Selection of Punj Pyare
Lakhvir Singh Khalsa · 31 Aug 2005
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
KhalsaJi,
Without getting into any arguements, can we discuss the process involved in selection of the Punj Pyare? Help me with these questions, giving details and references to Rehat Maryada, history and Gurbani. No short answers please, unless they are in themselves adequate.
Once your input is concluded, I will then tell the sangat here why I raised these questions. Please note that in no why do I intend to question the authority and sanctity of the Punj Pyare, but I ony seek the truthful approaches because in today's world, one does need to be equally well-informed lest we take a fall.
1. Does sangat select them?
2. Can one individual hand-pick?
3. What criteria is used to select?
4. If one is selected, can he humbly turn down the selection if he has reservations about his own self?
5. Accepted that the selected ones have to be chardikala(n), Naam-kamaai-wale, humble, principled GurSikhs. But how do we know if they are so?
6. If you feel that someone selected is questionable, do you raise an issue (without judging) or do you not say anything if you are not yourself a better Sikh to make that decision?
7. Is age is a determining factor?
8. As per the Rehat Maryada (correct me if I'm wrong), any 5 Singhs can form the Punj Pyare. This, I believe, is only done through selection and not self-nomination. However, if one desires to do the seva, is it possible?
9. Is correct pronunciation of the 5 Bania checked before the Punj Pyare do their seva?
10. Finally, is there a particular way to be bestowed Amrit, in regard to posture (standing or on bended-knee)? I know that the question may be immaterial, but just for knowledge is the question raised.
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
Re: Selection of Punj Pyare
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 01 Sep 2005
Like ALL our graet institutions..we Sikhs have almost NULLIFIED this Great Institution of Panj Piayaras....
Now a days you can find people pointing fingers at the Particular PANJ....oh I know that Singh very well..he beats his wiffe and is now in the Panj..wah wah....or that Singh drinks every week but also in the Panj..etc etc.
Most of the time we dont have any respect for teh Punj..WHY ??
Because we fail to SEE GURU GOBIND SINGH JI Mard Aggamrra in the ROOP of the PUNJ...we continue to see the Jarnail Singhs, and the Kulwant Singhs who we "know" in our everyday life.
I was reading a hsitory book one day..and I came across this anecdote ( actually a sad commentary on us). It seems a few Akali Leaders met and asked one of them why he was not eating meat anymore. He replied that he had chhak Amrit and the Panj had told him to avoid meat. OH there is a very easy solution to that "problem"..replied one of them...just get the Following Punj Tomorrow ( he named a few of his cronies)..and we will RE-Chaaka him Amrit and rectify the MISTAKE. This story relates to the early 1950's and Gyani hira Singh darad was one of the panj...
This is our MISFORTUNE..we have Made the Akal takhat OBEY US,..instead of the other way around...we have made the PUNJ SUBSERVIENT to US..instead of us being subservient to them...Gurdwara Politicians choose their particular PUNJ to give out decisions favouring to them..BADAL is an excellent example of How the PUNJ obey him and not the other way around.
The PUNJ is no more as "a FORCE" as was during the Hey day of the Khalsa...today the PUNJ is just a PAWN..for the Power Brokers to use as a weapon to defeat their opponents and score points....
The PUNJ are also MAHANTS..and they are everywhere....
Sorry if this TRUTH offends some...whats got to be said got to be said..Lets swallow the Bitter Medicine and think of a way to cure ourselves....before its too late... a TRUE SARBATT KHALSA..electing the TRUE PANJ is a MUST for our survival and success
Jarnail Singh