Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 16 Sep 2005

I was hoping someone here would answer these questions for me about bhai sahib randhir singh. 1) At what age did Bhai Sahib receive Amrit? 2) Did Bhai Sahib come from an Amritdhaari family? 3) When did Bhai Sahib begin to keep Sarbloh Bibek? 4) Was Bhai Sahib given Saas Giraas technique of simran from Panj Pyareh when bhai Sahib was first bestowed Amrit? 5) Which maryada was given to Bhai Sahib when he first recieved Amrit? please answer these questions for me. Veer Kulbir Singh please help answer these questions for me. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Rashpal Singh · 17 Sep 2005

1) Bh Sahib was 25 yrs old when he took amrit. 2) His family was influenced by him after he took amrit so originally his family was not amritdhari. 3) He kept Sarbloh Bibek as soon as he took amrit, but im not sure if he practiced it beforehand. 4) No, Bhai Randhir Singh did not get Saas Giraas technique when he was given amrit. 5) Whatever the normal maryada was at that time was given to him. [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 17 Sep 2005

Do you know if Bhai Sahib ever got Pesh from Panj Pyareh? If so when, and why? and if not, well then the when and why dont apply. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifatheh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Kulbir Singh · 17 Sep 2005

Chiranjeev Singh ----------- 1) At what age did Bhai Sahib receive Amrit? -------- I think he was in his mid twenties when he was blessed with Amrit. ------ 2) Did Bhai Sahib come from an Amritdhaari family? --------- No. ---------- 3) When did Bhai Sahib begin to keep Sarbloh Bibek? -------- Bhai Sahib had bibek i.e. not eating from non-amritdhaaris even before amrit. However, he kept Sarbloh in 1902 or 1903, before he got enlightened. -------- 4) Was Bhai Sahib given Saas Giraas technique of simran from Panj Pyareh when bhai Sahib was first bestowed Amrit? --------- Bhai Sahib did not even get Naam DriR from Punj Pyaray because Naam was given to him by a person who was not part of punj pyaray. Bhai Sahib writes that by receiving amrit he did get a new janam and his "kaya palat gayee" but Naam he did not get. How he got Naam driR can be read in the first part of Jail Chithiaan. --------- 5) Which maryada was given to Bhai Sahib when he first recieved Amrit? ----------- Bhai Sahib got pesh in the amrit samagam organized by the top Sikh Jatha of that time - Panch Khalsa Diwan. Panch Khalsa Diwan got deviated from the Gurmat path around 1913-1915 when Babu Teja Singh got wrong notions in his head. At that point, Bhai Sahib severed his ties with Panch Khalsa Diwan. Because Panch Khalsa Diwan deviated from Gurmat in their later years, Panth has forgotten the wonderful sewa they did of Panth from 1890s to about 1913-1914. It was their efforts alone that brought Sikhi to Malwa region of Punjab. If Panch Khalsa Diwan had not been there, Malwa would not have been Sikh. The Udasis and Nirmalas and other non-Khalsa orders had Malwa in their control. Singh Sabha Lehar worked through Panch Khalsa Diwan in Malwa region. Sant Attar Singh Mastuanawalay used to head the conferences of Panch Khalsa Diwan. Panch Khalsa Diwan was an avid supporter of dastar for bibiyaan and they also believed in Bibek, just like other Singhs of that time. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 17 Sep 2005

veer Kulbir Singh Jee, with love and satkaar, you have referred to me as Chiranjeev a couple times i think (dont worry, others singhs i have met have too). I know Chiranjeev is in Gurbaani, and you might feel that my name is such in Gurmukhi and i have mispronounced it in english. However by Guru Sahibs Bakhshish, my name is charanjeev singh (my jeev (body, life and atmaa live at the charan of my Guru, Sangat, and all humanity, singh was bestowed to me by my father, Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee) My other questions please answer these for me veerji and respected sangat. 1) If bhai sahib randheer singh did not receive saas giraas technique, where did this originate from? bhai sahib served as panj pyareh right? and if bhai sahib did not receive this technique, how come bhai sahib was instrumental in giving this technique as panj pyareh? 2) Did Bhai Sahib gain enlightment without saas giraas technique? I would imagine bhai sahib gained Waheguruus' presence through Araadnaa (this is the only way i believe one can attain Waheguruu Jees' Kingdom(Prakaash) whiile living on earth). 3) Do you know who were the first Panj Pyareh in the Jatha? and if any of them had recieved Saas Giraas Technique of Simran when they had first taken Amrit? and if so, do you know where they had been bestowed the boon of Amrit? The reason i ask this is as such. I am only going to touch the surface, for i only have limited knowledge. In all of us, there is what is called the kundulini, a snake coiled up you can say. And it is dormant. When this awakens, it pierces the dasam duaar. This can be awakened through two methods, one is araadhnaa (deep samadhi simran and milaap with Waheguru), the other is through a technique of breathing which is saas giraas technique with Waheguruu Simran. I know that enlightned souls have realized this, and other secrets of the body. My belief is that Gursikhs, whom have realized this secret of the body, realized two ways. Please understand, araadhnaa is very difficult, and it requires absolute prem. The Saas Giraas Technique can come with abyaaas. I believe that Gursikhs wanted everybody to feel this anand (when the kundalini rises, there is a blast of anand and bliss), however with araadha there is parkaash. I believe that realized souls wanted to all to feel this bliss, and this is why the saas giraas technique was given. However, i believe it was not the the method as given by the original Panj Pyareh. The original Panj Pyareh also gave Naam Drirtha. It was given a different method where Gursikhs would be given Parkhash through Araadhnaa. I would like to know before bhai sahib, and before the akand keertan jatha came to be, as we now know bhai sahib was not given the saas giraas technique, were other gursikhs whom served as panth khalsa through Panj Pyareh in the jatha recieve this method? And if so, where were they bestowed Amrit dee Daath? bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

k4ur · 17 Sep 2005

how did bhai sahib start keeping sarabloh?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

singh · 17 Sep 2005

bhai sahib realised waheguroo through aradhana charanjeev ji then as naam kamai sessions were done the saas giraas technique came into play

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Sengh · 18 Sep 2005

if the saas giraas method should only come through abhiyaas and should not be given by guru sahib, why is the method mentioned in bhai mani singhs, prem surag granth, and in sau sakhi guru gobind singh explains it to mata jeeto ji? in sant attar singhs (mastuana wale) biography written by sant teja singh, it says the same thing. if u are given naam drirrh, these types of PO-ed out theories would not be made up by people

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Paapi · 18 Sep 2005

So is saas giraas from guru jee's times?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

:) · 18 Sep 2005

Does anyone know where i can get Bhai Sahibs book jail chitian from, in the uk?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

s · 18 Sep 2005

aradhana? please explain?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singhstah · 18 Sep 2005

:) wrote: > Does anyone know where i can get Bhai Sahibs book jail chitian > from, in the uk? Sikh missionary society, theres also the site www.thebookthatchangedmylife.com

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

singh · 19 Sep 2005

send your postal address and you will get a copy [address removed]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 19 Sep 2005

if you are in uk and need any jail chettay in englishor punjabi please post your detials here andi will send the book by post . Also have alot of bahi saihbs other books in punjabi inclusing ranglay sujan etc.....

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 19 Sep 2005

can kulbir singh or some one else answer chiranjeev singh's questions in detail?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Kulbir Singh · 19 Sep 2005

