Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

reply · 19 Sep 2005

Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book Kim Bolan is the reporter for the Vancouver Sun who specializes in defaming Sikhs with wildly one-sided articles. (For example, when some manmukh beat up his wife, she said it was because Sikhs belong to a "warrior religion." Hmm, well, what sort of religion do all of the rest of the criminals in Canada's prisons belong to?) She has apparently now written a book by patching together all the evidence that the judge ruled inadmissible. Think, for a moment, why evidence is ruled inadmissible: It doesn't meet the standard for evidence in a country with a democratic setup. Doesn't Kim Bolan understand this? Or perhaps she would prefer "Star Chamber" type proceedings of medieval England or present-day India. Bolan and cohorts are saying there should be justice. Fine. I think we should agree that whoever comitted this act should hang. If it was Malik/Bagri, hang them. And if it was the detestable Indian spy community, extradite and hang them. Why was critical evidence in this case destroyed? Why did the Canadian authorities fail to investigate the Indian embassy officials? All so that a Canadian company could bid on an Indian gas project? For shame. Do politicians have any religion beyond money? (Evil never bears good fruit: After the Indian ambassador had done the bidding of the spy agencies, he was killed when he returned to India. What good did it do you to commit such a dastardly act? Death here and rot in hell. Gurbani says, Committing sins, you have no beli/friend.) Note that even though the crime was used to paint the Sikhs as terrorists threatening the Western countries, many of the passengers plus the pilot were Sikhs themselves. Everyone on this site should definitely take the time to read through the following sites: The second link is to a book called Soft Target, which details the highly suspicious actions of Indian embassy officials, who after determining that this particular plane would be blown up, had their own relatives cancel their flights. Excerpt: " Curiously, Malik (Surinder Malik, the Indian Consul general in Toronto) knew more about the details of the blast than did the police investigators. " This book is banned by the intelligence agencies and bureaucrats that control "the world's largest democracy". Also, please don't buy Bolan's book, "just to see what see says"; you'll just be filling up a hateful woman's coffers. Read it at a library, read excerpts at amazon.com or read it Barnes & Nobles or whatever store is nearest you. Note for Siddarth and Sitara ji: Criticism of the Government of India doesn't mean you hate the country, just as criticism of the King of England for its Star Chamber doesn't mean you are against England. Rather, it's tough love. The same sort of mentality that can kill innocent Indians to defame Sikhs is exactly the kind of mentality that leads bureaucrats and politicians to drink the blood of the parja (people) of India, as mentioned in Asa di Var. [%sig%]

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Maybe · 19 Sep 2005

when Malik and Bagri were aquitted...Bolan looked like an idiot she spent God knows over a decade trying to prove them guilty in the court of public opinion...and she succeeded...but in the end looked like a loser when the judge said "not guilty".. this book is her way of salvaging some respect...haha...poor old crank. probably has a dartboard at home with Malik and Bagri all smiles...

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

AS · 19 Sep 2005

Kim Bolan is just attempting to stir up controversy again. That is what she thrives on. Now she's gonna try to cash in on this book...think about it, whether you agree with her or not, you're still going to be interested in what she has to say and will probably buy or read her book somehow. This means that she is just going to attract more attention and get more money, publicity etc... and at the same time will attempt to smear the Sikhs again, that's what she wants. This Kim Bolan has been hell bent on portaying true GurSikhs in a negative light since the beginning and I doubt she'll ever change. It's pretty easy to tell just how biased and one sided her articles are. I'll try to dig up some of the old newspaper articles Ms. Bolan has written so the SInghs and Singhnees who don't live in BC can see for themselves. I think all of us should take some time to write or email the Vancouver Sun and tell them how inaccurate and sunjective her reporting is and encourage our family and friends to do the same. A reporter has to strive to be objective but her articles look like something out of some tabloid. Like reply said, don't buy her book but read it on the internet or at the library. That way you'll see just how biased her writing is without putting your hard earned money into her grimmy pockets.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

HEy · 19 Sep 2005

AS Singh do us a favor...make a collection of the controversial things she's said against sikhs...so we have some hard proof...wouldn't mind setting up a site to document her bias in a PROFESSIONAL manner, instead of the ususall rants we go on...cause at the end of the day, her writing reaches the masses, our's doesn't...lets change that.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

DSB · 20 Sep 2005

Do you not have an independent press complaints organisation in Canada like the UK? The press in the UK are very careful on what they say about minorities because of press monitoring. If a group of organisations ,Gurdwaras got together and wrote to them about Bolan it would be more effective.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Zorawar Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Kim Bolan syle of journalism is not really suited to Vancouver SUn, more like Sunday Sport or National Enquirer. Sikh need to either do a case on her for deformation. In the mentime, there should ba worldwide petition signed by all sikhs to get Vancouver sun to sack her. Plus everyone should write to the vancouver sun, asking how it can justify such bad journalism.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

S Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Soft Target is a pretty poor book. Contrary to what you read it does not even point a finger at Indian Intelligence. It questions the source of Parmars wealth and the fact that Malik or Bagri (forgot which one, the one with the finance/credit union business) was on the one hand advocating anti India views but pretty happy taking large loans from nationilised Indian banks. No doubt Kim Bolans book is just an attempt to profit from this terrorist outrage. We all know she has no invesitgative skills and is a poor journalist.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

amorphous_singh · 20 Sep 2005

AS wrote: > will probably buy or read her book somehow. This means that she Reading her book (diatribe?/disinformation?) is probably ok as that is the best way to education people about what she says. Those who do read it should publish counter tracts; which should be coherent, well argued and presented articles. Buying her book is contributing to her financially - so please don't buy her book. I'm sure you'll still be able to read a copy somehow as indicated previously. > try to dig up some of the old newspaper articles Ms. Bolan has > written so the SInghs and Singhnees who don't live in BC can > see for themselves. I think all of us should take some time to That would be useful; but even those of us not based in Canada are well aware of her articles and attitude. http://bolanwatch.org <--- anyone ??? Get it before she does ;-) The Internet a great campaigning tool! > write or email the Vancouver Sun and tell them how inaccurate > and sunjective her reporting is and encourage our family and > friends to do the same. A reporter has to strive to be > objective but her articles look like something out of some > tabloid. Like reply said, don't buy her book but read it on > the internet or at the library. That way you'll see just how > biased her writing is without putting your hard earned money > into her grimmy pockets. There's a further step here but it will depend on the BC community putting "their money where their mouth is" - actively BOYCOTT the VANCOUVER SUN as well; this is where much of her writing gets published. Don't advertise with them, don't read it, don't touch it. As a community get together and put out your own leaflets advising againt it's purchase. Even a small dent is a dent in their pocket and thats the only currency that talks with businesses. Even with some limited campaigning you'll pretty soon only have Sikh Uncle Toms supporting it. There's probably not much that can be done about these Uncle Toms other than to expose them as Uncle Toms. Maybe you're already doing that - I'm too far away geographically to know what happening on the floor. What do have to lose by boyotting the Sun and Kim Bolans - abosutely nothing; what do you have to gain? Some dignity at least and a lot more besides.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Zorawar Singh · 20 Sep 2005

maybe a expose should be done on Kim Bolan exposing all the lies she has made up against sikhs over the last decade.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Jagdeep Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Can somebody explain to me exactly what she has said wrong? Not in general terms about how she is bigoted and biased etc, but specific instances of what she has said that are wrong. If there has been extremism or malfeasance amongst Sikhs we should not be so sensitive to having it exposed. Mounting a campaign against Kim Bolan in the way you are suggesting is vindictive and will have a counter effect to the one you are trying to achieve - can you imagine for a moment the kind of publicity she and her book will get if you try to persecute a journalist for writing a book? It will be seen as trying to censor and will be seen in the context of personal villification. If you want to counter her arguments write about them forensically and specifically - I gurantee that the kind of thing you do (attempting to get her sacked) will end up making Sikhs look much worse - and provide publicity for the book it would not otherwise get.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Singh · 20 Sep 2005

can canada singh create a website like bolan watch with all her articles, then we in Uk can also write with proof against her writings.

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

LionKing (LK) · 19 Nov 2005

Singho, I can help with this project of making a website, however content will have to be provided by Canadian Singhs, I can only help with the website itself. Please email me if someone is interested in collecting false info she's spread about Sikhi, and we shall organise something thanks Vaheguru Ji Ka KHalsa Vaheguru JI Ki Fateh

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

What I think · 19 Nov 2005

I haven't read the book...but I feel that Sikh's were involved in air india bombing, maybe they did it on instructions from Indian Govt. to give bad name to Khalistan movement....but I don't think anybody have any doubts that people who were responsible have gotten away....CICS had to destroy the evidence as it exposed their own involvement and exposed the involvement of RAW (indian secrect agency)

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Gupt Singh · 20 Nov 2005

I don't understad one thing. How come Bagri and Malik have been released, but Inderjit Singh Reyat hasnt? Could the sangat please give us information on the latest of Inderjit Singh Reyat?

Re: Kim Bolan at it again: New Air India book

Admin · 21 Nov 2005

d singh, we've emailed "[address removed]" with a reply to your question