Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

SenghSational · 16 Sep 2005

Ok VJKK VJKF Me and a friend were having a convo on MSN regarding my display pic; I was slightly annoyed because she called Mariah a manmukh. She may or may not be...but who are we to say???? Please find the convo enclosed and your responses would be much appreciated! . says: i jus realised i find that pic offensive HARRY says: y do u? . says: ur makin a manmukh into a gursikh roop HARRY says: maybe she's a gursikh ..but not realised it yet HARRY says: who r we to assuHarry who is a manmukh? HARRY says: we arnt brahm giannnis . says: yeh like she cud be a gursikh in disguise . says: anyway i was jus messin dnt worry i wnt say anything bout ur precious Mariah HARRY says: butt..no this is serious man. u cant jus lash out lyrics to nex ppl and label them manmukh and stuff. I mean when bhai rama singh wasn’t in guru’s roop but was moving closer to god…cud u label him a manmukh? HARRY says: u get me? . says: man she is a manmukh . says: shall we ask kulbir singh HARRY says: Lol . says: nex u'll b sayin micheal jackson is a gursikh HARRY says: fine lemme post tapoban topic HARRY says: and we'll see ok? HARRY says: http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=53099&t=53099 HARRY says: that topic kiks ass . says: i was readin dat actually . says: yeh wateva harry . says: i swear down u need 2 chill . says: its like shes ur best mate or sumthin HARRY says: im chilled man HARRY says: im jus saying. how can normal sikhs label others manmukhs n gurmukhs . says: bcaz she isnt a gursikh . says: its a fact . says: im not a gursikh either HARRY says: hmm..ok was say...mother teresa a manmukh? . says: but im not a manmukh bcaz i aint followin manmat i follow gurmat . says: wats that gotta do with anything HARRY says: ur right. mariah carey is a manmukh HARRY says: khosh? . says: seriously man . says: im kush if u agree . says: and u aint jus sayin dat HARRY says: well..she may be a manmukh HARRY says: butttt...wha im tryna say is HARRY says: we as humans cant brand other humans HARRY says: u get me? . says: why not its not like its not true . says: im not being mean . says: or blamin her . says: she jus aint a gursikh full stop HARRY says: Yeh. But maybe she believes in god. HARRY says: but fine HARRY says: but all im saying is..jus be careful man. . says: i am i wudnt go and call u a manmukh . says: bcaz u do follow gurmat HARRY says: ok man. dont tek this wrong. but im unsure. so imma post a topic..not mentioning ne name's apart from mariahs

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

amarjeet singh · 16 Sep 2005

vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh just to clear up matters. marriah carrey is obvioulsy a manmukh, she cuts her hair, eats meat etc... , is therefore a manmukh. simple. if you cut your hair, or commit any other of the 4 kurehits ur not a sikh, even if she does believe in god, so what loads of people do, if you dont keep rehit, simple rehit your a manmukh vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

Jaskaran Kaur · 16 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh just read ur topic... i even understood where you coming from. Well i want to say that when Guru Nanak Dev Ji went for Udhasis and when he met Sajjan Thug and others what he preached them as "dont do deeds of Manmatiya's". Now you will ask how this clicks with your topic? It does cause from their you can see even Guru Ji preached Sajjan Thug saying that dont do the deeds of manmatiya's. So it goes same with this lady as you mentioned "Mariyah". A person is;nt a Gurmukh untill he/she do the deeds of Gurmukh. Even we being a Gurmukh we say that no we are just a manmukh. WHY? cause we think we are not as worth as calling ourself as Gurmukh cause we gotta move forw. SO looking at her i dont think she is Gurmukh or Gursikh. May be tomorrow but not today. As Guru Ji states Sajjan Thug as manmukh that time when after Guru Ji's preach made him Gurmukh. So i think we can judge that much right. When tomorrow she will be a Gurmukh then offcourse we will call her Gurmukh nottt Manmukh. Hope u get me, what i m trying to say. BHull Chukk Maaf. Sarbatt Da Bhala. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

wto · 16 Sep 2005

are u for real? doing what she does wearing the clothes she does, u still don't think she is a manmukh? do u know what manmukh is? one who is not a gurmukh, one who does not follow or even try to follow guru jis teachings......

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

. · 16 Sep 2005

thank you i told him he was insane to think she was an manmukh

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

SenghSational · 16 Sep 2005

OK lol. I think I named this topic wrong. How about this.... Is it ok for us to label others Manmukh or Gurmukh??