Veer Charanjeev Singh jeeo, Please accept my humble apologies for misspelling your name. For some reason, I did not read your name as “Charanjeev” but read it as “Chiranjeev”. ---------- 1) If bhai sahib randheer singh did not receive saas giraas technique, where did this originate from? bhai sahib served as panj pyareh right? and if bhai sahib did not receive this technique, how come bhai sahib was instrumental in giving this technique as panj pyareh? 2) Did Bhai Sahib gain enlightment without saas giraas technique? I would imagine bhai sahib gained Waheguruus' presence through Araadnaa (this is the only way i believe one can attain Waheguruu Jees' Kingdom(Prakaash) whiile living on earth). ------------- Bhai Sahib got Naam Drir directly from Guru Sahib. You should read Jail Chithian in detail to understand this. Bhai Sahib’s case was a unique one. What happened to Bhai Sahib may be repeated again with some other fortunate Gursikh but it makes logical sense to give technique of Naam when Naam is given by Punj Pyaray. I Don't understand, why this is seen as a problem by some. ------------ 3) Do you know who were the first Panj Pyareh in the Jatha? and if any of them had recieved Saas Giraas Technique of Simran when they had first taken Amrit? and if so, do you know where they had been bestowed the boon of Amrit? ---------- I don’t have answer to this. It could very much be that all Singhs who first started doing sewa in Punj learned the technique as Bhai Sahib did i.e. directly from Guru Sahib. ---------- In all of us, there is what is called the kundulini, a snake coiled up you can say. And it is dormant. When this awakens, it pierces the dasam duaar. This can be awakened through two methods, one is araadhnaa (deep samadhi simran and milaap with Waheguru), the other is through a technique of breathing which is saas giraas technique with Waheguruu Simran. -------- Please backup this claim through Gurbani. Please show us where in Gurbani it is written that Kundalini pierces through Dasam Duaar. Yes, the kundalini does get awakened but that’s just the side effect of doing Naam Abhyaas. That kundalini which Yogis want awakened very badly and for what they do numerous very hard exercises, gets awakened within a Gurmukh without any effort. Kundalini has no function in Dasam Duaar. It is Mann that reaches Dasam Duaar and gets Darshan of Vaheguru. -------- I know that enlightned souls have realized this, and other secrets of the body. My belief is that Gursikhs, whom have realized this secret of the body, realized two ways. Please understand, araadhnaa is very difficult, and it requires absolute prem. The Saas Giraas Technique can come with abyaaas. I believe that Gursikhs wanted everybody to feel this anand (when the kundalini rises, there is a blast of anand and bliss), however with araadha there is parkaash. I believe that realized souls wanted to all to feel this bliss, and this is why the saas giraas technique was given. However, i believe it was not the the method as given by the original Panj Pyareh. The original Panj Pyareh also gave Naam Drirtha. It was given a different method where Gursikhs would be given Parkhash through Araadhnaa. ------------- All this sounds like some Sant-dumm propaganda. Gurbani does not recognize your so called two methods namely Aradhana and Saas Giraas Method separate from each other. Saas Giraas Naam Abhyaas is saadhna and this is Araadhna. Aradhna means to worship and Sikhs worship through Naam. What Aradhana are you talking about? -------------- I would like to know before bhai sahib, and before the akand keertan jatha came to be, as we now know bhai sahib was not given the saas giraas technique, were other gursikhs whom served as panth khalsa through Panj Pyareh in the jatha recieve this method? And if so, where were they bestowed Amrit dee Daath? --------------- It has been proven beyond doubt by Balpreet Singh that Saas Giraas method appears in historical texts before Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was even born. Saas Giraas method must have been given along with Naam at the time of amrit. It makes logical sense to impart the technique of Naam along with Naam. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 19 Sep 2005

Despite the fact this may offend many, for the overwhelming majority of those who have actually received Naam Drirrh, the experience on its own is more than enough to convince anyone that it is a Puratan technique from Guru Nanak Dev Ji's time.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 19 Sep 2005

veer kulbir singh jee, waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh Firstly you have mentioned that Bhai Sahib recieced Naam Drir directly from Guru Sahib. I absolutely adhere to this and believe this, for this is the only way to receive Naam Drir. Naam Drir is when a drop mixes with the ocean, and cannot be seperated again. Naam Drir, is not what you think it is. Naam drir is received after a Gursikh following the teachings of Guru Sahib, 'Araadh' waheguruu after receiving Waheguruu Mantar from Panj Pyareh. The way you mentioned that Naam Dritha with breathing is logical sense is wrong. It is not Gurmat to give this in actuality. It takes away the Gurmukhs chance to Araadh Waheguruu, for s/he then in duality believe that breathing style leads to Waheguruu. You can never have Parkash of Waheguruu this way. The only way is through Araadhna. sadhaa sadhaa aaraadhheeai eaehaa math visaekh || ang 49 Forever and ever, worship and adore Him; this is the most wonderful wisdom. Araadhna is the only way to recieve Waheguruu Parkash. However breathing technique can open dasam duar through kundalini arising and piercing dasam duar nioulee karam bhueia(n)gam bhaat(h)ee || raechak ku(n)bhak poorak man haat(h)ee || paakha(n)dd dhharam preeth nehee har so gur sabadh mehaa ras paaeiaa ||14|| ang 1042 Inner cleansing techniques, channeling the energy to raise the Kundalini to the Tenth Gate, inhaling, exhaling and holding the breath by the force of the mind - by empty hypocritical practices, Dharmic love for the Lord is not produced. Only through the Word of the Guru's Shabad is the sublime, supreme essence obtained. ||14|| Please read this entire shabad. The first 10 pauris the Guru talks about Araadhna and the true fom of Simran. In Pauris 10 to 14 Guru sahib talks about manmat practices, including raising the kundalini to the dasam duar (breathing saas saas technique). Please note, it still rises to the dasam duar, and opens the tenth gate, however this method is not the way the Guru taught. The Guru taught us Araadhnaa Simran, as Bhai Sahib learned and realized through Gurbaani, and Guru Sahibs' Kirpaa. This method is very difficult, and only a few very fortunate recieve this Kirpaa, and this is how a Gurmukh is born. The other way (with saas breathing), one can still recieve anand and bliss, because when the tenth gate opens, there is blast of anand and bliss, however, this is not the path of the Gursikh, the path of a Gursikh, is to Araadh Waheguruu, and live in Waheguruu Jees Parkash and thus becomes a Gurmukh. Saas Giraas technique is not arraadhna, it is yoga with saadhna. Araadhnaa is veechar, and cannot be narrated by words. When the dasam duar opens this way, the Amrit tricles down and forever it rains Waheguruus' Parkaash. The breathing technique is not accepted by Gurmat even though it rises the kundalini to open the dasam duar. The dasam duar when opened by Araadhnaa is accepted raamakalee ghar 2 baanee kabeer jee kee ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || ba(n)dhhach ba(n)dhhan paaeiaa || mukathai gur anal bujhaaeiaa || jab nakh sikh eihu man cheenhaa || thab a(n)thar majan keenhaa ||1|| pavanapath ounaman rehan kharaa || nehee mirath n janam jaraa ||1|| rehaao || oulattee lae sakath sehaara(n) || paiseelae gagan majhaara(n) || baedhheealae chakr bhua(n)gaa || bhaetteealae raae nisa(n)gaa ||2|| chookeealae moh maeiaasaa || sas keeno soor giraasaa || jab ku(n)bhak bharipur leenaa || theh baajae anehadh beenaa ||3|| bakathai bak sabadh sunaaeiaa || sunathai sun ma(n)n basaaeiaa || kar karathaa outharas paara(n) || kehai kabeeraa saara(n) ||4||1||10|| ang 971 Raamkalee, Second House, The Word Of Kabeer Jee: One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: Maya, the Trapper, has sprung her trap. The Guru, the Liberated One, has put out the fire. When I came to understand this mind, from the tips of my toes to the crown of my head, then I took my cleansing bath, deep within my self. ||1|| The mind, the master of the breath, abides in the state of supreme bliss. There is no death, no re-birth, and no aging for me now. ||1||Pause|| Turning away from materialism, I have found intuitive support. I have entered into the sky of the mind, and opened the Tenth Gate. The chakras of the coiled Kundalini energy have been opened, and I have met my Sovereign Lord King without fear. ||2|| My attachment to Maya has been eradicated; the moon energy has devoured the sun energy. When I was focused and merged into the all-pervading Lord, then the unstruck sound current began to vibrate. ||3|| The Speaker has spoken, and proclaimed the Word of the Shabad. The hearer has heard, and enshrined it in the mind. Chanting to the Creator, one crosses over. Says Kabeer, this is the essence. ||4||1||10|| There are two ways as shown the tenth gate can open, one is Gurmat, and one is not. Gurmat is a marag of Araadhna Simran. Your stance that the technique has been proven through historical texts is false. A belief was first made (saas saas technique was given), and then the words were manipulated to fit that hypothesis. As i have said, the two methods arise the kundalini, one is Gurmat, the other is yoga and breathing with also straighten the kunalini to pierce the dasam duar. One is Gurmat and gives Waheguruu Parkash, the other is not, but gives Anand and bliss. As i have said, pyareh Gursikhs whom have realized this, wanted to benefit the masses by sharing with them the bliss, and then introduced this technique and taught it through Amrit Sanchaars. However, it is not Gurmat. I hope that all would attain Waheguruu Jees Parkash through Araadhna Simran, this is the true essence of this human jeevan. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh btw veer kulbir singh jee, as i have said to you before, the only Sant that i follow is Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, only Sant that i follow. I am a kookar of Sri Guru Granth, and Sri Guru Panth. By the Grace of the Guru may i never fall under the sway of any human, for they also make mistakes. bhulan a(n)dhar sabh ko abhul guroo karathaar || ang 61 Everyone makes mistakes; only the Guru and the Creator are infallible. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 20 Sep 2005

