Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Ek Kaur · 16 Sep 2005

Seems to be ocurring more and more within the Sikh fraternity. We begin to ask questions in order to deconstruct rather than asking questions to learn. I am guilty of doing this too. Really feel the need to talk to people who will explain gurbani without subjective bias.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

singh · 17 Sep 2005

no need to ask, we have bhai sahibs books

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Lionking · 17 Sep 2005

yeah read Bhai Sahib Singh ji's Books and Gurbani explainations. www.gurugranthdarpan.com it's amazing, straightforward, and realiable explainations!

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Ek Kaur · 28 Sep 2005

Thank you Veer ji :o)

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

amrik singh · 28 Sep 2005

lol. how about trying to converse with Dhan Dhan Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee? every question or doubt is answered by Maharaj's Hukams.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

guru's student · 28 Sep 2005

Amrik singh got it spot on - talk to Guru Jee through his Bani - He's Parthak - the Jaagdi Jot of the 10 Guru's. Contemplate on Gurbani, worship your Guru and you'll get all your questions answered through AnBhav. Trust your Guru - don't trust anyone else.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Ek Kaur · 28 Sep 2005

Respected Veer Amrik Singh Jee, This is what I wish to do, but I need to equip myself with a basic grasp of meaning. Although I can read punjabi I find the language on some ankh of Guru Sahib complex and repitition has not helped me to understand it. This is why I seek explanation. In the same way my punjabi teacher told me Sebh means apple I need someone to tell me what rekh and bekh mean. I have looked briefly at the website veer Lionking receommnded. I think this might help.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Me · 28 Sep 2005

Yes, but for some Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's books come first.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

a singh · 28 Sep 2005

lol to Me. i understand your pain.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

lil question · 28 Sep 2005

Why do people call Bhai Randeer Singh, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randeer JI? I AM NOT STARTING AN AGRUMENT, but isnt putting Bhai Sahib in front of Bhai like callling him Sant without calling him a Sant? I again i am not here to start agruments.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

amrik singh · 28 Sep 2005

penji, i re-read your post and i think it was more the statement from my brother "singh" that i was replying to. and on reading it again, i believe that "singh" has done exactly what you wanted to get away from. i feel that Maharaj makes everything clear (or answers a question) in some shape, way or form. for example, every interaction with a Gurmukh pyara or listening to Kirtan always leaves me in amazement. how beautiful are the words said by my brother/sister guru's student - Vaheguru. all i can is that its ALL Maharaj. Vaheguru. ps penji, veer jee is soooo much more than enough - the dust of your feet. Vaheguru.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Sep 2005

Author: lil question Date: 09-28-05 09:44 Why do people call Bhai Randeer Singh, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randeer JI? I AM NOT STARTING AN AGRUMENT, but isnt putting Bhai Sahib in front of Bhai like callling him Sant without calling him a Sant? I again i am not here to start agruments. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Maybe it has something to do with the fact that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji IS the One and ONLY Singh in our History to have been HONOURED with FIVE SIROPAS from the FIVE TAKHATS. NO ONE...before him...or after him..since today has been bestowed this UNIQUE Honour. So it is wrong to say" People" put this Honorific title before his name... the JATHEDARS of the Five takhats put it there...for ETERNITY. By the way "BHAI SAHIB" is a Honoriifc....BHAI is usual for all Gursikhs. And also note that BSB Ji spent almost a QUARTER CENTURY in British govt JAILS...some of the WORST RAT HOLES in the World....for the SIKH KAUM...and he "won" every single battle with the authorities whenever they tried to interfere with his GURMATT/BIBEK/NITNEM/PAATH/KIRTAN/REHIT etc. ( read his book Jail Chitthiayan to get a handle on this aspect of his life..and struggles) He was already a very high ranking Govt official when the British govt tore down the wall of Gurdwara rakabganj in order to make a road..and the SIKH KAUM Protested...BHai Sahib jee were arrested in this Morcha..and from then it was chaal so chall....BEPARWAH of all the nuksaan of his own person and property..and all for the KAUM. and also note that no "sant" has been called "sant" by any Takhat..as that would violate GURBANI. Even the takhats Hazoor sahib and Patna sahib which are very Pro Sants and out of sgpc Control....have NEVER bestowed any title on any Sant..past or present. And also note that by now it would be clear that i am a very strong "admirer" of Bhai Sahib bhai Randheer Singh ji ...have been ever since i read jail chitthiayan as my first present from my dad ( and as such my views may seem "biased"...but i welcome anyone to refute what i have written above. Jarnail Singh

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

... · 28 Sep 2005

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singhjee was given the title of "Bhai Sahib" by the Panth.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

incredulous · 29 Sep 2005

why does the modern day panth hand out such titles? the guru's never handed out the title bhai sahib bhai gurdas ji, bhai sahib bhai sati dass, bhai sahib bhai mati dass, bhai sahib bhai bidhi chand, etc. they were only called 'bhai' ... IS the MODERN DAY panth better than the gurus ... WE NEED eQUaLiTy between all humanity, not glorification of CeRTaiN sikhs - Bhai Sahib Bhai's, Panth Rattan, Sants, Baba, etc - it's all the SAME

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Ek Kaur · 29 Sep 2005

Hey! This isn't supposed to be a debate about titles... :o( Respected Veer Amrik Singh Ji... I've read your post about 10 times now and 9 times I've said "yeah but what if I don't understand the words..." and then the tenth time it dawned upon me that I if I keep reading and conversing with Guru Granth Sahib Ji I will understand when Waheguru decides I am meant to understand. Sorry for being a bit slow! You're absolutely right and so is veer / bhenji Guru's student about trusting Guru Sahib alone. Forgive my ignorance.

Re: Debate v's Gurbani Parchar...

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 29 Sep 2005

Author: Ek Kaur Date: 09-29-05 07:49 Hey! This isn't supposed to be a debate about titles... :o( Respected Veer Amrik Singh Ji... I've read your post about 10 times now and 9 times I've said "yeah but what if I don't understand the words..." and then the tenth time it dawned upon me that I if I keep reading and conversing with Guru Granth Sahib Ji I will understand when Waheguru decides I am meant to understand. Sorry for being a bit slow! You're absolutely right and so is veer / bhenji Guru's student about trusting Guru Sahib alone. Forgive my ignorance. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< THATS WHY the TRUE GURU IS LAREEDAAR SROOP just as Guur Ji Wrote GURBANI..... A...reads and GURU JI "speaks" to him/her in his unique way.. B reads...and something else happens.. C reads... D reads..and so on..EACH SIKH SPEAKS to GURU JI on His/HER own PERSONAL RED LINE.... IF we read a Padchhedd sroop.... we are Speaking to GURU JI as the Person who did the Padchhedd did...that could be Gyani so and so, Sant So and so, Bhai Sahib so and so....ITS NOT " YOU"...YOU dont have that persoanl conncetion anymore..your line passes throught he "Switchboard" of the Paddchhedd writer.... LEARN from various persons..translations...teekas..BUT SPEAK to GURU JI ALONE and on YOUR own Personal LINE.... Jarnail Singh.