Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

K Singh · 15 Sep 2005

Click on the following link to listen to the talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala. Very interesting! http://www.ggsacademy.com/1984/rehras.html [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

S Singh · 15 Sep 2005

Ranjit Singh is very reluctant to make a statement to the effect that he will not give a programme where they describe him as a Sant. He also likes to mention that he has given/inspired a few lakh to take amrit.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

agyani · 15 Sep 2005

yes and we can see that darshan singh has clearly not control his "krodh" and makes money to feed his family?

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

ekta · 15 Sep 2005

is it wrong to make money to feed or familly?

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

http://vaheguruu.blogspot.com/ · 15 Sep 2005

VaheGuruu Jee Ka Khalsa VaheGuruu Jee Kee Fateh Very Intresting... good debate.. :-) VaheGuruu Jee Ka Khalsa VaheGuruu Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

S Singh · 15 Sep 2005

At least Profession Darshan Singh does not use the Sant tag to make money.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kabadi · 15 Sep 2005

Prof Darshan Singh is full of Krodh, he told a lie in the hazoori of SGGS JI saying Ranjit singh wore a kalgi when it was really a khanda..... Prof Darshan Singh seems like a full feldged hater...

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

singh · 15 Sep 2005

It was good but i really hate just people in general when someone is talking they keep cutting that person off. Prof Darshan Singh ji did this through out the whole conversation gave baba ranjit singh ji very less chance to clear all the allegations against him... prof ji keep cutting him off...it completely ruined it... i don't know may be prof ji wanted to shove words in his mouth...or may be it's just his nature to speak in high tone and cut people off. I can imagine how frustrated radio host must be.. prof ji keep cutting baba ranjit singh off after every 2 secs after reptitive request from the radio host. It was really annoying.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

agyani · 15 Sep 2005

Author: S Singh Date: 09-15-05 10:14 At least Profession Darshan Singh does not use the Sant tag to make money. well the way he acted i wouldnt quite call darshan a sant. another word maybe more suitable.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

........ · 15 Sep 2005

all i have to say is only a man filled with pride and anger who thinks he is better than the other will cut them off every ten seconds or 2 in this.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK Wala · 15 Sep 2005

Ranjit singh had no clear answer to the questions at hand... Will he stop the wrong use of the word of sant? NO Will he stop singing kachi bani? NO Instead he used the same excuses that his hero, mann of pehowa used to use... Prof. darshan singh needs to cool down a little, allow ranjit singh to partake in the debate a little more... Ranjit singh is a talented stage personality....with general knowledge of sikhi, but not a SANT, nothing close.....(which he indirecty admits to when he says that he was wrong to let sanghat 'mathatekh' to him!) Give it time, he will slip too. (ranjit singh too showed his colors at the end of the debate, Krodh.) Gurfateh, Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK Wala

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 15 Sep 2005

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Author: Kabadi Date: 09-15-05 11:09 Prof Darshan Singh is full of Krodh, he told a lie in the hazoori of SGGS JI saying Ranjit singh wore a kalgi when it was really a khanda..... Prof Darshan Singh seems like a full feldged hater... ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ You decide whether Prof Darshan Singh Ji was lying or whether Ranjit Singh was lying: [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

........ · 15 Sep 2005

Manvir ji, why are u lying, it is confirmed it is NOT NOT NOT a kalgi so drop it please, i cant take all these false allegations. he allowed mattha tek is different, we know. he did not wear a kalgi and we know. Kulbir ji, are u waiting for ppl to slip, do u sit in the gurdwara and look at sikhs and hope they will slip. u r lost and i am lost for words. are u sikh? sikhs dont wait around for ppl to slip

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

m sher singh · 15 Sep 2005

yeh its definately confirmed its not kalgi, Punjab times in uk makin more allegations today - that paper jus cant stop!! It a bit hypocritical when on their front page today they got another sant, sant baba amar singh ji i think and a singh bowing to him in respect, which is ok, but when it comes to sant ranjit singh - "o no - hes a fake" and they got stories of him inside the paper!! Awaze Quam International newspaper in uk made an apology for releasing such rubbish allegations last week in todays edition and so have des pardes! soz 4 ne mistake i may hav made................................................

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

singh 2 UK · 15 Sep 2005

can i just say even if you dont think this... i have the up most respect for Sant Ranjit Singh. Sant Ranjit Singh as helped fill my life with pyaar for Sikhi, which something i will never forget... and in my eyes i will always hold him up there in the same esteem as any Sant. lets all drop the critisms about him and focus on the really things we need to do.. If you really think hes not doing good parchar then your just kidding yourself!! PLZ people lets stop putting down a fellow gurusikh! im getting tired of reading about people just trying to look for any reason to put the guy dwn... its not doing any one any good is it???think

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

khalistani · 15 Sep 2005

just one thng i think ranjit singh is also LYING about how many people attend amrit sanchaars hes organized cause at malton on his site it said 700 people took amrit and asking people were there no more, barley, 200 people came maybe thas a computer error, maybe its my own personal stupidity but thas wat i saw bhula chuka maf

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kulraj Singh · 15 Sep 2005

Yeah, I have to admit, thats definately a kalgi. But so what if Sant Jee is wearin it? how is dat againt Sikhi?

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

kulbir Singh · 15 Sep 2005

I just listened to the conversation / debate between Ranjit Singh and Prof Darshan Singh. This is what I have to say: 1) Ranjit Singh has admitted that he was wrong for allowing people to matha-tek to him and that he has now stopped doing this. 2) Ranjit Singh has admitted that he was wrong in wearing those Rang-birangay (colourful) cholay and dastars. He says that he has now stopped wearing such clothes. 3) According to his statement, no one is born with Gurmat and that everyone learns Gurmat in Sangat. He has made mistakes in the past and is still learning. Professor in return to this said that it is not true that no one can realise Gurmat from birth. He cited a Gurbani Pankiti - "Tain Janmat Gurmat Brahm Pachhaniyo". I think his interpretation of this pankiti was wrong. He interpreted pankiti as "O Guru Arjun Dev jee, you realised Gurmat and Brahm (Vaheguru) right from the birth". But these meanings are not in accordance to Gurmat. The meanings should be - "O Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaaj, you realised Brahm, through Gurmat, right at the time of your birth". It was not Gurmat that Guru Sahib realised but it was through Gurmat i.e. through Guru Amardaas jee's kirpa that Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee realised Brahm right at the time of his birth. Gurmat here means receiving Naam from the true Guru. At the time of Satguru jee's physical body's birth, Siri Guru Amardaas jee blessed Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee with Amrit Naam, in his ear. As soon as Siri Guru jee heard Naam, he realised Brahm i.e. Vaheguru. Probably, Dhadrian did not realise that Professor had done wrong meaning of the pankiti and hence could not reply back. 4) He did not admit his mistake of doing dhaarna. He said that Bhindranwalay Sant used to do so, Sant Ishar Singh used to do it and Sant Attar Singh used to do it, therefore it must be okay to do it. 5) He was very defensive on the word Sant and could not respond back properly. Dhadrian categorically denied ever wearing a Kalgi. He said he has only wore Khanda and never a Kalgi. 6) Professor was not very impressive. He could not keep his cool and this reflected in him losing his oratary skills. 7) Dhadrian too was a bit agitated but he maintained excellent composure over his speech and never lost control over his speech. 8) He mentioned that "lakhs" of people are taking amrit. He kept bragging about it. This did not look good. 9) While debating, Dhadrian could have attacked Professor for eating meat and eggs. Maybe he did not think of it. He did attack Professor for accepting sangat's money and spending it on his family. Professor was very irked at this remark and never recovered after this. 10) Since he has admitted his mistake of allowing matha-tek to himself, wearing colourful cholay, it is not Gurmat to continue to attack him for these mistakes. One who admits mistake is not wrong any more. By the same token, if he does not live up to his confession, then surely sangat has the right to bring back his old mistakes as well. After hearing him, I have come to the conclusion that Dhadrian can do good for Panth if he does the following: 1) Do Parchaar of Gurmat by staying a humble Sikh. 2) He should not wear non-Gurmukhi baana like green or red suits like non-amritdhari bibiaan wear. 3) He should never allow matha tek. 4) He should do kamaayee of Gurmat Naam and Gurbani. Best thing would be if he got Naam DriR from Punj Pyaray and kept Bibek Sarblohi Rehit. 5) He should not make amrit cheap and should maintain proper maryada of amrit. 6) He should not attempt division in Panth the way Pehowa did by doing parchaar against Jatha. There are many good things about Dhadrian and if he walks on Gurmat, he can be an asset for Panth. Just my views and my personal opinion. Kulbir Singh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

not sure · 15 Sep 2005

Kulbir Veer Ji, "9) While debating, Dhadrian could have attacked Professor for eating meat and eggs. Maybe he did not think of it. He did attack Professor for accepting sangat's money and spending it on his family. Professor was very irked at this remark and never recovered after this. " Does that mean prof darshan singh eats meat and eggs??? u sure? jus wonderin, no arguing lols Also u said: "6) He should not attempt division in Panth the way Pehowa did by doing parchaar against Jatha." could u just explain what parchaar baba maan singh did and against which jatha?? thanks veer ji, im not arguing or nethin lol, jus humbly askin questions im not sure of thanks waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

ss · 15 Sep 2005

Professor Darshan Singh eats meat and eggs, are you sure kulbir singh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

ekta · 15 Sep 2005

ignorance to the one's who say dharna is kachi-bani, there is no such thing as kachi-bani. bani is paki cause its guru jis word. dharna are for un-paar jantha like my self.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

singh · 15 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh Ji, I agree with most of your points but i would like to stress on the point you made: 4) He should do kamaayee of Gurmat Naam and Gurbani. Best thing would be if he got Naam DriR from Punj Pyaray and kept Bibek Sarblohi Rehit. I just wanted to let you know he has done sangat of mahapursh- sant baba karam singh ji rara sahib (not hoti mardan ) ..baba karam singh ji was one of top students in dharamsala run by siri man sant baba isher singh ji rara sahib and sant baba kishan singh ji so i think he already got naam jugtiya from baba karam singh ji in form of panj who is unfortunately no longer in this world- he went sachkhand at 50 years old i beleive. I also do think bhai ranjit singh or baba whatever you want to call him- he started with good intentions but maya is getting to him slowly because of his excessive fame....he should ignore both fame and nindiya as mentioned in gurbani and do more naam simran in seculded place and do sangat of senior gurmukhs/sant mandali to be firm in his bairaag bhagti marg. Also your point about sarbloh bibek sounds good..however, he inspired by noors of bhai dya singh samparda..you will see all kinds of mahapursh in that samparda- sarbloh bibekis like- sant jawala singh ji harkhowaley, sant jagjit singh ji harkhowaley to aval mast fakir like - baba khuda singh ji, sahib baba karam singh ji hoti mardan waley to sant sorma's like- baba sahib singh bedi, baba bir singh nuarangabad...so sarbloh bibek is not must in that samparda he belongs to but it's personal choice, has its own level. I seriously beleive - this ranjit singh started with very good intentions....he was very sick when he got cured by guru's kirpa in hands of baba karam singh ji rara sahib that made him chose bairaag bhagti wala marg. Also i don't think he is against any jatha ..in fact in malton i heard he has praised all the jatha's including- akj's for their abhayas and panthic seva.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Mr. Singh · 15 Sep 2005