waheguruujikakhlasa waheguruujikifateh I have to appologize. I have said through breathing technique the kundalini can rise to the dasam duar. I have to appologize for i have made a mistake. It might not rise to pierce the dasam duar even through saas saas (breathing), hence therefore attaining anand and bliss through this method far fetched, and maybe impossible. I must applogize that i am not sure if the kundalini can even rise to the dasam duar through breathing technique at all. However, it does rise through Saad Sangat, which is the sublimest, or best form for simran and araadhnaa imho. jinahu baath nischal dhhrooa jaanee thaeee jeev kaal thae bachaa || thinh thariou samudhra rudhra khin eik mehi jalehar bi(n)b jugath jag rachaa || ku(n)ddalanee surajhee sathasa(n)gath paramaana(n)dh guroo mukh machaa || siree guroo saahib sabh oopar man bach kra(n)m saeveeai sachaa ||5|| ang 1402 Those who realize the Eternal, Unchanging Word of God, like Dhroo, are immune to death. They cross over the terrifying world-ocean in an instant; the Lord created the world like a bubble of water. The Kundalini rises in the Sat Sangat, the True Congregation; through the Word of the Guru, they enjoy the Lord of Supreme Bliss. The Supreme Guru is the Lord and Master over all; so serve the True Guru, in thought, word and deed. ||5|| We are all bachay of guru sahib, and we all make mistakes. i hope the sangat and veers and bhens whom discussions are happening with will forgive me for my mistakes and vices. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 20 Sep 2005

aradhana? please explain? neone?? [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 20 Sep 2005

i think charanjeev singh makes a lot more sense than kulbir singh. how can one come dRiR in Naam just by physical actions at an Amrit Sanchaar - to me, dRiRtaa of Naam comes after intense Bhagtee, BaiRaag and Simran, so that an individual remembers Waheguru Swaas Swaas --> not at the Amrit Sanchaar The way Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh got Naam dRiRtaa from Guru Ji is consistent with how his love for Guru Ji and Waheguru meant that the Guru blessed him to remember God all the time. This is also consistent with how other Gurmukhs came to remember Guru Jee and Waheguru Swaas Swaas However, the Naam Abhiyaas technique taught by AKJ is one method towards helping to remember Waheguru Swaas Swaas. True Naam dRiRtaa comes from loving Waheguru by realising His greatness through understanding Gurbani, not through a physical breathing exercise - but nevertheless, the physical breathing exercise and repeating Waheguru can be part of the process, but it is not the exclusive way of getting Naam dRiRtaa * Can you provide a link of Balpreet Singh's research into the AKJ Naam dRiR method

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 20 Sep 2005

There are references to the naam technique in puraatan sources: Sant Teja Singh wrote the following: "The method of reciting naam (naam japan dee jugath) has been passed down from Gursikh to Gursikh. But this daas has only seen it written in two places. In Sau Sakhi its says that Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj tells Mata Jeetho Ji that the tip of the tounge (jeeb di teesy), with force (jOr naal), should touch the roof of the mouth (thaloo naal), and at all times keep saying Waheguru Waheguru. Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh, the one who sat and listened to the recitation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji by Sri Guru Gobind Singh himself, in Bhai Gurdas Ji's 'yarwee waar' in 'sheeha thay gajan dee sakhee', has written that when our breath goes in we should say 'Wahe' and when our breath goes out we should say 'guru'" also, In Prem Sumarag Granth it is written: "oupar saas naabh tay "vaah" say layvai, ar talay kaa saas "guru" say chhoDay. Vahiguru daa jap karai." Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was a very blessed soul in that he was given a number of rehits directly by Guru Sahib. This includes naam driR and sarbloh. That doesn't mean that we should wait for the same enlightenment. Old rehitnamas and Gursikhs will tell you that these were rehits. If the punj pyaaray are teaching these rehits, isn't it our own haumai if we say we won't go to learn them? I have done naam simran without naam driR and with. It makes a difference. That's enough evidence fore me. But if you don't feel any need and you are focussed completely, who's forcing you to go learn it?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

kulbir Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh, ------------------ Firstly you have mentioned that Bhai Sahib recieced Naam Drir directly from Guru Sahib. I absolutely adhere to this and believe this, for this is the only way to receive Naam Drir. Naam Drir is when a drop mixes with the ocean, and cannot be seperated again. Naam Drir, is not what you think it is. Naam drir is received after a Gursikh following the teachings of Guru Sahib, 'Araadh' waheguruu after receiving Waheguruu Mantar from Panj Pyareh. ------------ What you have written above is your interpretation of things. You write that Naam Drir is when a drop mixes with ocean. It seems like you are talking about the charam avastha or the topmost avastha of a Gursikh. Naam Drir simply means the process when Naam is made drir to the new seeker. What does the word driR mean? Drir means pakka, mazboot, strong resolved etc. At the time of amrit sinchaar, punj pyaray make naam drir to abhilaakhi by “activating” naam in the body. Everyone has naam inside as per the following pankiti: Naunidh amrit prabh ka naam|| Dehi meh iska bisraam|| (The naam of Prabhu parmatam is all treasures. This naam is placed in the human body.) The punj pyaray activate this naam inside the body. When the seeker hears the Amrit Naam from the amrit Rasna (tongue) of Punj Pyaray, Naam gets activated in the seeker. This is called Naam Drir karna. Included in Naam Drir is the way or method to japp Naam. After all, what would you do with a word if you don't know what to do with it i.e. how to japp it? So punj pyaray teach naam abhyaas at the time of Naam Drirta. There is no other way to get naam drir but through Guru Sahib and after amrit chhak. What you are talking about is the topmost avastha that comes after doing sewa of Naam by japping it i.e. doing aradhana of it. Aradhana of Naam and Japna of Naam are one and the same thing but you seem to be confused on this. ------------ The way you mentioned that Naam Dritha with breathing is logical sense is wrong. It is not Gurmat to give this in actuality. It takes away the Gurmukhs chance to Araadh Waheguruu, for s/he then in duality believe that breathing style leads to Waheguruu. You can never have Parkash of Waheguruu this way. The only way is through Araadhna. --------- If you have never experienced the process of Naam Drir, then you should not pass your judgement the way you are doing above. I don’t think you understand what Swaas Swaas vidhi of Naam Abhyaas is. You are apparently mixing it with some breathing technique like Pranayaam. You say that “you can never have parkash of waheguruu this way”. What kind of nonsense statement is this? What do you know about Gurmat Vidhi of Naam Abhyaas? You are mixing it with Pranayaam or other breathing techniques. First of all, to do Naam Abhyaas is Gurmat way of Aradhana. What other way of aradhna is there but to japp Naam? Japping Naam is Aradhana and Aradhna means to japp Naam. Prastish of Naam, Ibaadat of Naam, Pooja of Naam, Aradhana of Naam are all same thing. Today you are saying that Dasam Duaar can open only with Aradhana. Tomorrow some chela of a fake sant will say that Dasam Duaar can open only with the pooja of Akal Purakh. Then someone will say it opens only with Prastish of Naam. The fact of the matter is that all these words Japna, Aradhana, Vicharna, Pooja, Ibaadat and Prastish of Naam is same thing. It all means to japp Naam. What is aradhana? Aradhana means worshipping Vaheguru. How do Gursikhs worship Vaheguru? By japping Naam and by singing his praises through Gurbani. What other form of Aradhana are your talking about? ---------- sadhaa sadhaa aaraadhheeai eaehaa math visaekh || ang 49 Forever and ever, worship and adore Him; this is the most wonderful wisdom. Araadhna is the only way to recieve Waheguruu Parkash. However breathing technique can open dasam duar through kundalini arising and piercing dasam duar ------- Just re-read the pankiti you have quoted. How do you do Aradhana “Sada Sada”? How else but by Japping Naam? And how do you japp Naam? How else but by Gurmat Technique written in Gurbani numerous times: Saas saas simro Gobind|| Mann antar kee utrai chind|| (Do simran of Gobind, Swaas swaas. All your worries of your mind will get removed). You write that Aradhana is the only way to get Vaheguru parkash but according to Gurmat, Naam japna is doing aradhana. No other way. Naam is aradhana for Gursikhs. Singing Gurbani is aradhana for Gursikhs. What else are you talking about? What other way is there to do Aradhana of Vaheguru but by japping him according to Gurmat. And why do you keep mentioning Kundalini? Why are you so worried about awakening kundalini? This is the Yogic way and not Gurmat way to think of kundalini. All kundalinis and Sukhmana Ida and Pingula fall in place when Gurmat Naam is japped. Gursikhs do not try to awaken kundalini and don’t worry about Sukhmana, Ida or Pingula. ---------------- nioulee karam bhueia(n)gam bhaat(h)ee || raechak ku(n)bhak poorak man haat(h)ee || paakha(n)dd dhharam preeth nehee har so gur sabadh mehaa ras paaeiaa ||14|| ang 1042 Inner cleansing techniques, channeling the energy to raise the Kundalini to the Tenth Gate, inhaling, exhaling and holding the breath by the force of the mind - by empty hypocritical practices, Dharmic love for the Lord is not produced. Only through the Word of the Guru's Shabad is the sublime, supreme essence obtained. ||14|| ----------- Again you are mixing Gurmat Vidhi of Naam Abhyaas with Pranayaam. Empty breathing techniques or other worries of Kundalini etc don’t get us anywhere. The thing to do is to get engaged in Naam Abhyaas. Doesn’t the last pankiti that you quoted above make this clear that Gur-Shabad does it all? I again humbly request you to not mix up Gurmat Vidhi with some breathing technique. It seems like you don’t have experience with Naam dee vidhiee and as such should not pass judgement without knowing it. Non-akj gursikhs like Sant Attar Singh Mastuanawale used to japp Naam through swaas swaas technique. Those Mahapurakhs who first started by just saying Vaheguru Vaheguru, ended up doing swaas swaas. Swaas swaas is the way to go. And it won’t be out of place to mention that swaas swaas vidhi is only the start. After some time, the shabad movement in the body from naabh kamal to Dasam duaar can be done without the swaas. Gursikhs stop the pawan in Naabh Kamal and with surthee do abhyaas the same way as they would have done swaas swaas. All this happens with time. -------------. The other way (with saas breathing), one can still recieve anand and bliss, because when the tenth gate opens, there is blast of anand and bliss, however, this is not the path of the Gursikh, the path of a Gursikh, is to Araadh Waheguruu, and live in Waheguruu Jees Parkash and thus becomes a Gurmukh. --------- I don’t know who is feeding all this misinformation to you. It has to be some sant baba who is telling you all this. You are mixing Gurmat Naam Abhyaas vidhi with some Pranayaam technique of Yogis. Please get your facts straight before passing judgement. ------------ Saas Giraas technique is not arraadhna, it is yoga with saadhna. Araadhnaa is veechar, and cannot be narrated by words. When the dasam duar opens this way, the Amrit tricles down and forever it rains Waheguruus' Parkaash. The breathing technique is not accepted by Gurmat even though it rises the kundalini to open the dasam duar. The dasam duar when opened by Araadhnaa is accepted ----------- First of all, you are quoting irrelevant Gurbani pankities here. You write above that Saas Giraas technique is not aradhana. Who told you it’s not? Aradhana means worship and Gursikhs worship Akal Purakh through Naam and Gurbani. You write that Aradhana is veechar and cannot be narrated by words. What are you talking about? In most places when the word “vichaar” comes with Naam, it means to japp Naam. What else are you going to do with one word? The only thing you can do is Japp Naam with Gurmat Vidhi that involves not only your tongue but also your ears and your whole mind and devotion. You write that breathing technique is not accepted by Gurmat. I say that you don’t have a clue what Gurmat Vidhi of Naam is; otherwise you would not have written all this. You write”Dasam Duaar opens when aradhana is accepted”. What other aradhana are you talking about than japping Naam? Japping Naam is aradhana and pooja for Gursikhs. Har Araadh na jaana re|| Har Har Gur Guru Karta re|| (I don’t know any complicated ways of Aradhana mentioned in Aanmat Granths. All I know is to japp Naam). What more do you need to hear about Aradhana after reading the above pankiti? ---------- As i have said, the two methods arise the kundalini, one is Gurmat, the other is yoga and breathing with also straighten the kunalini to pierce the dasam duar. One is Gurmat and gives Waheguruu Parkash, the other is not, but gives Anand and bliss. ----------- Under the spell of ignorance, you are equating Gurmat Vidhi of Naam abhyaas mentioned in Gurbani countless times, with Pranayaam or other breathing techniques of Hinduism and Buddhism. And stop talking about Kundalini. Kundalini is a yogic thing and Gursikhs don’t worry about it. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 20 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh, To put everything in very simple terms; many people mimmick like parrots. i have a pet parrot who says waheguruu waheguruu; however by saying my baby (parrot) is not doing true simran; however it is still fortunate. all i am saying is dont mimmick, you seem to be pro mimmicker; i am not. (for people reading this, even though i have mentioned the parrot, and if it has come to your mind to get one, please do not. i had raised these babies many years ago, and have come to realize that birds should not be kept as pets, and should be free. the babies (parrots) i have cannot be released into the wild because they will not survive;) Kulbir Singh, i assure you i know what i am talking about; its you whom im worried about. But anyway, i have said all i wanted to say; and this will be my last post. All pyareh Gursikhs, please do ardaas that all matheen (unknowledgeble) souls, like myself, be blessed with summat (sublime) understanding. bhul chuk mauf to all and you kulbir singh waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

