Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Tajee · 09 Sep 2005

Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji ke fateh. I would like to know what sikh ideas and views are on sikh girls talking to muslim boys? I am not sure about many of you, but I find that I instantly can not trust Muslim boys. I feel that they are a little jealous of the sikh religion, hence muslims dated as far back as when the Gurus were in power, have always tried to over rule us? Also did any Gursikhs get any form of threats after the London Terrorist attacks? Did this widen your anger towards muslims as a raice? Maybe it is not fair to judge them, seen as Guru Nanak Dev Ji, was very good friends with a muslim, and said that "there is no muslim, no hindu" etc ... Please feel free to share your views, it would be interesting to know, what other sikhs think about this hugely contraversal on going topic. (go easy on the punjabi because sometimes it is hard to understand all the language you use, as I am a non amritdhari) Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji ke fateh.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Hari Singh · 09 Sep 2005

I don't trust muslims as a nation or as a people. However, there are individual muslims, whom I could trust if I knew them well enough.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

A Kaur (London) · 09 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji ke fateh. This is interesting but I would encourage this topic to be broadened further. I have met many Sikh guys who speak but worse (in my view) is that they have dated Muslim girls. I know, having read this numerous threads on this discussion board, that clearly they are not Sikhs but I can't understand why (even though we should be tolerant and discriminating) that Sikhs want to associate with Muslims. I personally am sick and tired of hearing Sikh guys say that they 'date' Muslim girls in revenge for what Muslim guys do with apna kuri's. Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji ke fateh.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 09 Sep 2005

"Also did any Gursikhs get any form of threats after the London Terrorist attacks? Did this widen your anger towards muslims as a raice?" I am a malaysian born Sikh, and was raised in a heavily muslim populated state .I had no problems with any muslims, although from time to time they would talk about their religion, one just explined one's own values to them.But then Malaysian muslims are not fanatical as those from indo pakistan. I have lived in London for thirty three years, with short break of about year in Melbourne, and another year in New York, I have personally never experienced anything that is racist. People have often asked mistakenly if I am a muslim, like in paris, but then in the same Paris , a few years down the road, I have been asked if I am Sikh and come from Punjab? In warzawa. I was asked if I am an afghan or pakistani?No I am Sikh born and bred in Malaysia. A few weeks ago, I visited a famous local spot in Surrey, known as Boxhill.We were the only Sikh family, among all whites.As my family moved to the view point, I sat back along the road on a little bench.Many familes often looked up,those nearby smiled or nodded, but carried on as usual. One family walked past me, nodding with a smile.Then suddenly I looked to my left I saw two muslim men walking along towards the Viewpoint along a foot path. As I was sitting fairly back of the crowds, I noted a few families looked up, and then said something to the other in the family, and people would look at those two , and mumbled something. Another family got up and walked past me in between the two muslims walking away now, the white man nodded his head at me and smiled , and as the muslims walked past , he turned to me and said ...ALQAIDA B... I was taken aback and said ..hmm.yes not very nice nice people...he said , "we have to be extra vigilant against these people and keep an eye on them..."I said yes, we have to ...by this time his wife and come with two children and she smiled and said , it is not safe anymore when such murderous people are among us ....they live here and get benefits yet are prepared to kill people ...I said yes, some people just have no brains to think for themselves...."have a nice day they said ...you have lovley children..we just saw the running there she said ...and wishing us good time went off. From the crowd I could see people feeling uneasy at thetwo characters...and one family moved and sat nearer me after saying hello.... I think people out there know who Sikhs are but sometimes one can get the most ignorant animal ...this happened after 7/7 and the 21/7 ...and I am yet to see any animosity towards Sikhs unless one happens to be unlucky ...sadly becomes a victim. We had a nice day ...