"ignorance to the one's who say dharna is kachi-bani, there is no such thing as kachi-bani. bani is paki cause its guru jis word." I heard Ranjit Singh Dhadrian valaa also lecture about this, that there is no such thing as kachi-bani. Hmmm. I suppose Ranjit Singh and ekta now know more than Guru Amar Daas Jee. I wonder why Guru Saahib would mention kuchi banee in the 24th paurree of Anand Saahib, if no such thing exists. I remember hearing Ranjit Singh saying this, and the whole time I kept wondering, "Doesn't he do nitnem of Anand Saahib? How can he say no such thing exists if he reads about it everyday in Anand Saahib?" If you want to defend dharnaa, go ahead, but don't deny that there is no such thing as kuchi bani. By doing so, you're questioning Guru Jee's words.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

poor vision · 15 Sep 2005

........ said, "Manvir ji, why are u lying, it is confirmed it is NOT NOT NOT a kalgi so drop it please, i cant take all these false allegations." I urge you to see an optometrist at the earliest possible time. Don't delay. Please.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kabadi · 15 Sep 2005

katha is not kachi bani, and it is done in the darbar of SGGS JI.... kavishar's also perform and so do dhadi jathas, ranjit singh basically does katha with dharnas to keep the sangat interested in the katha... but he is more of a katha vachak than a keertani he aint doing anythign wrong...

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

The Khalsa Fauj · 15 Sep 2005

Well, Prof. got hot because he has a reason. This guy also makes 5 Piaras touch his feet. There is a movie about it too. Read Sanjh Savera for more. derawalas ruin and have ruined the Sikh religion. Also old pople are expected to cut off others. They do it all the time. Old generation does it all the time. Everyone I have met has done this. Also no one is going to have all the qualities we look for in a person.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

kaur1978 · 16 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh Baba Ranjit Singh has taken Amrit already from the Panj Pyare. I do not understand why there is need to get pesh for him to retake Amrit and get Naam DriR. Amrit is Amrit. Why differentiate between Amrit from different jathas. What makes the Amrit from the Akhand Kirtani Jatha more superior? Amrit is a gift given by the Panj Pyares not a particular Jatha. He is not dividing the panth, he wants to bring the panth together. He tells people in his diwans that Nanaksar, Raara Sahib, Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Taksal are all good. People should rise above the jathas and attend programmes organised by all jathebandis and take the good points. I do not agree that he has made Amrit cheap. Amrit is given by the Panj Pyares to people who want Amrit and are ready for it. Amrit is for anyone who wants to take it and the Panj Pyares when they give Amrit tell people to abide by the maryada. I believe Baba Ranjit Singh is doing good parchar and pray to Waheguru Jee that he continues to do sewa this way. He has agreed that he will not allow people to matha tekh to him and wear colourful clothers and there is no point attacking him for those points as he has accepted his mistake.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

... · 16 Sep 2005

i agree with kulbir singh - ranjit singh can be good if he stays humble and keeps to his rehit and maryada - he's admitted that the matha-teking was a mistake - time to give him a break and stop doing nindiya of him - i pray that ranjit singh continues doing good for the panth darshan singh was awful in the interview - ranjit singh even said to him "i'll stop doing dhaarnas if you tell me to stop" but darshan singh just stayed quiet - if darshan singh thought dhaarnas were so bad, why didnt he tell Ranjit Singh to stop also about darshan singh making money from the sangat - he didnt deny it, whereas ranjit singh said that all money he received was always used for sangat purposes darshan singh just sounded like a jealous old man and a hypocrite

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

S Singh · 16 Sep 2005

>>Manvir ji, why are u lying, it is confirmed it is NOT NOT NOT a kalgi so drop it please, i cant take all these false allegations." I urge you to see an optometrist at the earliest possible time. Don't delay. Please. Looks like a kalgi with a khanda on it. Khanda for dastaar do not have them kalgi type decorations that lead from the front of the dastaar to the sides (ropes). You can say what you want now and perhaps you could see an eye surgeon if you still think it is a standard dastaar khanda.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Gurpreet Kaur · 16 Sep 2005

m sher singh, that guy on the front page of punjab times wasnt bowing to him, he bent down to recieve a saropa which didnt come up in the same picture, I was there so I would know, just wanted to clarify that. People generally bend down slightly when saying Fateh or something out of respect. Regarding the debate I have to say prof sahib made some great points, baba ranjit singh said he didnt even celebrate his birthday this year, that made me laugh.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Gurpreet Kaur · 16 Sep 2005

guys, proff sahib does eat meat and he spends the money on his family, but he needs to earn money somehow right? he spends all that time doing parchar, its only fair he can feed his own family, he has never ever asked for any money, that much I can say. My dad has audio tapes of him in which proff darshan singh has sung dharna, including 'dhan baba nanak tuhi nirankar', then he argues against it, bit weird. Oh well, lets look at both sides and be fair, no matter who he is. That looks like a kalgi to be honest, but er..dunno..maybe some khandey are designed to look that way now.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

agyani · 16 Sep 2005

Author: poor vision Date: 09-15-05 19:29 ........ said, "Manvir ji, why are u lying, it is confirmed it is NOT NOT NOT a kalgi so drop it please, i cant take all these false allegations." I urge you to see an optometrist at the earliest possible time. Don't delay. Please. EVEN 'prof' 'jealous' darshan admits that he was wrong for LYING on stage about the kalgi accusation!

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Sarabjit Singh · 16 Sep 2005

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh!! Its funny a person like Prof. Darshan Singh is being compared to a sel-proclaimed sant Ranjit Singh Prof. Darshan Singh spent 3 long years in jail for the sake of Panth. For months on end, we was made to stand in an iron cage during winters in the jail compound. Various methods of torture were applied on him throughtout his jail term but he never budged from his stand. Here we have Ranjit Singh with no contribution to the panth, proclaiming himself as a sant and declaring that lakhs took amrit because of him. I am reminded of the drama that Delhi Gurdwara Committee plays every year, in which thousands of people take amrit. Most of them repeating the exercise every year. Ranjit Singh's gimmicks are in similar fashion. I know some die-hard Ranjit Singh fans will continue to live in denial and refuse to accept him as fake but so does the followers of Radhasoamis and Nirankaris. The guy is just another wannabe who wants to make a quick buck in the name of religion. Panth will always be in Chardi Kala!! Sarabjit Singh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

? · 16 Sep 2005

Singh sahib Prof Darshan singh Jee has done alot for the comm funny how people suddenly slating him for a "sant" hunna. Prof Darshan SIngh Jee spoke out in 80's he has never been afraid to speak out and has don so much... hmae we forget.. I agree with Sarabjit Singh, and LOL to delhi Gurdwara committiee...

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

poor vision · 16 Sep 2005

agyani said, "EVEN 'prof' 'jealous' darshan admits that he was wrong for LYING on stage about the kalgi accusation!" I don't know who's admitted what. I am just going by what's in the picture posted above. Looks like a kal(n)gee to me. If it isn't, please explain what exactly it is.

Amrit sanchaar by present day fake baabe

Harpreet Singh · 16 Sep 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh I wish to bring in an important point here about all the discussion taking place about Ranjit Singh Dhadrian and other baaabe. Every month almost all self styled Sant/Brahmgiani baabe update their websites or can be heard somwhere in media/divaan that last amrit sanchaar made lakhs of people become amritdhari. Question I have is well if we have lakhs of amritdharis made by kirpa of these babaji's why the panth is still in so much disarray. Every single amritdhari singh = 1.25 Lakh. If we had lakhs amritdharis or even hundreds amritdharis produced every month or so, should we not have millions of them by now. Where do they disappear? Why is so much strength of Amritdhari khalsa not visible. Why we always see majority of gurughars being visited by patits and only very few amritdhari singh/bibis. Is it that there is something lacking? Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Sikher · 16 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh stated: 2) He should not wear non-Gurmukhi baana like green or red suits like non-amritdhari bibiaan wear. Q. Why do the Nihang and Taksal Jathebandies prevent people from wearing these colours? 4) He should do kamaayee of Gurmat Naam and Gurbani. Best thing would be if he got Naam DriR from Punj Pyaray and kept Bibek Sarblohi Rehit. Q. Surely he would have received naam when he took amrit.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Liongking · 16 Sep 2005

Prof Darshan Singh crushes him - the only response Veer Ranjit Singh has is - My parchar has given Amrit to lakhs and lakhs

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

kaur · 16 Sep 2005

Liongking - More like Baba Ranjit Singh crushes Prof Darshan Singh. At least Baba Ranjit Singh is doing parchar of Amrit and thats the most important aspect in Sikhi - so many lakhs of people have taken Amrit... the parcharaks in the Panth cannot take it any more and start criticising Baba Ranjit Singh. Its not only Darshan Singh but many others I know who have mentioned how he is doing wrong over the last couple of months. How many so called "Sants" are out there - How come Prof Darshan Singh has not confronted them. Its because Baba Ranjit Singh is doing a great job in the panth and the parcharak are worried about their positions in the panth. One should become happy when someone takes Amrit but here many hundreds of thousands are taking Amrit being inspired by Baba Ranjit Singh - Instead of being happy, there is a lot of criticism - jealousy as Baba Ranjit Singh sums up. If Darshan Singh is so concerned why did he not tell Baba Ranjit Singh to stop his parchaar..