kulbir Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh jeeo, It is unfortunate that you have not answered any of the issues raised in my emails. Let me repeat them again: 1) You keep mentioning kundalini in your emails and have put too much emphasis on awakening it. Please show me one Gurbani pankiti that says that we should try to awaken the kundalini. Gursikhs don't worry whether the kundalini awakens or not. They are not focussed on this. Yes, Yogis sure are focussed on this. It seems like you or your sant are too influenced by yogis. 2) You wrote that Kundalini pierces through the Dasam Duaar. Please show one Gurbani pankiti to back up this Yogic claim of yours. 3) You have written that Aradhana is different from Swaas Swaas Simran and my stand was that Swaas Swaas simran is what Aradhana, pooja, Prastish, Ibaadat etc is for a Gursikh. Please prove that Aradhana is different from Naam Abhyaas. Back up your claim through Gurbani. The quotes you gave were all irrelevant. 4) Please prove through Gurbani that Swaas Swaas Simran is prohibited in Gurbani. You have dared to attack the most basic foundation of Gurmat - Swaas Swaas Simran. You have dismissed it calling it a "Breathing technique". You have written that it is against Gurmat to do so. Pray tell us, if it is against Gurmat, then why is it mentioned in Gurbani again and again. 5) Why did you attack Swaas Swaas simran when you yourself don't know anything about his technique? You never got Naam DriR but you still dared to challenge it. What is your hidden agenda and why did you attack the most basic foundation of Khalsa Panth. -------- many people mimmick like parrots. i have a pet parrot who says waheguruu waheguruu; however by saying my baby (parrot) is not doing true simran; however it is still fortunate. all i am saying is dont mimmick, you seem to be pro mimmicker; i am not. -------- What does it mean when Guru Sahib writes: Har Araadh na Jaana re|| Har Har Gur Gur Karta re||? And let me assure you that Gurmat Vidhi of Naam Simran is by no means "Mimicking like parrots". During the time of Bhai Sahib, manmukhs used to call Gursikhs japping Naam, "Bakree vaangoo mooh maaran waalay" and today you have inherited the legacy of those manmukhs by calling Gursikhs who japp Naam - "Mimicking like parrots". Manmukhs in olden times used to equate Gursikhs japping Naam to goats, and you today have called them "parrots". Shabaash Charanjeev Singh! Bahut Khoob!! Shabaash to the naqli sant you believe in. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Shame on Charanjeev Singh for calling abhyasi Gursikhs parrots. What a shameful thing to say. You stick to your philosophy and meditation and Gursikhs will stick to their repitition like "parrots". We'll see who gets where.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 20 Sep 2005

Firstly, swaas swaas simran is the finest form of araadhnaa. you are a yogic expert, and this is what i refer to as swaas swaas technique Kulbir singh, please re read my messages. i am against yoga and breathing technique. for example, when "you, kulbir singh" do simran, you move your head up and down, you do yoga (please tell me why you have encompassed yoga with simran?) you are trying to awaken the kundalini, not me. i have never tried, and never will. However, by the Grace of Waheguruu, it still awakens if the Guru so wishes. This was the message in my messages above. And the Gurbani Shabads that have been referenced conclude that channeling the kundalini to the dasam duar with yogic exercises (like you move your head up and down) is not Gurmat. The True Marag of Gurmat Simran is Araadhnaa, that does not encompass the moving your head up and down, like how you do it. You are a yoga expert by the way, you have just called Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee a nakli sant. shabbassh to you japping is not simply mimmicking. Aradhnaa is the finest form of Japping. btw kulbir singh, i am not even worth the dust of your feet (and the sad part is, you know it) bhul chuk mauf karna waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 20 Sep 2005

I humbly appologize for my words. The essence of the message that i wanted to discuss was not conveyed by what i wanted to share (my lack of communication skills). The essence of my message was to recite waheguruu, with every swaas, and with love. And not just mere emptiness in the heart. The essence of my message was that to recite Waheguruu with love, there is no need to channel any energies, and i used to kundalini as an example. I want to humbly applogize for my words, and have decided that i will no longer take part in any discussions on this forum. For those whom i have talked to and communicated with during the years on this forum (tapoban.org), i would like to thank you for sharing with me many kind words, and sharing of veechaars. For those whom i have disagreed with, i humbly appologize for conveying my messages if they were given in a wrongful manner. If i have done any paapaas, i humbly ask the sangat to forgive, including bhai sahib kulbir singh. I will no longer be a part of this forum, for the mishaps, are far greater than its benefits. I thank everybody, and appologize to everybody, and i ask everybody to forgive me. For those whom reply on this thread, this will be my last thread. [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Sohagani · 20 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh, Please stop with the Sant thing, it's getting old. Singh told you who his Sant was. [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 20 Sep 2005

