Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Moorakh Kaur · 07 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I have a question which to some people the answer maybe obvious but it does confuse me at times. Are gursikhs allowed to dance? May it be bhangra dancing or anything along the lines is it against our religion? The american sikhs and a lot of gora sikhs on gurumustak singhs blog are seen dancing on stage or dancing at a small house party. Most of these people are amrithari aswell but is this right ? Another thing is dancing at a club.......It has been said dancing like that may put you in the wrong state of mind but what if you dance on your own doing your own thing and having no bad or lustfull intentions apart from enjoying yourself.........is it right? If not what is wrong with is....infact even going into clubs or going to gigs, would that be wrong? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

me · 07 Sep 2005

of course they can dance, and express their joy, ok guys you can start sending me to hell now.

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Scientific · 07 Sep 2005

There is nothing wrong with dancing. There is a quote in the guru granth sahib ji about dancing and i am sure some one is going to bring it up but quite logically, dancing is a just an expression of happiness. There can be nothing wrong with enjoying oneself. Life is meant to be fun. Scientific

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

* · 07 Sep 2005

If you are a Sikh, then you represent a certain image. Wherever you go, you take that image with you. We should, at all times, do our best not to sully that image. Can a Gursikh really stand in a club while upholding all the grace and dignity that comes with the Khalsa saroop? I wear full Gurmukhi baana to school and as I left class today and made my way out to the busy downtown street, there was some sort of Frosh-week activity going on. There was loud music and people dancing all around me. It was like some kind of Much Music video dance party. I started walking down the street in the midst of it all, but felt almost ashamed to be even mistakenly associated with it. So I turned and went back into the building and came out the opposite side instead. My mother used to say to me when I was younger and stupider, "Don't ever put a stain on your father's pugg", ie. don't do anything that will reflect poorly on him or disgrace him. In the same way, don't ever go anywhere or do anything that will reflect poorly on your real father, Guru Sahib. Would Guru Sahib be proud of you for going to a club? Will he pat you on the back for not having bad thoughts while you danced to degrading songs, surrounded by people with surely impure thoughts and intentions? If you keep in mind who's form you represent and who your father is, you wouldn't be caught dead in filthy settings like clubs or gigs etc.

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Iron Man · 07 Sep 2005

AND Audience.. Guru Sahib Says: Nach Nach Ttape Bohut Dukh Pavai! Dancing and jumping around, you will be in great pain DING DING DING WE HAVE A WINNER!!! *Applause*

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Harpreet Singh · 08 Sep 2005

