comments about Sikh issues just because you havent kept your hair. We are all on the same path. Spirtuality is a personal issue between you, your guru and god. Many people feel that just because they can physically stake a claim to be recognised as a Sikh, that are somehow entitled to belittle the ideology of those that havent made the same committment. Be strong in yourself and dont feel you have to justify your way of life to others. Ultimately each of us have to make peace with ourselves and with god. Our guru is there to guide us. Nothing more to say Scientific

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Deep · 30 Sep 2005

why do you think some of the matrimonials specifically ask for monay grooms.. even when posted by parents

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

Scientific · 30 Sep 2005

Good point. We are now seeing a break up of sikhism into different strands. The majority of young sikhs are now without the turban identity. Their children are also unlikely to be adhere to the identity. In effect this group is beginning to break away much like the non-orthodox Jews we see around us. The practice of the majority of jews we see in the west is pretty limited yet they are still counted as Jews by others and by themselves. I know people are going to say well if these people arent willing to preserve the identity they are not sikhs, but the reality is that this group is (whether we like it or not) still going to be recognised as Sikhs and is defining itself in a new light. Their future generations are going to come through and will want to marry within their group which for many will be monay. Its just the way things are at present and the way things will be in the future. S

Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within

stats · 30 Sep 2005

> somehow entitled to belittle the ideology of those that havent made the Just to be clear. No such sentiments was expressed in my previous posts. They asked to consider the one thing (kesh) within the same context as the other (Khanda) in light of previous comments made about "inappropriateness" elsewhere. It then suggested: "Maybe you can see where Keshidari guys are coming from now?" It was an analogy to try and help see where some people might be coming from. No more, no less. > same committment. Be strong in yourself and dont feel you have to justify > your way of life to others. Is there a line beyond which the above proposition is unacceptable and should not be crossed? Or does it it apply to anything?