Singh, I know of people whom do paath everyday, do sukhmani sahib everyday, do waheguruu waheguruu loudly, so everyone can hear them. Then they go and lie, cheat, and steal. They have no concience of their acts, yet still do soo much paath. They even do sehaj paaths regularly. They are whom i refer to as parrots. They do not Amal (live) the life of the Gurbaani, but recite mechanically, those of whom i am referring to as mimmickers. People whom will wear a certain kind of clothes, to give a certain image. Many gursikhs wear baana, and live their life contrary to those principles. They are mimmickers. I am not talking about true Naam Rangeeheh Pyareh Gursikhs whom have sublime understanding, and have Amal of their Gursikh Jeevan, and do paath with pyaar and veechar, and live the paath of which they are so lovingly reciting. Mimmickers are those whom portray themselves as something completely different as to whom they really are. For example; people who wear baana and swear and have girlfriends/boyfriends. People whom do paath and tell everyone they do a lot of paath, and show they do a lot of paath, and then lie, steal, and cheat. These are mimmickers. And i am saying, that a person should not be a mimmicker, but be one who is living the life of Gurbaani. There are many people whom use words as we are Panthic, and they will say everything bad as possible against Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib. These people are mimmickers. They wear the baana of Gursikhs, and then they bad mouth Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib. How can that be? There are two aspects of Guru. One is Guru Granth Sahib, and the other is Guru Panth Sahib. Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib is the foundation of Guru Panth Sahib. Some people say they are followers of Tat Maryada. When Tat is referenced in Gurmat, with maryada, it refers to how Guru Sahib had done things, from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee. Then they do not do Raag Keertan, and they still claim that they follow Tat Maryada. How can that be? They are simply mimmickers, whom use the word Tat, but do not follow it. This is what i am talking about. Those whom are True to the Guru, and follow Tat Maryada in its finest essence, whom love the Gurbaani so much that they live it so not to give a daag (stain) to the Guru, to them Namashkaarr to their pavitar charna. But such Gursikhs are far and wide, and one in millions. bhul chuk mauf waheguuruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 21 Sep 2005

veer kulbir singh, you have provided a Gurbaani Pankti to support your argument. Har aradh ne jaana rae Har Har Gur Gur Karta Rae Firstly veerji, you must veechar the entire shabad. I would like to do this now. Before i begin, i have understood that bhai sahib himself would use Gurbaani reference in order of angs in sri guru granth sahib jee to show the continuing message of Guru Sahib (please correct me if i am wrong). I will use this same method of veechar of Agaadh Bodh Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Firstly, i will veechar this shabad and more in essence of the pankties mentioned. Firstly, this shabad is in sorath raag on ang 612. Sorath Raag is believed to be a Raag that inspires motivation in the aatma. Now, the Guru has indeed said and given us motivation to har aaraadhh n jaanaa rae || har har gur gur karathaa rae || I do not know how to worship the Lord in adoration. I can only repeat, ""Lord, Lord, Guru, Guru."" The Guru is giving us motivation, this is the rang of my aatma at this time 'Hey Waheguruu, I do not know how to love you with adoration (araadh), I can only do the most best action of reciting your Pavitar Naam, Har Har, and Gur Gur" Guru Arjan Dev Jee has re-introduced the concept of Araadhna in this shabad in fact saying to us, 'Har Har Gur Gur Karta Rae', keep chanting the Name of Waheguruu. Does this mean 'araadhna' is out of the question, no? Why? I will explain. Please remember, this shabad is in Sorath Raag and on ang 612 As Guru Nanak Dev Jee continues on His Pavitar Sakhi "Gurbaani", the Guru continues to teach us to grow and grow, and reach the Sublimest and Highest state of milaap with pati pramatmaaa. Now the Guru has implanted within our souls Again, in Sorath Raag, but now continuing on the Sakhi, going ahead the Guru has now introduced Araadhnaa with Japping, not Japping alone, but now the Guru has introduced both, and saying this is the highest state. When araadhnaaa and jaap have mingled and become intertwined. Please note, now the Saakhi of Guru Sahib is continuing from ang 612, to pavitar ang 630 Our souls are too also continuing on the journey, and now with jap, araadhnaa has been called the sublimest state. Thus the Guru has said sorat(h) mehalaa 5 || sarab sukhaa kaa dhaathaa sathigur thaa kee saranee paaeeai || dharasan bhaettath hoth ana(n)dhaa dhookh gaeiaa har gaaeeai ||1|| har ras peevahu bhaaee || naam japahu naamo aaraadhhahu gur poorae kee saranaaee || rehaao || thisehi paraapath jis dhhur likhiaa soee pooran bhaaee || naanak kee baena(n)thee prabh jee naam rehaa liv laaee ||2||25||89|| Sorat'h, Fifth Mehl: The True Guru is the Giver of all peace and comfort - seek His Sanctuary. Beholding the Blessed Vision of His Darshan, bliss ensues, pain is dispelled, and one sings the Lord's Praises. ||1|| Drink in the sublime essence of the Lord, O Siblings of Destiny. Chant the Naam, the Name of the Lord; worship the Naam in adoration, and enter the Sanctuary of the Perfect Guru. ||Pause|| Only one who has such pre-ordained destiny receives it; he alone becomes perfect, O Siblings of Destiny. Nanak's prayer, O Dear God, is to remain lovingly absorbed in the Naam. ||2||25||89|| Now, very importantly, please note that the Guru has assured, and this is the Rahoo pankti, meaning where we must contemplate the most, and the Guru has assured us to enter the sublimest state (guru sahibs sarnaaee (santuary) through first jap, with araadhnaa, and thus you have been given the tools and protectoin in the Guru Santuary. That is why the Guru has said Naam Japo Naamo Araadho Gur Poorae Kee Sarnaaee The Guru has indeed said that this is the sublimest state of pyaar, and that is why Guru Sahib has concluded the shabad, after the Pavitar Rahoo pantki, that indeed (one in millions) one who has perfect destiny, recieves this and is absorbed, in pyaar with Naam thisehi paraapath jis dhhur likhiaa soee pooran bhaaee || naanak kee baena(n)thee prabh jee naam rehaa liv laaee ||2||25||89|| Only one who has such pre-ordained destiny receives it; he alone becomes perfect, O Siblings of Destiny. naanak kee baena(n)thee prabh jee naam rehaa liv laaee ||2||25||89|| Please also see, that the Guru has used here, that with Araadhnaa and begins with japna, that the liv (this is the what we all wish for), is joined to Waheguruu. This is the greatest of gifts from Waheguruu. This is greatest Daan (boon). And this is Guru Nanak Dev Jees Ardaas, Arjori, to Waheguruu, pati pramaatmaa. Continuing on this sakhi the Guru now on ang 950 has given instructions of what one should do of them whom have araadh waheguruu. Please note this pavitar shabad is in Raag Raamkali. Raag Raamkali is believed to be linked to vairaag where one learns the true form of yoga, and where one gives up the life of a wandering recluse, and gains the presence of Waheguruu within the Home. The Guru says that when one meets the Guru, the true Naam becomes Drir (like a water mingles with the ocean, you cannot seperate the person from Naam anymore), the Guru has become dya, and has made the person His own. And by meeting the Guru all dualities vanish and the person japs, and araadhs, and to such a person the world bows. sathigur milai thaa naam dhirraaeae sabh kilavikh kattanehaar || naam japae naamo aaraadhhae this jan ko karahu sabh namasakaar || If one meets with the True Guru, He implants the Naam, the Name of the Lord within; all his sins are destroyed. Let all bow in humility to that humble being who chants the Naam, and worships the Naam in adoration Thus veerji, it is through araadhna that Waheguruu Kingdom (Parkaash) is achieved. This is why bhai sahib is very respected, as a veer above has stated that Bhai Sahib did recieve Waheguruu Jees Parkash through Araadhna. My stance is that raising the kundalini through saas saas technique (when a person moves his head up and down and they do simran), is yoga in practice which raises the kundalini. My stance is that this is manmat. I began the post to try to find out where is the stance of this practice. I came to understand that Bhai Sahib himself was not given this technique. However it became prevalent in those times. My stance is that the panj takhats, with Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib being the highest, including Sri Takhat Kesgarh Sahib, where Guru Sahib first bestowed Amrit, and Takhat Sri Damdama Sahib, where Guru Sahib rested, and where Amrit Sanchaars were held regularly for the fortunate souls. The Takhats do not accept this form of saas saas technique, and in fact give the fortunate Gursikhs the tools of Araadhnaa (through Panj Pyareh); the sublimest state of this Jeevan. My argument is that saas saas technique (moving head up and down) is infact a practice not accepted by the Panth as represented by the foundation stones placed by Sri GuruHargobind Sahib. With movements of head up and down, is infact a practice to raise the kundalini to the tenth gate, which i have said is not the path of Gurmat, because Gurmat is a path of Araadhnaa. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh Again, the only sant i follow is Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, and Sri Guru Panth which was established by Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Patshaah Saas Saas Simran is the sublimest state of Araadhnaa done with absolute pyaar. Saas Saas technique is a practice to raise the kundalini please read the posts carefully before commenting [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Jagjit Singh T · 21 Sep 2005