There are times when we get questions in our mind about things that are good or bad for us. Most of the times we end up using gurbani to justify our wrong deeds by translating bani as per our own mind. Same happened a few days ago when we were invited to a party and people were dancing to the tunes of Punjabi bhangra music. No one bothered who was touching whom in a congested place. Every one so lost in the Bhangra fever. Some of us try to proudly declare Bhangra as our main cultural dance and recently it has got associated with Sikhs. Even people who were never aware of our culture have started thinking that probably Bhangra/Giddha are dances associated with sikhs. Is dancing a good thing? Is it prohibited in our religion? Is Guru sahib telling us to dance to tunes of wordly singers’ tunes? When ever there is an argument about Dance the very first tuk from bani used is “Nachan kuddan man ka chaao”. People justify the practice of dancing by saying that guru sahib has asked sikhs to dance and there are numerous examples in gurbani. I have tried to go to Guru Sahib and ask Daata ji his views on this. The answer he always gives me are very very clear. “Dance” he says, to the tune of Naam Simran. We always try to justify every wrong thing but we forget the real motto of a GURSIKH’s life. The real motto is swaas swaas, 8 pehar, 24 hours, each PAL, each Ghadi, every second just swaas swaas simran. “Ek ghadi aadhi ghadi aadhi hoon te aadh”. Every breath has to be only and only devoted for Naam Simran. NOTHING ELSE. NOTHING ELSE. NOTHING ELSE. Then we start with arguments again: - We can do simran while dancing, we can do this we can do that. The answer guru maharaaj gave me is a simple and plain NO. No, you can not do simran while dancing to the tunes of Bindrakhiya. No, you can not do simran dancing to the tunes of Daler mehndi. No, you can not do simran while dancing with people from opposite sex around you, as you touch them, you feel the touch and this only and only leads to KAAM. No, you cannot do simran while doing bhangra or giddha coz you are busy saying boliaan. Anyone who tries to use bani to justify their own misdeeds just do it to please themseleves and to please their koodi matt. GURU sahib has very very clearly stated: “Nach nach tapeh bahut dukh paaveh” Guru Sahib also said: “Nachi-ai tapi-ai bhagat na ho-ay” Some people will say then does this means should we just cut ourselves off the world/the society we live in and don’t follow the rituals/practices……… I will suggest, no don’t cut off, but don’t follow them. We are not here to follow what others are doing. Others are doing lot of good but others are doing lot of bad also. We only need to do what we are here for. We are here only and only for one thing: “Bhaee paraapat maanukh dehuria gobind milan ki eh teri bariya || Avar kaaj tere kitte naa kaam Mil saadh sangat bhaj kewal naam” Nothing else, just one thing …. “BHAJ KEWAL NAAM” So where does dancing to duniyaavi music lets you do that? Where does eating food for tastes let you do that? Where does working only and only to make money by each and every possibe way lets you do that? Hukam for a gursikh are very very clear: “Sleep”: Only to give body some rest. Not for hours to let vikaars overtake you. That’s why hukam is to get up early at Amrit vela. “Food”: Only to fulfill the basic needs of the body. Not for tastes. “Work”: Do kirat only to earn money which is needed for running simple life, and to do seva of panth and humanity. Not to make big bank balances. And SING & DANCE?? This is what Guru sahib’s hukam is to a Gursikh: “Baajay anhad baajaa. Rasak rasak gun gaavahi har jan apnai gurdayv nivaajaa. “ “Har har har jas ghoomar paavhu mil satsang omaahaa raam. “ Dance to the Praises of the Lord, Har, Har, Har; meet with the Sat Sangat, the True Congregation, with sincerity. “Gurmukh nirat har laagai bhaa-o.” The Gurmukh's dance is to embrace love for the Lord; And finally: Aasaa mehlaa 1. Vaajaa mat pakhaavaj bhaa-o. Ho-ay anand sadaa man chaa-o. Ayhaa bhagat ayho tap taa-o. It rang naachahu rakh rakh paa-o. ||1|| Pooray taal jaanai saalaah. Hor nachnaa khusee-aa man maah. ||1|| rahaa-o. Sat santokh vajeh du-ay taal. Pairee vaajaa sadaa nihaal. Raag naad nahee doojaa bhaa-o. It rang naachahu rakh rakh paa-o. ||2|| Bha-o fayree hovai man cheet. Bahdi-aa uth-di-aa neetaa neet. Laytan layt jaanai tan su-aahu. It rang naachahu rakh rakh paa-o. ||3|| Sikh sabhaa deekhi-aa kaa bhaa-o. Gurmukh sun-naa saachaa naa-o. Naanak aakhan vayraa vayr. It rang naachahu rakh rakh pair. ||4||6|| Make your intellect your instrument, and love your tambourine; thus bliss and lasting pleasure shall be produced in your mind. This is devotional worship, and this is the practice of penance. So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||1|| Know that the perfect beat is the Praise of the Lord; other dances produce only temporary pleasure in the mind. ||1||Pause|| Play the two cymbals of truth and contentment. Let your ankle bells be the lasting Vision of the Lord. Let your harmony and music be the elimination of duality. So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||2|| Let the fear of God within your heart and mind be your spinning dance, and keep up, whether sitting or standing. To roll around in the dust is to know that the body is only ashes. So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||3|| Keep the company of the disciples, the students who love the teachings. As Gurmukh, listen to the True Name. O Nanak, chant it, over and over again. So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||4||6|| [%sig%]

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Harpreet Singh · 08 Sep 2005

