Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Worship of Images of Guru's

Worship of Images of Guru's

Kal · 21 Sep 2005

Now many people have different views on this and mainly from the older generation i get a ''it's part of sikhism'' lecture. First point. Guru Nanak Dev Ji eradicated any forms of worship of Idols, (idolatry) or any effigy/image. Now what we see in the Gurdwaras and many homes are pictures of ''gurus'' when nobody even knows what they looked like. and many people give tooof (incense) which is totally against sikhi code of conduct. I think we should take a leaf out of Islam and discontinue illustrationg pictures of ''gurus'' and only have images of Gurbani & Gurdwara's in Gurdwara's and Homes. This way we keep in practice what the Guru's taught and what the Guru Granth Sahib Teaches Today! [%sig%]

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Legolas · 21 Sep 2005

Kaal, You are right, let us get rid of all image worship. Lets start by all of us taking out pictures of our wife or husband from our wallets and burning them. Then we can continue with those pictures of our kids stuffed in our wallets or on our desks and burn them, lets first burn these idiotic images before we remove pictures of the Gurus.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Singh · 21 Sep 2005

I agree, people have made pics of the Guru’s into some sort of idol. The pics also do little to tell us about the Guru, ie the pic of Guru Nanak as an old man with his hand up giving blessings does little justice to what he really is/was - a revolutionary, pioneer, prophet, family man etc. If anyone really wants to see the Guru all they have to do is go to see Guru Granth Sahib, however people who worship these pics rarely seem to understand really what Guru Granth Sahib is.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Reply · 21 Sep 2005

Kal ji, What then do you think of the new animated movie on the Sahibzade? The next one may be on the Guru Sahiban. Will that be OK by you? [%sig%]

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Legolas, Do you worship pictures of your family ? Stick to the point rather than going off on one.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Legolas · 21 Sep 2005

S Singh, You miss the point. When we have pictures of our darling wife stuffed into our wallets and we carry them around with us wherever we go and whenever we open the wallet we gaze longingly at the picture..........what else would you call it?? This is a form of worship. So, before you condemn all the pictures of our sahibaans relegate these pictures to the bin first. worship is a very big word. When I look at a picture of Guru Sahib Ji I do not "worship" the picture, but it reminds me of my Guru and I may say "Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji".......got to be a good thing. I would rather have pictures of Guru Ji so that as I go from one room to another room and say "Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji" and "Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Ji" rather then have an image of a family member, what good is that going to do yo your atma ?

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Legolas, I think you seriously miss the point. Perhaps you have experience of people bowing to pictures of family members and giving pictures thoof i.e worshiping the pictures. If you have a picture of your kids on your work desk, do you worship it ? I think not. Why can you not say Dhan Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji without looking at the picture ?

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Gurpreet Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

Legolas, good point. S Singh, please stop being so sarcastic, your posts are always really bitter, its not good for you, try being polite, its much better.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Gurpreet Ji I am not trying to be sacarstic. It is a simple question. I have not seen anyone worship family pictures. Maybe logolas has. If you cannot tell the difference between worship and non worship then that is not my fault. We have bank notes with pictures on, if we look at the note does that imply we are worshiping the note ? Before people give money to a keertan jatha they will look at the note before they put it on the stage, again that does not mean they are worshiping picture on the money. Also similar when you put money into the golak. Going by what legolas the underlying message of what legolas has written we should burn everything with a picture on it. People have stone carved animals statues in their gardens. Again this is far removed from worshiping the garden statue. Go to the Gurdwara in Punjab where they have statues and see how people worship them. It is common to see statues of palwaan, men on horses etc on top of kotia (homes) in Punjab. People do look at them, again looking at them is quite distant from worshiping them. Read what the original poster wrote. He did not write about family pictures. He was concerned with so called pictures of our Guru Ji. Fact is people do tend to worship these so called pictures of our Guru Ji despite what our Guru Ji taught us. As for being bitter, you worry about yourself and not concern your self with analysis of other peoples posts to come to your off the mark conclusions that they are bitter.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Gurpreet Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

>>If you cannot tell the difference between worship and non worship then that is not my fault.<< Dont make assumptions of what I know. You dont even know me, I havent even commented on whether or not I agree with the original post but you have made up your mind already. I didnt mean to offend you, but you really do seem very bitter, its not really something which is seen to be good, but if you are happy as you are, carry on. I do worry about others you see, Il try to be more selfish though.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Gurpreet If that is the case stop going off topic as Legolas has done and stick to the actual issues raised by the original poster. Judging by your previous posts like on the Ganga Sagar, I would worry about yourself and what bitter things without substance you write. Are you one of them people who nit pick just so you can have an arguement?