Dear Kulbir Singh veerji, Just recently vaheguru ji blessed me to be part of the sangat at an Akhand Keertan Jatha Rainsbai for the first time. It was such a beautiful experience - with lots of the Sangat singing Gurbani with love. BUT, I was shocked at what I saw when Jatha and some sangat started doing vaheguru simran!...They were breathing very very fast and moving there stomach in and out when saying vaheguru. It was basically the same breathing technique used in kundalini yoga classes to awaken energy within the body. They were shaking their heads from side to side - just like in a kundalini yoga class. This is basically FORCING your conciousness to rise up. I was so upset and thought - how can the Akhand Keertan Jatha (whom I admire so much) who place so much importance of Ladeevar saroop of Guru ji be doing some yoga breathing techniques in Gurdwaras! Is this the saas saas naam abyass technique taught to Sikhs when they receive Amrit? If it is, then it ain't Gurmat, it is more Yoga - where one uses force to get things moving (PUSH and FORCE with rapid breathing etc), and not the grace of vaheguru ji (letting vaheguru ji PULL your conciousness as one does naam abhyaas with sehaj by saying vaheguru (in the mind and tongue) whilst they breath NORMALLY). Maybe that 's why veerji Charanjeev Singh is mentioning kundalini and yoga so much, because the similarity is ALARMING and very SADENNING (for me anyway).

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Charanjeev, Because your argument has been absolutely Jutti-slapped from every angle by Kulbir Singh, does not mean you need to leave now. You have essentially implied that Naam Drirrh is Manmat and against Gurmat, yet you have never received it, and you do not even know what happens when someone receives Naam Drirrh. Stitching together a half-baked hypothesis trying to claim that Swas Swas is some kind of anti Gurmat Kundalini exercise is not something you can leave half finished - by making such accusations, you now need to substantiate them by answering the questions Kulbir Singh has posed to you. The most funny thing is you seem to try to imply Saas Giraas is such a technical thing, yet after most people recieve Naam Drirrh find Swas Swas Simran goes automatically (ie. it cannot actually be stopped)...depending on the Kamai of the person, the automatic, Saas Giraas that actually cannot be stopped, may continue for quite a long time - it comes completely naturally and without any effort whatsoever... this is an experience quite unlike any other, its a pity you are so against it.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Zorawar Singh · 21 Sep 2005

I fail to see what Charanjeev singh is complaining about. If both beliveve in swaas swaas simran then thats Great. Charanjeev posts got confusing by this whole kundalini thing. Not sure where that relates to Gurmat? The rest just seems to be agreeing as much as disagreeing on the same thing... Just a shame Charanjeev used the analogue of the mimicking parrot, as this seemed really bad. However I do not think that was intentional by Charanjeev....

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

DKhalsa · 21 Sep 2005

Sohagani, calm down. Kulbir Singh's post was well written. How is the "sant thing" getting old? Kulbir Singh, Keep up the good work!!!! Charanjeev Singh doesn't know what he is talking about

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh2 · 21 Sep 2005

make up your mind charanjeev singh. you keep saying that it would be your last post but you keep posting after that. and shame on you for calling naam simran parrot simran. and stop your fake humility. you don't have any.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

gupt · 21 Sep 2005

charanjeev singh !!! go bak 2 sleep u dono wa u on about!!! wjkk wjkf

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Jagjit Singh T · 21 Sep 2005

Dear veereo and paneo, veer Charanjeev Singh DOES have a point about the saas saas technique practiced by Akhand Keertan Jatha in Keertan rainsbai etc being yoga orientated. If you know people who do Kundalini yoga or do it yourself, then you will know he has a point. If you don't, then I dare you to Kundalini yoga class and then you will know the truth!... It is not the Guru's way of sehaj.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 21 Sep 2005

Singh, i am not against naam drirthaa, i am against the thought that people believe they have gotten it thus loose the goal to actually achieve it. Naam Drirthaa once recieved, NEVER leaves, for the entire life. It cannnot be lost, even by mistake, not at all. That is what i am saying, many people say they got naam drirthaa, but they do not have it. They have had experiences, this is not naam drirthaa. zorawar singh, yes sorry about the confusing kundalini relations; however, the kundalini is in every human being, and focusing on the kundalini through body movements, which gursikhs are doing, are not gurmat principles. This is what i am referring to. Dkhalsa, if i know about what i am talking about or not, that only Guru Sahib knows. Singh2, yes this is my last thread, topic. After this thats it for me for tapoban.org. No more coming here for me. And i have no clue what real humility is, so i guess yeah, that would make mine fake. Gupt, sometimes i cant sleep for days on ends, sometimes even weeks. And the wierd thing is i dont feel tired. I guess if it aint broken,why fix it? It would be nice to get a good sleep; but then again it might not. And Guru Sahib knows what we are all on about. Kulbir Singh, please answer me, why do you move the head in an up and down motion, and call this naam drirthaa? Where were you taught that this is Gurmat? If this was the method, the Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, would have aknowleded it. However, with Gurmat veechar, this technique is not accepted. Sohagani, the sant thing is getting old. Funny thing is, i dont follow any human sant, Kulbir Singh does. Amazing how Guru Sahib works. The accuser becomes the accused. Before you say you dont follow any human sant kulbir singh, answer my first question above, and then tell me how you dont follow a human sant. Your entire beliefe system undermined Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib and Gurmat Maryada. Surely, you did not arrive at this yourself. Guru Gobind Singh Jee left Anandur Sahib, and then Gali of Chamkaur obeying Panth Khalsa, why dont you and others whom so hold dear the same beliefs that you share? [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Zorawar Singh · 21 Sep 2005

sorry, but I disagree. Kundalina yoga is very different. It is dramatic, with body shaking. I have namm dhrii and have only seen a few singhs shake their heads, it is far from common practice. The breath of fire technique in kundalina yoga bears no comparison to Swaas giraras. The Guru way is of sehaj, but Gurbani also speaks to singing the sahbad loudly. So lets not close our minds so much, as this is the only way... Basically everyone can do it loud is that is how they stay awake or control their surat. Eventually it will go internal, with breaths, but this can take decades for some, and seconds for others. But there is no comparison with kundalina and saas giraas. I have to say that is a silly observation....