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

kaur · 16 Sep 2005

Liongking - More like Baba Ranjit Singh crushes Prof Darshan Singh. At least Baba Ranjit Singh is doing parchar of Amrit and thats the most important aspect in Sikhi - so many lakhs of people have taken Amrit... the parcharaks in the Panth cannot take it any more and start criticising Baba Ranjit Singh. Its not only Darshan Singh but many others I know who have mentioned how he is doing wrong over the last couple of months. How many so called "Sants" are out there - How come Prof Darshan Singh has not confronted them. Its because Baba Ranjit Singh is doing a great job in the panth and could it be that the parcharak are worried about their own positions in the panth. One should become happy when someone takes Amrit but here many hundreds of thousands are taking Amrit being inspired by Baba Ranjit Singh - Instead of being happy, there is a lot of criticism - jealousy as Baba Ranjit Singh sums up. If Darshan Singh is so concerned why did he not tell Baba Ranjit Singh to stop his parchaar.. Darshan Singh had no answer when Baba Ranjit Singh said that Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale, Sant Baba Isher Singh did Dharna.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kulbir Singh · 16 Sep 2005

------------- Does that mean prof darshan singh eats meat and eggs??? u sure? jus wonderin, no arguing lols ----------- I don’t think Professor would deny that he does not eat meat. A close Singh’s relative went to pick up Professor and noticed that Professor was eating eggs. I am not sure if he has given up eating meat and eggs now, but few years ago, he used to eat eggs and meat. -------------- Also u said: "6) He should not attempt division in Panth the way Pehowa did by doing parchaar against Jatha." could u just explain what parchaar baba maan singh did and against which jatha?? ------------- Pehowa used to speak very severely about Akhand Kirtani Jatha in his diwans. I personally witnessed this in one of his diwans when he first came to Toronto. I never ever went to his diwan again. He was saying all these things against AKJ to please the Taksali Singhs who were very prominent in the Gurdwara he was speaking in. He raised the issue of Keski and Raagmala and really came very heavily on Jatha. Kulbir Singh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

amarjeet singh · 16 Sep 2005

vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh [gurbani]nwnk AMimRqu eyku hY dUjw AMimRqu nwih ][/gurbani] there is only one amrit, when given amrit the candidat is given naam driR. this is the one amrit. in gurbani it says we should jap waheguru with evry breath, which is why when we take amrit and the naam is installed within us we are taught how to naam jap with evry breath (swaas swaas simran) vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

... · 16 Sep 2005

so what abt all those who had "amrit" but not "Naam DriR" - are they not Amritdhari in the true sense?

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

jss · 16 Sep 2005

kulbir veer just my observation... ranjit singh ji isn't teh same as maan singh in malton..he praised the akj... and he also stressed wearing of keski by the bibiyyaan....both in TOronto and the vichar i heard him do in vancouver...

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

S Singh · 16 Sep 2005

>>Author: Liongking Date: 09-16-05 05:37 >>Prof Darshan Singh crushes him - the only response Veer Ranjit Singh has is - My parchar has given Amrit to lakhs and lakhs To defend himself against the professors comments on dharna he said Baba Jarnail Singh Ji and Baba Isher Singh Ji used to do the same. Someone should have reminded Ranjit Singh Ji that these two servants of the Panth never boasted about numbers. All Baba Jarnail Singh used to say was that it was his work to inspire people to take amrit and Guru de lar loyna. This Ranjit Singh only cares about boasting about the lakhs he claims to have inspired. He should also have know that Baba Isher Singh Ji was known not to hanker after money and put any offerings after a program into Guru Da Golak. Ranjit Singh is always eager to cart away his nightly takings. If he wants to use the name of such highly regarded Sikhs he should act like them as well when it comes to money and not boasting about lakhs. >>darshan singh was awful in the interview - ranjit singh even said to him "i'll stop doing dhaarnas if you tell me to stop" but darshan singh just stayed quiet - if darshan singh thought dhaarnas were so bad, why didnt he tell Ranjit Singh to stop Ranjit Singh was worse than awful all he did was make boasts about these lakhs of people (I wonder where they are as everytime I go to Punjab I never see them and in fact see more and more mona). As if Ranjit Singh would do as the professor said, how many times in the interview did the professor ask Ranjit Singh to make a commitment not to attend any function where he was labelled a Sant, each time this was bought up Ranjit Singh failed to commit himself and meandered away form the question. If Ranjit Singh was only interested in parchar he could have openly agreed to the professors request.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

harpreet · 16 Sep 2005

Nobody is gona have all the qaulities we look for in a person. Wether it be Ranjit Singh or Professor saab. Someone said that above, i couldnt agree more. Stop pinpointing everything wrong about someones character and focus on the good of both individuals. Everyone has faults.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

.Singh. · 16 Sep 2005

Why is it necessary to have Naam DriR. Maskeen said that you do not need a technique to recite Naam. If you have the thirst you will recite it.. Do you need a technique to eat food, drink water... NO.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Sep 2005

Author: .Singh. Date: 09-16-05 10:16 Why is it necessary to have Naam DriR. Maskeen said that you do not need a technique to recite Naam. If you have the thirst you will recite it.. Do you need a technique to eat food, drink water... NO. <<<<<<<<<<<<<< MASKEEN JI IS JUST ONE PERSON...HE IS NOT GURU JI Secondly babies do need a "technique" to start sucking milk..drink from a spoon..and then from container ( without spilling)..etc how to eat food..chew..swallow without choking..etc... Just because we "learnt" as babies doesnt mean we DONT NEED a technique ?? BTW..I havent got the naamdrirr myself (YET) as I chhak Amrit from sgpc Maryada panj who just mentioned WAHEGURU is GURMANTAR and for japping...

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

............ · 16 Sep 2005

jarnail singh ji ''I chhak Amrit from sgpc Maryada panj who just mentioned WAHEGURU is GURMANTAR and for japping...'' you make it sound as if the panj didnt do a good job , whats with the use of ''just'', could be phrased better to show some respect

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

AS · 16 Sep 2005

Prof. Darshan Singh does not need to prove himself to anyone. He has been doing parchar longer than most of us have been alive. He has a deep and practical knowledge of Gurbani and has also never been afraid to speak of the Panth's political situation. Prof Darshan Singh does not make up folk lores and stories like most of these Pakhandy Babas and Sants do. He speaks of Gurbani very straight forward and logically in a way that makes sense. During this radio interview, I do agree that at times Prof. Sahib does come across as eager and irritated, but he is just as frustrated if not more with Baba Ranjit Singh as we are and so, he expressed his frustration with him. I believe that everything Prof. Darshan Singh said to Baba Ranjit Singh was right on the money and was called for, but the way he went about saying it was a little bit off at times.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

NS · 16 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Firstly Lionking and S Singh Jeeo you guys are 100% SPOT ON. Kulbir Singh Ji, I 'm most surprised at your view on Prof Daarshan Singh Ji , you thorw the spanner in anyway about meat and eggs just to get the momentum going on the thread... you haven't actually seen Prof Sahib eat meat and eggs and don't know if does so now or not.. The problem with us is that we seem to make a very immature opinion so quickly. I would reiterate to listen to the interview again. I listened to it several times and here is my view: 1. Prof Sahib Ji was 100 % spot on and reiterated to Ranjit Singh on the SANT stance Dharana and everything. Ranjit the young lad didn't have a leg to stand on. 2. If Ranjit Singh was such a great BABA AND SANT as procalimed by some on this thread...he should've had the humility to show respect to Prof Sahib who has been the Jathedaar of the Akal Takht and one of the gems in the panth today. Ranjit should've spoken to him as a father figure and admit his mistakes which 100 fold. 3. Prof Sahib was excellent never irked anywhere was steadfast on Gurmat Marayda and his interruptions were excellent to Ranjit Singh who still never got the message to apologize to the sangat and change his ways. 4. Prof Sahib gave him the full monty on Gurmat against the Pakand ways that Ranjit has presented himself. 5. Ranjit was excellent when he said that no one is born a Gurmattaya and he has changed his ways..now it'll be even more excellent if does change his ways further as he too is SIKH (Student) just like the rest of us. 6. Ranjit SIngh tries his best to say that the money he has collected goes on Gurdwaras..and the money Prof has received it has gone on his family...I would say what is wrong here , Ranjit Singh uses a weak argument, he should've thought before money, the air he breathes, that's given by God, the mind the body the intellect all given by God, one should use them as appropriately for the betterment for the panth if one has the specail gift. The gift is there and still present in Prof Sahib, and I for one wouldn't hesitate at all to give him money for the excellent parcahar of Gurmat and Tat Maraydaya he has done and continues to do so.. 7.Ranjit the young lad tries to be clever or is innocent on sikhe and uneducated to a certain extent on sikhe priniciples when he says to Prof Sahib that I will stop dharnas if you say... how absurd doesn;t this young lad know that the Akal Takht Marayda is against all Dharans, well of course he does but he doesn;t want to obey. He uses another childish argument that Sant Jarnail Singh Ji used Dharan..sure he did but look at the comparison of Jarnail SIngh as posted above by S Singh. Sant Jarnail Singh Ji wouldn't accept Jeeps or cars liek this young lad has out of pyar...he says.. People really need to listen to this again before making quick judgements. If he was a true SANT he should've shown the utmost respect for Prof Sahib and should've replied SATBACHAN to all the queries. Prof Sahib Ji has been Akal takht Jathedar and has suffereed in 84 but still continued his excellent parchar at that time he is one of the jewels in the panth today. I would request people to listen to Prof Sahib Ji's works which will always be excellent and a challange for the joe average sikh like myself to undertand and apply in daily life. [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

NS · 16 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh AS Jess absolutley correct ...