This is a message and the reply which was sent on another egroup following the post about Dance which I have posted above: ------------------------------------------- Dear Harpreet Singh ji, Thanks for your most enlightening article. The overall theme seems to suggest all manner of happiness is not recommended by our Gurus and I wish to bring your attention to 'Anand Sahib'. Without a means to express happiness the Sikhs will become most depressed and angry people. I suggest do not ban 'nachna kudna' 'bhangra-gidda' from the lives of Sikhs. Sikhs are better served when they are asked to remember 'Kartar' in every breath and continue to discharge their functions and obligations in this world. Be happy - make room for 'love' in your religious lives and enjoy this 'manukha janam'; this is your only chance. --------------------------------------------------- Reply: ------------------------ Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear Veerji, Thanks for your mail. Veerji, overall theme does not suggest taking away happiness from the life of a Sikh and I am not any authority to ban things from someone’s life. May be we need to be more specific on what we call as happiness. Personally I feel there are lot more things that we can do to keep us happy like doing seva, simran, keertan, going for walks in fresh air, get involved in learning Gatka, do sangat of gurmukhs, social work, look after your family and the best part is, while doing all of these things you can do simran every second. Anand Sahib talks about the bliss when Aaatma mets Parmaatma. When Sikh and guru, when jots become ik mik, one and only one. It no where talks about anand of worldy things which is nothing but giving fire to our 5 Indriaan, indulging in Kaam, Krodh, Lobh, Moh, and Hankaar. For a gurmukh, whole life is ANAND only if you have met GOD otherwise it is just hell even if you dance, drink, laugh, eat, weep do anything. Body: Keh Nanak eh sareer parvaan hoaa jin satgur seon chit laaya Eyes: Har bin avar naa dekho koi Ears: Saache sunane nu pathaaye Tounge: Rasna japti tuhi tuhi ANAND, HAPPINESS: Anand bhaya meri maaye satguru meh paaya. Tell me one instance from Gurbani where the hukam is not to do simran with every breath. This life is for just and just remembering god and nothing else. This is true happiness. This is true anand. You said without a means to express happiness: Veerji means to express hapiness for a gursikh should be the ones which don’t take him away from his only and only duty in this life. If you are happy you can do more simran, if you are happy you can do more and more seva, if you are happy share your happiness with others tell them the how great is the GOD who gave you happiness, talk to them tell them how happy you are to get the god, dance in happiness but please don’t dance to tunes of music that is trying to speak about duniyaavi kood, just dance to the tune of keertan, simran. Do more and more simran. “Gur mukh rom rom har dhiaavey” This will bring out happiness from every inch of your body. Don’t take me wrong, but my aim is not to stop people from doing what they are but just to remind them what they are here for. And to do what they are here for, they will have to come out of these vaashnaavaan’s, these wordly joys, moh mamta and go and get the real anad in name of Akal. For me anything which takes me away from my dear Waheguru is wrong. It may be my hunger for food, lust, dance, wordly music or anything. The truth is only and only one. Each and every second is passing by and we are just dancing, eating, singing where as we should be doing only one thing: Saas Saas Simroh Gobind Naam will never make you depressed and angry person because I have never every heard from history and currently about any real gursikhs who might have become depressed by doing meditation on Naam Baani. It is rather opposite that this world which is so much involved in lustful things of this Kaljug is too much depressed. “Aaeyo sunan padan kau bani || Naam visaar lageh an laalach birtha janam praani||” “Praani tun aaya laaha len || Lagga kitt kuffakade sabh mukdi challi ren||” “Beet jehe beet jehe janam akaaj re ||” Veerji please remember: “Chin chin kar gayo kaal tese jaat aaj hai ||” So it’s for all of us: “Naam japo naam japo mere saajan sena naam japo || Naam japo naam japo mere saajan sena naam japo || Naam bina nahin jeeveya jaaye || Naam Japo naam japo naam japo naam japo naam japo naam japo” Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak. Daas, Harpreet Singh [%sig%]

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Unscientific. · 08 Sep 2005

Scientific <<< There is nothing wrong with dancing. There is a quote in the guru granth sahib ji about dancing and i am sure some one is going to bring it up BUT QUITE LOGICALLY, dancing is a just an expression of happiness. >>> So there is a shabad quote against dancing, BUT QUITE LOGICALLY as you put it, it is an expression of happiness. So Guru Ji is being illogocal and you are being logical...............nice.

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Sikher · 08 Sep 2005

if a Gursikh feels its ok to dance thats their business, i have no objection but if a Gursikh is dancing to music like bhangra music; most of the lyrics are anti-Gurmat.. should they be dancing or even be there? they might want to ask themselves these questions if they feel their sikhi is strong enough & the that music/environment will not impact upon their Sikhi negatively; then all im going to say is he/she is a much a better Sikh than me, because i know it would def have a negative effect upon me