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Jugraj Singh · 21 Sep 2005

How do you know the picture you are looking at is what Guru Gubind Singh jee really looked like? You are just looking at the result of someone's imagination. Hang any paintings you want in your house but don't lable them as Guru Sahib.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Jugraj Singh you make an important point. Last year I had the opportunity to see an exhibition at Gurdwara Rakab Ganj. There was a drawing of Guru Gobind Singh Ji done by a court artist of one of the hill rajas. The image looked totally different to those we see today. The face and beard was very much differnt to the images most people have in their homes.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

............ · 21 Sep 2005

yes maybe but wen u wak past the pics u thnnk of Guru Jis, sometimes in our busy schedule we cant remember them so this way we can, why does someone have a prolbme with that?

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

AS · 21 Sep 2005

The images that you see in those pictures are not what the Gurus looked like. It's just the artists impression of what the Gurus MAY have looked like. They take into account what an average Punjabi male of the Sikh faith of that particular age group may have looked like in that year or decade and have made an image based on that. I've seen some young and old bibis praying with folded hands to these pictures and lighting insence and have also seen people put Hars of flowers around these pictures. This is pure Bipran Ki Reet. Has no part in Sikhism, infact, it goes against the basic tenents. I've also seen pictures of the GUrus in the worship halls of GUrdwaras where Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is. Totally wrong. I think having pictures are ok MAYBE to serve as reminders (even for that reason I'm not really sure), but these should never ever be worshiped or prayed to!

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

khalsa_force · 21 Sep 2005

so sikhs of present need help of PICS to remember guru jis? ki sadi sikhi aini kamjor ho chukki hai? and i need not pics of my parents to remember them or luv them. i think u hvnt seend ppl doing CHAUR SAHIB to some sants pic in my thread i posted sometimes bak. pics of guru jis r of importance which SENDS ANY MESSAGE and they too in museums in books to teach younger generations and not worshiping.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

. · 22 Sep 2005

S Singh, Did you get to take a picture of this drawing of Guru Ji, is there any where I could get a copy of this drawing ? can you describe what it was like ?

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

A Singh · 22 Sep 2005

<> I think we can really leave taking any leaves out of Islam - a set of rigid rules that are designed for people who have no thinking ability or control (e.g. women must veil themselves because men will get attracted to them! - wouldn't a true dharma seek to raise the 'matt' of man to control his urges in a proper manner???). Same thing here, because some bibis perform photo puja, doesn't make having "artist's impressions" of the Guru Sahibs in our homes incorrect. Address the root of the matter - education and understanding, not simply cut the branches - tomorrow, you'll say those premis who do a matha tek to the Nishan Sahib are also manmati and bipran reet, so what do we do then, remove the nishan sahib??? WHICH for that matter is Today VERY DIFFERENT from what it used to be in the times of the GURU!!!

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 22 Sep 2005

>>S Singh, >>Did you get to take a picture of this drawing of Guru Ji, is there any where I could get a copy of this drawing ? can you describe what it was like ? Security was very tight and cameras not allowed (I suppose camera flash can have a detrimental effect on a picture). The dastaar of Guru Ji was not the cone type dastaar you see in pictures. It was a gol/round dastaar. It looked nothing like a Nihang dastaar. It was a simple gol dastaar (have a look at an image of Guru Nanak Dev Ji). Amazing thing was that they had an actual dastaar of Guru Gobind Singh Ji on display (I think some family in Punjab own it). Again it was gol type with very loose bal (folds) The face was very different. With nice big cheeks. The beard was also not the one shown in images. Its hard to describe but if they ever have such an exhibition again it would be worth a visit.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Gurpreet Kaur · 22 Sep 2005

S Singh, stick to the topic, what I said in another topic has nothing to do with this thread. As for your attitude towards me, well I find it offensive and you will carry on, so be it. I think if a picture helps me remind me of my Guru, its a good thing, that's my take on this thread.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 22 Sep 2005