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

............ · 16 Sep 2005

well looks like the prof has not practiced sikhi with the krodh, inside he is got something missing, just cos u been preaching for milleniums dont make u a better person, age and experience do not make us better sikhs, maybe better drivers ;)

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Princess · 16 Sep 2005

In above picture it's a kalgi. How can you say it's not a kalgi??? I think you guys even don't know what kalgi looks like.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Sep 2005

MY Best Regards to NS.... For once someone else has beaten me to it. EXACTLY what i would have said and written. Anyone who acquired the SANT title TWO YEARS AGO...shouldnt Have celebrated his Birthday ( even THEN he was a SANT !! was he not ??) SO HOW can a SANT make a MISTAKE ?? To make matters worse he is NOT APOLOGISING..he is dragging in Sants Like Jarnail Singh to back him up on dhaarnas...when he should KNOW that this is BANNED by AKAL TAKHAT...and NO BODY..SANT or NOT is HIGHER than AKAL TAKHAT. PERIOD. Prof sahib has been a JATHEDAR of Akal takhat and deserves our very utmost RESPECT. ( Some babbling Id*** had the gall to call him a babbling old man.. shows his own immaturity...just wait till YOU are 65 years old and see what you turn into !!!). Prof sahib Ji has been a KIRTANIYA...and Shabad Bhet is a common thing....and whats wrong if he uses that to feed his family...he DOESNT recieve Mercedes cars and Gold necklaces and Kambals...or matha tekao to himself. Ranjit Singh goes agaisnt Maryada by NOT having a Family..and spends all his money on HIS DERA !! Listen agian..the upstart lad doesnt have a leg to stand on and NEVER admitted to any mistake..just DOUBLE SPEAK to tide the time. Jarnail Singh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

charanjeev singh · 16 Sep 2005

"Best thing would be if he got Naam DriR from Punj Pyaray and kept Bibek Sarblohi Rehit" what is Naam Drir according to you? Do you feel that the panj takhats give Naam Drir to the Gursikhs whom come for Amrit from Panj Pyareh? please answer this waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

jag · 16 Sep 2005

Newspaper Sanjh Savera, Radio Punjab UK, Punjabi Radio station Vancouver thanks Prof Darshan singh for his efforts to uproot Deras. http://www.sanjhsavera.com/sep1505.html#1 http://www.sanjhsavera.com/main.html Compare official sites of Prof Darshan singh www.ggsacademy.com and Ranjit singh www.parmeshardwar.com. On GGS Academy you do not find any of his pictures, as he is not photo and fame hungry. Whole discussion to me appear as a bad idea as person of caliber of Prof Darshan Singh should not waste his time talking to novice, but I think he actually wanted to help Ranjit Singh from going wrong path, We have seen his video, these sants have short period of fame, as tomorrow another new one will appear. In past 5 years so many have appeared and disappeared each with claim of making laks amritdhari but in Punjab villages you just do not see those Amritdharis. Not everyone can have same thinking on ideas but it is very sad to see that some of community today is giving lecture of humbleness to a person whose contribution and humbleness in the panth today is unmatched. Are we good only for lectures, where are all these voices when Kachi Bani is sung from gurudwaras. Did it not pain you to see Dhur kee Bani being replaced with Kachi Dharans? If we have to tolerate this insult of Guru shabad then why we upset over Ashutosh, Narinkaris etc. Do not think that attack always is in physical form like Blue Start, more dangerous is the attack on principles, refusal to accept Sikh Rehat Maryada and dividing panth into own maryadas is more dangerous. It is sad that while we held people from history like Bhai Sukha Singh and Mehtab Singh who could not tolerate the insult of Guru Darbar as our heroes but then refuse to acknowledge and support people who are trying to awaken quam to grave threats today. If a person comes to your house to steal, will you humbly tell him to go away, you will be upset, mad? Like us all Prof Darshan Singh ji is very upset and frustrated with Dera menace as is evident from last several programs which will be shared with sangat on same site and his inner upset feeling are clearly reflected in his talk. If folks ever look into 20-year-old history, that was the one voice, which went from Gurudwara to Gurdwara after 1984 blue star to raise the sprits of Panth, on the same very page there are several recordings from that period. Alias we as a sangat never supported him, for proof, I have two tapes with me one from Sept 1984 when a Parbandhak in Gurdwara in Ambala request him not to talk about Blue Star and other one from Gurudwara Karatpur Sahib Dec 1984 where Stage secretary announces that Prof Darshan Singh ji do not touch on political environment (he meant Delhi riots). Then later at sewa of Akal takhat when he saw criminalization of ranks of militants, he tried to bring them on right path, seeing that not happening he resigned. Armed Panthic committees could not threaten him, there was time when most of gurudwara abroad did not invite him for keertan because of so called militant pressure, but he never changed his principles. While most of other leaders preferred to remain silent and after 1994 they started speaking how militant movement was hijacked etc. where as he tried to put militants on correct path when it was right time to avoid unnecessary blood shed and bad name. Now when he has confronted Derawala's instead of supporting him we are trying to lecture him. In Sikh character today, occupying post is OK, but nobody ever gracefully resigns or sits home and give other chance, we have seen that some jathedars who were removed by SGPC never acknowledged even their sacking what to talk of resignation. In that period actually some who were not even nominated by SGPC like Gurdev Singh, GS Manochahal even claimed themselves to be jathedars, what more humbleness are we looking for………….

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kharkoo Singh · 17 Sep 2005

The goal of putting this link up wasnt for us to take sides and start mudslinging at the opposite party. It was merely to arouse awareness and the need for citical thinking which is so dearly lacking in the sikh community today. I agree with many of the above posts that perhaps Singh Sahib Ji came across as occasionaly interruptive and could have excecised some more patience in the discussion. But aside from that one criticism can anyone actually point out any part of his argument which was flawed or lacked merit? Yes Bhai Ranjit Singh came across as being less interuptive, but was this actually due to a much higher level of inherent patience in him (vs. Pro Darshan Singh) or simply silence due to a much more limited knowledge of gurbani and ability to form strong quick counterarguments to the debate? Singh Sahib stated from the start that he had no personal vendetta against Ranjit Singh, he simply wanted to adress the damage done within our community by the misuse of the word "Sant". One thing i did notice was that Ranjit Singh continually avoided answering the questions posed to him. He refused to admit his own mistakes and simply attributed them to lack of understanding (this from someone doin katha to the masses under the guise of sant) and later became more defensive and used references from other people as examples to support his own stance. I have nothing against Ranjit Singh, im sure he has many good qualities in him, for so many people to be attracted to his katha he has obvious charisma. However, what i do have an issue with is that he lacks the very fundamental understanding of gurbani and gurmat. And for someone in his position, to be able teach and inspire people by the thousands, it is absolutely critical that his base of the fundamental roots and prinicples of Sikhi be strong and clear. To argue that so many people have taken amrit as a result of my parchaar, or that ther is nothin wrong with singing kuchee dharnas, cuz as many "sants" before me thousands of people have taken amrit because of these dhaarnas is ridiculous. To distinguish somethin as being True and good vs false and bad simply by a number count has no merit whatsoever. People are ALWAYS drawn to falsehood in larger numbers. This was true during the time of Guru Nanak and is still true today. Otherwise, if the "sants" of today can give amrit to hundreds of thousands of people in their single lifetime, wudnt such incomparable and powerful personalites as the Ten Gurus have been able to make all the citizens of Panjab Sikhs during the span of over 240 years? And on another point, we have made amrit to mean simply khanday dhi pahul. Simply drinking some sweetned nectar, donning the panj kakar and magically becoming gursikhs in the saroop of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. But amrit isnt a baptism of the body by holy water, its a baptism of the mind by the Naam. Once someone enshrines the gunn, the virtues of Naam in their jeevan have they truly taken amrit. And this is a long process of mental, spirutal change. Not some magical sudden overnight change. Hence, why do we find the sad state where so many "amritdhari" men and women of today are engaged in slander, jealousy, anger, lies, corruption, ego. Are the "amrtidhari" people walking out of these fast-food "weekend amrit sanchaars" of the same noble and divine character as the sikhs who lived and dies so gallantly during the time of Guru Gobind Singh? And if not, does this mean there is a missing ingredient in the amrit of today versus then or have we missed the boat and started treating this Gift of armit as a mere religious ritual? And one final comment, for those who may unfortunately think that Singh Sahib himself is full of some sort of eerkha, or jealousy towards Ranjit Singh, i suggest u ponder this simple point: Why would someone suppsodly full of haumay voluntarily resign from the sewa of Jathedar of Akal Takhat in his prime, a post held in such high admiration and esteem throughout the world? And it shud be noted that the notion of eerkha was brought up by Ranjit Singh himself in the discussion, when he made the distinction that he at a mere age of 22, had attained such respect and a large following compared to Singh Sahib whose been doing sewa till now at the age of 65. Who has hints of jealousy there? hmmm... Again, nothing personal against bhai ranjit singh or any other self-proclaimed or sangat proclaimed "sant", but i think we all need to take some time and understand the true meaning of the term Sant and not be led astray by those who forever reasons exploit this title and use it for personal gain. And if they truly are unknowing and lack the understanding of gurbani and have made an honest mistake then it is our duty as Sikhs of the Guru, to point out these misunderstanding to them, in a calm, respectful manner so that not only can they become better Sikhs but so can the sangat who sits in their parchaar. Apologies if anythin came across as rude or being biased. The only side i take is that of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. May Waheguru bless us all with the understanding of Gurbani.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kharkoo Singh · 17 Sep 2005