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

(()__ · 09 Sep 2005

Dear All I know I am probably going to get hounded for this, but I think the reason Sikhs girls date muslim guys is the probably find them more attractive [sexually] than sikh males. It is just how we find white women fancying black guys (because of the obvious myth associated with them). grass always looks greener on the other side. thats why english guys are attracted to mediterranean women etc Muslim men seem to have a bad boy streak about them which sikh girls get tantilised by. Also many good looking guys tend to muslim (not that religion has anything to do with looks). also if find more and more muslim girls are attracted to indian/white guys becasue they are more sensative then muslim men [%sig%]

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Jaspal Kaur · 09 Sep 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji Tajee ji Like you said that Guru Nanak Dev ji was close to someone (Mardana Ji) born in a Muslim family. Mardana ji had good virtues therefore was worth being with. Guru ji travelled Mekha to spread the message of Narankar. So really with good will it is decent to have an open heart towards others which prb no doubt you have. When it comes to associating with muslim boys just use your judgment and think if they are the doser type and you have daily or occasional contact with them then keep it limited for i.e. if at work then just talk what is necessary to talk about. By this they wont provoke themselves to be silly with you or anything as such. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

little I · 09 Sep 2005

if a sikh girl is converted to Islam its not the fault of the Muslim person, its the fault of the sikh community/family. if she was educated as to what Sikhi really is, there is no way that she would leave her faith for any other.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

sunil · 09 Sep 2005

first of all to the guy who answerd with no name its got nothing to do with muslims being better looking than sikhs i have many sikh friends here and in punjab and trust me none are ugly theres nothing better than a six foot sikh in a turban and in uniform you are talking from a muslim point of view thats why you never left your name in this western country we live and work with people from all backgrounds boys and girls mix with each other at school collage work and some are atracted to each other regardless of weather there sikh muslim hindu west indian cocasian or any other race its based more on the the way a person pysically looks like than anything else

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

jag bassi · 11 Sep 2005

tajee this kind of thing is more a UK englandi sikh problem. in canada and america we do not have problems with muslims. england vale sikhs need to ask themselves why and what to do? You need to educate yourself better on global issues than just englandi problems. Please visit jattworld.com and visit the muslim jatt section our history is virtually intertwined with some punjabi communities bel;onging to muslims. muslims are not a race but a religion just like blacks are a race so are whites yet both share christianity. sikhi does not allow us to hate. Instead of flying union jacks with "we sikhs back britain" and then get targetteed for attacks you need to reassess why sikhs in uk are being attacked? is it your skin colour or your turban? have you known white sikhs to be attacked? have you hard of asian looking people non turbanned being picked on too? so to decipher the exact reasons of this hatred cou7ld be your race, hence the attackers have a problem with your pigment. It will not always be in the form of a physical abuse. Why are these bombers uk born? why is there so much racial tension in the uk? what makes drives these people to such circumstances? was you aware the 4 bombers belonged to a group long before they carried out their sins the group was known to be in constant racial conflict with white extremists in north england. There is no reason to excuse a bombing however england is not a multirace paradise. as far as girls are concerned. Now we say sikh girls when we talk about internal sissues then its suddenly they are not sikh but corrupt punjabis. Most punjabi girls like to go clubbing drinking and now have a reputation. This unfortunatly does not rub off for our honest rel;igious sisters, they too get tarnished with the same brush. It might takes years to build up the respect of sikh womanhood again. But bear in mind whats happening when you stereotype do you not think others are too?

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

kaur · 11 Sep 2005

i will tell you guys something that happend to me at University i was doing some work in the computer room when this muslim girl comes upto me asking for help. so we started talking and she was pretty nice to me then her friend came who was a muslim guy. he started saying arn;t you going to introduce me to your friend and he just wouldn't stop talking to me i got pretty uncomfortable as he was asking really dumb questions like about boyfriends and stuff. then he asked me if i go out and i said no the other muslim girl also said she's not like that. his reply was we don't worry we'll make her like that. that comment really suprised me i just said no you can't and walked off. then the guy started almost stalking me sending me emails i don't know where he got my adress from. saying things like hello sexy, i can see you etc. i knew it was him bout couldn't prove it. so i jus ignored his messages and he soon stopped. we should be aware and not make friends so easily we never know what someones true intentions are.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

mu-har-har-har · 11 Sep 2005

"Muslim men seem to have a bad boy streak about them which sikh girls get tantilised by. Also many good looking guys tend to muslim (not that religion has anything to do with looks). also if find more and more muslim girls are attracted to indian/white guys becasue they are more sensative then muslim men" My god thats aloud of crap, LOL, come down Cranford west london and youll c the TOTAL OPPOSIT of what you described, lol