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

gursikh · 21 Sep 2005

I believe Swaas Swaas Simran taught by the Panj Pyare to be a means to an end. It is a "tool" of remembering Waheguru. It is not an end in itself, rather a means to an end, i.e. helps us to remain in the yaad, consciouness of Waheguru. I went Pesh to recieve Naam DriR from Panj Pyare at and Amrit Sanchar. I felt "Waheguru, Waheguru" vibrating from my body and each hair. After recieving Naam DriR i sat down and continued to with the Swaas Swaas simran... i felt a tingling from toes going up my body. My toes went numb and no feeling. Then my feet, then my legs started twingling and couldn't feel anything - my breath continued to be taking away by "Waahe-Guru" in a mood of awe and wonder. I couldn't move my arms or legs, I was sitting there and tears of joy were coming over me, all i could think was "waheguru", all i could say was "waheguru" and all i could breathe was "waheguru." if you don't believe in "Naam DriR" then that's your right of choice, but 1) its not doing any arm to anyone, 2) its helping people to remember waheguru - so what's the big deal to put down those who choose to naam jap through each breath. In regards to moving the head - i think this personal thing rather than the Panj Pyare telling people to move their head. However, it is most likely that those people find it difficult to contain the feeling awe and ecstatic wonder from Naam Japnaa and therefore end up moving their heads. I have seen some people doing (or trying to do) Swas Swas simran and it is sooo fast that you can't even here "Waahe". Its just "Guru, Guru Guru, Guru,". You can barely keep up. HOWEVER, in the Amrit Sanchar I went to they told the Sangat that Swaas Swaas simran should be done "sehaj de naal" (i.e. slowly and gently) and the Singh Sahib showed the Sangat how to do it slowly. If you doing Swaas Swaas Simran slowly and gently with sehaj, with pyaar and you are "concentrating on each breath and each time you say Waheguru, rather than doing it without thinking or pyaar" (as told by the Panj Pyare at the Amrit Sanchaar) then why does anyone have a problem??? If i've said anything to offend anyone, then please forgive me. i am still learning. humble daas. [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Kulbir Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh jeeo, With great regrets I have to say that you have again not answered any of my questions and without any backup have repeated your baseless claim that swaas swaas simran is equal to some breathing technique and now you are saying that it is some yogic practice. --------------------- please re read my messages. i am against yoga and breathing technique. for example, when "you, kulbir singh" do simran, you move your head up and down, you do yoga (please tell me why you have encompassed yoga with simran?) you are trying to awaken the kundalini, not me. i have never tried, and never will. However, by the Grace of Waheguruu, it still awakens if the Guru so wishes. This was the message in my messages above. And the Gurbani Shabads that have been referenced conclude that channeling the kundalini to the dasam duar with yogic exercises (like you move your head up and down) is not Gurmat. The True Marag of Gurmat Simran is Araadhnaa, that does not encompass the moving your head up and down, like how you do it. ------------- Because I sometimes move my head up and down means that I am trying to awaken Kundalini? What a joke this is. Why are you making such childish claims? Next thing you are going to say is that since Yogis and Hindus breathe and Kulbir Singh breathes, hence Kulbir Singh is a yogi. What yogic practice tells you that moving head up and down will awaken your kundalini? Pranayaam technique of yogic breathing is totally different from swaas swaas simran. Swaas swaas simran is full of life because it includes Naam in it. Yogic breathing techniques are totally different. Gurmat Naam Abhyaas is done along with breathing and once Naam simran becomes part of breathing, then it is done automatically when breathing is done. Can't understand how you can equate this to yoga. Here are some Gurbani pankitis to prove to you that Swaas Swaas simran is according to Gurmat: [gurbani]swis swis nwnku swlwhy ][/gurbani] saas saas naanak saalaahae || (HHere Guru Sahib himself declares that he himself does salaah of Vaheguru through swaas i.e. through breathing. The sihaari in the end gives meaning of “through”) [gurbani]swis swis jnu nwmu smwrY ]3][/gurbani] saas saas jan naam samaarai ||3|| (here Guru Sahib makes it clear that the true servant of Vaheguru, japps Naam through Swaas Swaas). [gurbani]so smrQu ismir swis igrwis ]3][/gurbani] so samarathh simar saas giraas ||3|| (This is a clear hukam to do simran of Vaheguru swaas swaas). [gurbani]ieik AwiK AwKih sbdu BwKih ArD aurD idnu rwiq ][/gurbani] eik aakh aakhehi sabadh bhaakhehi aradhh ouradhh dhin raath || (in this pankiti, Guru Sahib clearly says that Gurmukhs do simran of Vaheguru Ardh Urdh) You tell us now, who should we listen to: your baseless assertions that swaas swaas simran is merely a breathing technique or to Guru Sahib who orders us in countless pankitis to do simran of Vaheguru swaas swaas? ------------ I humbly appologize for my words. The essence of the message that i wanted to discuss was not conveyed by what i wanted to share (my lack of communication skills). The essence of my message was to recite waheguruu, with every swaas, and with love. And not just mere emptiness in the heart. The essence of my message was that to recite Waheguruu with love, there is no need to channel any energies, and i used to kundalini as an example. ------------- You write that the essence of your message was that we should recite Naam with every breath and with love. Who told you that Gursikhs who japp Naam swaas swaas, don’t do it with love? I think you are getting confused now. Before you were saying that you don’t believe in swaas swaas simran but now you are saying that you do believe in swaas swaas simran if it is done with love. ---------------- The Guru is giving us motivation, this is the rang of my aatma at this time 'Hey Waheguruu, I do not know how to love you with adoration (araadh), I can only do the most best action of reciting your Pavitar Naam, Har Har, and Gur Gur" Guru Arjan Dev Jee has re-introduced the concept of Araadhna in this shabad in fact saying to us, 'Har Har Gur Gur Karta Rae', keep chanting the Name of Waheguruu. Does this mean 'araadhna' is out of the question, no? Why? I will explain. Please remember, this shabad is in Sorath Raag and on ang 612 -------------- I think you are confusing yourself by jumping from ang to ang. Your jump from ang 612 to ang 630 to ang 950 and your assertion that what Guru Sahib said in one Sorath Shabad on 612 is being continued on a shabad on 630 and then on shabad on ang 950 is purely your imagination. You are distinguishing between Aradhana and Japna. In Gurmat, when you do jaap of Vaheguru, you do it with love and thus Naam Japna is Naam aradhana as well. You don’t just japp Vaheguru but you do it with love and you do it with full technique i.e. you listen to it with full devotion and faith. This is the Gurmat way of Naam Abhyaas. Charanjeev Singh jeeo, why do you assume that Gursikhs who do Naam Abhyaas swaas swaas, don’t do it with devotion and love? Your whole argument and criticism of Swaas Swaas Naam Abhyaas is based on your baseless conviction that Gurmukhs who japp Naam this way don’t do it with love. I request you to ponder upon your judgement and rethink your stand. ---------------- The Guru says that when one meets the Guru, the true Naam becomes Drir (like a water mingles with the ocean, you cannot seperate the person from Naam anymore), the Guru has become dya, and has made the person His own. And by meeting the Guru all dualities vanish and the person japs, and araadhs, and to such a person the world bows. sathigur milai thaa naam dhirraaeae sabh kilavikh kattanehaar || naam japae naamo aaraadhhae this jan ko karahu sabh namasakaar || ------------ Here you have clearly proved what Jatha stand is on Naam DriR. The gurbani pankiti you have quoted makes it clear that when one meets Guru Sahib, one gets Naam DriR. In other words, at the time of amrit chhak, when one meets Punj Pyaaray, one gets Naam DriR from Punj Pyaray. This Naam Drir is Kilvikh Kaatanhaar i.e. capable of destroying all sins, as the pankiti above says. Then when one gets Naam DriR, then you do Naam Jaap i.e. Naam Aradhana, and then one reaches such stage that everyone does Namaskaar to that person. You have cleared all the dust yourself. There should be no doubt left in your mind now that first one gets Naam driR and then one does Naam Abhyaas. Gurmat Naam Abhyaas includes devotion and love and thus as per your definition or understanding of aradhana, aradhana too is done while doing Naam abhyaas. ------------ My stance is that raising the kundalini through saas saas technique (when a person moves his head up and down and they do simran), is yoga in practice which raises the kundalini. My stance is that this is manmat. I began the post to try to find out where is the stance of this practice. I came to understand that Bhai Sahib himself was not given this technique. However it became prevalent in those times. ------------ At the time of Bhai Sahib, amrit sinchaars used to give Naam Abhyaas technique at the time of amrit sinchaar. The amrit sinchaar at Bakapur, where Bhai Sahib took amrit, this methodology was not followed, hence Bhai Sahib did not get Naam DriR. This is why Bhai Sahib got Naam Drir from Guru Sahib directly. But it is evident from the writings of that time that in Panch Khalsa Diwan, and other amrit sinchars, naam abhyaasi technique was given at the time of amrit sinchaar. You are sadly mistaken when you say that doing swaas swaas naam abhyaas is trying to awaken kundalini. Gurmukhs who do this abhyaas don’t even care about Kundalini. N ---------- Saas Saas Simran is the sublimest state of Araadhnaa done with absolute pyaar. Saas Saas technique is a practice to raise the kundalini -------- Now you are trying to raise differences between Saas Saas Simran and Saas Technique. Charanjeev Singh, I don’t know on who’s behest you are doing all this but this is certainly an attack on the most basic foundations of Khalsa Panth. Go read historical evidence that propagates swaas swaas abhyaas of Naam. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Kulbir Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh, ----------- Singh, i am not against naam drirthaa, i am against the thought that people believe they have gotten it thus loose the goal to actually achieve it. Naam Drirthaa once recieved, NEVER leaves, for the entire life. It cannnot be lost, even by mistake, not at all. That is what i am saying, many people say they got naam drirthaa, but they do not have it. They have had experiences, this is not naam drirthaa. ---------- As per my previous post, Naam driRta is the first stage when you meet Guru Sahib and get Naam driR from Guru Sahib. Now a days this is done through Guru roop Punj Pyaray. ----------- zorawar singh, yes sorry about the confusing kundalini relations; however, the kundalini is in every human being, and focusing on the kundalini through body movements, which gursikhs are doing, are not gurmat principles. This is what i am referring to. --------- You are making a very ignorant statement. You yourself have never learned the Naam Abhyaas Jugti from Punj Pyaray and thus don’t know about it but you are very ignorantly claiming that this jugti is similar to Kundalini body movements. How can you comment on something you don’t know? You don’t know what jugti is but yet you make a comment on it. I think this is the height of ignorance and it is outright foolish to do so. ------- Kulbir Singh, please answer me, why do you move the head in an up and down motion, and call this naam drirthaa? --------- When did I say that you have to move your head up and down. You don’t have to move your head up and down. It’s not a requirement. ----------- Where were you taught that this is Gurmat? If this was the method, the Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, would have aknowleded it. However, with Gurmat veechar, this technique is not accepted. -------- Gurbani accepts Swaas Swaas simran and this is good enough for me. You tell me where in Gurbani it says that Naam Japna is not Naam Aradhana. Charanjeev Singh, you have got upset for no reason. You do your Naam Aradhana and allow us to do the Naam Abhyaas we have been taught by Guru roop Punj Pyaray. Why are you so upset with us? Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 21 Sep 2005