The goal of putting this link up wasnt for us to take sides and start mudslinging at the opposite party. It was merely to arouse awareness and the need for citical thinking which is so dearly lacking in the sikh community today. I agree with many of the above posts that perhaps Singh Sahib Ji came across as occasionaly interruptive and frustrated, and could have excecised some more patience in the discussion. But aside from that one criticism can anyone actually point out any part of his argument which was flawed or lacked merit? Yes Bhai Ranjit Singh came across as being less interuptive, but was this actually due to a much higher level of inherent patience in him (vs. Pro Darshan Singh) or simply silence due to a much more limited knowledge of gurbani and ability to form strong quick counterarguments to the debate? Singh Sahib stated from the start that he had no personal vendetta against Ranjit Singh, he simply wanted to adress the damage done within our community by the misuse of the word "Sant". One thing i did notice was that Ranjit Singh continually avoided answering the questions posed to him. He refused to admit his own mistakes and simply attributed them to lack of understanding (this from someone doin katha to the masses under the guise of sant) and later became more defensive and used references from other people as examples to support his own stance. I have nothing against Ranjit Singh, im sure he has many good qualities in him, for so many people to be attracted to his katha he has obvious charisma. However, what i do have an issue with is that he lacks the very fundamental understanding of gurbani and gurmat. And for someone in his position, to be able teach and inspire people by the thousands, it is absolutely critical that his base of the fundamental roots and prinicples of Sikhi be strong and clear. To argue that so many people have taken amrit as a result of my parchaar, or that ther is nothin wrong with singing kuchee dharnas, cuz as many "sants" before me thousands of people have taken amrit because of these dhaarnas is ridiculous. To distinguish somethin as being True and good vs false and bad simply by a number count has no merit whatsoever. People are ALWAYS drawn to falsehood in larger numbers. This was true during the time of Guru Nanak and is still true today. Otherwise, if the "sants" of today can give amrit to hundreds of thousands of people in their single lifetime, wudnt such incomparable and powerful personalites as the Ten Gurus have been able to make all the citizens of India Sikhs during the span of over 240 years? And on another point, we have made amrit to mean simply khanday dhi pahul. Simply drinking some sweetned nectar, donning the panj kakar and magically becoming gursikhs in the saroop of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. But amrit isnt a baptism of the body by holy water, its a baptism of the mind by the Naam. Only when someone enshrines the gunn, the virtues of Naam in their jeevan have they truly taken amrit. And this is a long process of mental, spirutal change. Not some magical sudden overnight change. Hence, why do we find the sad state where so many "amritdhari" men and women of today are engaged in slander, jealousy, anger, lies, corruption, ego. Are the "amrtidhari" people walking out of these fast-food "weekend amrit sanchaars" of the same noble and divine character as the sikhs who lived and dies so gallantly during the time of Guru Gobind Singh? And if not, does this mean theres is missing ingredient in the amrit of today versus then or have we missed the boat and started treating this Gift of armit as a mere religious ritual? And one final comment, for those who may unfortunately think that Singh Sahib himself is full of some sort of eerkha, or jealousy towards Ranjit Singh, i suggest u ponder this simple point: Why would someone suppsodly full of haumay voluntarily resign from the sewa of Jathedar of Akal Takhat in his prime, a post held in such high admiration and esteem throughout the world? And it shud be noted that the notion of eerkha was brought up by Ranjit Singh himself in the discussion, when he made the distinction that he at a mere age of 22, had attained such respect and a large following compared to Singh Sahib whose been doing sewa till now at the age of 65. Who has hints of jealousy there? hmmm... Again, nothing personal against bhai ranjit singh or any other self-proclaimed or sangat proclaimed "sant", but i think we all need to take some time and understand the true meaning of the term Sant and not be led astray by those who forever reasons exploit this title and use it for personal gain. And if they truly areunknowing and lack the understandin of gurbani and have made an honest mistake then it is our duty as Sikhs of the Guru, to point out these misunderstandings to them, in a calm, respectful manner so that not only can they become better Sikhs but so can the sangat who sits in their parchaar. Apologies if anythin came across as rude or being biased. The only side i take is that of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. May Waheguru bless us all with the understanding of Gurbani. [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

undergroundsingh · 17 Sep 2005

why u singhs r too aggresive towards the saints. they do a lot of sikhi parchar, and ur saying that they have not naam drid, but the paanj payaree earlier than 50 years ago gave naam and not jaaphi payee naam drid as now a days by only one organisation who call themselves superior than all the puratan taksaals,nihang singhs,dhadee kavasheree,nirmala saints.all these were actually began with guru's blessings,if you would read itihaas. this organisation do not have vishvaas on guru granth sahib je maharaj as i have seen not narrating some banis and even shankaa or doubts on bhagat baani and bhai gurdas je. i would say please do not nindaa anyone who is converting a lot of manmatias into sikhs,by the simple tradational means which were and are practised by great saints of malawa region in punjab. i hope you would not parchaar against the preachers. if you actually want to yhen come on the land of 5rivers and do parcharr in punjab

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Lionking · 17 Sep 2005

Regarding the debate I have to say prof sahib made some great points, baba ranjit singh said he didnt even celebrate his birthday this year, that made me laugh. ______________ I was gonna post about thay as well - atleast I'm not the only one who found tha hilarious - Mai ess sal apna janamdin vi ni manaya - in a sad voice lol _______________ My dad has audio tapes of him in which proff darshan singh has sung dharna, including 'dhan baba nanak tuhi nirankar', _______________ People change - if Veer Ranjit SIngh Changes and sings Gurbani too - most people will stop opposing him. _____________ m sher singh, that guy on the front page of punjab times wasnt bowing to him, he bent down to recieve a saropa which didnt come up in the same picture, I was there so I would know, just wanted to clarify that. People generally bend down slightly when saying Fateh or something out of respect. ____________ Thans for clarification. I can't believe people are now cussing Prof Darshan Singh ji who has done seva for over 50 yrs of the panth - Ofcourse he woudl get angry - I would be angry as well, on how he's trying to justify himself saying Bhindrawaley, Ishar SIngh ji etc did it so why can't it? 1- Is he trying to say he's at the same level as them? 2- WRong is WRong - like Prof Darshan SIngh ji said - According to Sikh Rehit Maryada its wrong - it's wrong... ____________ EVEN 'prof' 'jealous' darshan admits that he was wrong for LYING on stage about the kalgi accusation _______________ Is the exjathedar of Akal Thakat Jealous of Veer Ranjit Singh ji? Of what? the good Dharnas he can sing? HA! hahaha Sarcasm level: MAX ********* Prof. Darshan Singh spent 3 long years in jail for the sake of Panth. For months on end, we was made to stand in an iron cage during winters in the jail compound. Various methods of torture were applied on him throughtout his jail term but he never budged from his stand *********** Exactly! Veer Ranjit SIngh talks about giving AMrit to lakhs - but where are these? - Where has th emoney Gone? Shaheed parivar? that he didn't mention... *********** Liongking - More like Baba Ranjit Singh crushes Prof Darshan Singh. At least Baba Ranjit Singh is doing parchar of Amrit and thats the most important aspect in Sikhi - so many lakhs of people have taken Amrit... the parcharaks in the Panth cannot take it any more and start criticising Baba Ranjit Singh. Its not only Darshan Singh but many others I know who have mentioned how he is doing wrong over the last couple of months. ************** So Where are these Lakhs like BHai Harpreet Singh ji mentioned. If these Sants give Amrit to lakhs - WHere are they? WHy isn't Panjab overfull of Amritdharis? You can barely find Amrithdaris in Panjab now - so wheeree are these Amritdharis - is there a certain Pidn tha has trapped tham all? ******** How many so called "Sants" are out there - How come Prof Darshan Singh has not confronted them. Its because Baba Ranjit Singh is doing a great job in the panth and the parcharak are worried about their positions in the panth. ******** No he even said - keep oin doign the parchar - but do it ina GURMAT WAY- not MANMAT i.e Dharna - if he was worried he would have approached - Panjab Radio, Maskeen Ji, Bhai Gurqbal SIngh ji, etc - no he didn't , did he? **** One should become happy when someone takes Amrit but here many hundreds of thousands are taking Amrit being inspired by Baba Ranjit Singh - Instead of being happy, there is a lot of criticism - jealousy as Baba Ranjit Singh sums up **** SO where are these Amritdharis? ** If Darshan Singh is so concerned why did he not tell Baba Ranjit Singh to stop his parchaar.. ** Cause that isn't his point - his point is to stop the manmat - he even said - do the parchar u do - but do it in the GURMAT WAY ***** Darshan Singh had no answer when Baba Ranjit Singh said that Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale, Sant Baba Isher Singh did Dharna. ***** He did - he said Acording to Panthic Rehit Maryada - it was wrong These Guru key Lal, Gurmukh Pyaarey have 10000000's of good things - but the thing they didnt wrong, opposite to Gurmat - is manmat - as Jarnail Singh ji earlier mentioned in an earlier thread. GO T Akal Takhat and tell thme to change the maryada - they are wrong - the above mentioend where above Akal Takhat - GO AND SAY IT IF ABOVE WERE HIGHER THAN AKAL TAKHAT! Thank you SSingh for ur "Wicked post" :) Author: S Singh Date: 09-16-05 09:47 >>Author: Liongking Date: 09-16-05 05:37 >>Prof Darshan Singh crushes him - the only response Veer Ranjit Singh has is - My parchar has given Amrit to lakhs and lakhs To defend himself against the professors comments on dharna he said Baba Jarnail Singh Ji and Baba Isher Singh Ji used to do the same. Someone should have reminded Ranjit Singh Ji that these two servants of the Panth never boasted about numbers. All Baba Jarnail Singh used to say was that it was his work to inspire people to take amrit and Guru de lar loyna. This Ranjit Singh only cares about boasting about the lakhs he claims to have inspired. He should also have know that Baba Isher Singh Ji was known not to hanker after money and put any offerings after a program into Guru Da Golak. Ranjit Singh is always eager to cart away his nightly takings. If he wants to use the name of such highly regarded Sikhs he should act like them as well when it comes to money and not boasting about lakhs. >>darshan singh was awful in the interview - ranjit singh even said to him "i'll stop doing dhaarnas if you tell me to stop" but darshan singh just stayed quiet - if darshan singh thought dhaarnas were so bad, why didnt he tell Ranjit Singh to stop Ranjit Singh was worse than awful all he did was make boasts about these lakhs of people (I wonder where they are as everytime I go to Punjab I never see them and in fact see more and more mona). As if Ranjit Singh would do as the professor said, how many times in the interview did the professor ask Ranjit Singh to make a commitment not to attend any function where he was labelled a Sant, each time this was bought up Ranjit Singh failed to commit himself and meandered away form the question. If Ranjit Singh was only interested in parchar he could have openly agreed to the professors request. Gyni ji, I suaually gree with you, howeve rI'm goign to have to question you in this thread regarding - *** MASKEEN JI IS JUST ONE PERSON...HE IS NOT GURU JI Secondly babies do need a "technique" to start sucking milk..drink from a spoon..and then from container ( without spilling)..etc how to eat food..chew..swallow without choking..etc... Just because we "learnt" as babies doesnt mean we DONT NEED a technique ?? BTW..I havent got the naamdrirr myself (YET) as I chhak Amrit from sgpc Maryada panj who just mentioned WAHEGURU is GURMANTAR and for japping... *** So, out of curiosity you're going to oesh yourself again where u can get Naam DriRh? - Wasn't the Amrit Panj Gave you (at Akal Takhat I assume? Enough??? And no it's not sgpc maryada it's AKAL TAKAT MARYADA "jarnail singh ji ''I chhak Amrit from sgpc Maryada panj who just mentioned WAHEGURU is GURMANTAR and for japping...'' you make it sound as if the panj didnt do a good job , whats with the use of ''just'', could be phrased better to show some respect" Exactly - what you mean "just"? Is Amrit given by Panj Pyaarey "just"? _________________ Good posts "NS" Veer ji =) ___________ well looks like the prof has not practiced sikhi with the krodh, inside he is got something missing, just cos u been preaching for milleniums dont make u a better person, age and experience do not make us better sikhs, maybe better drivers ;) ____________ Would you not get into Krodh if someone is disrespecting your Guru by Singing his own compositions and asking others to "naal gaoo ji" - "Sing with"!! - Infront of the Maharaja of Maharajas - Guru Granth Sahib Ji! Again Prof Sahib makes a Solid point when Veer Ranjit Singh says - I will stop Dharna if sangat tells me to - So he's going to ask Sangat if he should to Manmat or Gurmat? Veer Ranjit SIngh should definetly continue doing parchar - however in the GURMAT WAY - by Singing GURBANI - and not trying to say that Sangat follows Guru ji if u sing Dharna but not if u sing Gurbani (indirectly said, as he would say tha Dharna is a method bring people into Gurmat - so Gurbani doesn't do that?) Again It's good he's doing Parchar - but should do it using GURBANI - doing KATHA of GURBANI - KIRTAN of GURBANI BHull chukk di Khima Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji ki Fateh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Gurpreet Kaur · 17 Sep 2005