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

hindu · 11 Sep 2005

Oh my god people people. My neice married a sikh boy. They were ment for each other. One hindu boy married sikh girl. Muslim Boy married Hindu girl. I tell you this is good because our familes can get together and understand each others religion. When we are born we are of no religion. All we want food and shelter which parents provide. Mahatma Gandhi said to muslim man to adopt a Hindu boy and raise him as a true Hindu, and told Hindu man to raise a muslim boy as true Muslim. Lets all get together and get along. This infighting between ourselves we are making our world dangerous for our children and grand children.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

? · 11 Sep 2005

CHeck out www.whyichosesikhism.com this is a major prob in UK, I was standing at sikh society stall an a muslim from islamic society wanted to put his name on mailing list. we have to be so carefull these guys are using backhand techniques you cant trust no one. i guess its more parents responsibility to teach sikhi so kids will remail strong... its not just muslims, hindus, christians, apne panjabi...

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

charanjeev singh · 11 Sep 2005

Regarding the title; i would like to share some thoughts here, and hopefully bring to light some very important issues. Firstly, everybody should be aware of some rules. For example: we know that sikhs look upon all as Waheguruus creation, and children, and we are under no circumstances to harm an innocent person. Even if we are to go to war, there are rules that a Khalsa must abide by. Muslims also have some rules. Some of thier rules are that they are allowed to take prisoners, and rape their victims. They are allowed to take slaves and have them as sexual slaves. Also, very importantly, please pay close attention to this, a muslim is allowed to lie, allowed to lie, allowed to lie, allowed to lie, to non-muslims. It is looked upon as a great act, and is rewarded, is rewarded, is rewarded. What does this mean. You will lied to, and taken advantage of, and they will be rewarded. So please do not fall into this. You may refer to muslim text at your liesure and argue with me if you so wish. I thought i would share this with you, and hopefully, as it seems the uk sangat, will benefit from this. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

nav · 11 Sep 2005

hey what do you mean mu har har har i live in west london explain your view on this topic

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

mu-har-har-har · 11 Sep 2005

i meant he talks about sikhs girls fallin for muslims cuz of their bad boy attirude, its the same thing down here but opposit, alot girls born in muslim families go out with sikh lads (the ameture bad boi type), especialy withihn schools, same goes with arab born girls over here (theyre worser than pakistani born girls). youl c all punjabis either muslim, sikh or hindu mingling with each other in clubs. The reason muslims vcan lie and be rewarded is cuz islam is distored beyond beleife. the mullahs 'over the years have made castes within islam and added their own 'masala' to their version of the 'great religion'

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

mirza ghaddasa · 12 Sep 2005

first of all list down th experiences of sikh girl and muslim boy on this thread and tell me which country they are in? england or canada? somebody tell me the national stats for muslims in canada is it far off from uk? so why do we not have this crap in cad? england has more sikhs than cad for a start th fact is this is not muslim and sikh its england sikhs and england muslims. the underclass pakitani kashmiris mad at their own state of affairs in kashmir back home using religion to pull a girl. Why is this sikh girl muslim boy not usually a turkish guy running off with a sikh girl? an arab muslim with a sikh girl? an african muslim with a sikh girl? why is it 99% pakistani lad with a sikh girl? So it is not religion its a PAKISTANI V angland SIKH THING. second thing england is full of jaat type bhaiyeh from kashmir and bengalis converts who were hindus just 20 years ago bottom of the pile trying to forge a hard man muslim identity. Hence using islam as a vehicle to do what charanjeev singh has talked about. Punjabi jatt have rspect and same cultue valus on both sides of the border whether sikh or muslim. I would appreciete some sort of understanding. stop blaming muslims as a whole and deconstruct the actual layer. Go to lahore visit the houses of our jatt brothers and see the brotherly welcome you get. Get off your high horses you will never be british your coloured, gore see you as people they once crappd on and always will. Sikhs in england need to sort their girls out. The girls of england are screwing with every nationality because they feel sikh guys are not good enough. The truth is its lust. This lust is giving all other sikh girls a bad name.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