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

SenghSational · 16 Sep 2005

OK after reading comments I agree. I guess we can say who's a manmukh by how they appear to us. phul chuk maaf. o<|:o)

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

TavPrasad Singh · 16 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! Forget Mariah, please have respect for the Bana. Its not a joke, its Guruji's roop! Do not abuse Guruji's roop by plastering it on someone for a laugh!

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

Bani is my Guru · 16 Sep 2005

Mariah follows here "mann"not Guru therefore MANmukh not GURmukh

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

Dogma · 16 Sep 2005

is she wearing a kalgi?

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

. · 16 Sep 2005

lol @ dogma shes the next dindariawale

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

35 · 16 Sep 2005

She is like a princess, the way she looks, she is a very nice manmukh, anyday!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

me · 16 Sep 2005

It is disrepectful to put a Dastar and Khanda on someone who dances around on her videos 90% naked. I find that picture VERY offensive.

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

okayokay · 16 Sep 2005

seing that she dont folow any of sikh gurus techings shes manmukh. Full Stop

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

............ · 16 Sep 2005

not only was i offended by the pic but can the person who said she is the next dhadrianwale please see the difference, she sings crap and this man sings kirtan.

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

::::: · 16 Sep 2005

I'm a little confused... Mariah Carey issue aside... this is waht your friend said: . says: im not a gursikh either [...] . says: but im not a manmukh bcaz i aint followin manmat i follow gurmat If he follows gurmat, i.e. the guru, then how could he not be a gursikh? also, there used to be a website to determine whether you were a manmukh or a gurmukh... obviously what it told you wasn't necessarily true, but the logic behind it was clever. i'll post it up here if it's still online somewhere.

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

me 2(ssscotty singh) · 16 Sep 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh singhs and singhnia. i too find this picture disrespectful and offensive and i agree with what me says. i was also disheartened at ppl above saying hw nice this mariah was because as far as i knw sikhs rnt ment to judge on hw ppl look. we shld treat every1 like our sisters. would u say ur stunning man to ur sister or mother??? of course not that would jst b a bit peculiar wldnt it. this is the same thing. we shld treat every1 as our family even if they are manmukh or gurmukh. sikhs do not go on looks either bcause that is manmukh. it is disgraceful that u shld look at other women. singhs didnt look twice at another woman in the chardi kala days. we cannot judge any1 else.no offense btw vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

singh · 16 Sep 2005

INTERESTING the majority of ppl on this forum usually stick up for "singhnees" who have been accused of plucking http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=49913&t=45743#reply_49913 you can clearly see whos wearin makeup and has plucked eyebrows, now someone has posted a pic of a christian wearing a dastar and you dnt think twice about saying its wrong in my opinion mariah carey is less of a paapi then "singhnees" who pluck and remove hair because they know better, they are intentionally going against gurus hukam and have become patit (apostate) i see apostates as being worse then manmukhs, they are a complete disgrace, walking around with a dastar yet commiting bujjar kurehit at same time, they should choose a path..............either stop plucking, or, take off their dastar.

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

s · 16 Sep 2005

is this a joke, obviously the person who posted this is up for sum controversy.

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

SenghSational · 16 Sep 2005

THANK YOU SINGH above me! THIS IS A LESSON IN ITSELF I guess we have learnt that no matter what roop a person shows them self to be in, its what their actions and deeds amount to; that counts. So in this case...if we see a Singh or Singhnee wearing a cholla, we shudnt automatically assume that they are beautiful, coz after all they could be baad! FOR EXAMPLE: if no one knew who mariah was; and saw this pic; they wud immediately assume; "awww, a beautiful singhnee" All you people who are crying need to calm down! who are WE to say who can be in GURU's roop and who can't? If you know a girl who is bad and cuts her hair. And one day decides to wear a dastaar with a chunni... Would YOU approach her and say that "That is highly offensive!!" The picture I made was simply to show people how Mariah would look with a dastaar if she was a Sikh. See how much more pleasant she looks? And how much more radiant she is? "in my opinion mariah carey is less of a paapi then "singhnees" who pluck and remove hair because they know better, they are intentionally going against gurus hukam and have become patit (apostate)" true that! Sorry if i have offended anyone