Proff darshan singh has sung dharna himself, so why is he attacking others who do? I mean, that dharna he mentioned sounded absurd, so that was wrong. Furthermore, people like sant jarnail singh did sing dharna, why is he so special that he is exempt from following the maryada, the same rules should apply to everyone, noone seems to be able to give an answer to this point!

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Lionking · 17 Sep 2005

Dear Gurpreet Kaur bhenj - I did respond to that too- _____________ m sher singh, that guy on the front page of punjab times wasnt bowing to him, he bent down to recieve a saropa which didnt come up in the same picture, I was there so I would know, just wanted to clarify that. People generally bend down slightly when saying Fateh or something out of respect. ____________ Thans for clarification. I can't believe people are now cussing Prof Darshan Singh ji who has done seva for over 50 yrs of the panth - Ofcourse he would get angry - I would be angry as well, on how he's trying to justify himself saying Bhindrawaley, Ishar SIngh ji etc did it so why can't it? 1- Is he trying to imply he's at the same level as them? 2- WRong is WRong - like Prof Darshan SIngh ji said - According to Sikh Rehit Maryada its wrong - it's wrong... _______________ My dad has audio tapes of him in which proff darshan singh has sung dharna, including 'dhan baba nanak tuhi nirankar', & Proff darshan singh has sung dharna himself, so why is he attacking others who do? I mean, that dharna he mentioned sounded absurd, so that was wrong. _______________ People change - if Veer Ranjit SIngh Changes and sings Gurbani too - most people will stop opposing him. Obviously Prof Darshan Singh ji has changed too - as I ahve NEVER heard him sing dharna - so these casettes you mention must be some odd 10-15 yrs old, and if he has changed his stance on it doesn't mean what he says is invalid bhull chukk dee khima Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Gurpz · 17 Sep 2005

whats wrong with dharna? they are a way of helping people understand bani, when a katha vachik translates a shabad he speaks out the means, instead of speaking them sant baba ranjit singh sings them. every1 knows how to insult baba ji behind his bak y not say it to his face. when sum1 does seva for the panth ppl try there best to disgrace them, but then they complain out panth is going down hill. if people can do a better job then go ahead n do it , what the point in critising others. no1 has go the right to judge others shri guru granth sahib ji ain't asleep!!!!!! there wide awake watching everything!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kabadi · 17 Sep 2005

Ranjit Singh goes agaisnt Maryada by NOT having a Family..and spends all his money on HIS DERA !! --- ARSHI, ... thats such a ridiculour comment u made... and he gave an opinion invitation to anyone to come check out all the money he recieves and where it is spent... if ur so hell bent sure on what he does, why dont u go prove, u have an open invitiation.... go for it... back up your talkkkk, walk the walk...

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Jitinder Singh · 17 Sep 2005

Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh! On the point of Prof. Darshan Singh interrupting Bhai Ranjit Singh, this is the way many people from India behave - seems to be part of the culture of that place. It's interesting that even great people, leading lights of Sikhism like Prof. Darshan Singh fall prey to this kind of behaviour. Bhai Ranjit Singh began by trying to be polite, but soon learned that you have to show your passion by arguing passionately. He then forcefully made his points and refused to let Prof. Darshan Singh interrupt him. Still, Prof. Darshan Singh is a supreme, deeply learned, gem of the Sikh qaum. He has time and time again proven his worth through both words and actions. I don't know so much about Bhai Ranjit Singh, but it's safe to say that time will tell how lasting his contribution to Sikhi is. I pray for unity, sense, humility and chaRhdi kala in the Sikh Panth. - Jitinder Singh Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Vahiguru Je Kee Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Karmjeet Singh · 17 Sep 2005

YES IT IS TRUE THAT PROF. DARSHAN SINGH EATS MEAT . THE PROOF IS THAT MY UNCLE SAW WITH HIS OWN EYES THIS GUY EATING MEAT IN A HOTEL IN INDIA . AND MY DAD TOLD ME THAT HIS MOTHER USED TO DO SEVA AT NANAKSAR JAGRAON , SHE WAS ALONE AND NO BODY TOOK CARE OF HER , I DUNNO I SHE IS DEAD NOW.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

singh · 17 Sep 2005

>>>Ranjit Singh goes agaisnt Maryada by NOT having a Family..and spends all his money on HIS DERA !! >>>> yeah so baba deep singh ji shaheed went against maryada by not having family, sant baba attar singh ji mustaneywaley went against maryada by not having family, baba budda ji went against the maryada by not having family rather staying celibate. people not to stop mixing their mat with "GURMAT"

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

jag · 17 Sep 2005

i have over thousand audio recordings of Prof Darshan Singh starting from 1963, never found dharana ones. His level has changed a lot from 1963 to 2005, started as a keertaniya around 1975 started Viakhiya for few minutes in end of shabd, Only around 1984 he started more katha and as late as 2003 first time started viakhiya of Various Banis. This shows that how person is learning over a time, that is Why he do not call himself Sant, as Sant or Guru Sahib do not learn or change over time once having ttained that position, point told in discussion also.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

ekta · 17 Sep 2005

its amazing how this topic has 66 replies but threads about gurbani or gur-sikhi don't have even 5replies. we love to hate!

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

d kaur · 17 Sep 2005

I really don't know what to make of this debate....but to lighten the mood, I'd like to share something my grandfather told us today. My grandfather spent time with Bhai Randhir Singh ji in India and he told us that Bhai Sahib would sometimes keep a "khundi" (walking stick) to keep people from touching their knees/feet. One time, an old woman went to go meet Bhai Sahib and she wanted to touch their feet, but Bhai Sahib got the khundi out to stop her. My grandfather said that the woman said Fateh and left...and on her way out, she said "ethai taan sant khundian mardiya". I thought this to be quite humorous

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

m-singh · 18 Sep 2005

Sikhs like Ranjit Singh have the ability to raise funds because of their charismatic personality (people of any failth for that matter). The question is 'is it wrong for them to collect money?' The answer is in 2 parts: 1st yes it is wrong if they make loads of money and stash it away to only use it for themselves and their 'partners' Secondly raising money could be great if the money is being spent on good causes such as helping 84 victims, or people dying of famine in Africa. So I have devised a very simple rule for myself when lending my support to any individual or organisation - if they have been recipients of large funds over time, WHAT DO THEY DO (or have done) WITH THE MONEY? If the answer is simply lots of tours doing parchar and nothing else, then things don't add up for me, and I tend not to get too involved with them. If the evidence says £2,000 to help gujarat earthquake, £500 people attended free eyecamps in India, £300 to help fund a sikhi camp, etc, then I'm tempted to get involved. This approach avoids wasting time on such questions as 'is this an AKJ affiliated peron or organisation?', 'does he wear kalgi?', 'do they do 'dhrir amrit?' (not sure what this is), etc. I'd rather not waste too much time debating about what others did or didn't do. The chances are that only those people who are following the Guru's message will be doing good work and pass under this test. Perhaps some of the learned posters could apply this test to the entities under discussion in this thread! Bhull chuk maf msingh [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

GS · 18 Sep 2005

I think Professor Sahib Ji is great, hes one of the most learned Sikhs I have met, Ive learnt a lot from them. But what Kulbir Singh Ji said about Prof Darshan Singh Ji is correct, regarding the fact that Professor Sahib ji eats meat. I know this because, Professor Ji is a good family friend of my uncles, and hes stayed at my uncles, where they would eat meat. My uncle then always offers me meat when i go to his house.. i decline, and then he says "Professor Darshan Singh eats meat, why dont you?". You can ask Professor Ji themselves they wouldnt deny it. Another point is that Professor Ji was close with Baba Isher Singh Ji Rarasahib wale, whom used to do Dharna... so i dont know why Professor Ji is all of a sudden against dharnas.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kaurvs Singh · 18 Sep 2005