w · 12 Sep 2005

british sikh girls should not associate with british muslim boys and british sikh girls should get into sikhi. most people here are way too much on the religious flex and think muslims are lik that meaning they are look9ing at muslims from a small box. Just lik we have punjabi culture muslims too have different cultures with 50 60 countries spanning from black white arab to pakistani each with their own ways. British sikhs are exposed to a deoband wahabite disease . This applis to britain only. Canada/america/auss sikhs are free to associate with muslims becauise we do not have a problem muslims are fine with us we are with them.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

mu-har-har-har · 12 Sep 2005

Its to do with how the families kids have been raised most iskhs came from punjab grew up in a sikh culture yet knew nuffin about the religion itself, like ive saids before take a trip to various clubs and youll c pakistani girls and girls born in punjabi hindu and sikh familys mingling with all sorts , theyr are as bad as each other, arab born girls are even worser! you dont need to take my word for it, go find out 4 YOURSELVES

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Scientific · 13 Sep 2005

The problem of Sikh/Muslim tension in the UK was probably at its peak in the 90s. With the massive onslaught of global media on Islam, inter faith tensions between the Sikhs and Muslims has been thrown to the side somewhat. Prior to 9/11 and more recently 7/7 the west tended to make disproportionate exception for muslims and their faith. They were in the past fortunate enough to have white mainstream champions for their causes eg Palestine/Israel etc. Radical Islamic opinion and movement in the past had gone unchecked and quite suprisingly was accomodated in westen society! An example would be Cherie Blairs sympathy for suicide bombers in Palestine and the Mayor of London hosting radical islamic leaders in London. All of the above has now been turned on its head. Take it or leave it but the western world is at war with Islam. There is no other way of rationalising virtually ever war that has occured in the last decade. The only other factor that is in play is global energy. With the Arab world sitting on a fair chunk of world energy this only fuels the war to crush Islam and create a conformist society. The moment Islam brought terror to the west, a line of no return was crossed. This fatal mistake will result in the ultimate demise and implosion of a religion which could never have flourished without force. Islam is a religion which is based on weak spiritual principles. It appeals to the lower/ugly senses of the pscyhe. There is no intellectual strength in this faith and it stands as an outdated dinosaur which simply cannot co-exist with the more spiritual faiths such as Sikhism, hinduism, Judaism and Budhism. The actions of Islamic radicals are based on the Koran. Its almost laughable that people can still say 'this isnt what islam tells people to do' Before making such statements one should read the words of the radical prophet. From his writing he comes across as a man of limited intelligence and one who openly propagates a faith and discipline of intolerance. So coming back to the point of islamic boys trying to convert Sikh girls there are only two things to say: 1. Islam is a dying religion (not in numbers at the moment) but in morale. I envisage we will see an implosion of this crazy religion in the not so distant future. The followers have no spiritual grounds to resist the might of the west. 2. If a woman is dumb enough to consider Islam as a religion which treats women anything above dirt they should be allowed to go because they are not needed. Scientific