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

charanjeev singh · 16 Sep 2005

Tell me this, who is a manmukh? A manmukh is one who has heard about the Gurus' sermon, and still does not adhere or live the principles of Gurmat; after hearing and being exposed to the Gurus' sermon. How can someone who does not know the Guru be a manmukh? They can be bhagheen (unfortunate), but how a manmukh? A bemukh is one who deliberately turn theire back to the Guru. A manmukh is one who does what their 'mann' wants to do, after knowing of the Guru. A Gurmukh is one who has become one with Guru and Waheguruu. Those who do kurreits are manmukhs. Those who do not know who the Guru is, cannot be manmukhs because they do not know what to do and what not to do. Those who know what to do as given by Gurmat, and still do not do it and turn thier backs to the Guru are bemukh. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifathe [%sig%]

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

SenghSational · 17 Sep 2005

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ VJKK VJKF ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I guess this shows us, never judge a book by its cover If someone didnt recognise this pic as being Mariah, they would have assumed she is a beautiful singhnee. Similarly, there are people who appear in the Guru's roop however, underneath this exterior, they are infact cold, and evil. One thing I don't understand is; if some sikh saw a girl who is bad later wearing a dastaar; wud they approach the girl and say; "oh i find that offensive!!"...?? Sorry if I offended anyone with the pic. It was jus me showing ma m8 how the dastaar wud affect Mariah :D. Phul Chul Hogayee, Maaf Karnaa VJKK VJKF!

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

Lionking · 17 Sep 2005

its not about whether shes Gurmuykh or manmukh - but whether we are anyoen to judge? Do WE HAVE ANY right to judge other people - isn't that God's job?

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

SenghSational · 17 Sep 2005

THANK YOU CHARANJEEEV SINGH AND LION KING! KILLED THE ARGUMENT! IT IS ONLY GOD WHO CAN JUDGE! NOT SOME PHASSIES SAT BEHIND MSN. :D FATEH!

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

charanjeev singh · 17 Sep 2005

I thought the pic was really nice to be honest with you.

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

Guruvah · 17 Sep 2005

well said charanjeev veer jee

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

. · 17 Sep 2005

how do you know she hasnt heard gurbani? do you stay with her 24/7?

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

yaa · 18 Sep 2005

" It is disrepectful to put a Dastar and Khanda on someone who dances around on her videos 90% naked. I find that picture VERY offensive. " I agree

Re: Is.......Mariah Carey...a Manmukh?

Harjas Kaur · 19 Sep 2005

The only thing we can judge are the actions of others. These we can judge because we see them. If someone is a murderer, I don't stand aside and say, "Only God can judge." We can call actions for what they are. If a Singhnee, is wearing Guru's bana, we get all crazy about it. "Is she for real? Is she a hypocrite? She's too pretty she must be wearing make-up!" But if a Singh is wearing bana, we don't get crazy about it and start insulting them, calling them hypocrite, manmukh, filth. Nobody that I know is perfect. We wear bana, not because we're great people, but because we want to be close to Guruji. We want Guru's image impressed on our hearts. We also know that a person can seem to be a sant, chardi kala and a good Gursikh and be a terrible person, so only God really knows. And a person can be a manmukh, but trying to be a Gursikh by Guru's grace, and we have no right to offend and discourage them. I do know a story of a shaven man given Amrit who later grew out all his hairs. But honestly, when a person simulates public sex act on stage and in lyrics like Mariah Carey, they need to make visible changes in their lives, like public Amrit, public pesh, public renouncing of the actions of the past. Otherwise they are unfit to misrepresent Guruji to the public. It is also insulting that without evidence of wrong-doing people insult young Singhnee's in bana because they think they might be plucking out their eyebrow hairs. But if it is a matter of a gora woman with blond eyebrow hairs, or geneticly light-colored, lighter weight hairs we have no right to denounce her as manmukh for shaving just cos those hairs aren't thick and black and visible. She has done no public disgrace that requires pesh. So why do we publicly repudiate her Sikhi? I can see having a doubt and questioning, but without proof how can you accuse and condemn? Can't we use common sense and have balance in how we treat people? Not everyone has the same appearance. Not everyone is the same race. But we can all become children of Guruji. Asians have very little body hair. Many Americans have Native American blood. You realize American Indian men have no beards because this race has very little body hair as it is an asiatic subrace. Many Americans are blond or red-haired and the hairs are almost invisible. Mariah Carey has a pretty face by worldly standards. That does not make her a Gursikh because her actions prove otherwise. Some women have a pretty face but that doesn't make them a manmukh. If someone has a reason to publicly judge and say they are a hypocrite and discredit them with, then we have to listen. Otherwise it's simply prejudice and hatred of an innocent person [i]trying[/i] to live gursikhi best they can. We don't shave our eyebrows! [%sig%]