Some please answer my questions: 1 If some one has deep pyaar for sikhi, would that person sing KACHEE BANEE as its against sikh rehat maryaada? 2. Would that person accept the presents from the people as shown in the recent video? 3. Would this person travel in a private aeroplane and say that he didn't take his SIRI SAHIB off?(Believe me or not but SANT Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwaley said that he would never travel in an aeroplane until he gets the freedom for it.) 4. How can this person sell the CDs and DVDs on such a high price during his programmes in the gurdwaras when the idea is to preach only? 5. Those who preach they do it. Why wouldn't this Sant(with due respect) be a sipahee as well and raise his voice for innocent people still in the custody of Punjab or Indian Police for no reason? 6. Why wouldn't this sant do something to help the innocent victims of Punjab? 7. Why wouldn't this sant show where all the money goes after the collections made in the gurdwaras? 8. Why wouldn't this sant stop people do matha tek firmly?( Take examples from Jarnail Singh Khalsa Ji's life to see what did he do to stop people.) KHALA JI THE LIST OF MY QUESTIONS IS ONGOING BUT ITS TIME FOR US ALL TO FOLLOW THE PREACHINGS OF ONE AND ONLY ONE GURU AND THAT IT DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI WE DO NOT NEED A MIDDLE PERSON AS DEHDHAAREE> WAKE UP BEFORE WE ALL DROWN> PYAAR GURU SAHIB SAANU SUMATT BAKHSHAN

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Sep 2005

Author: Kabadi Date: 09-17-05 11:01 Ranjit Singh goes agaisnt Maryada by NOT having a Family..and spends all his money on HIS DERA !! --- ARSHI, ... thats such a ridiculour comment u made... and he gave an opinion invitation to anyone to come check out all the money he recieves and where it is spent... if ur so hell bent sure on what he does, why dont u go prove, u have an open invitiation.... go for it... back up your talkkkk, walk the walk... <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Its not as "ridiculous" as you think..lol. Tell me WHICH of our Guru Sahibaans were NOT HOUSEHOLDERS ?? And hasnt GURU NANAK JI Himself made GRISTHEE JEEWAN one of the MOST IMPORTANT aspects of Sikhe/Gurmat. Becoming a "UNMARRIED" and then EATING off the Householder's Honest Labour is a DISGRACE...no need to tell me or quote me some other "sant/Babji" who also did the same. SECONDLY it is a UNDENIABLE FACT that HE OWNS the DERA..just look at the web site itself...His PHOTO in RED DASTAAR is plastered all over, his Name is SANT BABA ( he DENIED this on National Radio LIVE show with Prof Darshan Singh and said ''"the SANGAT forced me to be called SANT...what can I DO ?? Surely the SANGAT did not make His WEBSITE ?? A "SANT" and a LIAR ?? the two cannot MIX. IF I can Walk the Talk sitting right at home..why should I go to his dera ?? There are enough "F***S" outside his dera as it is.( look at his webiste..the DOORS are CLOSED !!! and the crowd of "F***S" are milling around OUTSIDE. Sorry but i am not at all impressed. ( Strictly MY own OPINION lol.)

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Kabadi · 18 Sep 2005

hes at such a young age, maybe he will get married... its to early to judge that... hes young, most ppl his age are not married

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Legolas · 19 Sep 2005

<<<<< Tell me WHICH of our Guru Sahibaans were NOT OUSEHOLDERS ?? And hasnt GURU NANAK JI Himself made GRISTHEE JEEWAN one of the MOST IMPORTANT aspects of Sikhe/Gurmat. >>> Do you know how ridiculous you sound Arshi? Ranjit Singh Ji is only 21/22 years old, he is barely out of his teens and you are accusing him of not being a householder and so condeming him.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Baljinder Singh · 19 Sep 2005

WOW! This is ridiculous. LET ME ASK ALL OF YOU IDIOTS THAT KEEP FIGHTING ON HERE: Why do you think Sikhi is dying in India? Answer: Because we fight amongst ourselves over the stupidest things. I've looked at every post on here and some people even mention how bad Punjab is now. Khalsa is fading in Punjab because we keep fighting amongst ourselves and doing nindya. Look at you guys...all fighting over a debate, why do you think the RSS is growing in India..it's because we are fighting amongst ourselves just like they want us to. The Sikh community does not have a leader like we did in the 70's and 80's under Sant Jarnail Singh and it has led to fighting and squabbling amongst each other. We need to unite satsangat ji, or Sikhi will not last and if you all stop beign so stubborn and egotistical, you will see this. I don't care who won the debate or whatever, you guys are just taking this too far. I don't want to hate anyone but this is getting out of hand. Everyone is attacking each other on here and you guys are supposed Gursikhs. It is issues such as these that are making the RSS stronger and the Khalsa weaker. STOP FIGHTING ! Drop this whole debate over Bhai Ranjit Singh now, the sangat knows what he's done and Waheguru will punish him accordingly. It is not for any of us to judge any of these people, including Professor Darshan Singh, it is the Dharam Raj who controls this. Also, I am so disgusted at how there are so few mentionings out of maybe 50 posts on this page of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. It is just me or do we all not do ardaas and say Sabh Sikhan toh HUKAM ha Guru manyoh Granth! The reasons for this whole forum was to bring about awareness, but the fact of the matter is no one on these forums has brought any awareness, all we have shown is that we are fighting over things that ultimately aren't in our hands. It is the Dharam Raj who will judge Ranjit Singh, who are we to judge? I will say a few things however: No one can question that Ranjit Singh has done good for Sikhi. People on here are just crazy, Prof. Darshan Singh is and will be a respected scholar in the Sikh community, you guys are just creating stories about people saying this and that about each other. Stop the speculation ! However, I'd like to add a few things: To the people that say Ranjit Singh has no knowledge, he learned from Sant Baba Karam Singh ji. To the people that question the amount of people that he's convinced to take anmrit, let me ask you this: have you seen the amount of the people that come to listen to him? Is it not conceivable that because, as many people have mentioned, Ranjit Singh is a great speaker and with his charisma, he could convice people to take anmrit after thousands of people attend his diwans? Like I said, the sangat is always large at every diwan so those numbers that are out there might not be as fake as people say. It was wrong for him to bring this up and it shows that he has been influenced by maya. However, what can pointing out his problems do? I'll tell you: Nothing but upset other people who find Ranjit Singh to be inspiring. Now here comes the main part: Ranjit Singh's as a person has been influenced by maya and we all know it (you've seen the photos). However difficult this makes it for us to go to one of his diwans, we cannot deny that he does great katha (i agree with some people about his unorthodox lines). Now sat sangat Ji, let us end this debate, we are not accomplishing anything fighting over this. Just drop this ! It doesn't matter who won the debate and who made the mistakes, Ranjit Singh is affecting people and if he's doing it wrong then he will find out the hard way from Waheguru. We sikhs need to get rid of our eerkha - jealously and be happy when someone is taking steps to increase pyaar for sikhi in the panth. Most of all, we need to get united. I hate how we are so divided, we are easy prey for all these anti-sikh groups. Smarten up Gursikhs, the Khalsa panth has bigger problems than Ranjit singh wearing a kulgi on his head. We are all the sikhs of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. We are all brothers and sisters. Lets act how our father would want us to act. Lets spend our time on remembering Waheguru instead of Nindya. Lets all do simran as we end this discussion: Waheguru! Waheguru! Waheguru! Waheguru! Waheguru!... Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

. · 19 Sep 2005

.......................I still think Ranjit Singh Ji won though !!!

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Guru_Charan_Preet_Kaur · 19 Sep 2005

veer baljinder Singh Ji, for all your talk of Dharamraj and waheguru being the Judge..and all that... YOU yourself JUDGED EVERYONE on this Forum as " IDIOTS, CRAZY...and what not. You yourself said SIKHE is FADING in INDIA..yet These BABAS and SANTS declare on their WEBSITES...LAKHS and LAKHS of AMRITDHAREES are chhaking Amrit almost DAILY..How can RSS get "stronger" with LAKHS becoming AMRITDHAREES daily ?? Is that LOGICAL ??..Just listen to theri VCD's DVD's selling like HOT CAKES at INFLATED PRICES....bab ji Ranjit Singh was even DECLARING on RADIO SHOW....Professro sahab jeeo, mein lakhan nu amrit chhakaiah hai jee ??? Implying that Tuseen kinia kunoo amrtidharee baniyah hai ?? Then he went on to say Mein 22 saal daa tuseen 65 saal de ho ?? Implying that at 22 he has already accomplished MORE than the Akal takhat jathedar at 65 !!! IF this is NOT haumaii and Hankaar speaking as plainly as anybody can see then I dont know what is that. The TIME is NOT to "CLOSE ones eyes and do SIMRAN"....the GOI would LOVE all of us do that and they take over the Punjab for good thru these babas and deras....a WEAK person is NOT at liberty to even close his eyes for simran!!! Did you not see how our Wives and Daughters and Fathers were BODY SEARCHED at the entrance to Darbar sahib by the CRPF B******S...they were just going in to MATHA TEK ONLY ( and also close their eyes to do simran as you advise)...BUT since we are WEAK... THAT is also a CRIME !! The TIME is to OPEN our EYES..OPEN everybody's EYES....keep on making noise ntil Everybody AWAKES to this BUKKAL DE SAPP...the enemy within us. The RSS we can ESCAPE..because we can SEE them as the ENEMY...but these SNAKES in our LAP...talk about Amrit, punj Piyaras, Guru Granth ji..and Singh JINGLES of their own making instead of GURBANI...and CUT our ROOTS from WITHIN. DO you think the Ex Jathedar of Akal takhat is also AN IDIOT and CRAZY to take on this Baba "BULL BY THE HORNS ?? Do you think the Jathedar doesnt know how to close his eyes and do simran ?? Did GURU JI cloee His eyes and DO SIMRAN before BABAR..JEHANGIR..AURENGZEB ?? I am only 16 years old but my blood boils at this sort of dhongee parchaar.. ( and mind you i have a brain of my own..so dont go hunting for excuses to blame !!)