Pyareh veer kulbir singh, I have recieved Naam Drirtha from Panj Pyareh. It is the Panj Pyareh whom have changed my life that i cannot explain in words. The Panj Pyareh are my Satguruu. The Panj Pyareh are my everything. The Guru is very thuta on Nimaneh, Nithaneh and Niotheaah. Without Guru, i have no life. I have shared what had to be shared. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Charanjeev, no offence but it cannot be anything but a lie, that you have been implanted and taught Swas Swas Simran by the Panj, reading your comments. Please be honest.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 22 Sep 2005

First you call me charanjeev, not charanjeev singh, then you say no offence, and then you call me a liar. Even bhai kulbir singh, with whom i have debated and we have disagreed on many issues, still called me charanjeev singh. A true Gursikh, holds no grudges. Anyway, a person cannot get any understanding of Gurmart Jugati unless they are bestowed this by Panj Pyareh. You have not understood what this thread was about because our realizations are different. There is nothing wrong with that. Bhai Kanayaa Jee was different from Baba Deep Singh Jee; but they are still both the same. Saas Saas simran, is the only way a Gursikh can live. It does not happen with udham, it is bestowed by Gurus' Kirpaa. It can only be bestowed by Gurus' Kirpaa after a person has a Guru. A person only has a Guru, after he has gotten Naam Drirtha and Gursikh Jeevan Jugaati from Panj Pyareh. Araadhna, is the same as saas saas simran. The saas saas technique of moving the body with simran has alot of benefits, no doubt. It raises many many experiences including riddia siddia. However, a Gursikh is a kookar of the Panth, and the Panth is under Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib. Any Gursikh whom truly loves the Guru, will follow the guidelines of the Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib. I was bestowed Amrit dee Daath at Takhat Sri Keshgarh Sahib. If i know what Saaas Saaas Simran is or not, if i 'know' what it is, or if i have 'realized' what it is, only Guru Sahib knows. Anyway singh, what i had to say has been said. If you do not like what i have said, take in one ear, and take it out the other. Doesnt matter. This is the last thread that i will take part in, so i wanted to talk about the panthic differences in simran that is one root problem that has divided the panth. When it comes to panth, simran, and jugati of amrit, should be the same for everbody. Please also understand that swaas swaas simran, with waheguruu coming with the breathing in and out with waheguruu, is araadhaa. Moving the body and head is what i am reffering to as anti-gurmat. Please understand what abyaas is. Abyaas is practice, practice for what? Practice for the rest of the day. So when you wake up Amrit vela and you do abyaas, this is the practice for the rest of your day. Can you move your head up and down or side to side when you are working, or taking care of family? You can when you are doing saas saas simran with araadhnaa. It is still swaas swaas, but there is no movement of the body and head. This is where the Gurmukh lives in the chautha padd, and has gone beyond the other three and the panj thatt (5 elements). I will not call you veer, for you have not accepted me as yours, and that is fine. But i will close this with a sikhi, that i hope you abide by in your life. This is the sikhi of the True Marag of Guru Nanak. Guru Nanak made a person an Amal Gursikh. A person whom lives the teachings. I know you are a vegetarian. I am also a vegetarian, i am actually vegan. Being vegan, i do not buy any leather goods, and all (i do not want to discuss tabla etc here. However, everything used for Guru Sahibs darbaar is blessed) And being vegan, i will not eat meat, including the meat that has been considered the most tabooed, or sinful meat to eat, and that is the human body. koorr bol muradhaar khaae || Telling lies, they eat dead bodies. My messages by me have been misinterpreted in many ways (this is my fault that i couldnt give the message that i was trying to). I started off by asking if bhai randhir singh recieved this technique of moving the head with simran. I was told and i do believe that bhai sahib received Waheguruus Parkaash through Araadhnaa. As i do believe so did Baba Attar Singh Jee, and Baba Nand Singh Jee and other pyareh Gursikhs. The focus was on how this technique came into the panth mainly in what we know as the akj. It is my belief, that pyareh Gursikhs through naam kamaai began to see the benefits of moving the body with simran. This in fact does serve a purpose, and it could be to raise the kundalini, or koombak, because the kundalini when risen does give certain affects. However that is only a speculation, because it cannot be proven. Then i went on to say that the 5 takhats do not support this, and i asked why? If this was the method, surely, at least one takhat would hold this stance. Guru Gobind Singh Jee had held many Amrit Sanchaars at damdamaa sahib, and we do know that thousands were bestowed Amrit at sri kesgarh sahib. My mat says that, even if someone disagrees with the takhats' stance, it is hukam of every gursikh to follow the rules of Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, because the Guru said that this is center of Sikhi. My concern is for panthic unity. As of right now, the biggest issue that divides the panth, is the form of simran between the main bodies of the panth, being Akaal Takhat, Taksal, and AKJ. Akj main difference is on the jugati of simran abyaas. Other factors are small, and they cannot divide the panth in actuality. I do not want to debate keski, etc. It is obvious that the Guru has a plan for the panth. I do believe this strongly. However, it is our duty to follow Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib. Again, if i have said something that you disagree with, that is fine, no two snowflakes are alike. All that matters is the individual do his best for themselves through Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, and try their best to benefit Sri Guru Panth Sahib Jee. The two duties of every Gursikh. Again, i will only come and read and reply on this thread for a short period. I hope for no one to reply anymore and this thread be closed. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Liongking · 22 Sep 2005

"Singh" - WHy because he's questioning it? Is it wrong to question what Bhai Randheer SIngh ji brought up? so next time some sant baba says do this - we shouldn't question it i'm not syaing that Bhai Randheer Signh was at the same level of so called babas , but there is nothing stopping Gurmukhs from discussing and questionign each other's thoeries. regards

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 22 Sep 2005

'Liongking' (and just what is a 'Liong'?) /There is nothing wrong with questioning but from the comments Charanjeev Singh has made, regarding Kundalini and the like, makes it extremely unlikely he has ever received Naam DriRh. Having practised Yoga a number of years ago, including fast breathing exercises and breath of fire, and also having received Naam DriRh, I can honestly say the two could not be any more distant. For anyone who has received Naam DriRh, the difference would be completely obvious. Naam DriRh is NOT teaching fast abdominal breathing. Naam DriRh is the process of implanting Naam in the seeker so that the Gurmantra is intertwined with every breath. It transcends any breathing exercises or physical techniques.****

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 22 Sep 2005

Furthermore, Naam DriRh is nothing to do with moving the head. When I do Abhiyaas, I do not move my head. When I do Simran in Sangat, even when fast, I do not move my head. I feel no need to. Other Gursikhs may feel the power of the Shabad vibrating up and down them at such pace that they move - some Gursikhs may even lift off the floor and levetate - I am not one to judge. You can do Simran and your body is completely still - again you would not know this since you have not received Naam DriRh (and let us not try to change the definition of Naam DriRh, or go off subject in an attempt to confuse - Kulbir Singh has posed you some question you have still not answered).

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

singh · 22 Sep 2005

charanjeev singh , I dont understand, have u gotten Naam Drirtha from abhyass singhs or are u trying to say that everyone recieves Naam Drirtha regardless of where u get Amrit from, be it DDT or SPGC etc? And i mean no offense in this question either.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 22 Sep 2005

You win. I lose. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh · 22 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh, this is not about "winning" and "losing". You have constantly written in this thread "I will not write any more", "This is my last post here", etc etc. You have made serious allegations that Naam DriRh is against Gurmat. You have misrepresented Saas Giraas Simran as Kundalini or "head movement". You have changed the definitions of Naam DriRh, alluded to Gursikhs doing Abhiyaas being like "parrots", etc afterwards claiming you actually meant something else. By all means have a theory and hypothesis, just be willing to back it up properly. True Nimrata comes from pure intentions and careful thought before speaking, not sweet words on internet message boards.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

charanjeev singh · 22 Sep 2005

"By all means have a theory and hypothesis, just be willing to back it up properly. True Nimrata comes from pure intentions and careful thought before speaking, not sweet words on internet message boards." Sat Bachan. And yes, this is my last thread (topic) meaning, i will not be sharing my views on any more threads on this forum. This is our last mulaakaat. We will never see each other again. If this thread is finished, we can go on our lives. As someone above said, "You do your Naam Aradhana and allow us to do the Naam Abhyaas". I respect that, and will live by that. As for my allegations, well i have 'been absolutely Jutti-slapped from every angle by Kulbir Singh'. So take it as it is. Those whom have naam drirthaa, know it. It is enjoyed everysecond while walking, talking, sleeping, laughing, eating, playing ball, playing gatka, going to work, going to school, going for a walk, everywhere; this is true naam drirthaa; it cannot be seperated from the aatmaa, even if they tried. The drop has mingled with the ocean, and cannot be seperated ever again; Naam Drirthaa If you have naam drirtha, congratulations, this is the highest sublimest, and most blissful gift from the Guru. And if i dont, then that is my unfortunate destiny. Could we please now finish this; i couldnt convey my message, and i still cant, so forget it. Goodbye [%sig%]