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Ek Kaur · 13 Sep 2005

Before answering this question I would like to humbly request that people refrain from making destructive anger evoking comments and try to answer questions using gurbani. This is afterall what the forum is about. My offering in answer to the original question would be: "Awal Allah noor upayaa kudrat kay sabh banday Ek noor teh sabh jag upjhaya kaun bhalay ko munday" Can't do a word for word translation at the moment but the basic gist is: We are all born to the same mother nature. The world was created from one light... no-one good, no-one evil. Under this order it is fine to associate with any other human being on the planet. There are sensible and not so sensible people in all denominations. It's not about the religion people happen to be born in to. Judge the person by their character. Judge them by the principles they hold and by the actions the commit. The question is what do you mean by association? Does it mean civil conversation? Does it mean friendship? Does it mean romantic or sexual relationships? In this instance think about what will benefit you and society at large. Civil conversation and friendship accross barriers is useful in obtianing understanding acheiving tolerence. Casual romantic / sexual relationships are purposless and destructive.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

basra · 13 Sep 2005

as a sikh jatt lad i will continue to associate with muslim jatt males and females. A jatt sikh cheema will always have more in common with a jatt muslim cheema jatt sikh gill with a pak punjabi gill than we will ever have in common with ramgharia indian president zail singh types who walk in Guru Darbar Saheb with shoes and umbrella on while his successors and followers call sant jarnail singh bhindrawala a terrorist while generel of pakistan zia al haque called sant jarnail singh a "holy saint" remaining a holy man for the peasantry of pakistan punjab. when it comes down to it tyhe original bloodlines of Greeater punjab magnetically merge such as 1984 and missal confedaracies with muslim peasantry. The question asked originally shoukd not be not religion but specific to downgraded people in a country living under a set of circumstances that do not apply to the universal nature of sikhism or punjabiat. If we are allowed to raise questions like the first then we should also ask ourselves if it is appropriate for gursikhs to associate with ramgharia ravidasis when they have divided sikhi into brahminist castism. ramgharia boys also prey on jatt sikh girls then dump them too. But how racist will it look if we ask ourselves to stop association? one medium is a minority of fanatics of muslims on the other side is parents with jelousy that is rtuining the lives of innocent girls.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

virk · 13 Sep 2005

arab muslims love and respect sikhs ask veer mehtab singh. but if sikh girls themselves no longer respect their own bodies, kes maboli izat modesty then what use is it blaming muslims? it is the mainstream girls who have a problem, with amritdharis on a minimal basis not being listened to when they try to help these clubber kuria. You can call proph moh whatever you want list out verses from the koran but in the end sikh girls elopin with pks will always be until sikh girls establish some form of respect for their bodies. The first question to ask is why are girls chipping with muslims?

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

realhistory · 13 Sep 2005

Scientific, that's one of the best posts I have read. Nice to know that some people actually go to the sources in order to understand what Islam is about and not the usual BBC bukwas about religion of peace! You are right the west is certainly changing in its attitude to Islam but the only downside is that other minorities suffer because of the actions of Muslim terrorists. Sikh schoolkids in France and now Belgium suffer though no fault of their own just because the Muslims want to dominate the west. Sikhs have been killed, assaulted and Gurdwaras attacked due to Muslim terrorism. Basra, I assume that since you have so much in common with your jat muslim brothers, you'll be ok with your sister marrying a muslim jat? You're no Jat in my book.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

boxa · 13 Sep 2005

ek kaur these english sikhs have a problem on their hands. In canada sikhi is strongish with a steady migration of singhs from punjab keeping things flowing too in states. In uk most sikhs tend to be afriki sikhs and hindufied sikhs with a very weak base affectyed by this muslim crap. If they fully followed gurmat and had faith they would not be in this gand. the afriki sikhs started off stuff like mini skirts in 1970s and mixing men and women together more. now their crying at moderate reforms biting them back.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Ek Kaur · 13 Sep 2005

Boxa ji... I am a Sikh woman who was raised in and lives in the UK. I don't wear mini skirts. I have friends of different denominations including muslims but I've never engaged in casual relationships with anyone be it with a Sikh or Muslim or with a person belonging to any other religion, group, culture. Please... I request again that people refrain from using emotive language and from making broad unquantifiable generalisations. Can I ask Tajee. Have you learned anything life altering from this thread? Has anyone learned anything from this thread? Has it contributed to your path to sikhi? I for one haven't learned anythin and am backing out of this conversation. Admin, I seriously think this topic should be closed.

Re: Should Sikh girls associate with Muslim boys?

Admin. · 13 Sep 2005

Topic closed. Admin.