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

S Singh · 19 Sep 2005

Baljinder Singh Ji, >>>Drop this whole debate over Bhai Ranjit Singh now, the sangat knows what he's done and Waheguru will punish him accordingly. Good job the Shaheed of 13 April 1978 did not think like you about the Nirankhari pretender. >>>Why do you think Sikhi is dying in India? Answer: Because we fight amongst ourselves over the stupidest things Because of these so called sant who are really just dere wale trying to emulate beas wala and all the other fraudsters.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

... · 19 Sep 2005

I agree entirely with every single word that Baljinder Singh said above. great post

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

ns · 19 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh 110% spot on Guru_Charan_Preet_Kaur Jeeo...said like a true Bhujangan Khalsa

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Baljinder Singh · 19 Sep 2005

I apologize for calling people idiots, I was just very angry at how we are acting here. Secondly, Panjee Guru Charan Preet said: > You yourself said SIKHE is FADING in INDIA..yet These BABAS and > SANTS declare on their WEBSITES...LAKHS and LAKHS of > AMRITDHAREES are chhaking Amrit almost DAILY..How can RSS get > "stronger" with LAKHS becoming AMRITDHAREES daily ?? Is that > LOGICAL ??..Just listen to theri VCD's DVD's selling like HOT > CAKES at INFLATED PRICES....bab ji Ranjit Singh was even > DECLARING on RADIO SHOW....Professro sahab jeeo, mein lakhan nu > amrit chhakaiah hai jee ??? Implying that Tuseen kinia kunoo > amrtidharee baniyah hai ?? Then he went on to say Mein 22 saal > daa tuseen 65 saal de ho ?? Implying that at 22 he has already > accomplished MORE than the Akal takhat jathedar at 65 !!! IF > this is NOT haumaii and Hankaar speaking as plainly as anybody > can see then I dont know what is that. !! Let me ask you this: What does fighting about this on a forum accomplish? Do you really feel great fighitng with other Sikhs about matters that we can od nothing about? Tell me, what can we hope to accomplish that hasn't already been accomplished, by fighting on these forums? Ranjit Singh has been embarassed everywhere, our fighting isn't going to do anything. Panjee, I am sorry to say this but you are one of the people that cannot open your mind to peace, maybe it is because you're just too young, I am not saying we shouldn't standup to people that attack Sri Guru Granth Sahib or Sikhi, I never once said that. Panjee, I suggest you read my post again I don't think you understood a word I said because your mind cannot get over the fact that we cannot do anything about Ranjit Singh. Waheguru can. We already know that he's been influenced by maya. Now you need to calm yourself down and realize that nothing is being accomplished by fighting here, amongst other Sikhs. > You yourself said SIKHE is FADING in INDIA..yet These BABAS and > SANTS declare on their WEBSITES...LAKHS and LAKHS of > AMRITDHAREES are chhaking Amrit almost DAILY..How can RSS get > "stronger" with LAKHS becoming AMRITDHAREES daily ?? I said that because we all know it is. You are putting ideas out there that I never accepted. I said Ranjit Singh has baptised many people but I never once said anything about amrithdharees taking anmrit daily or websites of "sants". I never said any of that was true, you know Sikhi is fading in India. Please, read my post again you need to open your mind young one, stop being so close-minded. >Did GURU JI cloee His eyes and DO SIMRAN before >BABAR..JEHANGIR..AURENGZEB ?? WOW, you are comparing this situation to that? Are you insane? How does this have any relation to Guru Ji's encounters with Aurengzeb or Babar? Ranjit Singh is a murderer now? An enemy of the Guru? I am not even going to make a reponse to this, as it would be foolish for me to defend my post against ridiculous comments such as these. <<were <B******S...they were just going in to MATHA TEK ONLY ( and also close >their eyes to do simran as you advise)...BUT since we are WEAK... THAT is >also a CRIME !! I don't understand how any of what I said implies that we should laydown and surrender to the GOI? Or how does any of what I said relate to 1984? Ranjit Singh doesn't work for the GOI, the man has done a lot for Sikhi just like Prof.Darshan Singh. Does Ranjit Singh spread lies and attack the Gurus? NO. So why are you considering him an enemy? He's been caught doing stupid acts, now the sangat knows. His unorthodox style of doing kirtan has worked (even if he doesn't get them to take anmrit, he's forcing people to come to the Gurduwara and listen to other Babas and to fall in love with the Guru) but Ranjit Singh has just been influenced by maya at his young age. All I'm saying is fighting over a forum about something that we can't control or add any awareness to is ridiculous. You need to read my post again panjee, as you are making outrageous analogies. >The TIME is NOT to "CLOSE ones eyes and do SIMRAN"....the GOI would >LOVE all of us do that and they take over the Punjab for good thru these >babas and deras....a WEAK person is NOT at liberty to even close his eyes >for simran!!! I am shocked to hear this from you panjee. There is never a bad time to do simran, never. A weak person SHOULD be doing simran and ask for Waheguru's help. But hey, you're right, some of these babays are corrupt and are working for the GOI. Everyone knows this, but the fact of the matter is we can't control these babays. All we can control is ourselves and each one of us should stop fighting about this whole issue like I've mentioned many many times. Please panjee, I urge you to open your mind to stop fighting with other Sikhs and relating everything to 1984 and the GOI.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

S Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Baljinder Ji, Where is the fighting. Forums are for debate and that is what is being done. No one is firing AK47 or RPG at each other so stop trying to castigate this debate into a fight.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Sep 2005

anybody who wants to see an ACTUAL KHANDA on dastaar....look at the pictures of BSB Randheer Singh Ji in the Phoots section of thsi website... Leaves no room for doubt ???

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Zorawar Singh · 20 Sep 2005

it is clear ranjit singh is uncomfortable at losing his sant title... it is clear ranjit singh by his own admission changes his stage routine according to sangats wishes, not according to what Gurmat is... it is clear ranjit singh at his dera does matta tekking and just does annoucements to stop it, but encourages it by himself. for someone who changes his opinions from time to time, he cannot have reached Gian khand, so is definately not a Sachkhand vassi Brahm Giani. The pictures clearly show a kalgi, so who is liar? Proffesor sahib or ranjit singh? Ranjit singh totally deflects all maryada issues and just makes it a maya issue. Proffessor Sahib demonstrates his ego and eagerness in constant wrangling, but he is no more hotter than Ranjit Singh. Proffessor sahib may have personal issues, but he only debated on issues of Gurmat maryada. Both make money from parchaar, so both cannot judge each other. However Professor sahib does not make money from matta tekking, kacchi bani, etc.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Manjit Singh · 20 Sep 2005

SAT SRI AKAL I have heard the radio discussion between Prof. Sahib & self claimed Sant. If you listen to Sants statement in which he said that video was made two years ago when he was 17 years old & now he is 22 after two years . he has said this few times . Sant should have treated Prof. Darshan Ji with more respect because Prof. Sahib has done so much for the sikhi . Prof. Ji was in jail geting tortured while Sant was getting breast fed . Also Mr. Beant Singh & Satwant Singh went for their mission after listening to kirtan of Prof. Ji at Moti Bagh Temple in Delhi . I can't remember any other kirtani jatha speeking out during Blue Star Opperation . I have most of the live audio recrdings of Prof. Ji during Blue Star , speeking against RSS , Mahabharat & our Gurudawara commitees . I don't ever think Ranjit have had spoken against our emamies , just worried about money collectin and brain washing sikhs . [%sig%]

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

charanjeev singh · 20 Sep 2005

Professor Sahib is a Panth Rattan; a jewel to the Panth of Guru Granth Sahib, and Guru Nanak Guru Gobind. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

... · 21 Sep 2005

>>Prof. Ji was in jail geting tortured while Sant was getting breast fed<< So it was his fault that he wasnt born around the same time as Proff Sahib?

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

S Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Manjit Singh Ji >>I don't ever think Ranjit have had spoken against our emamies , just worried about money collectin and brain washing sikhs . He does drop the odd name here and there like that of Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Ji. But only when he is abroad. Its just a gimmick on his part to collect even more money as he knows how highly people hold the sacrifice of Baba Ji.

Re: Talk between Prof Darshan Singh Jee and Sant Ranjit Singh Dadriawala

Bhavneet Singh · 23 Sep 2005

i think this is totally wrong...baba ranjit singh ji sings dharnas..which makes it easier for the people to understand..and i dont find anything wrong with that..and its nothing wrong either..its just a translation..and ive read much about this lil conversations all the people are having about baba ji..the thing is he isnt a fraud or anything..i just have some questions..please answer these for me..prof darshan singh ji said he was a fraud..he had some video to prove it too..but the video was made like 2 or 4 years ago..and baba ji said i didnt know much..so forgive me?think about it..baba ji didnt celebrate any of his birthdays afterwards..the thing is..people think about this..prof darshan singh ji said he sings "kachi bani"..i have a question for that too..WHY NOW?..prof darshan singh ji is 65 years old..and he was there when sant baba isher singh ji sang those dharnas and sant jarnail singh ji too..so why didnt he say something THEN?why NOW?the reason is..i read on the newspaper..that baba ranjit singh was in canada..and so was darshan singh ji..(he actually lives there) yeah but darshan singh ji's deewan was delayed..and i think from there he got jealous or something...i jus want some answers..people lets STOP NINDYA..PLEASEEE!!!...and one other thing...if we do have a problem like this PLEASE SIT DOWN AT A PROPER PLACE AND SETTLE EVERYTHING DOWN...DONT LET THE WHOLE WORLD KNOW IT...because then we say oh sikh KAUM is dhendikala now..ITS ALL OUR FAULT..ive never seen a pandit or kazi's being called frauds on the newspaper..well there might be some..but not as much as we see sikhs..all i want to say is LETS STOP NINDYA..and please dont get me wrong..i do not hate prof darshan singh ji or anything..i really love his parchar..ive met him many times..hes great..but hes mistaken or something..so lets all stop this and jus THINK ABOUT THAT ONE AND ONLY "LORD" bhul chuk maaf karni Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!