>>S Singh, stick to the topic, what I said in another topic has nothing to do with this thread. As for your attitude towards me, well I find it offensive and you will carry on, so be it. I think if a picture helps me remind me of my Guru, its a good thing, that's my take on this thread. Practice what you preach and stop delivering sermons on your perceptions of posts being bitter then. Just remember who first went off topic to attack my thoughts. Look at your own attitude against everyone else on this forum. Great to hear that you know better than our Guru Ji. If they thought that pictures were a good thing they would have mentioned this. Fact is pictures lead to a form of idol worship which goes against what our Guru Ji taught.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Dogma · 22 Sep 2005

I dunno about the word WORSHIP. But I know alot of people who actually use pictures of the Guru Sahibaan and of other Gursikhs to help motivitate and inspire themselves. As long as it's not WORSHIP, then I believe that's okay. Wahegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Sep 2005

The Worst Offenders in spreading this "Pictrue Waad" are the nanaksaris who claim to have discovered an original aslee picture of Guru nanak ji...one that doesnt at all impress anyone. No other DERA has so many pictures..of Guru Ji, of their own Babs, and what not. PICTURES lead to IDOLS..and STATUES.....and then to IDOL WORSHIP. Period.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

singh · 22 Sep 2005

i totally agree with original post

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 23 Sep 2005

>>The Worst Offenders in spreading this "Pictrue Waad" are the nanaksaris who claim to have discovered an original aslee picture of Guru nanak ji...one that doesnt at all impress anyone. I have also noticed this. They have a huge picture of Guru Nanak Dev Ji and one of the Nanaksari baba behind the Palki. So everytime someone does matha teyk they are also bowing to these pictures. The use of their babas picture next to Gurur Nanak Dev Ji also suggests they hold their baba on the same level.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

A Singh · 23 Sep 2005

S Singh wrote: <> Veer, this is very interesting and certainly any further info you can provide on either the picture or the actual dastaar would be great (the exhibitors, location, contacts etc). The view that Guru Sahib wore a Dumala in the fashion that is now popular (i.e. Dastaar Boonga, Farla, Aad Chand etc) is incorrect as this is style of dastaar contrary to whatever Nihangs or AKJ Singhs may like to think, is far from being any original Khalsa Roop. Even the earlier photo relics of Guru Sahib and Singhs of his era do not display him in a dastaar resembling the Dastaar Boonga. As per photos, again, "banning" them as people are suggesting here is going to achieve nothing. Even Guru Sahib himself mentions this in his Bani when writing to Aurangzeb about his 'idol-smashing'. Gyani "Arshi", I'm sorry but I disagree with you wholly here, photos and statues need not lead to murti-puja: These are expressions of artwork, just like Music, Dance, Poetry etc and are not manmati items, but the very thing that allows expression from one's heart, which is why we see such mediums employed by most faiths and saints over time (mainly music and poetry). Look at the west for a second, as many of the youth lives here now and frankly "think" with western thought processes - do Christians and others worship images or statues? Yet they (other than protestants - who let's face it are hardly a sampradha of any great religious standing) have statues, artwork etc. Even in the east, whilst the Buddhists have large Buddha Statues, they do not worship the image. So the issue is not to start "banning" books, art, thought, expression etc -which is not the act of a civilised person, but to address the root issue, i.e. have the Sikh masses understand WHY not to "worship" the image. Let's face it, people do the same thing with Nishan Sahibs (again which are only recent innovations in colour and khanda design), historical beri trees at certain gurdwaras etc - what do you propose seriously, banning Nishan Sahibs (like the Nanaksaris) and cutting out more of our heritage (trees, buildings etc). Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Gurpreet Kaur · 23 Sep 2005

S Singh, I have nothing against anyone on this forum, but you seem to find pleasure in being defensive towards me, that's ok, carry on. I dont think I know more than Guru Sahib, yet again that's an assumption that you made because of your bitterness towards me. Guru Jee forbade idol worship, I dont worship the images, I dont destroy them either, I think they are fine because they remind me of Guru Sahib.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Sakhi · 23 Sep 2005

We have a lot of pictures (from calendars n stuff) of Guru sahibaans in our house, what should we do with these? Doesn't feel right to recycle them, can we agni bhet them? But some are plastic, what should be do with these?