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

reply · 08 Sep 2005

Are gursikhs allowed to dance? >The american sikhs and a lot of gora sikhs on gurumustak singhs >blog are seen dancing on stage or dancing at a small house party. That is an symptom of a major problem in the panth these days: The inadequate transmission of seena-baseena rehit (oral rules of lifestyle). People want to know, "Where is written we can't dance?" Well, the first question is, "If it were written somewhere, would you accept it?" If not, why ask? And in fact, there are a few lines in Gurbani that, if we want to be ik-mik (one and the same) with Guru ji, we wouldn't think of dancing. But the mind wants to rationalize and dismiss such lines, just as some people will dismiss lines regarding hair and beard. So, the real answer, is that a lifestyle is transmitted by living it. The dear Sikhs who got their first introduction to Sikhi through 3HO were introduced to many, but perhaps not all, aspects of the Sikh lifestyle (rehit). The missing portions were then filled in by the modern Western cultural background. This is why we see various innovations coming out of 3HO. Imagine that you are meeting with a group of Gursikhs. Suddenly someone starts playing a CD with a chanchal (mercurial) tune. Men and women start pairing off (not necessarily with their husbands or wives), put their hands around each other, and start swaying their bodies. You are looking around unable to contain your amazement while the dancers see your response as narrow-mindedness. You will feel distance from them and they from you. Obviously, it doesn't portend well for the unity of Khalsa panth if various pockets of Sikhs have follow their own cultural patterns, some of which may be felt by others as grossly violative of Sikh piety. The remedy is that when preparing a new Sikh, we should take our time and familiarize him or her with all aspects of the Sikh way of life. When he is ready to replace to completely immerse himself into the Khalsa community, he should then be initiated. reply [%sig%]

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Amritpal Singh · 08 Sep 2005

Anybody who does paat and has sharda in guru sahib will find dancing a waste of time and NATURALLY not feel like dancing. I challange the people who believe dancing is fine for a gursikh to do, Please provide a name of ANY purattan gursikh who danced. Anybody who has any sort of sense of the word Bhagti, or has done any significant amount of paat or naam jaap will never want to dance. Heres an experiment.... picture Sri Guru Gobind Singh jee Dancing. picture Shaheed Baba Deep Singh jee Dancing..... Picture Bhai Randheer singh jee dancing Baba Gurbachan Singh jee dancing.... Cant picture it eh? exactly. Cause it never happend. Do more paat, spend more time with gursikhs, do more sewa and you'll never want to dance.

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

g · 08 Sep 2005

I dont have any problem with anyone dancing at home if they are listing to music... I dont think they should go out and dance... if your just doing it because its an impulse and your at home... thats fine... but if your out going to clubs I find that very wrong

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

g · 08 Sep 2005

I believe that qoute from Gurbani basically means you can spend your life looking for happiness playing games dancing going out... but you will still be in pain without the tru Guru... I know there's more line's to that than just that one you posted... but its not sayin not to do those.... its just saying if you think thats what happiness is your wrong... you wont find happiness until you find Guru ji... but that doesnt mean thats all you should do

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

person · 08 Sep 2005

dancing is against sikhism!!!! if guru gobind singh je danced, then i would dance. but did he? khalsa mero roop hai khaas||if dancing got u closer to god then it will be fine but, IT DOESNT!!!!!!

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

ekta · 08 Sep 2005

clubs are dogdy buisiness but when its in familly i think its all good, other then that its quite a degraded mentality that sikhs protray these days, we're hard-core, but won't lift a finger to help ppl dying around us, but we won't dance and eat only from sarbloh cause we're sikhs of teh guru.

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Amritpal Singh · 09 Sep 2005

how does helping dying ppl around us, and dancing have anything to do with each other they are two seperate things.... i dont get it.

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Harjas Kaur · 09 Sep 2005

One thing I have loved so much is going to Gurudwara, and during kirtan watching all the little kids get excited and start to dance. We could learn a lot from the children. They seem to have a lot more peace with themselves then we do. The evil is not in the dancing. The evil is in the mind. You know if something is bad or not. Gurumustak Singh is not bad. And I am not good. Westerners have a cultural tolerance of dancing maybe because in our thousands of years old spiritual traditions of Judaism, Christianity and Native American Indian spirituality dance is associated with prayer. We grew up seeing dancing as something more than only indecency and nightclubs. [%sig%]

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Hari Singh · 09 Sep 2005

Harjas kaur, I see the term "westerner" as a cultural reference. And if this is the case then please recognize that there is such a thing as Sikh culture and as far we I am aware, dancing isn't a part of it. Sikh Culture is quite unique, as it is not so much a set of social norms developed over time (since Sikhi is so young) rather it is a consequence of following Gurmat Rehit marayada. Because of oneness of Sikhi rehit, Sikhi culture doesn't change. It was the culture that Guru Gobind Singh jee enouraged ... too bad we seem to be driting away from it. Though some Singhs keep it intact.

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

ekta · 09 Sep 2005

what does it? sikhs are picking chosing their sikhi these days

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Singh · 10 Sep 2005

y dance when u can do pentra

Re: Are gursikhs allowed to dance?

Hari Singh · 10 Sep 2005

Pentra is so much like bhangra anyways, those of you who want to dance can get your fix by doing pentra. lol