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Gurpreet stick to the topic. Unless you have a compulsion to try and start online arguments. Fact is these pictures are leading to idol worship. People pray to the pictures offer them thoof light diva's in front of them. That is precisely why our Guru Ji forbade idol worship. Just becasue you do not do it does not mean others don't.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 23 Sep 2005

A Singh. The exhibition was held last year at the fine new building which is located towards the right of the car park entrance of Gurdwara Rakab Ganj. I think the building is named Guru Granth Sahib Research Centre. The exhibition had a wide range of items on display ranging from the picture and dastaar of Guru Gobind Singh Ji to the Bahowali bir. The exhibtion was only for a few months and finished some time in November 2005. If you want more information it might be an idea to write to Dr Jaswant Singh Neki who is a director of the Guru Granth Sahib Research Centre. I am sure he will know where the exhibits were sourced from. >>The view that Guru Sahib wore a Dumala in the fashion that is now popular (i.e. Dastaar Boonga, Farla, Aad Chand etc) is incorrect as this is style of dastaar contrary to whatever Nihangs or AKJ Singhs may like to think, is far from being any original Khalsa Roop. Guru Gobind Singh Ji's dastaar was on display and I agree it is nothing like the modern day gol dastaar. In contrast to the clean folds (bal) and lines of todays gol dastaar the folds Guru Ji's dastaar were very random (loose in appearance).

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

(()) · 23 Sep 2005

They had a dastar of Guru Gobind Singh Jee on display in its tied on form? And it was the original, tied by Guru Saahib and never untied again by anyone? Where did they get this from? I don't like accepting these things simply at face value, as there are lots of fake items out there. Also, about Christians and statues and paintings. Christians are about the biggest idol worshippers out there. Most of htem will pray to statues of jesus and mary, so let's not try copying them.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 23 Sep 2005

correction >>The exhibtion was only for a few months and finished some time in November 2005. should read November 2004.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

A Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Daer () No one is asking you to copy anyone - let's address the root of the issue not the branches. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

Gurpreet Kaur · 23 Sep 2005

I am merely expressing my opinion like everyone else and will continue to do so whether you like it or not. A Singh, I agree with your points, well said, I think this banning issue is going to extremes, but then what would we expect when people now think we should learn from the wahabism of Islam?

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 23 Sep 2005

>>>They had a dastar of Guru Gobind Singh Jee on display in its tied on form? And it was the original, tied by Guru Saahib and never untied again by anyone? Where did they get this from? I don't like accepting these things simply at face value, as there are lots of fake items out there. >>>Also, about Christians and statues and paintings. Christians are about the biggest idol worshippers out there. Most of htem will pray to statues of jesus and mary, so let's not try copying them. Yes it was in the tied form. The dastaar is with a family in Punjab. I have given contact info so feel free to contact the Study Centre for more information. There are lots of fakes but it is not impossible to have items dating back to Guru Jis times. Clothes wooden sandals etc of our Guru Ji are with some Gurdwara. I agree with you Christian comments. Our Guru Ji have told us such worship is wrong but people on this forum are propagating such worship by claiming imaginary pictures are ok.

Re: Worship of Images of Guru's

S Singh · 13 Nov 2005

For those interested the exhibition is being held again. See the story below. Exhibition of rare relics of Sikh Gurus R. Suryamurthy Tribune News Service New Delhi, November 12 An exhibition of Sikh relics has been organised in the Capital which showcases, perhaps for the first time, some of the rare artifacts and articles used by the Sikh Gurus, including the minature Guru Granth Sahib carried by soldiers during the second World War. The relics include the dastar, (turban) Kacchera, a low seated wooden chair, the tawa on which the food was cooked, metal utensils, handwritten hukumnamas, khadauns - wooden slippers, a wooden rabab - a musical instrument, metal utensils like pitchers, plates, bowls etc., handwritten letters, kirpan and bed-sheets used by of the 10th Guru, Sri Guru Gobind Singh and shoes of Mata Sahib Kaur. These relics were located, catalogued and photographed by the team of National Institute of Panjab Studies. Apart from these relics, Dr. Mohinder Singh, Head of the institute, said, on display would be rare Guru Granth Birs from Bhai Vir Singh Sahitya Sadan collection, including rare Bahowali Pothi and a mini Guru Granth Sahib 1” x 1 ¼” prepared for Sikh soldiers during the second World War. For the first time English, German, French, Spanish, Urdu and Hindi translation will also be on display under one roof. The exhibition has been organised as a result of initiative taken by INTACH , the National Institute of Panjab Studies, and the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Committee. The relics would be on display in Guru Granth Sahib Bhawan, Gurdwara Rakab Ganj, in the Capital till November 29.